4 ms·
in terms of raw capacity, I do not think that the intersatellite laser links (if/when they do get that working, which is a long ways off, 10 out of the 1050+ sa
by walrus01 6y ago
in terms of raw capacity, I do not think that the intersatellite laser links (if/when they do get that working, which is a long ways off, 10 out of the 1050+ satellites right now have them, and none in production use), will approach anywhere near the capacity of a 40 or 80 channel, coherent 100/200/400GbE DWDM submarine line terminal. it's a whole other order of magnitudes.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- GoOnThenDoTell 6y agoDo the markets need lots of bandwidth? Or just-enough with the lowest possible latency
- walrus01 6y agoA lot of serious HFT has moved to HF radio bands with giant aimed yagi uda or dipole antennas, already... London, new york, chicago, tokyo. It's very low bit rate but lower latency.
- cromka 6y agoSo Australian FinTech will definitely appreciate Starlink, then?
- arcticbull 6y agoI suspect Australian FinTech would be more interested in colocating near exchanges instead of trying to beam their orders through space, but I don't work in the sector so I can't say for sure.
- Dylan16807 6y agoTotally different use cases. If you want to observe events at one exchange and send orders to another, all that matters is total latency. For that use it doesn't matter whether your servers are in the same room as one of the exchanges or 200 miles away from either one.
- robertlagrant 6y agoIt's true that total latency is what matters, and minimising latency by sitting near one of them and taking advantage of low-latency connections between exchanges sounds reasonable.
- megous 6y agoDoes this have a name? Something like "a race to ridiculousness?" It's so bizarre that it matters that someone places an order a few ms before someone else. And it's probably ns now. No time to stop and think,... just be faster than someone else.
- arcticbull 6y agoCapitalism? :P
- AdamJacobMuller 6y agoMarkets don't, but, GP said: "I can't imagine much appetite for any future under-sea cabling out of Australia" And the reality is that satellites can not compete with the bandwidth of subsea cables for bulk data transfer, HFT is a whole other world.
- devoutsalsa 6y agoI’d guess that high speed data transfer competes with overnight shipping a hard drive in most current cases. In my day to day life, for most cases I’d rather has 10 Mbps with 10 ms latency than 1 Gbps with 250 ms latency. Generally speaking I’m looking for a snappy user experience and fast enough for Netflix streaming to a non-premium television. But high bandwidth and low latency would be super nice!
- nly 6y agoMany wired leased lines that connect data vendors to exchanges are only ~2Mbps even in 2021. You tend to get bandwidth spikes on most feeds at market open and close, but intraday rates are low
- Robotbeat 6y agoIt's not exactly a long ways off if a dozen satellites are already using it (there were 2 previous ones). Every time SpaceX makes a goal, someone claims it's really far away until it is completed. If there was a need for Terabit/s laser capacity for Starlink, there's no particularly good reason it couldn't be developed.
- n4r9 6y agoMusk does tend to achieve his goals eventually although the timescales are generally 2-7 years too ambitious: www.bloomberg.com/features/elon-musk-goals
- VectorLock 6y agoDamn that doesn't bode well for me getting a Cybertruck any time soon.
- rlt 6y agoWhy couldn’t intersatellite laser links have similar capacity to fiber? In principle, if not practice? Is it because ISLs will require more powerful lasers because the light is focused through a lens instead of guided through a fiber?
- andbberger 6y agoprobably less (literal) bandwidth, lasers are expensive
- walrus01 6y agoThat and because the atmosphere is not clear (this is why 1Gbps free space laser network bridges have very limited range), the links from satellite to earth in any rf band will be very small in capacity as compared to a singlemode fiber cable. Space to space lasers, sure... Much clearer.
- andbberger 6y agoStarlink ground links are RF
- walrus01 6y agoThat's what I said
- andbberger 6y agooops my bad
- bbarnett 6y agoHigh end fibre routers use multi-spectral bandwith, effectively allowing for multiple data streams to be transmitted on one fibre cable, and re-broken out at the other end. This significantly increases bandwidth. I doubt the laser links support this, and I wonder if any could, when in a non-encapsulated environment. EG, spectral pollution from sunlight/etc.
- bahmboo 6y agoCheck out this analysis of starlink ground relay routing vs fiber https://youtu.be/m05abdGSOxY https://youtu.be/m05abdGSOxY