7 ms·
What if rather than taxing bitcoin, we just tax carbon usage?
by whimsicalism 6y ago
What if rather than taxing bitcoin, we just tax carbon usage?
- sega_sai 6y agoI think it is probably good to tax for Co2 production as a way of addressing global warming. I just don't think we should equate bitcoin production with other CO2 producers. I.e. I personally think that the CPU-cycles used for science on HPCs are much more valuable than the bitcoin mining (that's just my opinion though).
- xur17 6y agoAs you noted, this is just your opinion - are we going to have a person or group that decides what forms of Co2 usage are most "worthy", and adjust taxes accordingly? And let's say we do go down that path - one could certainly make the argument that Bitcoin usage from folks fleeing oppressive regimes are much more worthy than Co2 used to search for aliens or participating in far out HPC research.
- whimsicalism 6y agoIncentivizing stupid things (like taking on mortgage debt or over-coverage by employer health plan) is already the status quo of the tax code. > Bitcoin usage from folks fleeing oppressive regimes Have bitcoin people (I don't know what else to call the people who want to talk about it all the time) actually convinced themselves that this is a substantial share of bitcoin usage?
- imtringued 6y ago>Have bitcoin people (I don't know what else to call the people who want to talk about it all the time) actually convinced themselves that this is a substantial share of bitcoin usage? It's not because this is literally Monero's value proposition. Why would anyone who wants to flee an oppressive regime publicly announce to their government that they bought Bitcoin in the oppressed country and sold it in a less oppressive country? Information about Monero (don't dare to even think of buying it for speculation) https://www.monero.how/how-does-monero-work-details-in-plain-english https://www.monero.how/how-does-monero-work-details-in-plain...
- whimsicalism 6y agoHow do I cash out monero?
- noobly 6y ago>don't dare to even think of buying it for speculation why not?
- sega_sai 6y agoI think, yes, somebody should adjust taxes accordingly. The status quo with existing costs and taxes already effectively establishes some preferences for industries/goals, just implicitely. I think trying to explicitely express those preferences is better. (and it will never be 100% optimal that's for sure)
- imtringued 6y agoThis is a terrible argument because the transaction fees on Bitcoin are high enough that anyone who wants to flee an oppressive regime would just buy any other cryptocurrency that isn't suffering from power consumption problems.
- xur17 6y agoFees are $3 if you are willing to wait 12 hours, otherwise $5 for 30 minutes.
- xur17 6y agoI agree, taxing carbon usage is the correct way to go about this. All the ways I can think of taxing Bitcoin directly wouldn't modify the right behaviors. It seems like the options would be: * Tax Bitcoin transactions - decreasing Bitcoin transactions wouldn't decrease energy usage * Tax Bitcoin holdings - this is already accomplished via capital gains taxes, and again, it isn't the holding or usage of Bitcoin that causes the energy usage. It's the fact that Bitcoin has value that causes usage.
- toyg 6y ago* Aggressively taxing GPU sales, with exemptions for some sectors and hard monitoring of commercial flows.
- xur17 6y agoWell for 1, that won't affect Bitcoin mining since it hasn't been profitable to mine on a GPU for years, and 2 that will just force mining overseas to locales that don't have this tax (possibly to locales that have less carbon efficient energy sources).
- gruez 6y agoGPUs are made in china/taiwan so good luck with that.
- thysultan 6y agoYou tax carbon, country B now has an advantage over you. You loose! Now all your products are produced in country B, you've changed nothing and country B is probably using coal so you're worse off from your initial goal. You loose double!
- jbay808 6y agoThis is why you sign up for an international treaty that has teeth, ratify it, and back it up with penalties including carbon tariffs.
- thysultan 6y agoName one international treaty that has ever had teeth where the benefits of non-conformance out weight the teeth. Country B could tarrif country A in return and some countries cannot afford the cost of what that may do to them. So you end up with an international treaty without international conformance or a treaty with no real teeth because the signee's have contributed to it what would allow "them" to game the treaty.
- jude- 6y agoBanning CFCs globally via the Montreal Protocol.
- galangalalgol 6y ago
- pyrale 6y agoWhile taxing carbon usage is a good idea, there is something fundamentally wrong with the idea of allocating so much resources, in servers, in power and in space, for what essentially doesn't improve people's lives. That this craze receives so much attention and funding while we face very real existential challenges is maddening.
- dylan604 6y agoIf the owners of the miners are actually able to turn their coins into wealth that increases their lifestyle, then the mining did improve someone's life. Just because it affects a very small number of people isn't much different than most other "traditional" financial products in exsistence.
- whimsicalism 6y ago> then the mining did improve someone's life On net, was it welfare enhancing for our species though? If I make $1 off of emissions that cause external harm worth $2 distributed among the 7 billion people on this planet, I'm basically just laundering money through a loophole in what the law today considers to be harming someone else.
- seibelj 6y agoYou just keep moving the goalposts by using the most extreme argument you can muster. To be honest the sports industry uses tons of energy in lighting stadiums, streaming them, training players, it goes on and on. Entertainment could be done much more cheaply and effectively. I think society should outlaw sport - so many people are hurt in injuries, and the climate is just utterly demolished through all the energy waste. I can’t see a reason why society would allow sports. It’s ultimately beneficial to a very small amount of owners and their players (who are exploited!) that take all the cream off the top. Completely immoral honestly. The fact society wastes so much thought, effort, energy, focus, when we could instead be going to Mars or training STEM graduates is just criminal.
- 6y ago
- undefined1 6y ago> we just tax carbon usage? yes please, that would be the holistic approach. externalities like carbon need to be priced in. if it's in the price, then the market will adjust accordingly. a $4 [thing] will jump to $12, people will buy fewer until producers figure out ways to reduce externalities in order to bring the price down. what's free will be overused. price it in to force efficiency and alternative seeking.
- Qwertious 6y agoI agree with every part of that sentence except the "just". People have been trying desperately to do that for 40+ years without success, it's clearly not easy.
- whywhywhywhy 6y agoCan we have a solution that doesn't mean giving the government yet more money.