6 ms·
>there is at most a handful of experts worldwide who can take specimens to a species-level identification. We also have the internet now. Would be cool if you
by hammock 6y ago
>there is at most a handful of experts worldwide who can take specimens to a species-level identification.
We also have the internet now. Would be cool if you could upload photos of bees someplace and have them identified.
- AlexandrB 6y agoThis already exists: https://www.inaturalist.org https://www.inaturalist.org
- Symbiote 6y agoThe machine vision on iNaturalist is great, but it's not necessarily adequate for distinguishing between insect species -- there can be details that are difficult to photograph, let alone identify from a casual user's photograph. And we still need training data (i.e. identified by the expert taxonomists) for future work.
- xipho 6y agoI have been at talks by their devs. They candidly admit it will never meet the needs (accuracy) to address questions at this level of specificity. Some things will be extremely successful, many (most) will not. Think of biodiversity as a curve, with a long tail. Will AI on poorly taken images specimens work for the bell? Probably. Will it actually get at the numbers at the tail? Almost certainly not. This is largely because 1) getting at the tail requires intimate knowledge of where to find that biodiversity (the vast majority of iNaturlaist pics are shockingly close to civilization, where diversity may not be) and 2) intimate knowledge, often of internal features or other non-imagable data, so that one can actually record data that fits in the tail.
- bliteben 6y agoinaturalist really needs the funding to support videos honestly.
- throwanem 6y agoiNat is good, but crowdsourced, and anything but a panacea; for example, I'm very confident in my identifications of the Auplopus mellipes and Auplopus architectus metallicus individuals I encountered and photographed last year, but those (plus one braconid, of which I'm admittedly uncertain myself) are the only observations I have on iNat that haven't had any species confirmations from other users. (That's fair; I needed considerable literature review to develop that level of confidence, and I doubt most iNat users share the extent of my interest in wasps.) Another option is BugGuide (https://bugguide.net https://bugguide.net), which I've actually found more useful - it did me a lot of good figuring out those auplopids. It doesn't provide any sort of dichotomous key (that I've been able to find), but there are a lot of observations available, often with very high-quality images, which helps a lot when specific identification depends on subtle features. In general, though, hymenopterans and especially solitary wasps are just difficult. There are many genera and even whole families that are hard to tell apart with much confidence. One of the first things you notice in the literature is the importance to specific identification of male genitalia, which are internal, practically microscopic, and only even potentially useful if you have the good fortune to happen on a very rare male of a solitary wasp species - and even then, sexual dimorphism can be such as to make a solid male identification useless for spotting a female unless you actually observe them to be in copula. (Female mutillids, aka "velvet ants", don't even have wings!) All of which is to say, I would expect the more obscure solitary bees to pose the same sort of difficulty.
- cmehdy 6y agoDo you know of any place where one could simply contribute? Bugguide seems to be North America only, but while I stayed in a remote area of the Indio Maiz reserve in Nicaragua I stumbled upon a spider that I haven't identified in years and can't quite find any place to simply share the photo[0]. [0] unknown spider on a banana leaf in eastern Nicaragua: https://i.imgur.com/iFMJxtl.png https://i.imgur.com/iFMJxtl.png
- Symbiote 6y agoIsn't this the primary purpose of iNaturalist?
- xipho 6y agoNot sure if a troll given I address this in the OP. You can't just upload images. Internal dissections, DNA sequences, imaging at SEM scale, all of these are not rare requirements, they are the norm. Specimens have to be meticulously collected, preserved, and vouchered in Natural History collections as part of this process (Science should be replicable to some degree). It's a wonderful aspiration to live in a society where anyone will have the free time to "level-up" to a taxonomists level of experience by making, literally, millions of observations, then "power-up" with their free access to SEMs, sequencers, high-powered microscopes and lighting, digital imaging systems (etc.) then "farm for $" to get access to travel and gear then gain "clan-clout" to navigate collecting policies and permitting, etc. etc. Something to strive for, but sadly not a reality anytime soon.
- MattGaiser 6y agoDo they actually have lots of species which look the same but are impossible to tell apart except for DNA?
- hospadar 6y agoLook into mushroom identification - many little brown mushrooms (LBMs) are differentiated only by careful microscopic analysis of their spores or DNA sequencing. Mushrooms are especially difficult because many of the potentially useful identifying features are only present at certain (short - hours or a day or two) phases of the lifecycle of the fruiting body.
- tp3 6y agoFinally, for those who think genomic/genetic studies are being used inappropriately, consider that while they may seem to me to be, in practice, just another sort of 'data processing' (which they are not - they are often just generalised (or even generalized), and their application to new contexts is not that different to simply applying similar analysis to previous contexts) it is possible, for example, that, for example, the study of the DNA sequences of fungi actually (if you want to make a broader and very broad claim about fungus genomics) might in the future yield, in this particular case, a much more detailed, more reliable (and possibly more objective) classification (if not entirely a direct one) of some of the fungi and their eukaryotes in our immediate neighbourhood. I've also got to say that for the same reason, I don't have a lot of confidence in the 'fungal genomic analysis' thing in particular, because, on the whole, it seems to me to be so easily manipulated.
- hinkley 6y agoI've seen plant identification groups, and the thing is that a blurry picture of half the thing is not conducive to accurate identification. When these are correctly identified, it's often because the person has a particular investment in that exact plant. So if the expert on irises or two-stripe bumblebees is offline at the moment you might get crickets, or wild-ass guesses. There is something about video that makes it easier to identify things. The object feels more three dimensional, I suspect, which makes it closer to field identification. That said, we use camera 'traps' for very shy mammal species. I wonder if we could tune those systems for bees. (A fox or cloud leopard might run if the camera gears make noise, but do bees give a damn?)
- rrrrrrrrrrrryan 6y agoThere's a bot on reddit that does this for mushrooms: https://www.reddit.com/user/Mycology_Bot https://www.reddit.com/user/Mycology_Bot This xkcd from just a few years ago has already aged poorly: https://m.xkcd.com/1425/ https://m.xkcd.com/1425/
- riffraff 6y agowell, that comic is seven years old, if anything it'd been accurate :)