7 ms·
This was somewhat surprising to me, but appears that he was accurately quoted the law. If you go through the flowchart on the State Department's website for th
by patio11 15y ago
This was somewhat surprising to me, but appears that he was accurately quoted the law. If you go through the flowchart on the State Department's website for the Visa Waiver Program, which would be my #1 suggestion for someone coming from the Netherlands,
For the purpose of the Visa Waiver Program, "business" generally refers to business activities other than the performance of skilled or unskilled labor. Examples of activities that are allowed include:
engaging in international commercial transactions, which do not involve gainful employment in the United States (such as a merchant who takes orders in the U.S. for goods manufactured abroad, or who travels to the U.S. to purchase American-made goods for export from the U.S.);
negotiating contracts;
consulting with business associates; and
participating in scientific, educational, professional or business conventions, conferences, or seminars.
The performance of any skilled or unskilled labor - even if it is unpaid - is most always prohibited. This includes performing work in the U.S. as a trainer or consultant.
Activities allowed on the VWP parallel those activities allowed with a standard "B1" category business visa. Please see our B visa information page for more details.
Working visas are, as stated, not exactly trivial to get. (And if you're already at the airport it is too late.)
- WildUtah 15y agoI continue to be astonished that anyone still comes to the USA without either a specific rule allowing his activity (e.g. tourism, negotiating contracts) or a consultation with a US immigration lawyer. Aren't there enough horror stories? Isn't the craziness well known abroad? In most of the world people who want to be tourists in the USA dread the extensive and humiliating application interview, questionnaire, and documentation process just to get a visa. The same is required to change planes at a US airport. The process is byzantine and irrational. Read all the available documents and hire a lawyer if anything seems uncertain. The border authorities routinely retain old documents, especially those submitted in error, and use them in a Kafkaesque process to deny all future permissions. Every thing you say or send to the government can be reinterpreted and used against you forever. It would be best to consult a lawyer every time you interact with CBP, though that would be expensive.
- akkartik 15y agoIs this any different from other countries? I'm just surprised you expect to go to any first-world country and work without a permit. For a very broad definition of work. London requires a visa for even changing planes. The paperwork for having your parents visit is even more onerous, I'm told. If you have a small child you're required to hire a nanny before they'll let your parents visit. So yeah all immigration authorities are moronic. OP said he's travelled all over the EU. Well, I assume he has an EU passport?
- davidw 15y ago> Is this any different from other countries? Very much so. Here in Italy for instance, I've known several people who have spent years here illegally, performing useful work. Sure, Italy has a large underground economy in any case, but still...
- dangero 15y agoI think the key here is "illegally". He could have marked, "Tourist" on his visa application and he would have been let in, but he didn't.
- christoph 15y agoI've marked business on my visa waiver customs form and the border officer has written WT (Waiver Tourist) on my passport around 50% of the time. Sometimes I've been asked a barrage of questions (company i'm working for, goods in my possession, amount of money in cash, amount of credit available to me, etc.), other times, not a single question. The whole process can seem very hit and miss depending on the customs officer you are getting and the mood they are in. As much as I love the US, it does feel these days as though they are segregating themselves from the rest of the business world. I had to queue at O'Hare (Chicago) for over 2.5hrs after a 8.5hr flight to get to the customs desk on my recent visit - how is this acceptable in any first world country?
- 15y ago
- tlrobinson 15y agoI wonder if he could have reworded his description to something that falls under "participating in scientific, educational, professional or business conventions, conferences, or seminars." People come to the US all the time to speak at conferences and don't have any problem, right?
- jvdh 15y agoNot a problem at all. I've been to the US (from the Netherlands) over a dozen times to participate in a scientific conference and have had no problem at all. Maybe some grumpiness, but that's about it.
- thebooktocome 15y agoIt depends what the conference is about. Some people in the security industry have had problems, as have political dissidents.
- wisty 15y agoOne of the questions on a visa application is something like: "Do you plan to attempt to overthrow the Government of the United States by force or subversion?". Political dissidents and crackers may have an issue there, if that's their stated purpose.
- WWWWH 15y agoI always enjoyed Peter Medawar's response: "No, and if I do it by accident, I'll be very sorry"
- tlrobinson 15y agoSure, but that's a different issue entirely.
- tptacek 15y agoThe cases that spring immediately to mind in security tend to have more to do with the fact that conference visitors are conducting business in the US than out of any particular concern with the subject matter. People come to, say, Black Hat, and in addition to speaking also have their names attached to training courses.
- oikjhgbpokj 15y agoEven more difficult to go to the USA to hear a talk. You can be invited to give a paper at an international conference and be allowed in no-problem. But is there is a workshop session where somebody is being paid to give the talk you can attend it without a student visa. And you can't get a student visa unless you are attending a school - workshop talks at conference don't apply. Everyone from overseas who goes to a paid-for session at a conference is breaking the law.
- jrockway 15y agoIt's probably a good idea to back a bold assertion like this with a citation of some sort.
- _delirium 15y agoI've never heard customs actually ask this level of detail; don't people just say they're attending an academic conference? Do they ask exactly how you'll be participating in the conference? I can believe it'd make a difference in getting a visa from a non-visa-waiver country, though; having a talk on the schedule, and a letter of invitation from the organizers, can make the application go more smoothly.
- oikjhgbpokj 15y agoWell you can always lie to immigration and do anything you like. The real problen is if you do come from a visa-waiver country - it is almost impossible to get a visa, because everybody uses the waiver that if you try and get a business visa to attend a conference they think you must be upto something