7 ms·
Find the Hard Work You're Willing to Do (2018)
- andrewflnr 6y agoThis accords with my experience. I think of myself as a lazy person... until I get into a project I care about, at which point I can happily work myself into the ground.
- moneywoes 6y agoCal Newport’s book so good they can’t ignore you comes to mind
- ibraheemdev 6y agoWhich book are you referring to?
- LukeShu 6y ago"So Good They Can't Ignore You" by Cal Newport.
- hyperpallium2 6y agoAgreed. His "Book So Good They Can’t Ignore You Comes To Mind" was disappointing.
- dmichulke 6y ago"They can't ignore you" met a similar, if ironic, fate.
- cambalache 6y ago"Cal Newport my great proof of this method working is this book?" I mean I know he is a tenured CS prof (no small feat) but the way he talks about his method and its result would make you think he has won 2 Nobel prizes
- stevegalla 6y agoIf I recall correctly (from his podcast episodes), he has said he knows what is required to get to the top of his field, but he isn’t willing to pay the price. Perhaps he will point to that in the future to say why he hasn’t won Turing awards. Or perhaps he makes more money from his “side hustles” as an author, blogger, and podcaster. Or it’s a good match for “finding the hard work you’re willing to do”. He is willing to do the hard work to get tenured, but not the hard work to be the absolute best in the field.
- cambalache 6y ago> If I recall correctly (from his podcast episodes), he has said he knows what is required to get to the top of his field, but he isn’t willing to pay the price. Is this the academic version of " until I took an arrow to my knee"?
- DoreenMichele 6y agoThe world thinks mathematicians are people for whom math is easy. That's wrong. Relatedly: We convince people that you -- yes, you -- need to sweat and find something burdensome in order to make the big bucks and make the world a better place. We do a poor job of clearly conveying how to add real value and how to capture some portion of that in the form of money in your own pocket. It actively causes problems for talented people who often think of their talent as something "easy" or fun and wouldn't know how to charge for it or how much to charge for it. We have all these proxies for providing value -- such as hours worked -- that I think of as "paying you to sweat" rather than paying you to be productive. I don't know what the solution is but it's something we ought to be more actively working on.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jmchuster 6y agoI think for lower-paying jobs, then they are paying you to sweat, and there also is a tighter correlation there with productivity. But higher-paying jobs are all salaried rather than hourly, which seems to indicate that society has already decided pretty low on the scale that more valuable jobs and work has less and less of a correlation with your hours worked. And at the top end, we pay people exponentially higher salaries, with CEOs making hundreds of millions, which in no way means that they're working thousands of times more hours than everyone else. The easiest way to get promoted isn't to work more hours, it's to manage other people. So leverage and scale of impact seems to be what society has decided is most valuable.
- DoreenMichele 6y agoIn theory, salaried positions pay you for adding value, not for your time. In practice, people on salary often work more hours, not fewer hours. (When I had a corporate job, one manager once joked to me "I make less than minimum wage for the hours I put in.") We tend to pay better for positions of trust. This may or may not involve more skill and such positions are often primarily given to people with certain traits, like upper class white males. Certainly, some people have gotten the memo on how to line their pockets for less time and effort. But I think we generally do a somewhat poor job of elucidating how to get paid for the value you provide rather than for who you know, what you are, how many hours you clock, etc. If we want a better world where good things happen, this is a problem. It actively creates social injustice and also maximizes for teaching people to get over rather than add value per se.
- 9erdelta 6y agoMy realization was similar but different wording. "If you have to work hard just to show up, find something else".
- PartiallyTyped 6y agoCharles Bukowsky expressed it multiple times in his work, there is a particular poem about becoming a writer, but can be adapted to any other endeavour. https://www.goodreads.com/quotes/652205-so-you-want-to-be-a-writer-if-it-doesn-t https://www.goodreads.com/quotes/652205-so-you-want-to-be-a-...: A segment: if it doesn't come bursting out of you in spite of everything, don't do it. unless it comes unasked out of your heart and your mind and your mouth and your gut, don't do it.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 6y agoAn easy thing to say when you're young and have familial wealth to fall back on or some other means of support while try to find some calling or whatever. I never found something I like doing that people will pay me money for, so I ended up doing the pragmatic thing and finding the job I have to put the least amount of effort into for a reasonable amount of money. I'm kinda sick of entitled people talk about finding your passion and similar advice like this.
- 9erdelta 6y agoFor me this ended meaning lots of student loans and feeling like I'm way behind in life. But glad nonetheless that I found something where it doesn't feel like hard work just to go to work.
- abdabab 6y agoYou don’t need a lot of money to claim freedom over your life. Bukowski didn’t have a lot. Diogenes the Cynic would be one extreme but valid example. People who you’re calling entitled are not all entitled. They’re just a bit more courageous and freewheeling than you and me.
- civilized 6y ago"Find the hard work you're willing to do" sounds very similar to what an economist would say, "find your comparative advantage"
- marcosdumay 6y agoWell, the economist one generalizes better, but the specific one from the article is just way more fun.
- civilized 6y agoI find it reassuring that the advice resonates with economic theory. "Comparative advantage" isn't the most accessible way of putting it, so it's good to have others that are easier to understand
- marcosdumay 6y agoIt resonates, but it isn't just another wording of the same advice. "Do things that you like to do" is a subset of exploit your comparative advantage, and a significantly smaller one.
- TrevorFSmith 6y agoThe great extension is to find the hard work that you're willing to do, that few others are willing to do, and that many people need.
- Flex247A 6y agoClean the toilet? ;)
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 6y agoIsn't it interesting that all the people we call "essential workers" make very low wages? What does that say about us as a society?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- killtimeatwork 6y agoIt says that we're mostly purely greedy and self-serving. That's why the government has to institute some form of basic decency in forms of minimum wage and labor laws, as otherwise the unlucky people would get stomped on even more.
- the_only_law 6y agoI’d love to, unfortunately it seems a good bit easier and at times more even more realistic to just try and works towards not having to work at all or minimizing for work.
- imafish 6y agoSorry for stating the obvious - but it seems you found your “hard problem” then :)
- CivBase 6y ago> Maybe this is what people mean when they tell us to "find our passion", but that phrase seems pretty abstract to me. Maybe instead we should encourage people to find the hard problems they like to work on. Which problems do you want to keep working on, even when they turn out to be harder than you expected? Which kinds of frustration do you enjoy, or at least are willing to endure while you figure things out? Answers to these very practical questions might help you find a place where you can build an interesting and rewarding life. I think this mode of thinking is useful for helping people identify passions... but as advice, I think it ultimately falls short in the same way that "follow your passion" does. It just assumes that everyone has a passion- an economically viable one at that. What if you don't? What about simple people who don't want to focus on solving problems? This might be hard for most HN readers to sympathize with. People with technical backgrounds tend to be driven problem solvers. But I don't think most people are really like that. "Do what you love and you'll never work a day in your life." Making a living doing what you love sounds great, but I frankly don't think it's a realistic expectation for everyone to have and I worry that we're just setting people up for disappointment by encouraging it so strongly.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 6y ago> What about simple people who don't want to focus on solving problems? This might be hard for most HN readers to sympathize with. People with technical backgrounds tend to be driven problem solvers. I don't know about that. If the the typical HN reader cared about solving problems they wouldn't switch jobs every two years and keep rewriting the same things over and over in the latest fad framework.
- shagie 6y agoIt isn't about finding passions... its about finding out what you can do to make a living. On /r/cscareerquestions there is a not infrequent subject of posting - people who get into software development and find that they really hate sitting in front of a computer or having to support and debug code. When everything is going well, they enjoy writing code but as soon as the harder problems come, it's not enjoyable. Personally, I love photography as a hobby. I've got (check Adobe Lightroom) 200 GB of photographs... a good chunk of those are from when I was shooting slide and scanning them. When I was unemployed in '09, I looked into what it would take to become a professional photographer - and I realized I really didn't want to do that. Clicking the shutter is fun, but the harder problems of being a photographer (scheduling, wedding photography, marketing, sales, etc...) I really didn't enjoy doing at all. A sibling of mine went from being a manager of a yoga studio to being an RN (the hard work of being an RN pays better than trying to run your own yoga studio). Its not something that my sibling is passionate about (like yoga was) - but its hard work that my sibling is able to do, endure, and be well compensated for. Yoga? Its now more of a hobby (and there are other outlets for the passion). From the blog post: > I realize that "Find your passion" makes for a more compelling motivational poster than "What hard problems do you enjoy working on?" (and even that's a lot better than "What kind of pain are you willing to endure?"), but it might give some people a more realistic way to approach finding their life's work. There are other parts of the workforce where someone can get a job that pays acceptably and probably something that people who don't want to be solving problems can find a job. The advice for job seekers shouldn't be "maximize your happiness" but rather "minimize your unhappiness".
- yeahnah22 6y agoThis is also the entire message of Mark Manson in his book ‘the subtle art’
- tardismechanic 6y agoAs always I keep coming back to the beautiful Japanese concept of Ikigai - "a reason for being" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ikigai https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ikigai Imagine four intersecting circles depicting: 1. What you love to do 2. What you are good at 3. What you can get paid for 4. What the world needs It's about finding a balance between these factors. See http://www.forastateofhappiness.com/ikigai-the-happiness-of-always-being-busy-in-japan/ http://www.forastateofhappiness.com/ikigai-the-happiness-of-... and http://www.forastateofhappiness.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/03/Ikigai.jpg http://www.forastateofhappiness.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/...
- eevilspock 6y agoWhat happens when they don't intersect? What if #4 needs people to compromise on #1 if we want to have any degree of equity, as opposed to the lucky elite doing what they love and everyone else serving them to survive? What if #4 needs people to not selfishly maximize #3, e.g. take the ethical job that pays enough rather than the unethical one that pays you much more? Modern culture has come to be obsessed with self actualization and happiness, at the expense of meaning, love (by definition not self-centered), solidarity in both difficulty and joy, and integrity/honor. I would LOVE TO HEAR YOUR THOUGHTS on this essay about Viktor Frankl, for whom "meaning came from three possible sources: purposeful work, love, and courage in the face of difficulty." https://www.brainpickings.org/2013/03/26/viktor-frankl-mans-search-for-meaning/ https://www.brainpickings.org/2013/03/26/viktor-frankl-mans-... Buddhist Economics: https://www.brainpickings.org/2014/07/07/buddhist-economics-schumacher https://www.brainpickings.org/2014/07/07/buddhist-economics-...
- abdullahkhalids 6y agoI think you are thinking #4 should be something like making a better Facebook or something global. I highly doubt that is what the concept means. It just means do things that benefit other people directly. Running the friendly neighborhood barbershop where you are not doing anything unethical (like recommending shady products) falls within #4.
- 6y ago
- kristianp 6y agoSurely the person who finds undergrad math easy will get further into advanced topics before things become too hard for them?
- raghuveerdotnet 6y ago'Hard vs Easy' is probably one of the worst dichotomies to invoke when you are trying to get people interested in something that you think is hard. And more importantly, no one ever who does hard stuff thinks to themselves that they are doing hard stuff. Almost every inch of such work is a combination of interest and constraint i.e., you want to do it or you have to do it. Secondly, you want emotions helping you here. Emotions evade this trap tactfully by being abstract in their appearance. Every person I know who works on hard mathematics is either a romantic who does it because of their love (interest) for mathematics or a foot soldier who does it because they have to. There is no way you can articulate your way into anything if there is no emotional vector involved(negative or positive). Hardness is just a detail that can be abstracted if you are emotionally aligned.
- tekkk 6y agoHmm. Well. Sure. There is often a drastic difference between learning the theory of something and then actual work of applying it. To me many things are interesting yet it's the practical work of CS that has felt the most easiest vs the value it brings to me. I would say a big part of learning anything is getting accustomed to the thing and molding your own brain to function the way it requires you to. Having studied and worked in CS has made my brains a lot more logical with the probable wilting of the more feeling-based thinking patterns. Didn't happen overnight but I guess my neural pathways were already inclined towards it so the jump wasn't that huge. Yet I think I could have been reasonably satisfied with any work with a layer of written abstraction (so writing in general) and some practical application to it. That's what I feel my natural advantage is. With physical labor, I think I would fared just as well. But I think in that case I would have gotten less out of my capacity (brains and impact-wise). I would say finding the thing that you can do what others deem too boring or tedious to do or learn with the intensity you are capable of, is where your best potential lies. This might also make it feel like "not-working" while you are doing much better than the average person. And if you feel like you _are_ working, then you should be doing great.
- bumbada 6y agoWhat usually happens when you are good at something is that you start being the best in your environment and that encourages you, for example you are the best in Math or playing football in your school. Then you go to compete with the best of other schools and it becomes harder. Then you go to compete with the best your country and you meet people that are amazing. Then you see people around the world that run circles around you. And even if you manage to compete in the world's league, you start competing against the best in History, in Math you will compete with Newton and Leibniz, Gauss or Euler. Even if you are the best mathematician of your time, you are insignificant against them. The advantage people have today is tools like computers and Internet that gives you and advantage over people of the past, but also gives you a disadvantage: It gives you access to the best works of humanity while also increasing distractions by levels of magnitude. It gives you computational power people in the past could only dream about, but uses that to power games, sexual scams and casinos in order to divert your attention and resources. Today there are more opportunities than ever to create something of value for Humanity, but doing it is as hard as always has been. And even "hard" work does not guarantee you anything. If you sacrifice a lot in order to create something worth it, maybe you will get rewarded, but it is not guarantied. I prefer to study how to work smart instead of hard, but that process in itself is hard work.
- niek_pas 6y agoThis is almost impossible to read on a phone.
- bobthechef 6y agoSure, though I would emphasize the role of habitus. What you are willing to endure is not fixed.
- luord 6y agoI tried chemical engineering first because in my country's system we more or less have to pick what major we want to apply for since even before finishing high school, and I had to do this at thirteen. And then I got my very first computer as a high school graduation present. Quickly found out that enjoying the high school chemistry classes the most didn't translate to chemistry processes being what I wanted to do for the rest of my life. On the other hand, I fell in love with tinkering with the computer's software (first in windows, and then even more after I installed Linux) right away. I stuck it out with chemical engineering for a year and half, before finally dropping out and starting fresh with systems engineering (more or less my country's equivalent to computer science) during what would have been my fifth semester. Haven't looked back since and, much like the author says, I love solving those puzzles.