2 ms·
I see you are representing all of Islamic jurisprudence here but somehow condemning things like sukuk?
by selimthegrim 6y ago
I see you are representing all of Islamic jurisprudence here but somehow condemning things like sukuk?
- ahepp 6y agoAre they condemning sukuk? I thought sukuk was an attempt to reconcile the desirable qualities of a loan with Islamic jurisprudence surrounding finance? So unless the commenter thought sukuk was illegitimate (I haven't seen them state this, maybe they have), wouldn't it be reasonable assume they consider sukuk acceptable? Perhaps obviously, I'm only vaguely aware of Islamic finance, so I may be missing something basic. *EDIT*: I've just seen the comments where they appear to be condemning sukuk, or at least common implementations. But it seems like their point is that they think it's simply slapping a different label on lending, which I'm inclined to agree with (especially if there are repurchase agreements and guaranteed returns).
- gher-shyu3i 6y agoA lot, if not most, of present day "Islamic finance" isn't compatible with Islam. They're simple relabeling of Western practices with Arabic terms, but underneath they're more or less the same. There are many Hadiths and narrations prohibiting and condemning these actions.
- selimthegrim 6y agoSo ghazwa is a preferable alternative for economic growth. Gotcha. Let me know how taking potshots at NATO in Syria goes. How are you any better than Western colonialists then?
- gher-shyu3i 6y agoPlease look up straw man fallacy: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Straw_man https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Straw_man It's well known that many Arab governments today have been installed by the Western colonialists. It's established history. We're still living the effects of post WWII colonization and Sykes-Picot. Of course, there is blame on us too, but to deny external influence is also ignorant.