3 ms·
This makes no sense. Are you saying that digital currency is a fancy term for a direct deposit? We've had direct deposits for a very long time. My tax refund co
by bawolff 6y ago
This makes no sense. Are you saying that digital currency is a fancy term for a direct deposit? We've had direct deposits for a very long time. My tax refund comes as a direct deposit. The government seems to be able to directly give me money digitially just fine.
- Mengkudulangsat 6y agoYou know what's new that hasn't been done before? Your government giving money to me (not a citizen) in an effort to popularize your currency. If President Xi wants to gift me some digital Yuan to spend how I wish (so the Yuan becomes more accepted outside China).. I say hell, why not?
- anm89 6y ago> Are you saying that digital currency is a fancy term for a direct deposit? Basically yes, but specifically only for the case of a direct deposit between the Federal reserve and an individual. That doesn't currently exist. But that's also basically my point. CBDCs are nothing new from an operational or technological perspective which I think is something many people are getting confused about. They are a new thing in terms of policy capabilities for central banks. They are not a new thing in any other way. All the technology already exists.
- bawolff 6y agoFair enough. I guess it feels almost unbelievable that all this fuss is over something so mundane. I guess i dont really understand why though. It sounds like the central bank is thinking about becoming, well, a normal bank. We already have normal banks. Governments can already transfer cash to accounts in normal banks. Governments can already sell bonds to people who want some sort of very stable investment backed by the state. What's the point of becoming a consumer bank? Why are they bothering? How do they benefit? Is there anything to this other than the desire to jump aboard the anything-that-sounds-remotely-like-bitcoin-even-if-unrelated hype train.
- sanxiyn 6y agoBenefit is that currently government insures bank deposit, which is subsidy to banking. For example, FDIC does deposit insurance in US. There is cap in FDIC insurance, which complicates large deposit. We can get rid of all these complexity with CBDC.
- bawolff 6y agoFDIC is funded via premiums paid for by member banks, not the gov. That's not a subsidary. As far as the insurance cap goes, if the new plan is that the central bank doesn't need insurance because it can always print new money, i suppose that's true, but that is one hell of a subsidary and one that sounds scary from a fiscal responsibility standpoint.
- anm89 6y agoI personally don't belive this has anything to do with deposit insurance.
- imtringued 6y agoNo, but it's the consequence of equating a dollar in a database with a real dollar and the subsequent ownership of that dollar. A deposited dollar in your bank account is a low yield investment. You don't own the dollars, you own the promise that you will get your dollars back.
- anm89 6y agoI think this is actually a monumental shift in the whole US political system were it to be enacted. Because it drastically broadens the scope of actions the Fed or another CB is capable of therefor increasing its influence and importance. And keep in mind the people running it are not democratically elected and are partially private banks. Right now the fed basically has no direct tie to the real economy. They always have to act indirectly via asset purchases from large institutions. They basically have one hand tied behind their back all the time. This unties that hand and allows them to interact with the real economy directly and not just the financial intermediaries.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- sanxiyn 6y agoYou can have deposit in a bank, and that bank has deposit in the central bank. That's the current situation. With CBDC, you can have deposit in the central bank. This is an important difference.
- bawolff 6y agoImportant to whom? As a private citizen, why would i want this? As a central bank, why would i want this? Which parties benefit from such an arrangement, which to me seems only superficially different from the staus quo? How and why do they benefit?
- sanxiyn 6y agoI answered elsewhere.
- PeterisP 6y agoOne less middleman that can only add extra delay and extra fees. Also, removes part of systemic risk since "digital currency" is held at central bank and not with retail banks, then it decouples transactions/accounts from deposits/lending. Currently, if a major bank fails because of lending issues, there's a push to prop them up since them failing would also cause immense harm to all the businesses who just transact through that bank, if this is decoupled, then the economic system would be a bit more stable during crisis.
- imtringued 6y agoBank bailouts will become very unattractive since there is a less risky alternative. It's like building a nice bridge that can collapse vs an ugly bridge that will never collapse.
- imtringued 6y agoConsider the difference between a Bitcoin and dollars in your bank account. You can own Bitcoin but your bank account just shows how much dollars your bank owes you, you don't own any of the dollars yourself.