15 ms·
Four Basic Truths of Macroeconomics
- tabtab 6y agoI get a "please subscribe" pop-up and can't get rid of it without fiddling with the CSS editor. Anyhow... Summary of Truisms: 1) During recessions, employers tend to lay off rather than reduce wages 2) Central bank stimulus helps recessions 3) Too much stimulus causes run-away inflation 4) Non-monetary problems like oil shocks and pandemics can cause recessions 5) Increasing population helps economies. ("Hump to de-slump?" Or immigration?) Summary of areas of disagreement and mysteries: 1) Acceptable level of debt 2) Acceptable level of inflation 3) Effectiveness of public sector versus private sector stimulus. (The left emphasizes first, the right second.) 4) Measuring the true value of intellectual property
- samspenc 6y agoThanks for the summary. There doesn't seem to be any way of getting around the Bloomberg paywall, outline.com doesn't work either.
- tiahura 6y agoReader view on iOS worked for me.
- em500 6y agoI get the full text after disabling JavaScript (Firefox).
- auntienomen 6y agoView source, then copy & paste the relevant bits into an .html file.
- WalterBright 6y ago> During recessions, employers tend to lay off rather than reduce wages There's a good reason for that. I've seen both done. An across-the-board wage reduction means your most productive leave. A layoff is getting rid of the least productive.
- Arn_Thor 6y agoI believe Germany has done the opposite. Unions have agreed to pay cuts so they wouldn't be let go. Part of the reason may be that wage levels are reasonably flat compared with the US, so the upside in switching jobs for a better paying one at a competitor is limited versus the hassle of doing so. In any case, it's an interesting alternative model which ensures stability for employees and employers alike.
- NortySpock 6y agoRegarding point 5: increasing population via reproduction adds workers in 16-18 years. Immigration adds workers immediately. Additionally, immigration increases both labor supply (obviously) but also labor demand (more consumption, because immigrants buy stuff and services just like anyone else) and as a result wages are flat even when a lot of immigrants join the economy in a short amount of time. "This has been tested under conditions such as the Mariel Boat Lift, where a large number of Cuban immigrants all joined the Miami labor market in a short period of time, increasing labor supply by 7% very quickly. Research found that there was practically no impact on wages and employment for locals." https://www.reddit.com/r/Economics/wiki/faq_immigration https://www.reddit.com/r/Economics/wiki/faq_immigration https://www.jstor.org/stable/2523702?seq=1 https://www.jstor.org/stable/2523702?seq=1
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago> "This has been tested under conditions such as the Mariel Boat Lift, where a large number of Cuban immigrants all joined the Miami labor market in a short period of time, increasing labor supply by 7% very quickly. Research found that there was practically no impact on wages and employment for locals." The problem with all of these studies is that they only apply to the specific circumstances of the study which will probably never happen again anywhere. What happens if the immigrants send more of the money they make back to their home countries? What happens if the minimum wage is lower, or the immigrants have a higher skill level, so that the potential downside for wages is larger? What if the unemployment rate or labor demand is different, affecting the number of new workers that displace existing workers? What happens if immigrants' wages are taxed at a higher rate and the money goes to cronies and corporate welfare instead of being recirculated in the economy? Measuring what happened at a different time in a different place doesn't really tell you much.
- xyzzyz 6y agoAlso, what would happen if the Miami economy hadn't had been experiencing a boom in cocaine industry during the same time period?
- neilwilson 6y ago
- WalterBright 6y ago> Non-monetary problems like oil shocks and pandemics can cause recessions It wasn't the oil shock of the 70's that caused recession. It was our response to it - Nixon's oil and gas price & allocation controls. We came out of that when Reagan repealed it. Our current recession is not caused by the pandemic, but the lockdown response to it.
- bawolff 6y agoThat seems like a silly splitting of hairs. Why stop there? By that logic the recession is not caused by the lockdown but by less businesses being open and reduced consumer spending.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- WalterBright 6y agoLet's say Bob insults me and I punch him in the nose. Did Bob cause me to punch him in the nose? Of course not. Just like the Terminator, I scrolled through a list of options, and selected "punch him in the nose". I could have selected "your mother is a hamster and your father smelt of elderberries." I could have selected "do nothing".
- bawolff 6y agoWhat's your definition of cause here? Human agency? In that case, people could have decided to donate part of their salaries to businesses they previously frequented,or other rediculous "choices" that humans would never do. I don't think there is a coherent notion of cause and effect where both covid does not cause the recession and the lockdown does. I can see very restricted notions of cause and effect where neither "cause" it, and more normak notions where both cause it, but not one where one causes but not the other. And that's ignoring the absolutely rediculous premise that the covid death toll and long term disability toll has no effect on the economic downturn and it was purely caused by the lockdown. There are reasonable arguments that lockdown has been a net positive for the economy in the long run (even more so for non-usa countries that did it competently)
- imnotlost 6y agoRegarding 3; are there examples of stimulus causing run-away inflation? Or has it usually been a political event, a complete loss of trust in the system?
- fuzzfactor 6y agoTrue, but false ;)
- foolinaround 6y agohttps://archive.vn/Vu6Cw https://archive.vn/Vu6Cw to get around the paywall
- xnx 6y ago"I also think measures of price inflation are almost useless over the long run, because a person today consumes a very different bundle of goods than one in, say, 1950." I agree with this wholeheartedly. How do we put a value on the fact that, for the cost of no more than a day's labor, most in the US can have a handheld device with access to nearly the sum total of the world's knowledge and entertainment? No one, at any cost, could've had such a thing even 30 years ago.
- phobosanomaly 6y agoAgree as well. We're seeing a lot of coming-to-terms with both the positive and negative fallout from this access. Hopefully soon we might be able to start deriving a utility function based on what people are using the devices for, and then assigning positive and negative utility accordingly, with externalities factored in. Then we could make an attempt at assigning dollar values, and begin to figure out what that means in an economic sense.
- AngrySkillzz 6y agoIt is tricky, but they try to apply what are called "hedonic adjustments." [1] If a new iPhone comes out that is way better than last year's iPhone, but it is the same price, then that's deflation! You got more stuff for the same price. Or even if your new plasma TV is more expensive than the old CRT, how do you compare them to decide whether the price level has increased or decreased while attempting to hold "quality" constant? They walk through an example like this on the webpage. Of course it is very difficult to compare for entirely new product categories, though the good news is that brand new products likely are not a large portion of the consumption basket at the time they are introduced. So it shouldn't make that much of a difference. Otherwise, you are comparing each year to the next in a sort of "family resemblances" kind of way - maybe you can't directly compare a smartphone to something in the 1950s, but you can do incremental comparisons along the way. [1] https://www.bls.gov/cpi/quality-adjustment/questions-and-answers.htm https://www.bls.gov/cpi/quality-adjustment/questions-and-ans...
- gowld 6y agoProgress is different from deflation. Hedonic adjustments is a trick to steal the benefits of progress from workers.
- chordalkeyboard 6y ago> Nominal wages are sticky, for a complex mix of sociological reasons, and so employers do not always respond to lower demand with lower wages for workers. Instead they lay some people off, and that can lead to a recession. > The second thing to know is that well-functioning central banks can offset such demand shocks to a considerable degree — or even prevent them from arising in the first place. The bank can engage in complex financial transactions or simply print more currency to stabilize nominal demand and restore some measure of order. Is it that hard to say “we think wages among the working class are too high so the central bank depreciates the currency”?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- AngrySkillzz 6y agoI'm just going to call you a conspiracy theorist because it's probably not worth arguing with you, and "the amount of energy needed to refute bullshit is an order of magnitude larger than to produce it." If what you want to say is that you think the government is run by a shadowy cabal of elites whose main purpose is to impoverish the common man, then just say that.
- phabora 6y agoThat governments act more in the benefit of business owners than workers was observed by Adam Smith and is still true today. Further that’s a sociological fact and not a “conspiracy theory”, but I don’t have time to write ten sentences to refute your single sentence of bullshit so I won’t bother.
- chordalkeyboard 6y ago> If what you want to say is that you think the government is run by a shadowy cabal of elites whose main purpose is to impoverish the common man, then just say that. I’m not sure why I would need to go that far afield when I can just deal with the actual words spoken by actual economists where they literally say this with slighty obscurant language. This isn’t a “shadowy cabal,” its mainstream media and economics here. If the actual intent of economic policy is so threatening to your worldview that you need to poison the well by invoking shadowy conspiracies, perhaps you should re-evaluate your own perspective on the issue. > I'm just going to call you a conspiracy theorist because it's probably not worth arguing with you, and "the amount of energy needed to refute bullshit is an order of magnitude larger than to produce it." Yeah it would probably require an infinite amount of energy to refute my assertions, since they are actually true. And I think we are beyond considering the existence of the central bank to be a “conspiracy theory”, it’s kind of established.
- anarchop 6y agoThe only truth: central banking facilitates theft of savings through debasement of the currency. This is the reason the founding fathers fought to keep central banking out of the US.
- arcticbull 6y agoYeah, it doesn't, though. Inflation only matters from the time you receive your paycheck to the time you invest it in productive assets or buy the necessities of life. After that it sets the benchmark rate of return for your investments. If your salary fails to track inflation that's between you and your boss who's giving you a pay cut year over year, or between you and congress if you're under the minimum wage umbrella. Currency only has value while its changing hands and inflation is an incentive to change hands. If you'd invested in anything at all 100 years ago you'd have just as much value as you did back then - at an absolute minimum. If you insisted on sticking a square peg in a round hole and hid your cash in your mattress the whole time, inflation did its job and took that value from you. > This is the reason the founding fathers fought to keep central banking out of the US. Well, they also fought for slavery, they weren't perfect people. Better to stick to arguments on their merits instead of appeal to 300+ year old authority.
- AngrySkillzz 6y agoSadly it isn't really worth arguing econ on HN. This place is full of cranks when it comes to that, unfortunately. Maybe better if we all just stick to programming.
- arcticbull 6y agoIt's amazing how otherwise brilliant folks get caught up in this anarchocapitalist conspiracy theory mumbo jumbo. There's a few bits of plumbing in this world you'd do best to familiarize yourself with so you can raise your socioeconomic stature with maximum efficiency, economics is one of them. I only tilt at them because I hope that they'll benefit from an understanding of how these things work in reality.
- idlewords 6y agoThe third great truth in this list is "an increase in the money supply leads to inflation, except when it doesn't" which is hard to argue with. Clearly a field where Nobel prizes should be awarded.
- 9oliYQjP 6y agoTo be fair it's not a real Nobel prize. It's paid for by a bank and it was first issued in 1968. One of Nobel's descendants is on record speculating that Nobel would never have agreed to the award. It's very much about public relations for the field of economics. The field's effect on the world has been to undermine democratic governments through the establishment of treaties that people never voted for and organizations comprised of people who were never elected. Governments merely act as middle managers to the "market" and their role is to keep their people within the constraints of these supposed universal truths. The Nobel Memorial Prize in Economics Science is a way for the field to convey prestige, expertise, and authority. My personal take is that the field is stuck in an existential local minima and are self-conscious about it: similar to how astronomy was stuck on the model of concentric spheres. I think everybody who practices the field is unconsciously aware of it too which is why they lean on hand-waving charts and opaque math that anybody in a harder science would instinctively call bullshit on. How psychology got to be the poster boy for the replication crisis in the social sciences and not economics is baffling given the scope and depth of influence the field has had on the world. But don't take my word for it... https://academic.oup.com/ej/article-abstract/127/605/F236/5069452?redirectedFrom=fulltext https://academic.oup.com/ej/article-abstract/127/605/F236/50... We investigate two critical dimensions of the credibility of empirical economics research: statistical power and bias. We survey 159 empirical economics literatures that draw upon 64,076 estimates of economic parameters reported in more than 6,700 empirical studies. Half of the research areas have nearly 90% of their results under‐powered. The median statistical power is 18%, or less. A simple weighted average of those reported results that are adequately powered (power ≥ 80%) reveals that nearly 80% of the reported effects in these empirical economics literatures are exaggerated; typically, by a factor of two and with one‐third inflated by a factor of four or more.
- AngrySkillzz 6y ago
- sadmann1 6y agoWhat are the best introductory books to get more grounded in economics
- aww_dang 6y agohttps://www.goodreads.com/book/show/3028.Economics_in_One_Lesson https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/3028.Economics_in_One_Le...
- Jommi 6y agohttps://www.amazon.com/Macroeconomics-N-Gregory-Mankiw/dp/1464182892 https://www.amazon.com/Macroeconomics-N-Gregory-Mankiw/dp/14...
- jkhdigital 6y agohttps://www.amazon.com/Basic-Economics-Thomas-Sowell/dp/0465060730/ https://www.amazon.com/Basic-Economics-Thomas-Sowell/dp/0465... https://www.amazon.com/Applied-Economics-Thinking-Revised-Enlarged/dp/B004HOVCKW/ https://www.amazon.com/Applied-Economics-Thinking-Revised-En...
- neilwilson 6y agoIf you want actual Macroeconomics rather than the myths from this article try https://www.amazon.com/Macroeconomics-William-Mitchell/dp/1137610662/ref=sr_1_1?dchild=1&keywords=macroeconomics+mitchell&qid=1614058316&s=books&sr=1-1 https://www.amazon.com/Macroeconomics-William-Mitchell/dp/11...
- huitzitziltzin 6y agoThis is not a good recommendation. Wray and the MMT school have a bizarre set of views which are wildly outside the mainstream of macroeconomic thinking. Moreover, when serious macroeconomists have tried to engage with MMT on its own terms (which they do!) the MMT people always get evasive and vague in response to the very simple question: “why didn’t your monetary ideas work for Venezuela/Zimbabwe/Weimar Germany?” There are much better textbooks available. Wolfers/Stephenson is a recent one I’ve thought about using in class.
- viburnum 6y agoThis is a good example of how so much economics is meant to distract you from what’s important. Cowen is framing economics to exclude things like unemployment, the process by which investment, savings, and income are determined, and the distribution of income. If you get people into the weeds about sticky prices and whatnot, it’s like putting blinders on a horse.
- dataking 6y ago> This is a good example of how so much economics is meant to distract you from what’s important. I think your assumption of malice is unfounded. A likely benign explanation is that Cowen focused on areas there economists are in broad agreement without intent to mislead.
- RobertoG 6y agoThe grandparent is not attributing malice to the author, but to the way the framework of economics is built. Cowen probably believe that what is saying is true and can't see different anymore.
- viburnum 6y agoI’ve been reading Cowen for nearly twenty years. He plays dumb when he gets caught out (“I’m not really a macroeconomist,” “I’m not really familiar with Keynes,” etc). Think of him as a lawyer representing his client. He’s not going to introduce evidence that hurts his case.
- cambalache 6y agoNah, in this case the accusation is warranted, Cowen has always been an unconditional cheerleader for unconstrained capitalism,the status-quo and the dubious predictive and normative power of mainstream macro.
- TheOtherHobbes 6y agoEconomists are in broad agreement because they're paid to be. This is well-documented historically. The Mont Pelerin Society was specifically founded to promote a certain view of economics, and the Chicago School was supported financially by some very rich sponsors who wanted a a pet academic alternative to progressive slant of Keynesianism. The "consensus" in neoliberal economics and its core ideas - including "rationality" and "efficiency" - is a wholly manufactured political project, not an organic open-minded attempt to find credible scientific foundations.
- RobertoG 6y ago>>"The third thing to know is that if central banks go crazy increasing the money supply, the result will be high price inflation. There is one exception to this, which was evident in 2008 and 2009 [..]" Japan has been doing that for decades now, and none of the mainstream macroeconomics prediction came true. >>"If central banks simultaneously act to decrease the velocity of money — that is, if they take measures to reduce borrowing and lending — then price inflation will be limited accordingly." What are those measures he is talking about?
- rufusroflpunch 6y agoThat’s because we measure inflation stupidly, IMO. If there would otherwise be, say 6% price decrease, but central bankers inflate the supply of money to 1% price increase, then they say we had 1% inflation when in reality there was 7% inflation.
- lmilcin 6y ago> Nominal wages are sticky, for a complex mix of sociological reasons, and so employers do not always respond to lower demand with lower wages for workers. Instead they lay some people off, and that can lead to a recession. And the main reason is that reducing wages creates unhappy, unmotivated people. If you own a business you want unhappy unmotivated out. By laying off people you keep people who (supposedly) are happy that they have not been and kept their salary. If you are business owner, it is better to keep 90% of your crew but motivated vs keeping 100% but unmotivated. > That may sound pretty simple. But it is one of the most important discoveries in history. I wonder why is that. If you are a business owner this is common sense. > The second thing to know is that well-functioning central banks can offset such demand shocks to a considerable degree. It is unfortunate that they are called "banks". We need to have better differentiation in naming, as central banks and regular banks don't share same goals. Except they do, and that is next point. > The third thing to know is that if central banks go crazy increasing the money supply, the result will be high price inflation. Because the reality is that increasing money supply is theft/taxation (is there really a difference?) By printing money central bank taxes each unit of currency decreasing its value. While central banks print money directly, the "regular" banks "print" money indirectly. By having ability to lend more than the cash they actual have the "regular" banks are also creating supply of money out of thin air. This can't be called taxation anymore so the only way to call it is theft.
- bondarchuk 6y agoTangentially related but I'll take this opportunity to ask. One thing I have never understood is the idea that a weak currency is good for exports, because it makes goods cheaper (more competitive) for the foreign buyer. It seems like it would be very simple for exporting companies to adjust their prices instantly to counteract any weakening of the currency. If not, they are essentially lowering their prices. Alternatively, why can't exporters just lower their prices without weakening the entire currency?
- haakonhr 6y agoI think a first-order explanation (that probably breaks down quickly) is that often many fixed costs are paid in the local currency, such as salaries and rent. To be profitable (in the local currency that they care about) they need to take a certain price, otherwise they're operating at a loss. Currency fluctuations affect all these factors equally so that in the end your product is cheaper for the importer. The salaries and other costs are of course lower as well when the local currency is exchanged to whatever currency the trade is taking place in. The flip side is of course when you rely on imports to produce your exports (natural resources for example)
- scatters 6y agoYes, exporters can choose to raise their prices in the local currency. However, this comes with some administrative overhead and is visible to the buyer, hence prices tend to be sticky. Alternatively, they can price in dollars in which case they take on currency risk in the other direction but get the full benefit of a fall in their local currency. > Alternatively, why can't exporters just lower their prices without weakening the entire currency? Because then they wouldn't be able to make a profit after paying their local employees and suppliers.