4 ms·
>If the past had predictive ability, historians would be billionaires. It only takes one person to become a billionaire. The historians that could become billi
by imtringued 6y ago
>If the past had predictive ability, historians would be billionaires.
It only takes one person to become a billionaire. The historians that could become billionaires surely did and thus exhausted the potential for other historians to become billionaires. So this argument is pretty weak. I haven't even considered the fact that in practice there is no way for an individual historian to make billions without also being good at business and being good at business is not a unique quality of historians.
There is also the problem that nobody claimed to predict the future in an economically viable fashion. Did historians ever claim to predict the future (human nature is not the same as the future) at all? What you have built is a straw man. There are so many holes in this argument, can't you think of anything better?
- solosoyokaze 6y agoWe’re literally discussing a blog post where the author makes extensive and detailed predictions about the future. It has exactly as much legitimacy as astrology. It’s anti-intellectual.