28 ms·
Articles like this miss the main point and instead focus on culture war material. There are plenty of sites that would happily accept more nuclear being built,
by epistasis 6y ago
Articles like this miss the main point and instead focus on culture war material. There are plenty of sites that would happily accept more nuclear being built, but all other forms of energy have undercut the cost of nuclear. It's no longer cost competitive, and places like China that adopt a "let's try everything and see what works best" approach have heavily pulled back on nuclear.
The issues aren't safety, waste, and environments opposition. There are plenty of climate hawks that support nuclear too. It's all excessive costs.
They briefly mention the cooling retrofits for Diablo Canyon in San Lui Obispo, but they don't mention that they bids from Bechtel to simply build a modern cooling system were all billions of dollars of expense. Just the cooling system is more expensive than alternatives.
And this is a trend we will see in the future. For primary generation of electrons, steam based thermodynamic cycles are pretty much obsolete. The number I typically hear is that it's $1-2W to build, say, a cooling system for coal steam. A nuclear plants cooling is pretty much identical. Solar and wind are going to undercut that cost very soon.
So the name of the game is now storage. Attaching four hours of storage to a solar generation farm, just enough to get through the duck curve, is now slightly cheaper than coal.
The best estimate of what the cheapest possible future grid looks like is: solar/wind capacity at 4x of total demand (thermal generators are roughly at 2x on the current grid), with 3-4 days of storage. This translates to world with abundant energy, at certain times, that's generated at zero marginal cost. There are still lots of transmission costs however. The future of energy is all about spatial and temporal arbitrage of renewable electrons.
- flaque 6y agoThis assumes that larger investment in nuclear won’t yield reduced costs, just as larger investments in solar did.
- afterburner 6y agoIt seems like the largest feature of modern nuclear power is that it got a lot more expensive as we realized how much safety we truly needed to build into it. Whereas, without much prompting, solar got a LOT cheaper. When nuclear develops that significantly, we will all pay attention. Until then, build cheaper sources. Also consider when building nuclear, you are locking into technology from 10 years ago (when the plant is finally done), for the next 50 years (when the plant is finally decommissioned). Solar and other sources have much faster iteration cycles and much lower commitment.
- hntrader 6y agoIsn't the point of nuclear to provide power when it's not sunny as a cheaper alternative to storage in batteries? If so then what's the purpose of comparing the cost of solar and nuclear as if they're directly competing for the same use case?
- afterburner 6y ago> Isn't the point of nuclear to provide power when it's not sunny as a cheaper alternative to storage in batteries? If so then what's the purpose of comparing the cost of solar and nuclear as if they're directly competing for the same use case? What the hell are you talking about.
- hntrader 6y agoSolar doesn't provide off peak power without storage. So comparing nuclear directly to solar in the way you've done makes no sense.
- afterburner 6y agoI believe solar and wind can provide for ALL power. Same as nuclear. That is the basis for my comparison.
- hntrader 6y agoStill doesn't make sense. Even if what you say is true, then the valid comparison is to compare nuclear to wind rather than nuclear to solar.
- afterburner 6y agoAgain, what the hell are you talking about. These are bad faith arguments. Moving goalposts, redefining everything. What a joke.
- orwin 6y agoIt would, but not as much as solar did. But people don't include recycling cost in PV, as well as electrical grid maintenance, impossibility to work as a baseline, no pilotability. Solar is good if the population is mature enough to accept the cost of sending PV to a recycling plant. And as long as it doesnt go past 50% of the energy production (you NEED a baseline of 30 to 40% at the very least)
- afterburner 6y ago> impossibility to work as a baseline Not true. Just overbuild it, and make sure your grid is large enough to transfer power between areas or just store it. Still cheaper than nuclear.
- orwin 6y agohttps://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0306261918312790 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S030626191...
- bryanlarsen 6y agoBase load power is unnecessary. The only type of power that's required is dispatchable power. If you have enough dispatchable power to meet peak demands you don't need anything else. For example, the northern towns served by a diesel generator. Other types of power are optional, but should be thrown into the mix for cost, reliability or environmental reasons.
- vlovich123 6y agoMy (perhaps erroneous) understanding nuclear is the only power source that can generate the power/heat that many very heavy industrial use cases need can’t be supplanted with renewables, no matter how inexpensive/efficient they are. That’s why countries like France have significantly lower coal usage whereas Germany has higher, even though both have similar levels of renewables.
- 6y ago
- simplicio 6y agoWe already tried that, didn't we? Several national gov'ts, subsidized the building of hundreds of reactors, trained gillions of nuclear scientists and engineers, etc. And indeed, nuclear power still is a bigger fraction of US electrical generation then renewables. Obviously, a new effort might yield a break-through the old one didn't. But it seems likely all the "low-hanging" fruit in lowering reactor costs have already been picked.
- zaik 6y agoGiven that nuclear has existed for quite some time now and hundreds of very costly plants have already been built, how much more cost-effectiveness can we expect? It feels like the current state is exactly what "larger investments" in nuclear get you.
- simplicio 6y agoObviously what we need is some sort of "Manhattan Project" for nuclear energy! :)
- pfdietz 6y agoThat was a very good one. :)
- sir_bearington 6y agoNuclear was considerably cheaper when it was built at scale. Both the US during the 70s and France both built plants at a cost of 1-2 billion per GW. Which, in the context of 24/7 carbon-free energy is fantastic.
- kragen 6y agoIt was fantastic for the 1970s, but it's not low enough to be competitive with current PV pricing, even with storage.
- sir_bearington 6y agoThere isn't remotely enough storage available to make renewables at all feasible for decarbonization. To put this in perspective 8 Gigawatt hours is just under one minute of storage for the United States' alone. This is why pointing to the the raw generation costs of intermittent sources is misleading. Generating another 500 MW of solar energy doesn't actually represent any decarbonization if that energy is produced when demand is already saturated.
- 6y ago
- lukeschlather 6y agoAccording to the IEA we are spending more on nuclear power research than any other category. (More than wind and solar combined.) More money won't magically give us better nuclear technology. If renewables keep getting better we're going to have to start some serious conversations about cutting nuclear funding in a few years, we're investing too much money with basically zero return on investment. https://www.iea.org/reports/energy-technology-rdd-budgets-2020 https://www.iea.org/reports/energy-technology-rdd-budgets-20...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- balfirevic 6y ago> According to the IEA we are spending more on nuclear power research than any other category. Does that include fusion research?
- vkou 6y agoHow much of this R&D goes into nuclear power research, and how much of it is nuclear weapons research that is billed as power research? For example, the laser fusion research that hit 'break even' a few days ago was a byproduct of work on nuclear weapons.
- Zigurd 6y agoThere is a track record for nuclear and the line does not go in the good direction. Even France, which is often cited as a nuclear success, has underfunded decommissioning costs by a factor of 3 or 4. Building nuclear results in gouging ratepayers.
- galangalalgol 6y agoA grid that relies on transmission to that degree will require unifying some disparate grids won't it? Also it seems horribly vulnerable to attacks digital or physical.
- afterburner 6y agoIf you're worried about attacks, you should be even more worried about nuclear.
- Enginerrrd 6y agoNot really. This is actually a primary design consideration taken very seriously at nuke plants. The same can NOT be said about the rest of the grid, and renewable generation facilities.
- afterburner 6y ago> This is actually a primary design consideration taken very seriously at nuke plants. Yeah, because they're so dangerous. If you're worried about the grid, you were always worried. We use a grid now, and in the past. Massive near-continent wide failures happened before major renewable use.
- galangalalgol 6y agoProtecting single facilities is very hard, protecting an entire grid seems impossible. Ild hope for a decentralized grid where every generator, user, and conveyer of electricity was assumed to potentially be a subverted actor. But that seems super hard.
- biren34 6y agoI'm squarely of the opposite opinion. There are 2 main concerns I think "only renewables" solutions miss: 1. Impact on land usage. The sheer amount of land required to provide 3-4x global use is impractical and has major environmental consequences. It's not free to pave over large areas with solar panels or make huge swaths of air unsafe for birds. 2. Cost of storage is usually projected using current prices with some decline due to production efficiencies. However, producing grid-sized storage would put such pressure on the supply of critical metals that the subsequent price rise would put bitcoin's performance to shame. Whereas, we know we can scale nuclear to meet global demand, at least as a major base load supply as part of a mixed-generation strategy.
- afterburner 6y agoYou're worried about birds? Better raze all buildings and kill all the cats. Wind turbine bird deaths are negligible. https://www.evwind.es/2020/10/01/the-realities-of-bird-and-bat-deaths-by-wind-turbines/77477 https://www.evwind.es/2020/10/01/the-realities-of-bird-and-b... You know you can set up solar panels on roofs, and in the desert, right?
- vlovich123 6y agoDeserts are not ecosystems devoid of all life. Here’s a life long anti-nuclear activist talking about how his direct experience in this space evolved as he started looking into the data more: https://www.ted.com/talks/michael_shellenberger_why_i_changed_my_mind_about_nuclear_power?language=en https://www.ted.com/talks/michael_shellenberger_why_i_change...
- afterburner 6y agoYou know deserts are BIG, right?
- throwaway894345 6y agoCan you please contribute something other than snark?
- StreamBright 6y ago>> It's no longer cost competitive If you compare apples to oranges it is not. Once you start to compare apples to apples it is very competitive. What do I mean by this? People like to compare nuclear to wind or solar. There is a fundamental difference. Wind or solar is not controlled by the energy demand while a nuclear power plat's energy production is. This is why you cannot compare them. If you talk about solar or renewables you should talk about: - the production part (solar panels or wind mills) - the energy storage part (some sort of batteries or pumped-storage hydroelectricity) - if you do not want to build either batteries of pumped-storage then you have to build in the same amount of quickly accessible power source (this is natural gas turbines mostly) There are few other challenges: - solar or windmills require massive amount of construction because the energy density is very low - the damage to nature with windmills especially is bad (there is preemptive maintenance during animal activity for many of the windmills) - weather can damage these facilities - the lifetime of windmills or solar panels are much shorter than nuclear power plant lifetimes Given all these and the general public's hatred towards nuclear energy largely fuelled by politicians many countries shut down research into nuclear with very few exceptions. Instead, these countries invested billions into renewables without much success yet. I think soon we are going to be at a tipping point when this whole circus ends and we are going to get back on track with nuclear which is much needed in the coming of space era.
- jasonwatkinspdx 6y agoIt's straightforward accounting to address the issue you mean. Go read Lazard's levelized cost of energy slides. The cost comparison isn't some sort of mystery everyone but you is getting wrong.
- StreamBright 6y agoThanks, it just confirming what I thought. Solar is in the same bracket as nuclear. The difference is pretty small. Adding the energy density to the mix makes it obvious which one is a better option.
- pfdietz 6y ago
- js2 6y ago> steam based thermodynamic cycles Technical question: my understanding is that the frequency of an electrical grid is literally related to the RPM of turbines providing power, and that over/under frequency are related to supply and demand. https://www.brighthubengineering.com/power-plants/45640-grid-frequency-and-speed-effects-on-power-generation/ https://www.brighthubengineering.com/power-plants/45640-grid... If we hypothetically had a grid that was 100% solar, presumably there'd no longer be any spinning turbines. At that point, would the grid frequency be completely synthetic? How would supply/demand impact the frequency in that case? Edit: partially answered here ("smart inverters): https://www.energy.gov/eere/solar/solar-integration-inverters-and-grid-services-basics https://www.energy.gov/eere/solar/solar-integration-inverter...
- ouchjars 6y agoSouth Australia, which generated 60% of its electricity with renewables last year, is installing synchronous condensers to provide some kind of grid stabilisation. (The current conservative government is aiming for net 100% renewables by 2030 and 500% by 2050.)
- throwaway894345 6y agoDo solar and wind cost estimates account for the sheer volume of land? How much land would be required to convert us fully to green energy (where “fully” means not only replacing existing electrical applications but also transforming other fossil-fuel operations such as transport and various heavy industry applications and residential/commercial heating and etc)? Also, don’t we need more storage than 4 hours? What about those times when weather patterns mean little sun or wind for days or weeks on the scale of the whole country? I’m not trying to be a wind/solar pessimist; these seem like important questions and I don’t hear them discussed often.
- maxerickson 6y agoWinter is hard to store for, but in general there aren't times where both sun and wind are low production across wide areas. Of course solar isn't operating at night, but wind keeps blowing. One way to check this would be to find a wind farm that publishes their output over time. Looks like NREL has some good resources: https://www.nrel.gov/grid/wind-toolkit.html https://www.nrel.gov/grid/wind-toolkit.html
- throwaway894345 6y ago> in general there aren't times where both sun and wind are low production across wide areas. I'm sure those times aren't common, but we need to have some answer for when they do inevitably occur. The recent Texas freeze was a once-in-a-century event and I don't think many consider that acceptable (and I would think that the no-sun / no-wind scenarios are more frequent than once-in-a-century). I'm sure someone has researched the amount of storage necessary, but the numbers I've heard from articles and podcasts tend to be in the days-weeks range--much longer than 4 hours.
- pfdietz 6y agoYes, they include the value of land. In Texas, for example, land cost for PV might be a couple percent of the cost of a PV field.
- 6y ago
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- airhead969 6y agoI worked in nuclear. There's definitely no way now to insure a new plant and make money. Try as they may, even Duke couldn't break ground on any new US project because there hasn't been money in it for about 40 years. The economics kill it and there aren't going to be anymore PWR/BWRs, with the possible exceptions of BCH, 2 PWRs at Turkey Point, and 1 ESBWR at North Anna. Renewables will likely undercut them all to cancellation.
- undefined1 6y agohow much of that is due to regulations or other overhead or inefficiencies? e.g., "China Tariffs Blocked Bill Gates’ Plan for Safe Nuclear Power" https://futurism.com/trump-china-tariffs-bill-gates-nuclear-power https://futurism.com/trump-china-tariffs-bill-gates-nuclear-... also, SpaceX managed to make reusable rockets, I just have to imagine we could make nuclear energy feasible if we approached it from first principles and took a hard look at the entire process.
- epistasis 6y agoI always ask: what regulation would you change? Nobody in the nuclear industry has suggestions for what is unnecessary, as far as I can tell. And as Texas showed us last week, without regulations, profit motive alone is not enough to maintain proper equipment. The nuclear plant that tripped off could have made months worth of profit in less than a day. Yet they did not do simple weatherization preparations that they knew they should have based on 2011's events.
- airhead969 6y agoThe usual answer from the unreasonable, irrational, and selfish Rand Paul-types is "gubberment always too big, so regulations bad." I would modify Madison's quote: If everyone were angelic, proactive, and wise, no government or regulations would be necessary. Since none of these can ever be true, government and regulations will always be essential. I'm in Austin and froze for 3 days because of piss-poor under-regulation due to lack of grid and backup power investment. ERCOT did they best they could while under-resourced and then thrown under the bus by the MSM and libertarian, anarcho-capitalist sympathizers like Abbott.
- dalbasal 6y agoIt's hard to put your finger on the true "main point." Energy, especially nuclear energy has always been fraught, politically and technically. Your point is definitely poignant currently. Renewables are looking like a good bet atm. A fundamental point is that nuclear energy has a lot of potential, ultimately. The debate will always be about investing in nuclear now. Long term, it's hard to imagine nuclear energy doesn't have a place. In fact, it's surprising that nuclear energy hasn't been a bigger gamechanger. That's my last point. Nuclear energy has been, historically, somewhere between "eh" and disappointing. Applicable where natural gas is inconvenient. The fact that most nuclear plants them are nuclear powered steam engines... something not right. Generally, nuclear is promising. Particularly, the options available to a region that needs power just aren't that attractive.
- ortusdux 6y agoI've done a fair amount of research into molten salt reactors, and if we can solve the containment issue they should be very cost effective. The molten salts are extremely corrosive, which cuts their lifespan down to ~5 years. Newer designs should reach 10 years and there is extensive research into designing systems that will last 20+ years. They should be much cheaper to build and operate because they have several inherent safety features. They operate at one atmosphere, so you don't need expensive pressure containment systems. The fissile material is already melted, so meltdowns are basically impossible. Most designs have a drain line to a gravity fed safety containment vessel full of control rods. The drain line is actively cooled to solidify the salt, forming a plug that automatically melts during a power loss or over-temperature event.
- calaphos 6y agoGiven the enourmous costs of decommissioning nuclear power plants already I fail to see how a reactor containment that lasts 10-20 years at best improves the situation.
- epistasis 6y agoThis is solving the wrong problem, and therefore will not advance nuclear. Cost is the impediment to nuclear, not any sort of safety concerns. That molten salt reactor will need to have a negative cost in order to compete with the cost of stored renewable energy. The future of nuclear energy must either abandon the thermal steam cycle for electricity generation, or generate massive value from the nuclear reaction part apart from generating steam.
- sofixa 6y ago> Cost is the impediment to nuclear, not any sort of safety concerns That's not entirely true, and safety features and regulations are a major part of nuclear's cost. > That molten salt reactor will need to have a negative cost in order to compete with the cost of stored renewable energy Does stored renewable energy come for free? From what i recall, there's still no actual solution to that problem on a big scale.
- blabitty 6y agoForgive my nitpick but power generation doesn't generate electrons it pushes existing ones around, very slowly. Highly recommend http://amasci.com/miscon/whatis.html http://amasci.com/miscon/whatis.html to anyone interested in discovering how inconsistently electrical concepts are defined and taught.
- epistasis 6y agoThat was an especially unfortunate typo in a post riddled with typos. I will stand by my use of electron arbitrage though.
- Ono-Sendai 6y agoI don't think you are correct. For electricity to propagate at near light speed, electrons will have to move at near light speed, if only for a short time. Or to be a little more precise, shape changes in the electron wavefunction will need to propagate at near light speed. I think we can do this to electrons because their mass is so low. This only really applies when a circuit is opened or closed however. Once a circuit reaches a stable state (voltage is unchanged) the electrons don't move fast, I guess.
- StillBored 6y agoNo, he is correct, its the wave that propagates at a fraction of the speed of light (depending on the conductor). The electrons themselves don't move very fast. "An electron travels at a speed of about 1 cm/sec. " (in copper) per: https://www.informit.com/articles/article.aspx?p=2916283&seqNum=4 https://www.informit.com/articles/article.aspx?p=2916283&seq... This should be taught in a basic AP physics class in HS (where i initially heard it). I vaguely remember doing some of these calculations in my physics for engineers class as a first year engineering student too.
- Ono-Sendai 6y agoThat article is probably wrong too. A changed electric field requires a change in the position of electrons. Hence a fast signal change requires fast position changes.
- iso8859-1 6y ago> China that adopt a "let's try everything and see what works best" approach have heavily pulled back on nuclear. They have brought 15 GW online the last 5 years, and they have another 15 GW under construction. How is that pulling back? https://www.world-nuclear.org/information-library/country-profiles/countries-a-f/china-nuclear-power.aspx https://www.world-nuclear.org/information-library/country-pr...
- philipkglass 6y agoIt's still the country building the most new nuclear power, but it's also reducing ambitions from just a few years ago. From your own link: The 13th Five-Year Plan formalized in March 2016 included the following nuclear projects and aims: ... Reach target of 58 GWe nuclear operational by end of 2020, plus 30 GWe under construction then. China actually has 47.5 GWe operational now. See table "Operable nuclear power reactors" in your link. They fell short of the 2020 target and with only 15 GWe under construction they're not catching up with their original goals either.
- sudosysgen 6y agoA large part of that is actually due to civilian opposition after Fukushima that led local governments to attempt to get others to build nuclear. The really long term Chinese goals are ~80% nuclear still.
- boomboomsubban 6y agoFalling 20% short of a five year plan that included 2020 is not strong evidence they're pulling back.
- philipkglass 6y agoThat 58 gigawatt goal for 2020 was already less ambitious than the goal of 70 GW by 2020 from 2012. "China may resume approving nuke plants in H1" (January 2012) https://www.reuters.com/article/china-nuclear/china-may-resume-approving-nuke-plants-in-h1-media-idUSL3E8CI0B120120118 https://www.reuters.com/article/china-nuclear/china-may-resu... The government will resume approving new plants after the announcement of the nuclear safety plan which recently won clearance from the Ministry of Environmental Protection (MEP), the China Securities Journal said. The report also said in order to meet the government-set target of having non-fossil fuels to supply 15 percent of China’s primary energy use by 2020, the total installed nuclear capacity should not fall under 70 gigawatts (GW) by then. That in turn was less ambitious than the 2020 nuclear goals China had before the Fukushima accident. "Nuclear power to rise 10-fold by 2020" (July 2009) https://www.chinadaily.com.cn/china/2009-07/02/content_8346480.htm https://www.chinadaily.com.cn/china/2009-07/02/content_83464... China is planning for an installed nuclear power capacity of 86 gigawatts by 2020, up nearly 10-fold from the 9 GW capacity it had by the end of last year, two people familiar with the matter said.
- johncolanduoni 6y agoSolar power (or any other type of terrestrial power source) does not generate or capture electrons, so I don’t know what you’re trying to say about steam cycles. Similarly I can’t imagine what you mean by arbitrage of renewable electrons, a charged battery doesn’t have any more electrons in it than an empty battery.
- slfnflctd 6y ago> Attaching four hours of storage to a solar generation farm, just enough to get through the duck curve, is now slightly cheaper than coal This completely ignores scenarios of extended cloud cover, cold temperatures and low wind (somewhat like we just saw in Texas) where properly winterized baseline power would be the only way to keep everything up the whole way through. Barring future unknown tech, we will always need either nuclear or natural gas if we want five nines of uptime in our electrical power. There is just no practical way currently to build enough storage across the grid to maintain 100% uptime during a week or more of reduced renewable generation.
- epistasis 6y agoIf I were in Texas last week, I would have loved to have a home solar system with a battery that let me island from the grid. This is definitely practical and happening even at today's high prices. In a decade, ERCOT will look nothing like it does today. It will have massive amounts of solar and storage, and even more wind. This is replacing gas plants as they age out.
- jfubxyb 6y agoA buddy of mine has solar panels. During the storm they got covered in ice and snow, and generated about 180 watt hours in a 24 hour period
- epistasis 6y agoThis is not a typical experience, from what I've heard. But for exceptional cases, in addition to fixed storage in our homes, we should be able to use our EV batteries for items of exceptional need, as they typically can handle 3-4 days worth of energy needs.
- selimthegrim 6y agoYou would think that but some municipalities like New Orleans are addicted to the franchise taxes from new gas plants and roll over for the utilities (I am speaking about the South in general)
- fsflover 6y ago>but all other forms of energy have undercut the cost of nuclear. It's no longer cost competitive If markets valued the low-CO2 nature of nuclear, they’d be doing better https://whatisnuclear.com/economics.html https://whatisnuclear.com/economics.html
- lrem 6y ago> Attaching four hours of storage to a solar generation farm, just enough to get through the duck curve, is now slightly cheaper than coal. How much would attaching two weeks of storage, which is how long panels around here have been under 20cm of snow twice this winter, cost?
- temp8964 6y agosolar generation farm takes way too much land. If it's in a desert, that would be fine. But many of them are on otherwise beautiful mountains, how can this be environmentally acceptable?
- Zigurd 6y ago"It's no longer cost competitive" is just the tip of the financial iceberg. Nukes are no longer price competitive, if they ever were, even with all the unpaid externalities: Waste containment and storage is a public sector megaproject. Nuclear plants are not insurable. Set-asides for decommissioning are gamed by selling plants nearing EOL.
- macspoofing 6y ago>There are plenty of sites that would happily accept more nuclear being built, but all other forms of energy have undercut the cost of nuclear. Honestly ... it isn't just about cost. Nuclear is expensive but it isn't prohibitively expensive. The big picture is we know that nuclear can power an economy, it does not emit global warming gasses, and also places a tiny footprint on the surrounding ecosystem. Solar and wind cannot power an economy. But let's pretend they can so as to not get bogged down on this point. Let's also pretend they are non-trivially cheaper than nuclear. Even under those assumptions nuclear still wins in my eyes. Global warming is only one environmental problem we have to solve and it may not be the most important one either. The other one is regular environmental collapse due to needing to support 7-10 billion people. In this context, solar and wind are atrocious and a total disaster because they have massive land-use requirements (land-use around mining for necessary materials, deployment and maintenance of the collectors, and finally land-fill once out of use). And they will always have those horrendous land-use requirements because solar and wind are diffuse energy sources. Worse, we're going to need to increase solar and wind collector production by several orders of magnitude (and come up with a battery technology that doesn't exist today) to fully support a fossil fuel transition. What cost do you think the environment will bear for that compared to nuclear infrastructure?
- brightball 6y agoThe thing about land use that always got me was that solar can be implemented as a roofing system in parking lots. We have a lot of parking lots out there. IMO the model used for parking at Lego Land looks like the ideal approach for solar expansion to me.
- macspoofing 6y ago>The thing about land use that always got me was that solar can be implemented as a roofing system in parking lots. That's not enough. Rooftop solar panels on a single family home roof cannot provide adequate power for even that family (forget even trying to use appliances like washer/dryer/stove when on solar, much less charging your electric car). And if they cannot do that, then how the hell are they going to provide power to even moderate-density housing (e.g. a small apartment building), much less high-density buildings and housing (like office buildings), or heavy industry and transportation (from electric cars, to buses, to trains). Solar and wind are diffuse energy sources. That will never change. So you will always have to have a large number of collectors. Our population will continue to go up for a few more decades. Our per capita energy use will also keep going up for a few more decades. So you're going to have to build huge solar and wind farms and place them somewhere. You're going to have to mine necessary minerals to build those farms from somewhere. You're going to have to landfill the collectors somewhere.
- dmix 6y agoHow much of the cost thing like the $1B cooling solution because Diablo Canyon was an “old” design from the 70s. I’d imagine future investment doesn’t doesn’t mean building more Diablo style reactors. A big problem that promoting nuclear usually comes with plenty of arguments in the form of the problems of old reactors (like the Tokyo disaster one being built in the 1950s).
- ed25519FUUU 6y agoTo be fair this is California, which can’t been been a mile of high speed rail for under $1B. It means absolutely nothing in terms of costs.
- lisper 6y ago> all other forms of energy have undercut the cost of nuclear Only because the cost of carbon emissions are externalized. If carbon were properly accounted for, nuclear would most likely be economically viable.
- pyrale 6y agoA significant part of the cost issues come with how the market is structured. If consumers can buy power on a hourly basis, nuclear plants can not be more expensive than gas/coal (and even with some carbon tax, this is not going to be sky high prices), and can not make a profit during abundant renewable availability, because renewables drive prices close to zero. If you structured markets by selling kW rather than kWh, renewables would have to bear the cost of low wind/sun availability, either by building storage or by pairing with fossil power producers. This would price the stability of production, which is simply not priced today.
- screye 6y agoAfaik, nuclear energy is more expensive only because it is regulated far beyond what any other form of energy for the same level of risk. Disposal of nuclear waste is a huge expense, but the main waste product generated by natural gas (CO2) gets away scot free despite literally being the cause of what might be our generation's biggest problem. The end-of-life expenses of nuclear plants are included in the cost sheets, but dams get away scot free. Material procurement is justifiably expensive, since security measures for handling nuke-fuel are far more stringent. But, that is more a virtue of global politics than the actual cost of nuclear energy. Another cold-start problem is that the USA does not have the same experience with frequently building nuclear plants, vs say a country like France has. Thus, any new contractor spends extra money to be the first to wade through bureaucratic / training related challenges that would otherwise have been resolved if building nuclear plants was more common place. Just saying, the numbers for energy source comparison aren't always as fair as they look. _______ > Attaching four hours of storage to a solar generation farm, just enough to get through the duck curve, is now slightly cheaper than coal. Wow, I didn't know we were that close to dealing with the storage/temporal variability problem. If we can solve that problem with money to spare, then I can see the adoption of solar + wind going up through the roof.
- cycomanic 6y agoThat's simply not true. Nuclear has always and is still receiving significant indirect subsidies. A huge subsidy that nuclear power gets is that plants are not insured against incidents (because essentially nobody is willing to sell them insurance), so it's essentially the state that does it. Also many argue that the nuclear waste storage costs are significantly underestimated, I mean I understand estimating cost for safe storage for thousands of years is difficult. Interesting you mentioned France, the only project they are building is Flammanville 3 which started in 2007 with an estimated cost of ~3 billion euros, it is now estimated to go online in 2022 with an estimated cost of 19 billion euros. That's just construction cost. Regarding the cost for decommissioning, the European commission has actually called out France for currently significantly underfunding the cost by a factor of 3 or 4.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- cbmuser 6y ago> It's no longer cost competitive, and places like China that adopt a "let's try everything and see what works best" approach have heavily pulled back on nuclear. Another renewables advocate who equals the LCOE (levelized cost of energy) with the system costs, completely ignoring that it’s not the LCOE which drives up the costs for renewables, it’s the necessary backup plants unless you have access to lots of hydro power per capita. Case in point. France: 50 million tons CO2 p.a. in the energy sector, 50 g/kWh Germany: 350 million tons CO2 p.a. in the energy sector, 400 g/kWh Germany: 31 Euro-Cents/kWh France: 18 Euro-Cents/kWh Please stop spreading the “nuclear is expensive” narrative.
- thewarrior 6y agoCompletely disagree with this assessment. Storage is the key problem. There are no easy solutions and you need scalable capacity that can quickly spin up in the mean time. Otherwise you’ll have to build some sort of crazy world wide energy internet that won’t be finished in time to beat climate change.
- epistasis 6y agoI agree that storage is the key challenge. But it's a lot easier for us to build storage than it is to build new nuclear. In the time it takes to build new nuclear, we can build two consecutive generations of battery factories. We do this all the time, lots of different companies are building battery factories, and they never get delayed or abandoned due to inability to build. Nuclear, even if we were happy to throw all the money we have at it, is not a climate solution because it can not be deployed quickly enough. In addition to its economic costs in terms of labor and materials, it has huge time costs, and it's now too late to try to build something that may or may not be able to scale. We have zero examples in the West of being able to build nuclear in a scaleable manner within the past 30 years. It's all failure after failure. And the only reason that any utility has tried again is 1) regulatory capture to put all the economic risk on ratepayers, and 2) intensive lobbying of utility executives to make the bad economic decision to try nuclear once again. SMRs are literally the only hope for nuclear in the US, and even their best predictions don't look that great.
- credit_guy 6y agoYou implicitly assume the goal is to replace the current power generation capacity. What if the goal is to increase it 10 times? The US and Western Europe got to a point that's possibly close to "peak power", but what about China, India, Pakistan, Africa? Billions of people who hope to reach the living standards of the Americans one day.
- tedk-42 6y agoJust stop the anti-nuclear argument please. Cost shouldn't be a thing if it means we can avoid a climate disaster. The whole, 'nuclear is too expensive' argument was had 10 years ago with electric vehicles and look where we are now. If cost is your main motivation to be anti-nuclear, you're hiding a bias whether you're aware of it or not. We need a replacement for base load power and nuclear can fill that capacity.
- thinkcontext 6y agoCost is certainly relevant. Its the reason that older plants are shutting down in the US, because even though they are already operating they can't compete with gas. Cost is also the reason that what was supposed to be the reactor of the US's nuclear renaissance, the AP1000, has had all its projects cancelled. The two projects that started construction under Obama were financial failures, with one getting cancelled after spending $9B on a hole in the ground, the other is about to go online after going 2x+ over budget for time and money.
- teslaberry 6y agoChina-nuclear plants , not wind or solar. only for export . India--nuclear plants, no wind/solar. Texas. Keep telling yourself that grid batteries solve every problem with renewables, let alone all intermitancy issues with renewables anytime soon. you're living in your own bubble.
- kragen 6y agoAs I said the other day, nuclear energy is the Amiga of energy sources. Ahead of its time, it was unjustly rejected and persecuted by the ignorant masses. Its advocates are bonded by the quiet pride that at least they weren't unthinkingly siding with those masses. (And they're right!) Meanwhile, as the Amiga stagnated for terribly unfair reasons, other, scrappier technologies like the i386 and UMG-Si grew from being worthless boondoggles (except in special circumstances, like spaceflight) to being actually far better and cheaper. But the Amiga advocates keep the faith, sharing their suffering and resentment. They inevitably try the alternatives a little and perhaps even start to like them. Gradually their denial recedes, decade by decade. But they know that however much fab costs go down and leave their beloved Amiga behind in the dust, you'll never be able to run nuclear submarines and Antarctic research stations on solar panels. You say, "Solar and wind are going to undercut that cost very soon." But the truth is that wind, where available, undercut the cost of steam power (including nuclear and coal) a decade ago, and PV undercut it in equatorial parts of the world about four years ago, or even more of the world if you don't include storage.
- LargoLasskhyfv 6y agoGuru Meditäyshun!
- belorn 6y ago> So the name of the game is now storage. If I look at my own country (Sweden) at what is currently being planned on a political level and invested in, the name of the game is to use fossil fuels under a plethora of different schemes which hides the fact. The first and primary scheme is to call the energy grid free of fossil fuel if the total amount of renewable energy being exported each year exceed that of imported fossil fueled energy. Find someone willing to buy the energy at some point in year, and you can subtract the numbers from fossil fuel usage during other parts of the year. In order to sustain increased capacity the government uses tax money to invest into better power line connections between countries for higher export and imports. The second strategy is to use tax money to pay fossil fueled power plants directly, but rather than calling it a subsidy which would have a negative connotation, we call it "reserve energy plan". Fossil fuel plants first get paid for just being a fossil fuel plant that is ready to start the generators at demand, and then they can get paid a second time for any energy they do generate. The third scheme is to use fossil fuels to create artificial fertilizers, grow and harvest biomass using machines that operate on fossil fuels, transport the biomass on ships that travel on fossil fuels, and then call it carbon neutral when we burn it. Storage for wind farms (or the much smaller portion of solar that we have) is not being planned, invested or built. It is not being discussed on a political level. No tax money direct to it. I would like it if storage was cheaper than the above schemes because then maybe they would go away. I do not want tax money to be given fossil fuel. I would prefer if a ultimatum was set in the energy sector so fossil fuels no longer is a possible choice. Under such ultimatum we would find out very quickly which of the choices between storage and nuclear is cheapest, and then it would hopefully see some actually investment.
- StillBored 6y agoThe costs of wind/solar are basically lies. The numbers are based on best case generation and fail to account for storage, and overbuild requirements to supply that storage. AKA today you say wind is X dollars a MWh, but in order to actually be free of NG or other fossil fuels it needs to be built at some multiple of total demand (say 3X) to compensate for low periods. Then there you need sufficient storage (4 hours is a joke) to smooth it all out. In the end the actual cost is ballpark an order of magnitude more per MWh if one actually tried to run 100% renewables. You need only dig up the recent TX ERCOT generation numbers to see just how useless wind/solar can be. It was functioning at less than 1/10 of its installed capacity for the entire week. During most of the winter months its a good 1/3 of its summer peaks/etc. And that is one of the leading wind providers in the entire world. Nukes are really the only technology we could deploy in the next 5-10 year to completely eliminate CO2 production in the electricity grid. Build enough of them to supply peak generation and rather than trying to load follow use the excess energy for syngas production via CO2 recapture and it would be possible to turn a part of the vehicle fleet carbon neutral as well.
- afterburner 6y agoAre you seriously bringing up the wind turbines that ERCOT repeatedly failed to winterize and failed in a major storm as evidence that wind turbines are bad? This is an extremely bad faith argument. Wind turbines in the rest of the country where it's even colder aren't failing, because they're actually built for the weather, and the power company didn't cheap out.
- StillBored 6y agoIt was mostly the NG plants the didn't get winterized and weren't available, in some cases due to lack of NG. The wind actually was after some initial glitches AFAIK working as expected. Pretty much everything failed (including a nuke). My point wasn't that there were failures, its that the wind capacity was pretty poor leading up to the failures too. Why that is, isn't clear to me other than its apparently not unusual to have significantly less during the winter in TX. This isn't usually a problem because the demand is low as well. (random link with graphs, these are a bit harder than the one I was looking for but are good enough https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2021/02/19/climate/texas-storm-power-generation-charts.html https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2021/02/19/climate/texas...) edit: maybe the first graph here https://pv-magazine-usa.com/2021/02/17/3-graphs-that-shed-light-on-the-ercot-power-crisis/ https://pv-magazine-usa.com/2021/02/17/3-graphs-that-shed-li... shows just how poorly the wind was performing, even before the storm relative to its peak.
- ekianjo 6y ago> It's no longer cost competitive There is no equivalent in energy density. And this is what matters the most.
- mikedilger 6y agoI'm glad you said storage and not "batteries". Batteries are not even in the ballpark for this kind of usage. The reasonable means of storage are hydroelectric (via water) and offsetting usage of fuels (coal/natural gas/oil/wood/biogas/nuclear). I'm pro-hydro because it is reliable (24h/day) throttable, significant, non-emitting, renewable, and behaves like a battery. The downside is that locals will lose their precious local ecosystem under the reservior. Some costs are worth paying. There has been concern that reservoirs emit methane - this is easily solvable by evacuating the plant material and topsoil ahead of time. As for the concrete issue, I don't have any good answers. If you really want solar/wind at 4x demand capacity, then the hydro reservoirs could be refilled by pumping water from a lower reservoir. But I think a better mix is just more hydro: use wind/solar when you have it, hydro when you don't. To back up my battery point, I'll quote Bill Gate's new book: "How many batteries would they need in order to power Tokyo for three days, until the storm passes and they can turn the turbines back on? The answer is more than 14 million [1kwh thought experiment varity $100] batteries. That's more storage capacity than the world produces in a decade."
- EricE 6y agoChina is increasing its spending in molten salt reactors; they are NOT pulling back. And not all designs have to be expensive. Turns out smaller can be dramatically better: https://www.forbes.com/sites/llewellynking/2020/10/13/new-design-molten-salt-reactor-is-cheaper-to-run-consumes-nuclear-waste/?sh=5057fc5533c6 https://www.forbes.com/sites/llewellynking/2020/10/13/new-de... Lots of smaller distributed generation sources closer to the points of consumption also help with complexities (and fragilities!) in the electrical grid. Also solves the issues around transmission loss as well. Solar and wind are not going to undercut costs any time soon. For every current nuclear plant that gets taken offline, the bulk of the load is made up for with fossil fuel generation. If solar and wind were as awesome as you are convinced, then why aren't they picking up the slack? Until we come up with something far better than current battery technology for energy storage, solar and wind will never be more than a niche solution. The disproportionate amount of money being dumped into them is downright criminal when proven technology such as molten salt reactors is overlooked for either political or emotional reasons.