9 ms·
House Republicans propose nationwide ban on municipal broadband networks
- lrobinovitch 6y agoPlanet Money did a 20min episode covering the City of Wilson's attempt at municipal broadband. Worth a listen: https://www.npr.org/2020/05/29/865908114/small-america-vs-big-internet https://www.npr.org/2020/05/29/865908114/small-america-vs-bi...
- michaelbrave 6y agoI've lived in places with local Co-op's for broadband and phone service (in Kansas) it was some of the best service I've ever had and cheaper too. They only did this because the larger companies were ignoring them and not giving proper service since it was a smaller community. In short, banning these is bullshit it should rather be encouraged.
- artificialLimbs 6y agoYes. I live in Arkansas, am on co-op owned fiber. It is by far the most stable, fastest, and fair priced service I've ever had. I can call down to the shop any day and get a call back from a network admin within an hour. They provide TV and phone here too. The other option is AT&T (MAYBE 6mbit) dsl.
- beauzero 6y agoYes. My mother lives in Montana on an Indian reservation. 60 miles from a population center greater than 50k. She has better broadband options than I do and I live 40 minutes outside of Atlanta and had to file an FCC complaint for ATT to hook up DSL at my home. ...her CLEC/co-op is still in existence because it was too small to be a valuable acquisition during WorldCom's flameout.
- coldcode 6y agoDead on arrival given the current state of the House. I can't even understand why anyone would propose such a thing other than to gain support from the big network companies. I have on shitty option and that's Spectrum even though I am in the middle of a huge metro area; most people I know have multiple options especially AT&T Fiber. I have a massively fast (sic) 6mb upload. I can't even hold a zoom call with video. Maybe Starlink will finally goad them into competition. But if we had non-profit muni internet, everyone would need to compete.
- mywittyname 6y agoTelcos are big, big Democratic supporters. And they only need to flip a handful to pass a bill like this (which will be upheld in the supreme court)
- chrismcb 6y agoHow can the supreme court uphold it?
- rabidrat 6y ago> I can't even understand why anyone would propose such a thing A bill that won't go anywhere but gets a lot of attention is a great time-waster. Think of it as part of a DoS attack on meaningful legislation.
- mips_avatar 6y agoTechnology does sometimes find a way, I am posting this via starlink internet right now. Despite being only about 3 miles from a fiber line, Centurylink wouldn't give us anything better than DSL that fails out 30 times a day.
- davidfstr 6y agoBanning the building of ISPs by local governments - who probably care about their people - and relegating ISPs to private companies only, in the name of “promoting competition” is ludicrous. One does not increase competition by limiting supply. I can only conclude this proposal is in bad faith. I therefore speculate that big ISPs like Comcast must be paying the politicians behind the bill. NPR covered a local government a while back that tried to build a local ISP but was shutdown when players like Comcast brought in their legal teams to make building a government-run ISP illegal in that jurisdiction. We absolutely must not see a ban like this at the federal level.
- TheOtherHobbes 6y agoOne increases profit by limiting supply - an obvious anticompetitive move.
- Naac 6y ago>> NPR covered a local government a while back that tried to build a local ISP but was shutdown when players like Comcast brought in their legal teams to make building a government-run ISP illegal in that jurisdiction. >> I therefore speculate that big ISPs like Comcast must be paying the politicians behind the bill. And after reading this quote from the article: >> PCMag recently named Chattanooga, Tennessee, the best work-from-home city in the nation, citing in part the city's "widely available broadband Internet" provided by the Chattanooga Electric Power Board. Comcast initially tried to block that public network from being built but eventually upgraded its own service to better compete against the public option. It seems very plausible.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- blockmarker 6y agoGovernment-run enterprises are not fair competition since they have unfair advantages. One does not create competition by allowing enterprises which can do dumping at worst, and always have special advantages at best. The ISP market, being usually a duopoly or monopoly, is an exception due to how broken the market is. But in most occasions it is a bad idea. I don't doubt the proposal is in bad faith, but the excuse is reasonable.
- cardiffspaceman 6y agoHow about "House Head-on-straight Party proposes nationalizing all consumer broadband and delegating it to the municipalities."
- thayne 6y agoHow on earth is that supposed to promote competition? In my area, the only places where there is any competition for ISPs are where there are municipal broadband networks.
- aaomidi 6y agoFree market in action /s
- zoobab 6y agohttps://twitter.com/Diskonnekt_/status/1354805885348974605 https://twitter.com/Diskonnekt_/status/1354805885348974605
- JohnJamesRambo 6y agoI cannot imagine what mental gymnastics allows a person to support this.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- btilly 6y ago"If you support this, we'll give a million dollars to your next re-election campaign. Otherwise it will go to your opponent." It doesn't take a lot of mental gymnastics to decide to support it.
- hkt 6y agoNon-American asking unironically.. I thought these guys were about free markets?
- criddell 6y agoThey are. I think the argument is that a company that has to turn a profit can't compete with a municipal system that doesn't have to turn a profit.
- btilly 6y agoThey will also claim that the municipal system gets subsidized out of taxes. Conveniently ignoring the fact that the telecom industry gets subsidized to the tune of billions per year, despite decades of failing to accomplish the objectives that they said they would while being subsidized.
- jschwartzi 6y agoAnd in the former case, the people lose.
- spacemanmatt 6y agoRepublicans are just anti-public.
- teekert 6y agoTo me, this is US politics in a nutshell. Everybody knows Americans have mostly poor quality internet, with little freedoms (ie blocked ports, changing IP addresses) and most people understand that there is currently 0 competition. People try to fix it and the government jumps in (which is just a front for companies usually nowadays) and they have the audacity to come with something called "connect act". Both Ayn Rand and Karl Marx would turn around in their graves if they learned about the government and companies being this close and so anti-people. Just look at other countries, why do other countries have better AND cheaper AND more free network access? Nobody (in the right place at least) seems to ask themselves that in the world's greatest nation.
- aaomidi 6y agoIt's quite interesting that the majority of us have accepted political donations and getting your way with giving money to politicians as a "Standard" way of life. What is it going to take for us to get rid of this absolutely broken system?
- shmageggy 6y ago> The bill has an exception that would allow existing government networks to continue in cities and towns without substantial broadband competition. How is this even logically coherent? If there is one private provider then municipal provides competition and is good, but as soon as there are two providers, municipal somehow becomes becomes competition-limiting overregulation? Give me a break.
- flyinghamster 6y agoRemember, hypocrisy is very much a strategy of the Republicans. They'll hoot and holler about "fiscal responsibility" as they rack up record deficits without batting an eye, and that's just one of many examples. Any slogan of theirs is only relevant until it becomes inconvenient to them, at which point they just drop it and say "When did we ever say that?" If challenged, it's the old walkback, like describing their presence at the coup attempt, storming the Capitol, as "We were just there to witness history." They're basically using the Nazi playbook, as described by Jean-Paul Sartre: "Never believe that anti-Semites are completely unaware of the absurdity of their replies. They know that their remarks are frivolous, open to challenge. But they are amusing themselves, for it is their adversary who is obliged to use words responsibly, since he believes in words. The anti-Semites have the right to play. They even like to play with discourse for, by giving ridiculous reasons, they discredit the seriousness of their interlocutors. They delight in acting in bad faith, since they seek not to persuade by sound argument but to intimidate and disconcert. If you press them too closely, they will abruptly fall silent, loftily indicating by some phrase that the time for argument is past."
- jimmygrapes 6y agoI can't flag a post on mobile but this comment has no place here.
- flyinghamster 6y agoI stand by it. The never-ending hypocrisy that comes from them needs to be countered whenever it occurs. After 1/6, it's clear that it needs to be countered more than ever.
- shmerl 6y agoCorrupt ISP cronies bribed by monopolists who don't like the idea of someone actually making competitive networks. Why such absurd pro-monopoly laws can be even proposed? They should get jail time for corruption.
- legerdemain 6y agoIf you thought Comcast was bad, imagine an Internet provider that's as competent and responsive as a visit to the DMV. Can you imagine municipally provided cell phone service? Who wants any of their utilities to be managed by dysfunctional local government?
- mywittyname 6y agoIn many states, DMVs are private enterprises that are provided a license by the state to conduct business. I think one way you can tell is if the the DMV handles titles or there's a title office in an annex forcing you to wait in line twice. A relative of mine runs a few DMVs in my area.
- forgotmysn 6y agoremember that you're comparing against companies like AT&T and Comcast. municipal broadband has had almost universal acclaim from users who previously subscribed to those companies
- sudosysgen 6y agoWe had this in some Canadian provinces. The service was the cheapest in the country and the most liked. People got very angry when it got privatized. Some people's bills doubled. It wasn't even subsidized.
- mywittyname 6y ago>It wasn't even subsidized. Internet access is insanely high margin. Once the lines are laid, the cost to provide service is next to nothing. The bulk of the costs come from paying off the loans associated with laying the original lines. There are probably many cities in the country who could provide free 10Mb symmetrical service to every house, then have tiered monthly charges starting at $10 up to $50 for 50Mb to 1Gb services for those who want it, and turn a profit on internet access.
- drdaeman 6y ago> next to nothing That’s not exactly true, I believe maintenance costs are non-negligible. It’s not like networks are “set up once and forget forever” - over time shit always hits the fan somewhere: lines degrade, network hardware goes haywire (frequently, in subtle ways), so after monitors (or customer calls) indicate an issue, it all requires dispatching people to check and fix. Ot doesn’t help that a significant fraction of the reported issues are in customer’s systems (poor WiFi reception, pets nibbling on the wires, malware, etc), and lots of issues are sporadic and non-persistent (something failing at random for 10 minutes a day is even worse that a complete outage). I was a software developer working for a (non-US) ISP, and while I wasn’t working in the field I can say that our line engineers were almost always busy. If it would be easy to set things up, no one would have crappy Internet. The ISP I was working for had a decent competition - IIRC on average our users had about 4-5 alternatives, so unlike some US monopolists we weren’t able to just ignore the issues.
- theluketaylor 6y agoRepublicans are all for states' rights. Unless it's something they (or their corporate sponsors) want to regulate, then they have never heard of states' rights. Democrats are nearly as bad, so it's not like they can claim any sort of moral high ground here, but at least the areas they want to regulate federally are a little more self consistent. Since the telecom companies have divided up regions to avoid completing with each other, the threat of municipal broadband is one of the few competition inputs to prevent the exact stagnation and poor service that has taken hold.
- duxup 6y agoIt has to be really frustrating for local municipalities / regions who want to make it desirable to life / work there ... but they're in a hole of crappy internet determined by some monopoly that isn't responsive / responsible to anyone. I know some local areas near me are just SOL as far as good service goes. The local monopoly actually has run lines across people's yards and just left them there exposed for years. Some folks just bury them themselves... they're doing work for the company, so they don't accidentally mow over their neighbor's internet connection.
- snarf21 6y agoSo much for the free market. It will be interesting to see what StarLink does to broadband over time.
- theluketaylor 6y agoThe most charitable interpretation for support of municipal broadband bans is that municipalities have a natural monopoly over rights of way and telecom installation that private companies can't compete against. Not totally unfair, but the better protection is requiring municipalities lease access to last mile lines at fair rates rather than banning them from participating in the laying of lines. I also highly doubt anyone supporting this bill is actually concerned about monopolies, since if they were they'd also be banning the non-competition between telecom companies that has municipalities considering their own broadband in the first place.
- random5634 6y agoHere's the thing. Municipal owned fiber is great -> you permit and add it on EVERY dig. Putting a new sewer line in? Run fiber. Someone wants to replace their sewer lateral? Run fiber. Repaving? Run fiber. Someone doing a new development. Run fiber. You can actually wholesale it out as well if you want and let folks compete on top of it with backhaul etc (at whatever level you want, from customer service / billing handoff only to some backhaul network comp). That said, fiber to the home is pretty close to a natural monopoly. Everyone should have a fiber to their house, but it makes NO sense for competing providers to string up fibers in most cases and so they do not. I'm on fiber now with a hardwired set of connections to pretty much everything. It is AMAZING! I do remote work, video conference, large files. Even my 300Mbps cable service only had 10Mbps upload (or less), so wife and kids doing whatever on things (dropbox file sync maybe for large vidoes) meant my zoom calls were dropping. Gigabit is 4-6ms (!) ping to major services. And symmetric.
- adolph 6y ago> Municipal owned fiber is great -> you permit and add it on EVERY dig. Putting a new sewer line in? Run fiber. Someone wants to replace their sewer lateral? Run fiber. Repaving? Run fiber. Someone doing a new development. Run fiber. Ok, I can see how a municipality can make everything else very expensive and slow if they become an ISP with a government attached.
- gremlinsinc 6y agoThis is what Utopia did in Utah...they worked with UDOT and was a collaboration between the state and smaller telecoms to build out a network but it was in collaboration with a lot of providers. Everytime there was road construction they laid conduit, first from SLC to Provo, then to all the smaller communities off i15, then all the rurals. I live in a rural town with 45 thousand in the entire county and I have access to 1 gig fiber. In my previous rental in an even more small town (500 residents) I still had fiber. This was 45 minutes from any other town. Utah rocks for broadband and is one of the best models I've ever seen.
- adolph 6y agoOk, the links from the article are interesting. I can't claim any deep understanding [0] but are there rural/underserved cross-subsidization issues with muni broadband if the feds don't get taxes/fees from it? The bill that directly addresses muni broadband [1] seems very specific to "a State or political subdivision thereof." Would a community nonprofit/coop style muni broadband be affected by this bill? 0. https://republicans-energycommerce.house.gov/news/press-release/ec-gop-leaders-unveil-the-boosting-broadband-connectivity-agenda/ https://republicans-energycommerce.house.gov/news/press-rele... 1. https://republicans-energycommerce.house.gov/wp-content/uploads/2021/02/CONNECT-Act.pdf https://republicans-energycommerce.house.gov/wp-content/uplo...
- gz5 6y agoThe fiber itself needs to be infrastructure. Managed by a for profit company but one which does not sell the services. Instead, the fiber company sells access to a multi-tenant, open environment for all service providers, enabling consumers to choose which services they want to consume. Note: expect the big ISPs to increase this anti-competitive lobbying as they are concerned by Starlink (and its competitors), new ISPs funded by rural broadband grants and dev such as CBRS and software defined radio.
- dang 6y agoProposed bills are usually off topic for HN. That's because they rarely go anywhere, are mostly political theater, and the discussions around them tend to be generic and predictable. https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&query=by%3Adang%20bills&sort=byDate&type=comment https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que... It's better to wait until something significant happens and there is significant new information (SNI) to discuss. https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&sort=byDate&type=comment&query=%22no%20harm%20in%20waiting%22%20by:dang https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&so... https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&sort=byDate&type=comment&query=%22significant%20new%20information%22%20by%3Adang https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&so...
- duxup 6y ago>and the discussions around them tend to be generic and predictable. That's a pretty easy claim to make about most articles.
- dang 6y agoYes, but it's a matter of degree. It's more true of articles about proposed bills than it is of the median submission, and maybe even the median political submission. HN does better when it steers clear of generic discussion, the same way an exploring spacecraft does best to steer clear of the largest planets or any black holes in the vicinity. https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&sort=byDate&type=comment&query=generic%20discussion%20by:dang https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&sor... That goes 10x for generic ideological or political threads. https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&sort=byDate&type=comment&query=generic%20ideolog%20by:dang https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&sor...
- duxup 6y agoI'll be honest and say I have no idea what those links are supposed to tell me.... The idea that a bill proposal article is somehow going to " rarely go anywhere" and etc seems such a generic idea that you could apply to anything. It's clear in this thread and others that content of the bill and the issues it involves is what drives the discussion, not the fact that it is just a bill proposal, and that's what should determine the quality or whatever we're determining about the discussion. As for 'ideological' that again seems a simple way of just applying a generic stamp that could go on any topic. These brush strokes you use are way too wide and random IMO. Beyond that if ideology even does plays into things, that's not a reason to sweep it away. Ideology has collided with infectious disease, we still talk about it. If there's too much ideology in a thread, that just seems like a great tool for folks to use to simply derail the discussion.
- snake_plissken 6y agoThis is from the same political party which, apparently only when convenient, stresses the need for a smaller federal government and stronger state and local governments. The hypocrisy is mind numbing. I guess one can attenuate the hypocrisy through a parallel overarching economic philosophy whereby every kind of consumable should be delivered/created/provided by a private business entity in the face of competition. But who is to say that a local government going into business to provide something for the local community, which other private businesses have failed to do, isn't such an entity?
- nullsmack 6y agoNothing Republicans ever do is in the interest of common good. Nothing. They should be laughed right out of the House for even thinking about proposing this BS.
- korethr 6y ago> Most of the others remove regulatory requirements or speed up permitting processes for ISPs. This, I can possibly get behind, depending on the details. Part of the reason we end up with regional monopolies or duopolies is the high up-front capital costs involved with building out a network. This unto itself favors bigger players. Additional costs, whether from regulatory controls or making the permitting process more painful than intrinsically necessary further stacks the deck in favor of big players. So removing unnecessary regulations and making it easy to get permits is Good. Arguments against government-provided services are not intrinsically wrong in all cases, either. It is quite easy for the government to set the rules such that competition is impossible for all but the biggest or politically-favored (or both) players. That's if competition is possible at all; de jure and de facto bans have the same effect. So, I do view government-provided ISPs as something to be approached with caution. However, if there's any governmental level where the locals have a chance at keeping their government accountable to abuses and forcing the government to allow an ISP that sucks less to offer services, that's going to be at the local level. It's a numbers game, and the getting the numbers together needed to remind the administrators, councilors, and other officials that they are servants, not masters, is far more achievable at the neighborhood, municipal, or county levels. At the state level, it gets a lot harder a lot faster, and come the federal level you are playing on hard mode. That's why consider this proposal to be misguided at best. Time to add another thing to the list of things to write my rep and senator about.
- xivzgrev 6y agoMy local telco built a dialup. This wasn’t a monopoly, it increased competition because now there were two options. This shall not pass.
- chrismcb 6y agoHow is this constitutional? Even for wifi, I don't get how Congress can regulate this(or attempt to)