7 ms·
> Once at its destination and hooked in, its V12 had to be run at a specific, constant rpm' to generate AC current at 60 hertz, the frequency used by most North
by Scoundreller 6y ago
> Once at its destination and hooked in, its V12 had to be run at a specific, constant rpm' to generate AC current at 60 hertz, the frequency used by most North American utilities.
I don't think this is exactly right. I'm sure it wasn't consistent either, but few loads really cared too much.
From the article's link, about a different locomotive doing the same thing:
> Conrail actually had a set of standing instructions on how to provide quasi-commercial power from a locomotive. For an SD40-2, you attach to the bus before the diodes. Operating in notch 6 runs the generator at 647 RPM. Since the AR10 is a 10 pole machine, that gives 64.7 Hz power. You could tweak the governor to get it closer to 60 Hz if you really wanted to, but for powering everything but clocks, it's close enough. I think the method for regulating the voltage was to disconnect the load regulator from it's governor-powered vane motor and dialing the voltage in manually. The output is 3 phase power. Max output in notch 6 is about 1000KW. If the avg home draws 2-3 KW on the avg, that'd power several hundred homes.
http://cs.trains.com/trn/f/111/t/194245.aspx http://cs.trains.com/trn/f/111/t/194245.aspx
- collin128 6y agoNot an engineer but I used to sell generators. I believe constant rpm eng/alternator is pretty common practice. From memory and a quick Google search, 1800 rpm produces 60hz and 1500 produces 50hz in newer alternators. I'm unfamiliar with these engine/alternator combos so they likely operate slightly differently. Most power generating units operate at a relatively fixed rpm for longevity and will ramp a little during heavy load. Source: https://www.generatorsource.com/Generator_Frequency_Conversion.aspx https://www.generatorsource.com/Generator_Frequency_Conversi... Also pulled up an old spec sheet for a Cummins and it had the same rpm/Hz specs. Link to PDF: https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&url=https://powersuite.cummins.com/PS5/PS5Content/SiteContent/en/Binary_Asset/pdf/Consumer/specsheets/a-1362.pdf&ved=2ahUKEwi9jN2apv_uAhWFsZ4KHUnUCxAQFjABegQIGBAK&usg=AOvVaw1M3py-D7kc1kO2luiSNysw https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&url=https:/... Edit: added link to spec sheet
- Ballas 6y agoOlder/basic generators would run at fixed frequency to generate the correct frequency. I believe the voltage is regulated by regulating the field strength in the rotor. Modern generators have inverters that handle the output and regulates the 60Hz/110V or 50Hz/220V etc. In this case the RPM is controlled by the wattage required (with a min and max RPM). Motor -> alternator -> inverter -> load
- namibj 6y agoIt depends on the size. The larger the generator, the more likely you have a constant-RPM setup.
- bluGill 6y agoTrue, but that is changing. Inverters are not very expensive anymore, provide cleaner power, and can match the frequency of the something else allowing you to put several generators in parallel and disconnected one for maintenance. They also allow running lower RPM which at lighter loads can save fuel/money. (A constant rpm generator often uses more fuel at 50% load than at 80% load!) Inverter generators can also sell power back to the grid. To pay for the fuel you need more than the typical retail price of electric, so this is only worth it if you have a need for a backup generator anyway. However if you have this need talk to the power company, they often will give you a discount because when there are load issues (See Texas last week), and the ability to add power to the grid in this time will be something they are interested in. Today most large generators are still constant RPM, but I don't expect that to last.
- namibj 6y agoWhy would a constant-RPM generator not be able to feed into a grid? Also, you can run them in parallel without problems, as long as you keep the governors from oscillating. But proper PID tuning and sensing architecture should turn that into a non-issue. Larger engines btw. just disable cylinders for part-load operation.
- 6y ago
- eigenvector 6y agoDiesel engines for power generation will have a governor control that sets the throttle based on the load to maintain whatever rpm is required for 60 Hz (constant speed control). The load in this scenario is uncontrolled and the genset simply follows it. A diesel locomotive's engine controls are about producing the right amount of power to match the operator's throttle control. Electrical frequency at the generator (alternator) terminals is irrelevant since that output is being rectified to DC anyways. This is great for a train, because it means you can have full power at any speed - the speed of your train and the speed of your engine are completely decoupled from each other. But if you now connect this normally variable frequency AC output directly to 60 Hz loads, you will need to figure out how to set the throttle to best maintain something close to 60 Hz and your power output will be limited.
- jhoechtl 6y ago1800 rpm 60hz / 1500rpm 50hz given a four pole alternator. One of the reasons old stationary engines (in Europe) in the pre-governator time ran at a fixed speed of 1500 RPMs
- bluGill 6y agoIf you buy a large engine for a generator the manufacture will have one pin on the ECU for the 50/60hz switch which just changed the RPM. Generators are not enough of a market for the manufactures to make their own engines (unless they have other divisions that also need an engine for something else) that meet emissions, but they are large enough a market overall that companies that make engines want to get in on the extra profits they can by selling to the market (they get to spread the cost of emissions development across more engines), and the 50/60hz RPM needs are only a few hours to code/test on top of all the other work they are doing anyway. There may be minimum quantities in your engine order, though the contract will provide for spare parts which might get you a single replacement many years after the generator is manufactured (if the rest of the engine is still available)
- totalZero 6y agoWith what part of it do you take issue? I don't see the discrepancy...
- exikyut 6y agoI understand that more load reduces frequency and less load raises frequency. Maybe something got lost in translation and "specific, constant RPM" was describing (a feedback loop of) "watch the frequency and keep it steady" as opposed to "always use this value"? -- Also, wow. Seriously, wow. A locomotive running flat out could power several hundred homes. Transportation is expensive, both from a relative cost perspective, and also from a resource(-wastefulness) perspective. Electric (specifically grid-connected) trains also suddenly make a bit more sense.
- petertodd 6y ago> Transportation is expensive, both from a relative cost perspective, and also from a resource(-wastefulness) perspective. It really isn't. That locomotive running flat out may use a lot of energy. But it's also moving an enormous amount of freight, making the energy used per unit mass fairly small. For instance, CSX estimates it can move about 1 ton of freight 492 miles per gallon of diesel: https://www.csx.com/index.cfm/about-us/the-csx-advantage/fuel-efficiency/ https://www.csx.com/index.cfm/about-us/the-csx-advantage/fue... Your trip to the store and back will probably use more energy.
- dredmorbius 6y agoRunning rail relatively slowly and on the level is low-power. Put hills or other load factors (start/stop, speed up / slow down, even wind) into the mix and it can go up. Elevation most especially --- railroads will go up to a thousand kilometers out of a straight-line route to avoid elevation gains. A passenger car should get 20-30 miles (30-50 km) per gallon, so unless your store run is several towns over (or you're in the sticks), probably less energy moving a ton 500 miles by rail. Though yes, personal autos are, relative to size and cargo capacity, profligate energy users.
- sudosysgen 6y agoWhat goes up must go down. Every joule you have to put in to climb, you get back in the downhill. So in the end it mostly works out.
- rob74 6y agoI think the only actual reason why the power frequency has to be precise is so all the power plants can be synchronized. But in an emergency situation, you don't really care if it's 60 or 65 Hz...
- VBprogrammer 6y agoWild variations are bad for heavy inductive loads like transformers and motors. Within 10% is unlikely to damage anything though.
- raphaelj 6y agoIn the video, the French-speaking news anchor says that one of the biggest challenge was to convert the DC from the engine to AC (around 1:10).
- jacquesm 6y agoSlight change of interpretation: the biggest challenge was to disable the AC->DC rectification circuitry, the generator already made AC.
- caf 6y agoOperating in notch 6 runs the generator at 647 RPM. Since the AR10 is a 10 pole machine, that gives 64.7 Hz power. This part doesn't quite make sense though, because it mixes RPM (per-minute) with Hz (per-second) without scaling. 647 RPM is 10.8 Hz, and more poles should increase the frequency not decrease it - 10 poles means you'd multiply it by 5, so would give you 54 Hz.
- hwillis 6y agoprobably 54 Hz- split phase power has a GND, positive phase, and negative phase: https://techblog.ctgclean.com/wp-content/uploads/Split-Phase-Power-IIaa-e1438697473899.jpg https://techblog.ctgclean.com/wp-content/uploads/Split-Phase... Alternating phases would be hooked up to one phase or the other, with negative phase poles connected backwards. I know traction motors are brushed, so probably the generators are as well. If that's the case then you should be able to just bolt new wires on (brushes are consumables, so they are easily replaceable). edit: managed to misread your conclusion as it would be 110 Hz, lol.
- mindslight 6y agoI wonder what they did with the 5 phases? Use them asymmetrically and let the engine struggle with the unbalanced load? Also it seems like this feed would be no good for powering 3 phase motors, or really any phase-phase load. Although maybe city hall back then was only on single phase power, and they could balance circuits between all 5 phases, with the probable addition of temporary electric heaters etc.
- shsbsi 6y ago“but few loads really cared too much.“ There’s some room for error, but frequency is the a very important metric for the utility to get right. The reason is that motors start to burn when the frequency is significantly off of the design f [1]. So, the blower in your furnace will die (-> no heat in the home). Your laundry machines’ motor burn. You ovens convection oven burns. Etc. You’re better of with rolling black ours (Texas forgot the “rolling” part) than get the frequency wrong. [1] think of a motor as an LCR circuit. There’s a natural f, and if youre far from it it will cause heating of the windings
- anticensor 6y ago> Your laundry machines’ motor burn. Modern laundry machines have sophisticated power electronics between mains and drum motor.