4 ms·

A Georgia lawmakers also sued Tennessee to move the state border so that they could siphon water from the Tennessee river: https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/n

A Georgia lawmakers also sued Tennessee to move the state border so that they could siphon water from the Tennessee river: https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2013/04/01/tennessee-georgia-water-border-dispute/2044429/ https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2013/04/01/tennes... Georgia and Atlanta have unsustainable growth which their natural resources can't support and are trying to pass off the externalities onto their neighbors. I am biased as a former resident of both Tennessee and Florida.

mc32 6y ago
Georgia? They get enough rain. Seems to me they need to learn about water conservation.
- bpodgursky 6y ago
  Yeah, if Las Vegas can figure out how to make do with the Colorado, I'm pretty sure Atlanta will be ok.
  - Jtsummers 6y ago
    Las Vegas got to take advantage of an early 20th century hydroelectric dam project. They also had frequent water restrictions when I lived there in the 90s, and the population has only grown so I imagine it isn't much improved now. Atlanta's artificial lakes/reservoirs are from a similar time, new ones aren't being made fast enough if at all, and the population continues to grow. Dealing with multiple jurisdictions (the region known as Atlanta encompasses the city of Atlanta, many other cities, and is spread across several counties) further complicates the issue when it comes to funding and determining responsibility. You could argue the state of GA should step in. However, there's a huge political chasm between the metro Atlanta area and most of the rest of the state (A "fuck those city slickers" attitude is very common in rural Georgia and the smaller cities, Atlantans aren't viewed as Georgians given how many are transplants). The water in the Atlanta region also needs to travel down river to many other areas (and other states) in order to sustain those regions.
    - specialist 6y ago
      I was last in Las Vegas 10+ years ago. The shrinking of Lake Mead, the reservoir made by the Hoover Dam, was alarming back then. I'm afraid to even check it's current status. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lake_Mead#Drought_and_water_usage_issues https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lake_Mead#Drought_and_water_us...
      - cobookman 6y ago
        Cheap solar in the west (California, Arizona, Nevada) coupled with desalination plants. We'll be fine for *urban/residential* water needs for the foreseeable future.
        mc32 6y ago
        Where is the briny/salty water in ariz/nev? Cal, yes, lots.
        cobookman 6y ago
        Not that crazy to have a pipeline from California to Ariz/Nev. With Ariz/Nev supply Cali with their excess solar to the desal plants.
        yoloswagins 6y ago
        The current plan is to pay for a plant in Mexico in exchange for them to give up their share of water from the Colorado River Compact.
    - hinkley 6y ago
      It's just a One Major Metropolis versus rural thing. Chicago is Chicago, not Illinois. Watch two Illinoisans try to sort out they're "From Illinois" but one's from anywhere but a Chicago exurb, and they'll say, "Oh, you're from Chicago," not, "cool." More like, "Yeah you're technically in Illinois ... You're in the corner by the weird lake and you're way too close to Wisconsin and Indiana for comfort anyway."
  - brudgers 6y ago
    The Colorado has almost 250,000 square miles of basin. The Chattahoochee less than 9000. Atlanta metro is about six million, Las Vegas metro about 2.5. Politically, the Colorado is a different animal. Mexico is downstream and historically has just had to lump it when the river runs dry. Which it has as the US built dams. And today, it has to make do with just a remaining 5% of the historical wetlands where the Colorado flows into the Sea of Cortez.
- Mountain_Skies 6y ago
  They need more reservoirs. Georgia gets plenty of rain but it's very unevenly distributed over the years. Lake Lanier was a good start and some of the counties have built lots of tiny reservoirs but if the state wants that region to continue to grow, they need to get serious about creating a couple of large reservoirs. Conservation is good but is only one piece of the solution and not one that is mutually exclusive with the temporal rain distribution issue.
Mountain_Skies 6y ago
Well, the border actually is in the wrong place so he had a point but given how little of the river would have been in Georgia under the revised border, they still wouldn't have much of an argument for being entitled to much of the waterflow.

mc32 6y ago

Georgia? They get enough rain. Seems to me they need to learn about water conservation.

bpodgursky 6y ago
Yeah, if Las Vegas can figure out how to make do with the Colorado, I'm pretty sure Atlanta will be ok.
- Jtsummers 6y ago
  Las Vegas got to take advantage of an early 20th century hydroelectric dam project. They also had frequent water restrictions when I lived there in the 90s, and the population has only grown so I imagine it isn't much improved now. Atlanta's artificial lakes/reservoirs are from a similar time, new ones aren't being made fast enough if at all, and the population continues to grow. Dealing with multiple jurisdictions (the region known as Atlanta encompasses the city of Atlanta, many other cities, and is spread across several counties) further complicates the issue when it comes to funding and determining responsibility. You could argue the state of GA should step in. However, there's a huge political chasm between the metro Atlanta area and most of the rest of the state (A "fuck those city slickers" attitude is very common in rural Georgia and the smaller cities, Atlantans aren't viewed as Georgians given how many are transplants). The water in the Atlanta region also needs to travel down river to many other areas (and other states) in order to sustain those regions.
  - specialist 6y ago
    I was last in Las Vegas 10+ years ago. The shrinking of Lake Mead, the reservoir made by the Hoover Dam, was alarming back then. I'm afraid to even check it's current status. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lake_Mead#Drought_and_water_usage_issues https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lake_Mead#Drought_and_water_us...
    - cobookman 6y ago
      Cheap solar in the west (California, Arizona, Nevada) coupled with desalination plants. We'll be fine for *urban/residential* water needs for the foreseeable future.
      - mc32 6y ago
        Where is the briny/salty water in ariz/nev? Cal, yes, lots.
        cobookman 6y ago
        Not that crazy to have a pipeline from California to Ariz/Nev. With Ariz/Nev supply Cali with their excess solar to the desal plants.
      - yoloswagins 6y ago
        The current plan is to pay for a plant in Mexico in exchange for them to give up their share of water from the Colorado River Compact.
  - hinkley 6y ago
    It's just a One Major Metropolis versus rural thing. Chicago is Chicago, not Illinois. Watch two Illinoisans try to sort out they're "From Illinois" but one's from anywhere but a Chicago exurb, and they'll say, "Oh, you're from Chicago," not, "cool." More like, "Yeah you're technically in Illinois ... You're in the corner by the weird lake and you're way too close to Wisconsin and Indiana for comfort anyway."
- brudgers 6y ago
  The Colorado has almost 250,000 square miles of basin. The Chattahoochee less than 9000. Atlanta metro is about six million, Las Vegas metro about 2.5. Politically, the Colorado is a different animal. Mexico is downstream and historically has just had to lump it when the river runs dry. Which it has as the US built dams. And today, it has to make do with just a remaining 5% of the historical wetlands where the Colorado flows into the Sea of Cortez.
Mountain_Skies 6y ago
They need more reservoirs. Georgia gets plenty of rain but it's very unevenly distributed over the years. Lake Lanier was a good start and some of the counties have built lots of tiny reservoirs but if the state wants that region to continue to grow, they need to get serious about creating a couple of large reservoirs. Conservation is good but is only one piece of the solution and not one that is mutually exclusive with the temporal rain distribution issue.

Mountain_Skies 6y ago

Well, the border actually is in the wrong place so he had a point but given how little of the river would have been in Georgia under the revised border, they still wouldn't have much of an argument for being entitled to much of the waterflow.