8 ms·
Virtual passport app presents real data risk, experts warn
- Faaak 6y agoIn the UK, you can renew your passport online too. I don't really see the risks: they check that your picture matches the old one and you still have to send your old passport for them to issue you the new one..
- tialaramex 6y agoYeah, it's very convenient. If you've already sent them a photo for a driving license (for example) the system can just use that photo on your passport, or if your passport expires before your license, vice versa.
- tinus_hn 6y agoSo what does the app do?
- JBorrow 6y agoIn the UK, you upload a photo from your phone of yourself (that it checks to make sure is valid), you put in your old passport number, and you send your old passport by post to the office. Then in a few days you get your new passport with the photo from your phone.
- tialaramex 6y agoValid here means, the app tries to determine if you did any of the things the rules tell you not to do, like, wearing sunglasses, or using the photo of you with your best friend, or taking a full body photo when they want a face. Later a human will check, and also compare the photo to your last one. Maybe you dyed your hair blond... and grew a different moustache... But how did your missing eye grow back? And why is your nose now further up your face? So the app catches a lot of dumb mistakes that you could make, before a human had to waste their time, but it isn't the only validation.
- tinus_hn 6y agoOkay. Does the UK not have the requirement of carrying your ID at all times? Or does everyone have multiple forms?
- tialaramex 6y agoThe UK doesn't have a requirement for anyone to carry ID. I've never carried ID. Most young people will carry photo ID because it's needed to get into a night club, to buy booze and so on. There are policies like "Check 25" enforced in some places which tell staff they ought to refuse to serve people who seem under-25 unless they can prove they're legal to drink (18 in the UK) but (a) I don't drink and (b) I haven't looked young enough for many years now. For this purpose they can use a driving license if they have one, and there are several other acceptable forms of photo ID including some non-government ID. If you're driving a motor vehicle police can require you to provide proof that you (and thus you'll need ID) are entitled to be driving this vehicle but it's not instant, so if it happened to me I'd put a note in my diary to take my driving license to the police when it's convenient. Historically German occupied countries in the war had mandatory ID and so there's an association in British minds (largely false) between winning WWII and not needing to carry ID. Government has tried various strategies to try to change this but they haven't been successful. Certain non-citizens have to physically attend somewhere at intervals so that government can keep track of them, a Russian colleague of mine would sometimes be late because she'd spend the morning waiting for her local police to confirm that yup, she was still here, still had a visa authorising her to work here, hadn't gone anywhere else. But since citizens do not carry ID the non-citizens don't need ID the rest of the time anyway although I expect many do carry some out of habit. Many older British people won't own any photo ID. If you can't or don't drive, and never travel abroad you'd have no practical use for it. I suspect my grandmother (who hadn't driven since WWII) didn't have any ID more recent than a war-era government ID with no photograph.
- croes 6y agohttps://mask.id/en/ https://mask.id/en/
- UncleMeat 6y agoYou still have to send your old passport in. Somebody who has stolen your passport can renew it. That's a fairly minimal consequence for all the trouble.
- refurb 6y agoI think the risk is now all the data in your passport app is online? The old one for Canada was a fillable pdf, which seems more secure? But then again, I assume they just optically scan it and it sits in a database anyways? Maybe it doesn’t matter. I just talked myself out of any concern.
- cm2187 6y agoThe part that I find extraordinary is the authentication process for the first UK passport (like after acquiring a citizenship). They don't have an old photo to compare to, they won't look at a foreign ID either. So the authentication process consists in asking me a series of personal questions (that I know they don't know the answer to because I never gave it to them at any point in the process) and look at me in the eye to assess whether I am truthful.
- zo1 6y agoWelcome to the world where your government does not actually have a proper, audited, secure and centralized database of all its citizens. Even third-world countries have it better. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Identity_Cards_Act_2006#Objections_to_the_scheme https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Identity_Cards_Act_2006#Object... Reasons for disbanding it: 1. Costs 2. "Effectiveness" 3. "Racism" 4. "Privacy Concerns"
- sebmellen 6y ago* passport application app
- bluesign 6y agoeven * passport application web app
- thegeekbin 6y agoIBM? Well, I'll never be using that app. To my knowledge, Phoenix Pay System is still in the shambles...
- skocznymroczny 6y agoDon't worry, you probably won't have to worry about the choice if they will make it mandatory to confirm your "vaccination status".
- thegeekbin 6y agoThat is a nightmare. I'm not as concerned with "vaccination status" (though, I disagree) -- but, at least 50% of my concern is IBM. Everything IBM touches turns into a hot pile of garbage that needs billions to rewrite and it never gets better. We'd get a better job if we outsourced to another country -- OR -- gave contracts to companies that aren't IBM (& know what they're doing, of course).
- pcora 6y agoThis title is very misleading. The app is just for applying to a passport.
- jbob2000 6y agoPeople here will criticize this, but then turn around and put the same information through Binance or other crypto exchanges.
- williesleg 6y agoChina has all the data already, this just makes it a little more normalized for them.
- danpalmer 6y ago> IBM Canada has won $1.5M contract to develop new platform for IRCC This will buy what? A team of 4 interns and new grads for 6 months. At the end they'll have a slide deck with too much wordart in ith containing some half-baked ideas, and a few lines of code that don't do anything useful at all and are further from production readiness than starting from scratch.
- danpalmer 6y agoI wish I was being facetious, but I really don't think I am. IBM hired extensively from my university, I know people who worked there or adjacent to IBM in industry. They hired the bottom of the cohort (computer science/software engineering) at university and didn't hire anyone who could code. They emphasised communication over technical ability (fine, ok), but their style of communication is business buzzwords in slide decks, not substance. They are keen on business understanding, but that's not product thinking, understanding systems, or the limitations of solutions or anything like that, it's marketing, it's how can we look good. A friend of mine worked for a company who regularly tidied up IBM messes. He was brought on to a project that had been run by a 5 person IBM team for a year. After a year they had detailed requirements for a system that no one wanted. His team of 3 spent 2-3 weeks building a boring CMS on top of Postgres and S3 and the client were ecstatic because it solved the problem they'd had for years. The tech talent at IBM still exists, but it's doing the quantum computing research, or developing their mainframe or server business. The rest is a below average consultancy company.
- znpy 6y agoCame here to post pretty much the same. I got a message from IBM CIC (customer innovation center). The HR lady was very rude, was looking for somebody with 6 more years than me and was disappointed by the fact that my yearly salary of the time was waay out of budget. After that experience: - a guy came for an interview, had been working in such place (IBM CIC). that guy had been studying agriculture (with a degree) but pivoted to computer science. he was okay-ish, but had limited experience outside of the power-point level competencies (some-times you have to come up with creative ideas) - a colleague had worked in CIC. they really hire pretty much anyone and throw them at the customer. which basically means that it's a good place to get your foot into the industry, but you should be aiming at leaving as soon as you get any hands-on experience Apaprently unless you work for the real IBM (doing research, ideally, or research-related stuff) you're working in a glorified sweat-shop.
- nuccy 6y agoIn Ukraine, there is a DIYA (Дія) app developed by the government, which holds electronic national passport, passport for traveling abroad, driving license, car registration documents (including car insurance information), child birth certificate (in parents app) and tax payer information. The app generates temporarily barcodes which can be scanned by another DIYA app to verify somebody's identity or presented documents. The national electronic passport can already be used in some companies, like post offices (state and private), banks, etc. Driving license and car registration can be presented to patrol police when requested. Very handy in general, especially if one forgets his wallet. I have a general concerns about privacy and security of this service, but I can also imagine that all the individual databases, which are accessed by this service, may have their own security issues, so having a single entry point is somewhat reducing the attack surface, which may actually be an advantage.
- ChuckNorris89 6y agoThat sounds super convenient. Wish we would have something similar in the EU. Edi: yes, I know Ukraine is in Europe, I meant EU
- croes 6y agoConvenient ok, but is it secure? https://globalvoices.org/2021/02/11/security-concerns-and-legal-ambiguities-threaten-the-future-of-ukraines-state-in-a-smartphone/ https://globalvoices.org/2021/02/11/security-concerns-and-le...
- ChuckNorris89 6y agoAs a security engineer, nothing civillian-facing is ever 100% secure, it all depends how much resources your attackers have. When modelling your security profile, it's always a matter of "when", not "if" your widget can get hacked. Most you can do is deter black-hats, but not much you can do against well funded state actors.
- jacquesm 6y ago
- stagas 6y agoWhy do we still have borders? Is it a form of learned helplessness? As a European travelling freely inside the Schengen zone is one of the most amazing things and you can argue it has stopped war among those countries. What is the problem of not extending it to the entire world? Does anyone know? Also, it seems that tons of resources are wasted maintaining them when they could be used for increasing prosperity for everyone instead.
- andi999 6y agoI am not sure if this is a serious question. Generally the idea of a common travel area makes sense if the countries at a similiar economic development (like the Schengen zone). This also means that the training skills of the people are not too differend; and this prevents all kind of social problem you would get otherwise.
- stagas 6y agoIt's an honest question. I just don't see that question ever being asked by anyone, to me they don't make too much sense. I understand there'd be a period where things would get messy but won't we eventually reach an equilibrium where everyone is where they want to be, no resources wasted on borders and immigration and everyone just travels and works freely everywhere?
- andi999 6y agoWell everybody probably agrees it will be messy, and not everyone thinks the equilibrium will be good, so the incentives to try this are low.
- stagas 6y agoIf the argument is "everybody thinks that" then that's the form of learned helplessness I talked about, which is why I asked here, to hear some pragmatic reasons. The only argument I hear being repeated is the same vague "otherwise it would be bad" from one side and the "borders are imaginary" from the other side. To me it seems we just keep them because it's been this way since the Roman empire and noone knows really why they're still there. On the other side of the argument, yeah many things are imaginary but that doesn't invalidate them. A football team is an imaginary group but serves a purpose, to play a game. Country borders as well separate cultures, food, music and people with different languages, that's fine, these make sense, but why isn't free movement allowed? Polish didn't move to Germany en masse nor Germans to Poland while there is no border control and there certainly is economic inequality between these countries.
- znpy 6y agoi can't help but wonder... Sometimes I feel like just dropping my phone and never pick it up again. Let it shut off and never turn it on again. Will it be mandatory in the future to own a mobile phone? What if I don't want to have one?
- ghaff 6y agoIt becomes harder and harder--and harder still if you also don't want to use email, etc. You're an edge case and institutions tend to forget about edge cases or just don't want to be bothered with them. So, for example, you now need to show up in offices because you can't sufficiently validate your identity otherwise. I actually know one senior person in Silicon Valley who refused for years to get a cell phone and only relented when his nanny insisted after he and his wife adopted a child. I think he still doesn't have a personal smartphone although his current employer gave him a company phone to carry.
- tialaramex 6y agoI don't imagine it'll be mandatory in free countries, but it'll be horribly inconvenient without. You didn't have to have a telephone either but by say 1980 if there's an important service and it's only available by telephone the government is likely going to say well, there are public call boxes, good luck with your weird lifestyle choice. I got vaccinated at the weekend. SMS to my phone, with a personalized URL in it from my doctor's practice. Follow URL, pick time slot, turn up. No smartphone? Copy the URL by hand to a computer. No Internet? No appointment for you. No SMS? Too bad, you don't get an invite until they're chasing the last people. In July I'm sure anybody with a pulse will get a jab here just by turning up but right now you need an invite. There was an attempted queue jumper at the site. "I don't know why my name isn't on the list, you called me". "We called you? Nobody got a phone call. We sent texts.". "Yeah that's what I meant, I got a text". Sure you did Pal.
- ghaff 6y ago>good luck with your weird lifestyle choice That's a good way of putting it. Furthermore, while the government is theoretically under some obligation to accommodate weird lifestyle choices and people who otherwise don't have access to modern technology, private companies have no such obligation for the most part. They can just say "Nope, you're too much trouble to do business with."
- yabones 6y agoAs a Canadian, I will provide some context around our application for passport process. I went through it a year ago (got my passport 2 days before lockdown), so it's still fresh in my head. To get a passport, you have to go to the post office, get the paper forms (and a spare or two in case you mess up), and fill them out. They need info about where you were born, the doctor who delivered you, your current address and previous addresses, your employer, and your family. Then, you need to go get your photo taken. With a (provincial) drivers license, you just go to the license office and they take your picture. For (federal) passports, you're kind of on your own. You have to go to _a guy_ and get the photo taken that conforms to their specs. If it's not correct, they make you do the whole process again. Most pharmacies and photo stores have gear on hand to make these, but not all do it correctly. Finally, you need a public servant of some sort who has known you for at least two years to sign the back of one of the photos and fill out the back page of the application. They also need to be available to be interviewed about you to verify your identity during the approval process. All in all, it took us about two weeks to get the details together, than another six weeks to get the paperwork processed. It's not a very easy process, and it's a huge bar against people who have never applied before. Having the system more user-friendly would be a massive help to the under-serviced in our country, so something like this is greatly needed. Of course, this solution is awful, but it's certainly worth the effort in my opinion.
- cdmckay 6y agoI'm also a Canadian and my experience has been much different. I've done the process many times, and it takes a couple hours max to gather everything you need. You can download the forms from the Government of Canada website and complete them using the free version of Adobe Reader, or you can print them out and do them by hand. Probably the most annoying part is getting the photos, but nearly every pharmacy can take the passport photos for you, and they all know how to do it because it's very common. I've never had a photo rejected by the passport office. You don't need to know who the doctor who delivered you was. You don't need a "public servant of some sort". The passport application clearly says they just need to have known you for 2 years and have a Canadian passport already. It's also rare that they ever call the guarantor, or the references. I've never heard of it happening to any of my family or friends. It's a pretty simple process and you only have to do it every 10 years. Source: https://www.canada.ca/content/dam/ircc/migration/ircc/english/passport/forms/pdf/pptc153.pdf https://www.canada.ca/content/dam/ircc/migration/ircc/englis...
- encryptluks2 6y agoI live in WA state and receive unemployment. I recently had to verify my identity after getting unemployment for 6 months. This required that I send them a color copy of my DL & SS card, and a passport too since I had one. It was announced shortly thereafter that the system they use to process documents was compromised. A virtual passport app may present real data risk, but no more than the government already does in the multitude of breaches that take place every year with no end in sight.
- ta_abcd 6y agoAs someone with inside knowledge, They have already spent $200MM+ on several failed attempts to develop something like this internally.
- crawdingle 6y agoThey gave them this contract even after the whole phoenix pay system debacle?
- peeters 6y agoWhy on earth are we accepting IBM tenders for government software contracts after the Phoenix shitshow?
- m3kw9 6y agoThis is a “what could go wrong?” moment
- Elessar 6y agoCanadian here, and I'm asking "What's the threat vector they're concerned about?" I see the following listed in the article: * Data Residency - Canada and US (CBSA and Homeland) have plenty of data sharing agreements, including exit records being passed between the two (see Entry/Exit initiative - https://www.canada.ca/en/border-services-agency/news/2019/07/entryexit-initiative.html https://www.canada.ca/en/border-services-agency/news/2019/07...). Why are they so focused on 'applicant' data when there is literal tracking of movement going on due to other, existing acts? * Applications being online might be exploited by criminals - one can already apply to them via mail, so things are already done remotely. The process of validation is no worse digital than by mail (though with the caveat that one executes competently) * Public vs private tendering - This has nothing to do with privacy or data All this noise, and the trade-off is to make it harder for individuals to get passports by forcing them to do things in person. Even if there wasn't a pandemic, lineups at Passport offices are frequently 1+ hour and are a burden to those without flex time at their jobs. Alternatively, they could pay to courier their passport in the mail to the Passport Office in Ottawa, which is a cost (on top of the passport fees) that is wholly unnecessary given the Internet. I see this as those with privileged office jobs attacking a convenience, all the while the Entry/Exit initiative continues without mention.