34 ms·
Activists who embrace nuclear power
- systematical 6y agoGo heavy nuclear and invest in fusion. The later will lead to clean abundant energy and eventually a reduction in resource scarcity. What is the economics of air? That's the economics we want.
- afterburner 6y agoFusion research? Sure. I hope you aren't expecting practical commercial reactors anytime soon. I believe the current fusion scientists just entering the workforce are hoping for major strides by the end of their CAREER when they finally retire.
- simplicio 6y agoYea, plus we've reached the point where even if you do believe the most optimistic timelines for fusion power development, its not going to come in time to make a meaningful contribution to fighting climate change.
- sudosysgen 6y agoI don't see where that's implied. The scenario that makes sense is that by the time our heavy investments into nuclear pay off and then some, maybe in 80-100 years, we can transition to fusion.
- codecamper 6y agoLuckily we already have a working fusion reactor. It's 92M miles away, but it's a big one. All that is required are some solar panels and wind turbines to harness its power.
- systematical 6y agoI'm down for a Dyson Swarm.
- codecamper 6y agoWe'll get there. As soon as we stop listening to the morons that want to do step Z before they finish step C.
- codecamper 6y agooh... I see the "we're going to Mars" wet dreamers did not like my post. techies... lol.
- wavefunction 6y agoI think it behooves the US and any other country serious about both climate change and extra-planetary exploration and colonization to develop a robust terrestrial nuclear power program as well as encouraging a trained cadre of nuclear engineers who can manage nuclear power sources on other planets, satellites and space-craft.
- phabora 6y agoIs the US serious about extra-planetary colonization?
- dylan604 6y agoif (US == "Musk") ? true : false
- wavefunction 6y agoAs serious as any other country from what I can tell.
- dotancohen 6y ago> encouraging a trained cadre of nuclear engineers who can manage nuclear power sources Ignoring the context of the rest of your comment, it should be noted that the US Navy has a near-perfect record in nuclear safety. This is often attributed to them not working for a profit motive. If we're going to use nuclear power on other solar system bodies, and I expect that we will, then most likely that knowledge will come from US Navy expertise.
- wavefunction 6y agoI am aware of the US Navy's nuclear engineering program but it's likely not capable of producing enough nuclear engineers for future needs, I expect.
- AngryData 6y agoThey also have the benefit of being able to flood and sink reactors in the ocean to prevent meltdowns. Which is why im an advocate for off-shore nuclear power, either floating, or even better, completely underwater. Of course that increases costs, but it would make nuclear almost completely safe even in the worst case scenarios.
- mcenedella 6y agoAccording to the Department of Energy, nuclear energy creates minimal waste, has a small land footprint, and is cleaner for the air. https://www.energy.gov/ne/articles/3-reasons-why-nuclear-clean-and-sustainable https://www.energy.gov/ne/articles/3-reasons-why-nuclear-cle... Interestingly: “ All of the used nuclear fuel produced by the U.S. nuclear energy industry over the last 60 years could fit on a football field at a depth of less than 10 yards!”
- afterburner 6y agoCleaner than than the air compared to what? Coal? No shit. How about the cost compared to solar and wind? Oh, don't want to talk about that? I wonder how much nuclear waste solar and wind creates.
- p_l 6y agoInterestingly enough, CO2g per W of energy is considered much higher (4 times?) for PV than for nuclear, at least in common statistics used to evaluate power plant emissions (12 gCO2eq/kWh for nuclear, 11g for wind, 24g for hydro and 45g for solar - source:IPCC2014). Most nuclear waste can be reprocessed and burned further down (that's the strategy that was used by France). A big issue with that is the effective voiding of non-proliferation treaty by, among other, USA - nothing scares them more than a country running plutonium economy, thus proposals of designs with remote kill switches operated by USA and other imperialistic moves like it.
- throwaway69123 6y agoNuclear waste is nuclear fuel
- einpoklum 6y ago> According to the Department of Energy Isn't that the department that corrupt US politicians staff with people who are partial to the interests of the industry they're supposed to regulate? Anyway, the link seems rather propagandistic. Let the Secretary of Energy bury a football field's worth of nuclear waste next to his town.
- phabora 6y agoI would rather risk a few local meltdowns than a global heatup.
- afterburner 6y agoJust buy solar and wind, avoid both.
- reedjosh 6y agoSolar & wind != nuclear. Solar and wind are not on demand and require storage that's not currently practical.
- cygx 6y agoNuclear also isn't 'on demand', but load-following at best. You'd have to add some peaker plants (or storage) into the mix if you wanted to go majority-nuclear as well...
- sir_bearington 6y agoNuclear can handle variable load by more aggressively cooling the reactor. Same thermal output, lower electrical output.
- colinmhayes 6y agoNuclear isn't really on demand either, it takes days to change production capacity.
- armada651 6y agoYou're never going to have a powermix that's 100% renewables. There will always be a few power plants to pick up the slack if weather conditions are unfavorable for a long period of time. Should these plants use coal, gas or nuclear?
- afterburner 6y ago
- krustyburger 6y agoWhen she first contemplated working at Diablo Canyon, she imagined the rat-infested Springfield Nuclear Power Plant on “The Simpsons,” where green liquid oozes out of tanks. Eventually, like Hoff, she changed her thinking. “What we were doing actually aligned with my environmental values,” she told me. “That was shocking to me.” You can tell from my username what an enormous fan of The Simpsons I am. One of the few things I wish the show hadn’t done is inserted into its world such a thoroughly negative vision of nuclear energy. If you don’t know much about the subject, The Simpsons leaves you thinking that using nuclear power at all is incredibly dangerous and foolish, and motivated by simple greed. It’s especially effective in this because the show is so pitch-perfect in how it depicts so many other aspects of society and human nature. I see this one element of the show as an unfortunate relic of the prevailing counterculture that informed Matt Groening’s otherwise generally brilliant worldview.
- afterburner 6y agoBumbling idiots and greedy management causing a major disaster is what happens in real life. Not sure I'd blame The Simpsons for merely reflecting that.
- iso8859-1 6y agoThe Springfield plant is cheap to operate compared to real reactors though. It would cost only $56 M to bring it up to the latest safety code. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Springfield_(The_Simpsons)#Springfield_Nuclear_Power_Plant https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Springfield_(The_Simpsons)#Spr...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- fulafel 6y agoTMI (plus other 80s US NPP incidents) and Chernobyl had happened in the previous 10 years when Simpsons started. Those plants had real problems and caused badly needed corrections to NPP safety culture and standards. It was a pretty reasonable take for its time.
- epistasis 6y agoArticles like this miss the main point and instead focus on culture war material. There are plenty of sites that would happily accept more nuclear being built, but all other forms of energy have undercut the cost of nuclear. It's no longer cost competitive, and places like China that adopt a "let's try everything and see what works best" approach have heavily pulled back on nuclear. The issues aren't safety, waste, and environments opposition. There are plenty of climate hawks that support nuclear too. It's all excessive costs. They briefly mention the cooling retrofits for Diablo Canyon in San Lui Obispo, but they don't mention that they bids from Bechtel to simply build a modern cooling system were all billions of dollars of expense. Just the cooling system is more expensive than alternatives. And this is a trend we will see in the future. For primary generation of electrons, steam based thermodynamic cycles are pretty much obsolete. The number I typically hear is that it's $1-2W to build, say, a cooling system for coal steam. A nuclear plants cooling is pretty much identical. Solar and wind are going to undercut that cost very soon. So the name of the game is now storage. Attaching four hours of storage to a solar generation farm, just enough to get through the duck curve, is now slightly cheaper than coal. The best estimate of what the cheapest possible future grid looks like is: solar/wind capacity at 4x of total demand (thermal generators are roughly at 2x on the current grid), with 3-4 days of storage. This translates to world with abundant energy, at certain times, that's generated at zero marginal cost. There are still lots of transmission costs however. The future of energy is all about spatial and temporal arbitrage of renewable electrons.
- flaque 6y agoThis assumes that larger investment in nuclear won’t yield reduced costs, just as larger investments in solar did.
- afterburner 6y agoIt seems like the largest feature of modern nuclear power is that it got a lot more expensive as we realized how much safety we truly needed to build into it. Whereas, without much prompting, solar got a LOT cheaper. When nuclear develops that significantly, we will all pay attention. Until then, build cheaper sources. Also consider when building nuclear, you are locking into technology from 10 years ago (when the plant is finally done), for the next 50 years (when the plant is finally decommissioned). Solar and other sources have much faster iteration cycles and much lower commitment.
- rpiguyshy 6y agoi just dont buy it. hypothetically, there is a nuclear power plant design that is perfectly safe in that it will never melt down. but there is no nuclear power plant that produces no waste. as long as you are producing waste, you are depending on bumbling bureaucrats to properly dispose of that waste and manage the waste often for extremely long periods of time. its just not an ideal situation. the government cant even keep the water potable in certain places. meanwhile, solar is safe to set up, safe to operate, and there is no radioactive waste to manage. if flint michigan has a solar array, then the worst that can happen is that their lights go out. this is a small but critical advantage in my eyes. and then look at the bigger picture. there hasnt been a nuclear reactor that is perfectly safe to operate. its still hypothetical. solar is growing every year, the battery market is growing every year. panels and packs never truly retire, just decline in capacity. solar wins.
- rrdharan 6y agoIsn’t there still a lot of implied waste from the solar panels themselves though, as well as the storage batteries i.e. once they’ve reached their end of life? My understanding is that this cost and the manufacturing cost (rate earth metals etc.) are often overlooked when reasoning about the total footprint of both solar and electric vehicles..
- sjg007 6y agoBatteries should be refurbish-able and definitely recyclable.
- reedjosh 6y agoAnd definitely energy intensive to recycle.
- afterburner 6y agoAre you under the impression decommissioning a nuclear reactor is a simple and tidy task?
- ssijak 6y agoNow that launching stuff into orbit is getting much cheaper, is there any reasonable calculation to just ship nuclear waste into orbit? Or even further away (crashing it into Sun would be ideal but too expensive I guess)
- einpoklum 6y agoNIMBY on steroids: Not on my back-yard planet :-) Luckily for you there aren't other sentients in the Sol system.
- chihuahua 6y agoSome rocket launches fail, and it would be a problem if you're constantly launching radioactive waste into space and 1% of those launches end with a crash that scatters dangerous material on the ground.
- cozzyd 6y agoThere goes the carbon benefits...
- thinkcontext 6y agoThe US produces 2,000 metric tons of nuclear waste per year. There's also about 90,000 metric tons in storage. Falcon Heavy is the most cost effective rocket in operation. For $90M it can send 8 tons to GTO (its harder to get things into the sun but the numbers are available for GTO). So just the launching would cost would be $22.5B per year. And it would be $1T to take care of the existing waste. But that's way too low because transporting the waste and preparing it for launch would be very expensive in itself.
- neonate 6y agohttps://archive.is/PDebD https://archive.is/PDebD
- nharada 6y agoI'm sick of every single thread on nuclear turning into a flame war of wind/solar vs nuclear. It really detracts from the real issue of high carbon sources -- why is the conversation never about nuclear vs the natural gas plants that are being built at an astoundingly fast rate? Those two things are even more similar since they are both baseline power sources.
- runarberg 6y agoI’m guessing that is because nuclear is often framed as a solution to the climate disaster. If the discussion was simply: “see how cool of a technology nuclear power is; see how nuclear powers the latest mars rover” I would not guess there would be a lot of backlash. However in this thread you see a lot of: “wind and solar has some problems too”, or “nuclear waste is better then the warming of the planet”. The problem with pitting nuclear as a solution to the climate disaster is that there are existing technologies that can solve the energy part of it, those technologies are primarily wind and solar. And there is ample reason to be skeptical about how well nuclear could solve it. So naturally when someone states that nuclear is good actually at solving the climate crisis, a natural response would be: “well actually, it isn’t. Wind and solar is”.
- Robotbeat 6y agoHuh? Nuclear is an existing solution to climate change, though. More existing than wind and solar. It provides more electricity in the US than wind and solar combined. The problem of climate change would already have been worse without it. So it already is part of the solution. It doesn’t have to be and isn’t the entire solution. But no activist calling for the end of nuclear electricity is doing any favors to climate action.
- runarberg 6y agoI always took it as: As the nuclear plants from the 70s and 80s are getting decommissioned because of age, there is no plan to replace them with new nuclear. So they should be replace them with wind and solar, because wind and solar is a cheaper, quicker, and more reliable alternative then new nuclear (as this tread demonstrates). I don’t see the debate as existing nuclear vs. new wind and solar, but as new nuclear vs. new wind and solar.
- kart23 6y agoFun fact: one aircraft carrier (CVN-78) has the same number of nuclear reactors as the entire state of California.
- gdubs 6y agoI read Stewart Brand's 'Whole Earth Discipline' about five years ago, and came away pretty convinced by his pro-nuclear arguments. The price situation has definitely changed dramatically in the last few years, with solar dropping remarkably. So some of it may be worth revisiting. But that said, something else has happened in the last five years that has made me a bit ... cautious about being decisive on nuclear. And that is general global instability. E.g., things sure feel like they've come off the rails recently and things I used to take for granted: that competent people would generally be in charge, has been challenged. So to me, the biggest risk with nuclear isn't the technology itself. In isolation I see it as a great solution to one of the key challenges of climate change. To me, the biggest risk is political stability. It's a technology that requires constant competence. All that said – I aim to be open-minded. If the new breed of reactors can safely shutdown under neglect, if they can't be weaponized if society breaks down – awesome. I'd love to hear more about it.
- runsWphotons 6y agoI suppose you could see it the other way. A nuclear plant in everyone's backyard might be incentive to put competent people in charge?
- theodric 6y agoRespectfully, i think this is a naïve position, given the Zeitgeist of the last few years
- runsWphotons 6y agoYes the question mark should be read with hesitancy. I suppose you are right. Too hopeful.
- andrewflnr 6y agoI don't think people would be more inventivized in a practical sense than they already are.
- Nasrudith 6y ago
- jaakl 6y agoIf anything can reduce/limit now the climate catastrophe then it is total transformation to clean electric energy which is produced with minimal emissions: housing, transport, industry, everything must go electric. Producing does not need to be renewables, it can be even fossils, it just has to be without GHG emissions. Nothing else matters. These theoretical risks, long-term waste storage etc are at best secondary questions which are totally irrelevant in current situation where we have almost lost that battle. Considering that full electrification requires automatically 3-4 times hike of energy demand any clean enough tech has to be considered and where possible deployed right away. It is simple like that.
- slymon99 6y agoThe more interesting climate advantage of nuclear power is it can be used directly in manufacturing, for example in creating steel (which represents 8% of GHG emissions). You can't make steel with electricity - the current strategy involves essentially setting a bunch of oil on fire on top of the requisite components (you can tell I'm not actually an industrial engineer, but steel generation is very not green). However, you could harness the heat from a nuclear plant directly (instead of using it to create steam and drive turbines) to create steel. This has been discussed for decades[1], but modern improvements in nuclear technology could make it a reality [1]: https://inis.iaea.org/search/search.aspx?orig_q=RN:8341064 https://inis.iaea.org/search/search.aspx?orig_q=RN:8341064
- philipkglass 6y agoFrom your link: "The most promising concept is a High-Temperature Gas-Cooled Nuclear Reactor heating helium to a temperature sufficient to steam reform hydrocarbons into reducing gases for the direct reduction of iron ores." That still consumes fossil hydrocarbons. Hydrogen can substitute for hydrocarbons in the production of direct reduced iron from iron ore. "Assessment of hydrogen direct reduction for fossil-free steelmaking" https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0959652618326301 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S095965261... Hydrogen can of course be produced cleanly from nuclear power. But it's questionable if nuclear-derived hydrogen will be cheaper than other clean hydrogen sources.
- TedShiller 6y agoI'm all for nuclear power too, as long as it's nowhere near me.
- macspoofing 6y agoWe're going to have to build up our Nuclear infrastructure eventually because outside of fossil fuels, geothermal and hydro (both of which need particular geography so they can never be the final answer) there is nothing else. Unfortunately the cultural push is for wind and solar, so it looks like we're going to have to give wind and solar the 'old college try' and lose precious decades before we realize we need nuclear. It would have been nice to invest in Nuclear in the 70s to the same level as France, for example, and thereby prevent trillions of tons of CO2 that were emitted between the 70s and today from being emitted, and the trillions more between now and whenever we wake up to the fact that wind and solar just can't scale. I suspect future generations will take a dim view of the anti-nuke environmental movement. Worse, though wind and solar collectors may reduce CO2 emissions they are incredibly environmentally destructive in other ways. Let's keep mind that global warming is only one aspect of environmental destruction. The other is regular habitat and ecosystem collapse due support of human civilization (cities, agriculture, transportation etc.). Solar and wind collectors have horrendous land-use requirements (land-use around mining for necessary materials, deployment of the collectors, and finally land-fill once out of use). So when it comes to ecosystem destruction, solar and wind make it worse on all counts. I have no fuckin clue what environmentalists think will happen to the environment when we increase Solar and Wind collectors by several orders of magnitude (which would be necessary to support 7-10 billion people move partially from fossil fuels). Pure Insanity. Oh well. It is what it is.
- Daho0n 6y agoCitation needed.
- macspoofing 6y agoCitation for which part? That solar and wind have huge land-use requirements compared to nuclear (and even other generation sources)? That we need to increase production of solar and wind collectors by several orders of magnitude to fully replace fossil fuel generated power, and by extension need to increase mineral extraction (rare-earth or otherwise) to build them? That every single collector we build today will need to be land-filled at some point in the future and replaced by another one we have yet to build? That there is no battery technology today that can bridge the intermittency issues of solar and wind in order for that technology to actually power the economy without fossil fuel backup? That global warming is not the only environmental problem we are dealing with? Those are all statements of fact.
- codecamper 6y agoSo Bill Gates doesn't think we can do this with a majority solar, wind, and storage. He invented the backslash and has a lot of money, so he is getting a lot of attention. But has a good computer simulation been made? Just collect annual sunlight data from a million points across the US, along with wind, throw in 200M electric vehicles (can use satellite data and image recognition data to guess how often they are parked for V2G), and see how far we can get towards a 100% green grid. I haven't seen a computer simulation and yet here is Bill saying it's impossible. Is it? Or is this just another "computers will never need more than 640k" moment?
- throwaway69123 6y agoIt is hard to take peoples arguments of cost seriously when governments around the world are printing fiat at alarming rates. Covid has proven that where there is a will the money can be found.
- gumby 6y agoAs it happens, macroeconomics and microeconomics are different, like chemistry amd physics are different.* The printing presses are not running in order for governments to buy more stuff. That printing could be good or bad, but any argument based on “run printing presses as a way of raising money” doesn’t address any of the issues. Nobody has advocated that in decades (the odd Zimbabwean despot aside). * I’m not claiming economics is anywhere near as scientific as chemistry or physics, heavy trappings of math notwithstanding.
- lawrenceyan 6y agoThe risks you end up taking on don't make sense for the amount of energy received. Solar, wind, geothermal, and hydro are more than enough to power the world. They're cheaper too. In terms of baseload requirements, batteries are the far safer alternative for transitioning away from fossil fuels. Nuclear power may have been tenable as a solution, even with the heightened risks, if improvements in battery technology were stagnant and/or stagnating. But this hasn't been the case, and so nuclear fission as an energy source will likely become a relic of our past. Now nuclear fusion on the other hand...
- quelsolaar 6y agoThe risk people aren't considering is public opinion. It takes about 10 years to build a nuclear power-plant. Historically when have had one major accident every 30 years. Each time an accident have happened, projects have been canceled or put on ice. This mean that if you start planing a power-plant today there is ~33% chance, public opinion will stop it before its completed. One good illustration id the documentary "Inside Bills head". Bill gates spent untold millions to develop safer, cleaner, less expensive nuclear power. One day he woke up to the news of the accident in japan, and all of a sudden all partners pulled out, permits where revoked and no one was interested anymore. (The costs, risks and time lag are more important arguments against nuclear, but I think this one is worth considering too)
- lawrenceyan 6y agoYes, Fukushima definitely put a huge damper on nuclear. And I do generally agree with you. Every time an accident happens, which is an inevitability, it's guaranteed that some investors will pull out.