6 ms·
"I also think measures of price inflation are almost useless over the long run, because a person today consumes a very different bundle of goods than one in, sa
by xnx 6y ago
"I also think measures of price inflation are almost useless over the long run, because a person today consumes a very different bundle of goods than one in, say, 1950."
I agree with this wholeheartedly. How do we put a value on the fact that, for the cost of no more than a day's labor, most in the US can have a handheld device with access to nearly the sum total of the world's knowledge and entertainment? No one, at any cost, could've had such a thing even 30 years ago.
- phobosanomaly 6y agoAgree as well. We're seeing a lot of coming-to-terms with both the positive and negative fallout from this access. Hopefully soon we might be able to start deriving a utility function based on what people are using the devices for, and then assigning positive and negative utility accordingly, with externalities factored in. Then we could make an attempt at assigning dollar values, and begin to figure out what that means in an economic sense.
- AngrySkillzz 6y agoIt is tricky, but they try to apply what are called "hedonic adjustments." [1] If a new iPhone comes out that is way better than last year's iPhone, but it is the same price, then that's deflation! You got more stuff for the same price. Or even if your new plasma TV is more expensive than the old CRT, how do you compare them to decide whether the price level has increased or decreased while attempting to hold "quality" constant? They walk through an example like this on the webpage. Of course it is very difficult to compare for entirely new product categories, though the good news is that brand new products likely are not a large portion of the consumption basket at the time they are introduced. So it shouldn't make that much of a difference. Otherwise, you are comparing each year to the next in a sort of "family resemblances" kind of way - maybe you can't directly compare a smartphone to something in the 1950s, but you can do incremental comparisons along the way. [1] https://www.bls.gov/cpi/quality-adjustment/questions-and-answers.htm https://www.bls.gov/cpi/quality-adjustment/questions-and-ans...
- gowld 6y agoProgress is different from deflation. Hedonic adjustments is a trick to steal the benefits of progress from workers.
- AngrySkillzz 6y agoyes, comrade, you have nothing to lose but your chains
- uGotit7 6y agoLol it’s funny because anything you don’t like is Russian communist propaganda
- michalu 6y agoIf the workers own the progress should we also blame them for deforestation and pollution?
- ARandomerDude 6y ago> Hedonic adjustments is a trick to steal the benefits of progress from workers. How so?
- huitzitziltzin 6y ago> Hedonic adjustments is a trick to steal the benefits of progress from workers. This claim is crazy. Sorry. No one in the BLS or BEA is trying to “steal benefits”. They are trying to understand the very hard problem of valuing consumer goods for which prices are generally falling and quality is generally increasing.
- LeifCarrotson 6y agoTrue, but a smartphone has become a component of participation in society. No one buys landline telephones anymore, but they were a part of a typical family budget in the 50s.
- xyzzyz 6y agoYes, but you can easily buy a smartphone for <$50. It might be crap by today standards, but it will still be better than any smartphone was in 2010.
- ido 6y agoI thought so too and then bought a cheap motorla android phone (it was more than $50, i think more like $100+) and it was absolutely much worse than a 2010-vintage iphone 4 (or the highest end android you could get in 2010). The CPU is faster and it has more RAM but somehow the user experience is absolutely atrocious - it was not even fast enough to be able to reliably answer calls (the UI was stuttery and it took multiple seconds to unlock the screen, which by then the call went to voicemail). It would constantly fail to do every days tasks (apps would freeze and crash, including the built-in apps) and would slow down randomly making it barely usable.
- teddyh 6y agopostmarketOS might be useful for you or anyone in a similar situation.
- p1necone 6y agoSure you can have the entire worlds information and entertainment at your fingertips with a $50 smartphone, but if you can't afford to have a roof over your head I'd argue the smartphone is irrelevant. I don't think we should be including basic necessities alongside improvements in entertainment in the same statistic, because it will just hide problems.
- mandelbrotwurst 6y ago> I'd argue the smartphone is irrelevant. Access to information helps you obtain and maintain a roof over your head. > I don't think we should be including basic necessities alongside improvements in entertainment in the same statistic, because it will just hide problems. Agreed.
- Arn_Thor 6y agoYes and no.. The smartphone is extremely relevant because access to the internet is essential for modern life. So much necessary activity takes place online, from banking to accessing public services. That needs to be factored in, perhaps not as the cost of a smartphone, but rather the cost of a laptop plus internet. And yet, it doesn't matter if you have a smartphone and internet access if there are no jobs, or if those jobs don't pay sufficiently.
- p1necone 6y agoTo add to that internet connected device is required, but latest iPhone that costs 15x as much is not really materially more important than a $50 one for looking at job ads/emailing potential landlords. Likewise, a flagship phone 5 years ago might be technically less advanced than a flagship phone today, but that doesn't mean todays flagship phone is any better at looking at job ads today than the other one was 5 years ago either. This idea that we should weight technical improvements like this when judging how the economy is performing just seems like a (maybe unintentional) attempt to paint a rosier picture than actual reality to me.
- 6y ago
- nathias 6y agoJust compare food, shelter and education, not luxury goods.
- jjav 6y agoThe important things people must buy are exactly the same in 1950 and indeed for millenia before. Food, water, shelter, clothing. Luxuries change century to century and within decades but those hardly matter for inflation since those are by definition not necessities.
- sokoloff 6y agoIf you’re trying to measure inflation of necessities, then non-necessities should be excluded. If you’re trying to measure aggregate, broad-based inflation, you need to consider aggregate, broad-based baskets of goods/services. Even with the necessity bucket, things change century to century which I think should not be considered luxury. Electric utility service and internet access I do not consider luxuries, but they were obviously not available in 1850 and 1950, respectively.
- pfortuny 6y agoIn fact, you can always decrease necessities by a little... Humans do not live out of necessity but out of convenience.
- another-dave 6y ago> How do we put a value on the fact that, for the cost of no more than a day's labor, most in the US can have a handheld device with access to nearly the sum total of the world's knowledge and entertainment? I know that this is a tangent to your point and I'm not trying to be pedantic, but it always crosses my mind when people mention "access to all the knowledge and entertainment" — how much that would actually cost someone, even with the internet? For knowledge — You have access to Wikipedia and it's a great resource for what it is, and more and more, universities are making some of their material available for free. But there's still an awful lot of academic knowledge that's locked up in research journal subscriptions and a huge amount of knowledge & expertise in e.g. industry text books from publishers like O'Reilly. For entertainment, leaving aside piracy (as otherwise a discussion on costs seems odd), how much would it cost you to be able to access all TV, films, music, books? You'd probably need recurring subscriptions to multiple platforms to even cover main-stream (Prime, AppleTV, Disney+ etc.) Then there's titles that aren't on any subscription service, etc. I wonder how many days labour it would cost to actually get access to all of these?
- mellavora 6y agoOr how much time it would take to find them under the barrage of adds and non-relevant links. Or how much of the world's knowledge is actually relevant to what you want to access at a given moment.
- inter_netuser 6y agoAre you familiar with the term Hyper-normalisation?
- onion2k 6y agoNo one, at any cost, could've had such a thing even 30 years ago. 30 years ago was 1991. That was one year before the IBM Simon was announced - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Smartphone#Forerunner https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Smartphone#Forerunner People definitely imagined smartphones back then. When it went on sale a couple of years later it cost a little over $1000, or less with a cellular phone contract. You couldn't get the internet on it though. Web access on mobile devices didn't arrive until about 1999 with things like iMode.