10 ms·
Huh? I know the few times that gas has had a run on it in my lifetime, people immediately bring up gouging laws. Quickly reading, sounds like this is only a f
by taeric 6y ago
Huh? I know the few times that gas has had a run on it in my lifetime, people immediately bring up gouging laws.
Quickly reading, sounds like this is only a few states and depends on a few other factors?
- WalterBright 6y agoI thought the gouging laws only applied when disasters are declared. The gouging laws are stupid, anyway, as they simply ensure there's no gas to buy. Everybody is worse off.
- taeric 6y agoThat is inline with what I was reading. I'm assuming the outage last week was an emergency, so assumed something like this would apply, but I see no evidence that is the case.
- tzs 6y agoIn most disasters for which gouging laws would apply, won't the gas stations still run out even without such laws? The gas stations usually run out because the disaster stops transportation into the disaster area so the gas stations can't get resupplied.
- taeric 6y agoThis is an argument that feels right. However, you are just shifting first in, for biggest wallet. In large, I confess I am ok with that shift. But it really doesn't help more people. Or more at risk people.
- WalterBright 6y ago> you are just shifting first in, for biggest wallet Not shifting because there's no supply. The mosquito fleet of entrepreneurs driving in to make a buck selling gas, water, food, supplies, etc., disappeared. Which would you rather do in Texas: watch your house slowly freeze and know you'll have 5 figures in freeze damage while waiting several days for the government to restore power, or buy a generator and a can of gas from a redneck who threw his own generator into his pickup with a can of gas and drove in from the next state to sell it to you for 3 figures? > it really doesn't help more people It really does help more people. Before the anti-gouge laws, there were always stories in the media about these people driving into disaster zones with supplies. But the media always demonized them, and so now they're against the law and you get to freeze. Of course, there are good people who will still drive in and give away supplies, but they're a tiny fraction of the crowd that trucks supplies in to make a buck.
- imtringued 6y agoHonestly, this is such an interesting problem. If one were to assume that price gauging laws for fuels didn't exist one would be allowed to think about how to provide this emergency service in the most effective way possible. Uber could just have a new category for emergency deliveries. The government could also take advantage of this service for emergency relief.
- taeric 6y agoFeels like this is an area where the ounces of prevention more than out weigh any bickering on pounds of cures. That is, the best response to many crises is best taken before the crises.
- taeric 6y agoThe problem with this hypothetical is that there is a non zero chance that generator will cause problems. Worse, if it is profitable, expect cheating and corners to be cut. Is especially odd, in that a well regulated power market seems to handle this better. Yes, other places had outages. Not comparable in scale, though. There is also the oddity that similar arguments could be made that you could get medication on the street market. Why would anyone cut corners there? :). Surely, if you are in need, you should be allowed to buy someone else's medication from them at stupid high prices? Edit: so to directly answer what I would rather do if I was in Texas. I would rather have had risk of failure properly priced into the market such that they were more ready to deal with it.
- kristjansson 6y agoThe argument goes that if prices were unbounded above, demand would drop, and suppliers would move heaven and earth to deliver more to take advantage. No one fills their tank ‘just to be safe’ if the gas is $50/gallon; if they really could charge $50/gallon the oil companies would have private road clearing crews and tanker trucks outfitted like storm chasers? I don’t know. While such a policy might maximize economic utility I think you’re correct that it’s advocates gloss the obvious physical - but also social - constraints. Sometimes gas (or whatever) just can’t be delivered for any price. Since demand obviously drops off with price, it’s hard to believe suppliers could justify mammoth investments in delivery infrastructure. More importantly, such a policy means rationing a essential resource proportional to wealth. Those with the most get what the need; the well off get a little at a painful price; those struggling under normal circumstances just go without. The argument does that a little at a painful price is better than none at a artificial price. I think that misses the size of the lattermost group, and the risk that expressing a fundamental inequality between humans during exigent circumstances - that if you don’t have money, you can’t have gas or heat, or whatever it is - puts social cohesion in jeopardy. Rationing resources either by explicit (1 gal per customer) or implicit (first come first served) policy might be economically inefficient, but socially expedient
- WalterBright 6y agoRationing and anti-gouging laws prevent supplies rushing in. A lot more people suffer as a result. Rationing is particularly stupid because then the supplies are not going to those who need it, they are wasted on people who don't need it. WW2's gas rationing created a thriving (and very illegal) black market of people selling their gas rations they had no use for to people who did. A whole crime industry grew up around this, complete with drive-by shootings.
- jacobr1 6y agoSo how can you get the benefit of price-surge based supply without the social-inequality disruption? Minumum subsidized purchases (like first gal costs low-$, more at market rates)? Direct-to-citizen cash payments? "Community based purchasing" - local towns buy what they need, at market rates, but they get massive federal cash influxes to enable them to do so? I'm sure I'm missing something here, but probably there is some mix of tradeoffs that could bette make this kind of thing work.
- WalterBright 6y agoWhat happened before the gouging laws was random people would fill 5 gallon jerry cans with gas and drive into the disaster zone and sell it out of the back of their pickup. They'd do other supplies, too. They'd appear on the scene almost immediately, sometimes days ahead of government relief. But the anti-gouging laws put a stop to that, and now people are forced to wait for government relief.
- imtringued 6y agoGovernments should always be considered a provider of last resort. They are absolutely necessary, you can't talk yourself out of that, however this should never prevent the existence of a private market that can respond faster. The primary advantage of markets is that they excel at providing value very efficiently. The downside is that they service the most profitable customers first so in fringe cases there will be a large segment of people without service. The primary advantage of governments is that they can afford to be altruistic and ensure fairness. However, they are inefficient and slow to respond, meaning they will not solve the problem to a satisfying extent and only do the bare minimum. If you do both you get the best of both worlds. Those who cannot afford private service can wait for government relief. Those who cannot wait for government relieve can pay for private service. The private market keeps the government in check, the government keeps the private market in check. They cover each other's backs.