8 ms·
> The CMP version is a straight-to-landfill product. As soon as it stops being profitable for mining it will have zero resale value, and become e-waste. Like l
by arcticbull 6y ago
> The CMP version is a straight-to-landfill product. As soon as it stops being profitable for mining it will have zero resale value, and become e-waste.
Like literally every other piece of Bitcoin or crypto mining technology. It’s straight to the landfill every 6 months.
Bitcoin generates 100 GRAMS of ewaste for every transaction. Every 2 transactions consumes as much energy as driving a Tesla from SF to NY [edit for clarity: round trip] and as much ewaste as throwing your phone out the window along the way.
Don’t hate the player; hate the game. Nvidia is maximizing shareholder value as per their charter, creating differentiated product offerings for different segments. Quadro, RTX, CMP. It’s all segmentation, and better, likely binning. I wonder if CMP products are just failed RTX and Quadro parts they’re offloading. For every card Nvidia doesn’t sell, Ant will sell 2 ASIC miners.
Time to push back on proof of waste, and end the economic incentive.
- SSLy 6y agoNo one mines bitcoin on GPU's anymore, since 8? years.
- jrrrr 6y ago[citation needed]
- arcticbull 6y agoHere ya go: https://digiconomist.net/bitcoin-energy-consumption/ https://digiconomist.net/bitcoin-energy-consumption/ And here: https://www.solarreviews.com/blog/how-much-does-it-cost-to-charge-a-tesla-is-it-the-same-as-the-cost-to-charge-other-electric-vehicles https://www.solarreviews.com/blog/how-much-does-it-cost-to-c...
- jrrrr 6y agoWhat needs a citation is the comment I replied to, SSLy's assertion that: > No one mines bitcoin on GPU's anymore, since 8? years.
- formerly_proven 6y agoWhich cryptocurrency of the day is mined does not matter to the argument.
- windexh8er 6y agoYeah this just isn't true. Given the rally in coin prices GPU mining has come back to the black if you have cheap/free access to electricity. With a 3080 you can make over $12/day in BTC and the electricity costs required are less than $2 in a majority of the US [0]. [0] https://www.nicehash.com/profitability-calculator/nvidia-rtx-3080 https://www.nicehash.com/profitability-calculator/nvidia-rtx...
- deepakhj 6y agoBtc mining only works on asics. You can mine ethereum on gpu’s. NiceHash rents your hash rate to buyers, you mine ethereum, while they pay your rewards in btc. If you want ethereum directly, you can mine for a pool like ethermine or flexpool.
- Karunamon 6y agoThe link directly contradicts this. Pooled mining with BTC (ETH too, but also BTC) on a GPU is something you can do and make a modest amount of money right now, to the tune of around $5/day at current prices. There's a profitability floor on hashes/KWh. When coin's price goes as sky-high as it has been, it pushed GPU mining back into the black. This is likely a temporary state of affairs; either the network difficulty will increase to where only ASICs can break through, or the price will decline.
- deepakhj 6y agoThe link shows paying in btc because they don’t give you what you mine. You rent your hash rate and people bid on it with btc. You’re not mining btc directly. I use NiceHash at the moment. Your gpu mines ethereum (or whatever the most profitable coin is as NiceHash has a profit switcher.)
- hobofan 6y agoCould you explain to me why someone would offer their hashing power on NiceHash vs. just directly working for a pool? The main cases I image are: 1. The miner doesn't want to deal with price fluctuations and wants to prevent arbitrage risk 2. It might be more profitable to outsource smallish coins that have to buy hashing power to stabilize their network (though that would probably also be covered by the profit switcher) 3. Money laundering <--- Which I assume is the biggest portion
- hobofan 6y ago> It’s straight to the landfill every 6 months. Isn't that a trend that has mostly ended or is about to end now? It looks like that was mostly caused by nm process improvements for ASIC chips in the past. With 7/5nm ASIC chips it seems like it should now progress as fast/slowly as the nm process capabilities of chip manufacturers in general. Not pro-BTC, but this seem very much like faulty interpolation based on a past trend.
- WanderPanda 6y agoI was wondering the exact same thing a couple days ago, would be great if a more knowledgable person could confirm this
- Closi 6y agoTechnology continues to advance - I don’t think there is enough evidence to say that we have hit a fundamental limit on computer/asic power/speed performance yet. 3nm will hit in 2024, but until then there will always be advances in chip design. It’s not just about speed, it’s also about thermals, power consumption and manufacture price to work out the TCO of mining.
- hobofan 6y ago> 3nm will hit in 2024, but until then there will always be advances in chip design. I'm not an expert on chip design, but I would have assumed that there isn't a lot of room for improvements of ASIC mining chips, given that they are probably a straightforward implementation of the hashing algo used in Bitcoin (and that a few thousand+ times), in contrast to CPU design which is more dependent on other computing/hardware trends.
- Closi 6y agoWell even without chip design, for instance if you decrease unit cost, that also has the impact of changing the mining landscape because many more ASIC miners can enter the game. Also remember an ASIC miner will generally use more than it costs in electricity each year, so a relatively small improvement in hashes / watt makes a big difference to overall profitability. CPU design is more complex, but also has more people working in the space and has been going for longer. I just get sceptical if someone says this is as good as it is going to get because history shows usually those predictions end up being wrong. As a child I thought Super Mario 64 was as good as computer graphics were ever going to get...
- roter 6y agoI checked your numbers against [0]. Road distance NY -> SF = 2900 miles [1]. Model S mileage is 290Wh/mi [2]. That is 840kW for Tesla against 657kW for a single transaction. This is all order-of-magnitude stuff but... wow. [0] https://digiconomist.net/bitcoin-energy-consumption/ https://digiconomist.net/bitcoin-energy-consumption/ [1] https://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=road%20distance%20san%20francisco%20to%20new%20york https://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=road%20distance%20san%... [2] https://www.zeviecars.com/browse-cars/tesla-model-s https://www.zeviecars.com/browse-cars/tesla-model-s
- mlyle 6y agokWhr, not kW. It's also 1/2 to 3/4th the electricity used in a month by a typical US household.
- Freak_NL 6y agokWh, if we're going to be pedantic, which I approve of. :) It bugs me that even quality newspapers frequently mistake power (watt (W)) for energy (joules (J) or watt-hour (Wh, often with the usual metric prefixes)).
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- arcticbull 6y agoYeah the distance thing was ball parked, based on the last time I ran the numbers. To your point, I accidentally omitted to say “round trip from SF to NY” - I also used the great circle distance (2586mi) and ballparked a phone at 200g, roughly the weight of an iPhone. Thank you for going through the numbers and adding the sources. I was on my phone and meant to circle back.
- autocorr 6y agoCan someone explain how transactions are not insanely cost prohibitive for Bitcoin with power consumption figures like those? Those numbers would suggest something like >20 USD. Is it because most transactions in practice actually happen internally on exchanges that avoid putting every individual transaction on the blockchain? I have limited knowledge of Bitcoin so maybe not quite "explain like I'm five"... but close. :)
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- squeaky-clean 6y ago> Like literally every other piece of Bitcoin or crypto mining technology. I don't get this comparison because Nvidia isn't a Bitcoin mining technology company. Or at least they weren't until a week ago. When someone deems it not profitable to mine on a set of 50 GPUs they purchased, they can resell those to gamers. But these mining cards are just e-waste. > Don’t hate the player; hate the game. Games don't exist without players.
- vorpalhex 6y ago> When someone deems it not profitable to mine on a set of 50 GPUs they purchased, they can resell those to gamers. Except they can't. GPUs used for mining are trash - too much heat and stress continuously. Think about the average load on a consumer card used normally - maybe a daily 4 hour gaming binge max? Meanwhile a mining card is running near 100% capacity 24/7, probably without enough cooling.
- m4rtink 6y agoI have an exactly opposite experience - already got a second card from friends using them for mining when it was not good enough for them. Good price and both still working just fine for gaming. :)
- anonisko 6y agoAssuming the crypto bubble pops catastrophically and never recovers, yes we'll be left with a lot of worthless ASICs and GPUs, but also a ton of newly freed energy sources and chip manufacturing facilities, the development of which will have been funded or subsidized by the crypto speculative craze. A world with more access to energy and cheaper silicon chips is probably necessary to address the immense challenges civilization is facing.
- Forbo 6y agoLots of professional mining operations will actually undervolt the cards to get them to run more effeciently, decreasing electricity and cooling costs overall. Also there's less thermal stress due to them running constantly, so you don't get the physical stresses of fluctuation between hot/cold cycles.
- threeseed 6y agoNo. It's time to push back on Bitcoin. It is disgraceful to watch people such as Elon Musk and most of the VCs put money ahead of the environment.
- ubersync 6y agoI am sorry you did not buy it when it was cheaper. No need to hate it now because you were stupid back then.
- ShamelessC 6y agoThis comment is in clear violation of the site's rules. Please don't be deliberately rude to others here and try to interpret comments in good faith rather than as some sort of veiled attack.
- ardy42 6y ago>> No. It's time to push back on Bitcoin. >> It is disgraceful to watch people such as Elon Musk and most of the VCs put money ahead of the environment. > I am sorry you did not buy it when it was cheaper. No need to hate it now because you were stupid back then. You're obviously defensively making some false assumptions. The big one is probably assuming that people are primarily motivated by greed and jealousy, and that other motivations are fake and meant to disguise that. And for the record, I agree with the GP, and I've made quite a bit of money off of this bubble by selling some bitcoins I mined a decade ago.
- caycep 6y agoGiven the energy requirements and how it's kind of morphed into this beast of greed, I'm inclined to agree....but how to pull this off? Fiat bans cannot really work well against just doing math. Taxation schemes/financial regs tamping down on bitcoin speculation, what you can spend it on? By design I don't think you can just pump money into bitcoin in order to "deflate" its value without similarly consuming a lot of energy?
- lurgburg 6y ago
- ubersync 6y agoI am sick and tired of this bullshit logic, about how much energy per transaction Bitcoin uses. Bitcoin's blocksize is being forcibly kept low. It can easily be increased 100 MB, if not more, without causing any serious issues. That will increase the number of transactions per second to a thousand. Plus, comparing a Bitcoin transaction to a traditional transaction is like comparing apples and oranges. A Bitcoin transaction is completely different as it is irreversible. That energy consumption is the price we pay to make sure our transactions remain irreversible.
- heavenlyblue 6y agoOn the other hand if you were a person who needed to make a transaction in person because you can’t use banks for that (I.e. mafia) you would take that ride and probably spend even more energy commuting several people (arms, team of people) for a sufficiently large transaction. In the Wild West you would need maybe several horses each in order to exchange a certain amount of gold. What does the carbon usage be here? Bitcoin solves that problem in software, which is magnificent. For the same carbon footprint.
- paulsutter 6y agoBitcoin transactions use almost no power. Bitcoin SECURITY uses an immense amount of power, in order to make a 51% attack difficult. I'm not saying that's a good thing, I'm just saying its not the transactions that use power.
- gary_0 6y ago100 grams per transaction. Wow. That's sounds insane, but here's a reference: https://cen.acs.org/environment/sustainability/Bitcoin-poses-major-electronic-waste/97/i11 https://cen.acs.org/environment/sustainability/Bitcoin-poses...
- 015a 6y ago> Don’t hate the player; hate the game. Fuck that. I can hate the game, and the players who decide to play it. There's zero chance of ending the economic incentives of cryptocurrency mining without (global) government intervention. Instead, the best effort the US government has provided is increasing SUPPORT for it. Apple took a unique, aggressive, and still-controversial stance for privacy. This position has easily cost them a double-digit percent of their revenue; the amount of money they could generate from selling out their billion+ users, who are generally above-average income, in the same vein Google does, is unfathomable. I don't like Apple as a company, but I still feel its important to give them recognition for how industry-leading they were, and still are, in pushing for Privacy. There are ethics which can transcend corporate interest, even when considering negative PR. There are some things companies just don't do. The excuse of "optimizing shareholder profit" and "hate the game" is bullshit; it moves the onus of responsibility off of companies who are fully capable of acting more ethically by blaming some Invisible Hand as if they had no choice in the matter. That's bullshit. Jensen Huang had a choice. He made it. End of story. You want to shift some blame onto Ant and the miners themselves; that's all fair game for Round 2. But at this time, we're still on Round 1. Its reasonable for Nvidia to stand by and do nothing. Graphics cards are, after all, general purpose computing hardware. Even after they've outlived a useful life in a mining farm, those miners may attempt to extract an ROI by reselling them in secondary markets. Not ideal, but certainly better than Nvidia's plan for the future. Nvidia's plan is to, instead, support miners directly, while intentionally tiering consumer hardware, then positioning the entire move as somehow "Standing By Gamers". A dystopian science-fiction author legitimately could not write a more canonically evil storyline. I would change this position if Nvidia walks back, cancels the CMP line, and continues forward with driver limitations on the RTX 3060 with public plans to move to in-silicon ethereum mining protection on future cards; I think that's reasonable, given its fair to assume that the "ship has already sailed" on Ampere. Until then, fuck Nvidia; I'm not touching anything their hands are involved in.
- girvo 6y agoOne can easily hate both, no?
- mr_toad 6y ago> Time to push back on proof of waste, and end the economic incentive. That won’t stop Nvidia having a near monopoly on high end GPU. They use this to jack up the price of machine learning cards as well.
- tomnipotent 6y ago> They use this to jack up the price The Titan RTX is ~$2,500, which is incredibly well-priced considering that a 100G dual NIC is going to cost you $1,250.
- inter_netuser 6y agoJust give miners a 10 year tax break for using clean energy and they'll build a whole new green powergrid. At no cost to you, taxpayers, or anyone else. But no! Let's dispense with any rationality and just BAN TECHNOLOGY. It's rather strange to see so many luddites on HN advocating to ban technology they dislike. First, they came for the miners. You'll be cancelled someday too.