8 ms·
Doomsday Ships Were Ready to Ride Out Nuclear Armageddon Before Doomsday Planes
- INTPenis 6y agoReminds me of the scifi post-apoc novel "The Last Ship" by William Brinkley about a US navy ship taking part in mutual destruction and surviving to roam the dying world and start over with a partly female crew.
- germinalphrase 6y agoAlso similar: “on the beach”
- King-Aaron 6y agoIn On the Beach I seem to recall the crew of the submarine dying horribly, along with everyone else
- fogihujy 6y agoA spoiler alert would be a good idea -- not everyone has read it. :) It's a very good novel on the same theme, and thus relevant. Highly recommended.
- King-Aaron 6y agoI mean yeah, but the books from 1957 so I'm not sure if thats completely necessary :P
- aksss 6y agoThey made a TV show of that right? Haven’t seen it but may check it out. Was the book any good?
- crooked-v 6y agoThe show is very loosely related, as rather than a nuclear war the ship takes part in, there's a pandemic that devastates the world that the ship is coincidentally protected from by isolation.
- INTPenis 6y agoIt was pretty ok but not good imo. Too much emotional introspection by the narrating character, the captain. Not enough action or detail in the society building. Never heard of the TV show. I'm sort of afraid of watching it, kinda like the Timeline movie based on the Crichton novel.
- koheripbal 6y agoThe show performed terribly.
- ggm 6y agoRichard Rhodes in his two-volume work on A-Bomb and H-Bomb development talks a lot about MAD and how it led to rational but awful thinking. In the absence of better choices, the planners did what they thought was best, but both sides came to realise the only suitable posture was to be capable of retaliation and make sure the other side knew it, but also to minimise belief there was specific hostile intent. Politicians didn't like it. the US never renounced first strike. I still struggle with how "hard" a hardened C&C jet can be, and I think there is a general principle, that the EMP pulse you can defend against is not as big as the one the enemy can produce. I read that defector provided soviet jets at one point had tiny weeny valves, which were not indications of how backward their electrical engineering was: they were capable of being rad-hardened more than the IC's of the time. I'm not sure this is true.
- Retric 6y agoI have heard what seemed like a rational justification for first strike. For MAD to be effective you need to convince people you’re both able and willing to vindictively kill off large swaths of the worlds population. As such you do want to come off as just slightly unhinged which having first strike capability projects.
- secfirstmd 6y agoThe main reason for US/NATO not to renounce first strike was because it would be fairly easily overwhelmed by Warsaw Pact forces if WP attacked conventionally. Probably some kind of large WP exercise turned real very quickly combined with Spetsnaz causing havoc behind NATO lines. First strike was needed in order to slow things down and do some damage, in theory to a) give the US time to rush conventional forces to Europe, b) bloody the nose of WP enough to make them think twice and c) destroy as much as possible of the WP rear areas and reinforcements. If the WP had gone through the Fulda Gap or the South option near Switzerland -tactical nuclear mines, Special Operations nuclear devices, tactical nuclear artillery, tactical aircraft attacks etc would have been used pretty quickly on them. In reality it probably would have escalated to far worse than that pretty quickly I'm guessing.
- doyouevensunbro 6y agoA Vault-Tec ship docking after 200 some odd years in a port city sounds like a good idea for a Fallout game. Get on it Bethesda!
- tholman 6y agoIt's fiction, but I really enjoyed the chapters of World War Z [1] from the perspective of the nuclear submarine, and their "oh it seems like the world is ending, we have to wait this out" perspective. Really something that just get's you thinking, and I'm not sure if I feel safer, or more worried that people have been thinking about exactly that. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_War_Z https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_War_Z
- tra3 6y agoWhat a fantastic book. The movie was such a disappointment.
- ASalazarMX 6y agoMy guess is that the studio knew the adaptation of such book would make a mediocre movie, and decided to save the effort and go straight to mediocre movie instead.
- tra3 6y agoI guess it doesn’t have a likeable protagonist per se and is mostly episodic. Maybe it would work better as a Tv show instead? Still I came away disappointed.
- azernik 6y agoYeah, as a TV show it would almost be an anthology series. Lots of little vignettes told in the same continuity with totally different casts.
- ASalazarMX 6y agoIf I had seen the movie before reading the book, I think I would have enjoyed both, maybe the problem was our high expectations.
- tehbeard 6y agoI've always said it should have been handed to HBO to make a mini series out of it.
- trhway 6y ago>the Wright could deploy an unmanned QH-43 Huskie helicopter, a unique version of the Kaman design that could lift a super very-low-frequency antenna over two miles into the air and thereby communicate with Navy submarines around the globe.
- aksss 6y agoWow, I wonder if that’s really for a two mile wave or if it’s coiled to really be far bigger.
- xxpor 6y agoAlmost certainly coiled, where "coiled" might be using the earth itself as half of a capacitor: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jim_Creek_Naval_Radio_Station https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jim_Creek_Naval_Radio_Statio...
- ghaff 6y agoThere's at least one other US Navy VLF station as well in Cutler Maine. A few countries have lower frequency ELF transmitters, but the US abandoned its facility.
- madengr 6y agoThe sub comms are at 25 kHz, which is 3000m at 1/4 wavelength. So 2 miles makes sense for a 1/4 wave monopole with the Earth as a counterpoise.
- opwieurposiu 6y agoThe VLF land stations are on 24.8 kHz, which is 7.4miles wavelength. The two mile antenna is probably a 1/4 wave dipole.
- walrus01 6y agoTake Charge and Move Out: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TACAMO https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TACAMO
- Ichthypresbyter 6y agoThe UK had plans in the 1960s for the Queen, the Duke of Edinburgh, and the Home Secretary to spend WW3 on board the royal yacht Britannia, which would use remote Scottish lochs to hide. (The Home Secretary was there to allow quorate meetings of the Privy Council, including to appoint a new Prime Minister). Later on, a class of car ferries were built with airtight doors that could seal the car deck, as well as other features allowing them to be used as floating nuclear bunkers.
- arethuza 6y agoPresumably one of the reasons the Britannia carried Royal Marines was to fend off Spetsnaz or possibly rebellious locals.
- implements 6y agoHMY Britannia was commissioned and crewed by the Royal Navy, and like other RN vessels would carry Royal Marines as part of the “Ships Force Protection Team”. With the Head of State onboard, and visiting foreign ports ... it would have made sense to have a lot of amphibious infantry on hand, just in case.
- arethuza 6y agoI knew someone who was having a quiet walk with their dog on a secluded beach in the Outer Hebrides when they were surprised to find marines landing and running past them into the dunes and not speaking to them. A few minutes later Elizabeth and Margaret arrived with their dogs - an obligatory conversation about the weather and respective dog breeds was had before all the visitors piled back into their boats.
- Freeboots 6y agoThis is fun just because im rereading Seveneves, which i highly recommend as a fun fictional 'what if a cataclysmic event took place with near current technology'. One of the minor plots is a submarine equipped to handle thermonuclear war being further fitted to survive the several thousand years to ride out the event. I wont spoil it further.
- hutzlibu 6y agoSince the ships main purpose was communication, wouldn't that mean, it could have been easily detected by the enemy, and then the command chain would vanish?
- nradov 6y agoDetection is one thing, targeting is another. Back then the Soviet Union didn't have much of a blue water navy, or many reconnaissance satellites, or missiles that could accurately hit a moving ship.
- hutzlibu 6y agoThe text mentions spy satelites as the main factor that came later, as well as cruise missiles etc. But still, radio triangulation was a known technic and submarines did exist and should have been expected to be build by the sovjets, so I am still wondering a bit, why the dedection issue was not mentioned.
- dannyphantom 6y agothanks i now have 8 tabs open of different articles from this site.