3 ms·
It makes perfect sense. When there was not enough power, because generation was frozen, electricity was in demand. Now that those power plants are unfrozen and
by mindslight 6y ago
It makes perfect sense. When there was not enough power, because generation was frozen, electricity was in demand. Now that those power plants are unfrozen and there is enough power, over-generation is a liability.
The real question is does the spot price being able to go to $9,000 produce a useful market signal? Or is it just a pointless hazard to ensnare the unprepared? Normally this kind of question doesn't make sense because if there are still transactions at a high clearing price someone has decided they're getting $9k of utility. But in this case the market is a post facto settlement system decoupled from most usage, rather than something built on deliberate transactions.
Also, does anyone know who ends up paying for energy usage that cannot be attributed to any specific customer? Like if someone jumps their meter while the spot price is at $9/kWh, does the local transmission company just end up eating that or what?
- epistasis 6y agoThe PJM market also operates capacity markets, where energy produces are paid for being available to produce energy when called upon. This would be one way to pay people to at least think about reliability, in that they are explicitly getting paid for it. However, I believe that in the last polar vortex incident, something like 20% of people paid on the capacity market failed to be available. Unless there are steep penalties built into these contracts for failure to produce when needed, there still might not be proper incentive to perform proper design and maintenance. As we go forward, it will be interesting to see which incidents fall under force majeure, and which incidents result in actually breaking contracts. This particular incident was foreseen: the 2011 FERC report on smaller similar outages in ERCOT recommended fixes to prevent this. And I know of at least one energy expert who was tweeting days before this happened that he hoped Texas had fixed their problems that were identified in 2011. Personally, I favor regulating the ever living hell out of it, and having the state force carbon free electricity by 2035. I think that's the only way we will see movement towards more reliability and less carbon: guarantee that there's a market for such products.
- imtringued 6y ago>The real question is does the spot price being able to go to $9,000 produce a useful market signal? If electricity was like gas the pump would refuse to operate since your wallet is too light.