11 ms·
The longer I am in this profession (and it's been over 20 years) the less I see my peers as "dicks and idiots" but more as victims of the same broken game. I wo
by cmrdporcupine 6y ago
The longer I am in this profession (and it's been over 20 years) the less I see my peers as "dicks and idiots" but more as victims of the same broken game. I work with very smart people, to be honest. It's the technology and the employers and the culture of development that's the problem.
Retiring sounds good right about now.
- PragmaticPulp 6y agoHow so? The job situation for good developers has never been better. We can make salaries that would have seemed unthinkable two decades ago while working from home and doing something we enjoy.
- Grimm1 6y agoThat's true but that is to offset the really negative aspects. How many places never let dev's actually design systems that stand up to scrutiny because the execs don't care if BS is pumped out because as long as the business floats then it doesn't matter. Then the code base becomes a mass of spaghetti that at this point the revolving door of devs have to both figure out and keep alive in ever increasingly stressful situations until they either burn out or move on for greener pastures perpetuating that cycle. So far in my career the split is 60:30:10 places who don't care about actual engineering and run their business on crap, those who recognized things are biting them but the amount of inertia you need to counteract things and rebuild is huge and then the very fine percentage of places that actually have a good culture around engineering. The first is horrible because you're a fungible asset and the job is miserable the second is better but still bad because at this point they do see you as valuable but you're going to be spending your time digging them out of a grave and then the third is just a magical experience where you're valued and the codebase isn't constantly a light breeze away from collapsing. The majority of the industry is in position 1 and I guess we'll see if it ever makes it to 2 or 3. Worth noting that I made high salaries and could work from home in every case but it would be correct to say I continue to enjoy programming in spite of the industry. I also don't think it's a coincidence that companies who are in group 3 are typically leagues ahead of 1 and 2.
- blackrock 6y agoHow old are you now? Or what age group are you in now? It seems like businesses want the expertise of a 20+ veteran, but want to hire 18 year olds, so they can pay them less, and dangle silly trinkets like free cafeteria food in front of them. Oh and, why is it taking so long to work on it?
- notriddle 6y agoThe other problem is that there's factors in a company other than, strictly, its engineering culture. I could get a good job, in a good engineering culture, working in adtech, but as long as I have a choice I'd rather not. The place I work instead can charitably be described as "a victim of regulatory capture," but at least I'm working in a business that I believe has a legitimate reason to exist.
- hackerfromthefu 6y ago+1
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y agoThis has not been my experience. It seems that it's a young person's game, and us older folks are not particularly encouraged to participate. Frankly, I've been stunned by the way in which I was treated, in the short period of time I spent looking for work, after leaving my last company. Thankfully, I am not required to work, and have been having the best time I could imagine, since giving up on working for others. Instead, I work with people for free, on projects that I think are constructive and give back to society. I am working from home, doing something that I enjoy tremendously. I'm doing the best work of my life. I just got done refactoring a fairly large backend that I wrote a couple of years ago, and am actually thrilled at the quality (and quantity) of my work. It's driving the application that I'm developing. I wasn't satisfied with some of the popular offerings, and had already written the backend as an exercise, so I used that, instead. It just needed a bit of tweaking to fit the new application. I love programming and system design. I'm really good at it. I write code every single day of my life (My GH profile is solid green, and it's not "gamed"[0]). It's just that I found others are not interested in working with me. It hurt, as I had spent my entire career, working on teams, but I rubbed some dirt on it and walked it off. In the aggregate, I'm actually glad that I went through that. [0] https://github.com/ChrisMarshallNY#github-stuff https://github.com/ChrisMarshallNY#github-stuff
- wwww4all 6y agoCompanies look for expertise in older software engineers. They want senior level to help them maintain legacy systems or lead the upgrade to latest tech stack. If backend is your specialty, market oneself as expert in backed solutions using latest stack. The fundamental CS principles never change. Learn the basics of cloud, containers, orchestration, micro services, and inform recruiters about experiences delivering solutions in latest stack. The recruiters will be rushing to your profile and demanding interview slots. Good luck.
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y agoActually, frontend is my strength. I've written (and shipped) dozens of apps. I'm quite good at "closing" the app development process. I've been shipping (as opposed to just "coding") applications for over thirty years. The backend was just a more challenging project. I won't go into all the reasons that I wrote it, but it works a charm. A dedicated backend engineer could probably do better (actually a dedicated backend team. I'm fairly productive). I'm just glad I have a use for it. I was assuming it would never be used. I wrote it on a lark. Took seven months, but it was fun. I do stuff like that. A number of years ago, I taught myself to program Android, but decided I didn't like it, and never followed through. As far as recruiters...They do rush to my profile. I have a lot of nice buzzwords. As soon as they find out how old I am, though, the call suddenly has "connection problems," and I never hear from them again. I've taken to making sure that my age is clear upfront, just to save time. It's amusing how quickly they start discouraging me. They start by lowballing me, and when I make it clear that I would have no problem working for low wages (I do it for fun, and I don't really need the work), they start trying to find other reasons I wouldn't want the job. Like I said, I bailed on the rat race. It was just making me grumpy.
- eeZah7Ux 6y agoA good salary motivates people temporarily or if they are in dire need for money. In the long term, it's far from enough.
- ljm 6y agoPeopleware, Mythical Man Month, Five Dysfunctions of a Team, and similar classic texts were all written decades ago. It's been over forty years and many organisations haven't learned a damn thing from it. I don't blame developers for it, there are no dicks and idiots involved here. Read one of those books now and it will still feel like an epiphany.
- leetrout 6y agoYou are very correct. I think they all have weak spots but any one of those will indeed illuminate one on how broken pretty much every place is. I’d like to try working at bridgewater where there are less games played. One thing I’ve noticed is pretty much nowhere wants to acknowledge and act on employees emotions (for better or worse). I love this comment https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16603929 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16603929 And this article is pretty good: http://hbswk.hbs.edu/archive/5289.html http://hbswk.hbs.edu/archive/5289.html
- Delk 6y ago> It's the technology and the employers and the culture of development that's the problem. What is it about those things that you find to be the problem? Genuinely asking.
- convolvatron 6y agoi can take a whack - no one works as a team anymore. everyone gets their project, and they sometimes chat about it, but the whole group dynamic has been lost. this is huge. it almost guarantees that someone is pissed off because they dont have a voice. and that at least two developers are working at cross purposes. that someone is off diligently working on their piece without a real understanding of where it fits in. in the absence of group coordination, there generally is little or no technical management to prop up the group. requirements are dumped on engineering without the valuable back and forth about what makes sense (and how or why) no one tests anymore. we've all decided that those 8 units that the cicd runs on every commit is somehow adequate. alot of places dont even try to triage bugs anymore or even keep information in tickets so that someone down the line might figure it out no one plans anymore. there is no more grand arc of the project. we just do what we can get done this sprint, and pick up a little work for the next one. no one reads anymore. technical design discourse used to be the most important thing to do. now if you write up a draft, no one really wants to read or discuss it beyond grammar corrections same for reviews - i've been at organizations where every PR was a chance to really get into the design choices and the tradoffs. now you're lucky to get some useless style comments the scope is radically reduced. what used to be a glorious exercise in world building is now reduced to a choice of which large modules to use and the application of just enough glue to stick them together. no one feels responsible anymore. the project is a mess. i've got my part and I'm doing the best I can.
- chris11 6y ago> no one works as a team anymore. everyone gets their project One complaint I have about some agile implementations is that it takes away individual ownership and reduces larger problems to a series of less interesting choices. I agree with a lot of your other points though.
- 6y ago
- reaperducer 6y agoRetiring sounds good right about now. I'm with you. If I had another skill, I'd give up computers entirely. Maybe have a smartphone, and that's it. But only for limited use. I wish I could build things with my hands, or play an instrument, or just be good at something else, and let the tech world pass me by. I used to love technology because it was fun and interesting. It's no longer either of those things.
- blackrock 6y agoA lot of people seem to just create YouTube videos of their woodworking skills. Building drawers, cabinets, anything. They just drone away at it, but because it’s so visual, and you get a cacophony of random noises, that it makes for a good YouTube candidate. Maybe you can segue into that? Or maybe you can build and test drones. And the noise from the spinning propellers adds to the mystique of robotics development.
- vlunkr 6y agoI know it's the biggest cliche in the world, but the grass isn't always greener on the other side. Lots of musicians wish they had a skill that let them sit at a desk all day and get a stable paycheck. Not saying you have to keep working in tech forever, but I don't think it's objectively stopped being fun and interesting.
- cjsawyer 6y agoI think the “trick” is to find a fulfilling non computer based hobby
- Osiris 6y agoI agree. I don't do side projects, I do BJJ and ride motorcycles. Those things keep me from getting burned out on coding.
- vlunkr 6y agoMy rule about side projects is that I only work on them until they stop being fun. I'm ok using my free time to try out a new language or something, but once I'm tracking down bugs I just stop. I'm not doing that for free.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- RickS 6y ago> victims of the same broken game. I work with very smart people, to be honest. Couldn't agree more. I'm an SDE1.5 at best, working with a guy that's probably a 3.5. Writes code that's way over my head sometimes, and always well-tested and elegant. Lately I've been helping him by debugging issues in eg tsconfig and various JS build fuckery, and it's been both a relief and a surprise that even really brilliant people struggle with a lot of the same stuff I do. It's not (just) that I'm stupid and unintuitive – the tools are too, even for experienced engineers.
- amenod 6y agoOf course they are. They are written by people and often become standard because of good marketing instead of merit. However, I still find satisfaction in learning new things, trying to be better each day, overcoming new and more challenging problems and solving riddles in a nicer and more elegant way. I fail in all these things, too, of course - but it does give me a sense of purpose. And I don't appreciate any tool that comes my way, I'm picky that way. I love Python for its stdlib, React for its declarative nature, C for its simplicity... and avoid dealing with the JS build system of the month as much as I can. Enough to understand, but I try not to lose too much time and mental energy on them. That said, if I didn't enjoy programming, I would be happy to move to management or even leave the industry to become a carpenter. I think that as long as you do something meaningful and also help other people (so that you can live off it), it doesn't matter much what that thing is.
- M5x7wI3CmbEem10 6y ago> That said, if I didn't enjoy programming, I would be happy to move to management would you go for project management in particular or are there other paths?
- dleslie 6y agoI've never worked at a company which took titles seriously, let alone fractional title levels; what on earth do those mean?
- taf2 6y agoI’m 20 years in as well... I think it’s still fun... it’s just a game of fixing things... the other game about how people interact is not as fun but still kinda interesting... game on old friend
- mgkimsal 6y ago"it’s just a game of fixing things" 25+ years in, I get little joy/fun from constantly 'fixing things' that shouldn't have needed fixing (or nearly as much fixing) had people planned ahead, or communicated, or tested, or just listened to the people they'd hired that do these things (plan/communicate/test/etc).
- cunac 6y ago35+ years in and I am grateful every day that I do what I love. It is fun to make things tick.
- wwww4all 6y agoI've been wrangling software bytes for a while and I am pragmatic about the business. Software engineering is extremely difficult. High performance engineers are rare and valuable. Some times, they become jaded and burn out. This is my career and my craft, so I'm inclined to ride the waves and trends in software engineering. Negotiate for above average salary while maintaining my tech stack and producing at above average output. Most people don't understand what it takes to develop and deploy software solutions. They only see the unicorns like Google, Facebook, and think software engineers are common. They don't see the vast swaths of land of failed software startups and dreams and incompetence in software engineering. Most people in software engineering doesn't know or comprehend basic data structures and algorithms, which form basis for all software solutions at scale. Yet, they are filled into dev position slots by HR/management and asked to develop complex systems. To have long term career in software engineering is like any other trade. Observe how the game is played, learn to play the game and play the game right. A software engineer with basic skill stack and right long term view can ride the software wave for decades, just by understanding basic CS principles and utilizing them to develop solutions. Switch jobs regularly and negotiate hard for salary and levels.
- sircastor 6y ago> Switch jobs regularly and negotiate hard for salary and levels. I’ve been at my current role for almost 7 years. It doesn’t pay nearly what I could be making elsewhere. I’ve interviewed and been offered better money, but it means giving up the kind of work I do now for something less interesting. I’ve turned down those offers and stuck where I am, even though it means less money. As my wife told me when we were talking about this: This is the work that you’re going to be doing every day, and that has to be worth it. That said, there is a cost to my career sticking here instead of moving around.
- wwww4all 6y agoThere’s a phrase I heard while back, I don’t live to work, I work to live. High performance software engineers negotiate for higher salary and the type of work environment and type of projects. They work to live by taking control over their salary and project assignments. Sometimes, they have to work on less interesting projects. They deliver solutions. At the same time, they regularly have conversations on other more interesting projects. Make sure they line up more interesting projects in the roadmap. There’s more risk in stagnating position than taking control and regularly switching jobs for higher salary and more interesting projects. There are significantly more software engineering problems than people that can deliver solutions. High performance software engineers can have their cake and eat it too.
- WalterBright 6y ago> Retiring sounds good right about now. I tried that. After 6 weeks of watching TV I restarted my business and went back to work. Retirement is a living death.
- syndacks 6y agoHey, thanks for sharing this. Mind expanding? I'm curious to hear what you had planned going into retirement and what you seek going back to work. Are you right back to the same as you were right before "retiring"? Knowing how your first round of retirement went, what would you have done differently in the years/decades leading up to it?
- WalterBright 6y agoWhat I discovered is that a life without purpose is not a life. The fun is in having worthwhile goals and striving to reach them. Being passively entertained, bleh. It's also why I have a very limited appetite for "see the world" traveling. I can only look for so long, then I need to be doing something with a purpose. I've seen what happens when people retire. They suddenly get old and lose their vitality. They become boring people. My plan is to work until they carry me out in a box.
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoThis guy planted an entire forest by himself, probably did more for the world thank most of us ever will: https://metro.co.uk/2018/08/08/man-turned-desert-forest-planting-tree-every-day-40-years-7814241/#:~:text=In%201979%2C%20a%20teenager%20became,went%20entirely%20unnoticed%20for%20decades https://metro.co.uk/2018/08/08/man-turned-desert-forest-plan....
- rufus_foreman 6y agoI tried it. I figured out I can make a few dollars a minute sitting in front of a computer screen or I can make 0 dollars a minute sitting in front of a computer screen. Those are my two choices. The choice is pretty clear.
- medium_burrito 6y agoRetirement sounds amazing. What really gets me is my employers hiring engineers for $500k per seat and they can memorize their way through Leetcode interviews but can't even structure small programs in a modular, easy to understand way, and when it comes to larger pieces of software, it's complete chaos.
- arjun-menon 6y ago> Retiring sounds good right about now. My personal plan, instead of retiring, is to work on inventing solutions to the issues plaguing large and complex software projects. One of my primary sub-goals under this mission, is to create a new programming language that'll handle complexity excellently, while also making it hard for a programmer to write bugs in it (strong static type system, deep static analysis, thorough linting, some kind of automatic proofing or verification, paradigms that make writing bugs less likely, paradigms that handle modularization and complexity gracefully, etc). Overall, when there are big problems in the world (poverty, human rights abuses, climate change, bad software), I want to try to use my skills and abilities toward solving those problems, rather throwing my hands in the air, and giving into hopelessness.
- wffurr 6y ago>> create a new programming language The problems with software engineering aren't technical. They are organizational, political, and cultural.
- Aqueous 6y agowith respect i think it's a combination. business demands value delivery and features on a constant basis, and programmers are constantly layering crap over crap in order to deliver. nobody stops and says "hey, wait a second - let's pause, and figure out how we're going to invest now to make the changes you're asking for easier in the future." programmers need to learn to identify when this is happening (a technical skill) and demand change, and product needs to learn to listen and understand the consequences of not heeding this advice. because after 5 - 10 years of 100 different people working on a given system, the complexity becomes unmanageable, and the business grinds to a halt. and then heads start to roll. and yet the people demanding the new features now are never going to have suffer the consequences, because they'll be off to another venture in 5 - 10 years.
- wffurr 6y agoThat's exactly right in some cases. You are describing one set of organizational and cultural problems with software engineering that can only be solved through a cultural and political approach Other organizations and cultures have different sets of problems.
- FpUser 6y agoI've been programming for about 40 years. Had ups and downs. But I mostly worked on creating new products (not always purely software). Also been on my own for the most part. In the end. I love it and I hate it. I love it because it let me express myself and it is a great feeling when you see others using your products. I hate it because there is always way too much non creative work and general BS around but that's life. But generally I enjoy it and are not planning retirement. Will just maybe work less.
- trhway 6y ago>It's the technology and the employers and the culture of development that's the problem. Classic "it is the other people" cope out. We all are willing participants in building that mountain of mostly garbage, and there is still huge civilization progress enabled by it.
- elwell 6y agoWorking with Clojure/Script is fun.
- spaetzleesser 6y agoI think change would be good. After 30 years software I have a very strong craving to do something totally different. I never got really settled into the corporate life so I am pretty exhausted with it now. Programming would probably be still fun in a different context.
- scrozier 6y agoAfter being an entrepreneur and an independent contractor most of my career (I'm 62), and now finding myself working for a company "rolling up" a bunch of software companies, I will say that the state of employment seems to have gone downhill drastically over my lifetime.
- iorrus 6y agoCould you expand a bit on this? Do you mean the quality of the people in employment has gone downhill or do you mean that equality of life for employees has reduced? Less job security, poorer working conditions etc?
- scrozier 6y agoThe latter. All the things you say, plus inexpert management, ridiculous legalese in employment matters, lack of respect for employees, poor hiring practices, etc.
- harel 6y agoI'm 25 years in, give or take, and I still find myself amazed people want to pay me money to do this. I do find it romantic. The whole thing.