25 ms·
I have been using a starlink beta terminal for 3 months now, ask me whatever you want. Day job is senior network engineer for a regional-sized (4 US states) fib
by walrus01 6y ago
I have been using a starlink beta terminal for 3 months now, ask me whatever you want. Day job is senior network engineer for a regional-sized (4 US states) fiber based ISP.
My most important message to everyone reading this is that it's not intended to compete with properly implemented wireline based services. It's going to absolutely blow away consumer-grade highly oversubscribed, bottom of the barrel ku and ka band geostationary satellite services (hughesnet, viasat in the USA, xplornet in Canada), and any WISP that can't keep up with a 150 Mbps figure.
And eventually for really hard to reach places in the developing world, and much of the same offshore/aviation/maritime industry that right now pays tons of money to Inmarsat.
- IgorPartola 6y agoOne of the big issues I’ve had with anything but wired ISPs is latency. They specifically talk about 20-40ms latency being expected in most locations, but don’t specify to where. I currently get about 20 +/- 4 ms from me to 8.8.8.8 consistently. Is their latency to my first hop? Also, what is their IPv6 support like? Can I get a routable /60 or similar? Static IPv4/IPv6? And do you need to use their router or can you hook in anything you want? Bandwidth limits? Any other restrictions, either via their TOS or through some kind of firewall? Is this experience ever going to approach something like fiber or even cable?
- walrus01 6y agoa. absolute lowest latency I've seen to a major IX point in seattle is about 15.8ms. More often it's 22-23ms. On a longer term, averages between 20-30ms. That's for the combined total of four 550km paths through space plus terrestrial latency from their earth station to seattle. Keep in mind that on something like a DOCSIS3 cable coax last mile segment can have a minimum latency of 12-16ms from just the cablemodem to the local CMTS in the neighborhood, so that's actually really good. It's not as good as fiber but it's significantly better than many other options. One has to account for the need for the antenna/modem to modulate and apply FEC on the Tx at both my CPE antenna and the spacex earth station on the other end (at least a few ms). b. no ipv6 yet. They have people who know what they are doing for neteng so I am sure it is planned. c. all IPs are in cgnat IP space right now. Nobody is getting a discrete dhcp-assigned public ipv4 /32 yet. You can hook up whatever router you want, anything you plug into the PoE injector that is an ordinary 1000BaseT 1500 mtu DHCP client will be given an address. The router they hand out is a very bare bones 802.11ac 2x2 MIMO thing that is based on openwrt. restrictions, you can't move it from your designated service location. That's part of the beta TOS. Using it, it is a real 150 Mbps down x 16.5 Mbps up. I have put non technical guest users on it doing various things and from their perspective it cannot be distinguished from the separate terrestrial connection at the same location.
- dogecoinbase 6y ago> b. no ipv6 yet. They have people who know what they are doing for neteng so I am sure it is planned. heh, my assumption when I hear that people who know what they're doing are involved is the opposite ;) Thank you for the detailed report! I'm very excited for the tech, especially once the lasers are up and it doesn't rely on the base station (i.e. I can take my uplink on a road trip)
- sgtnoodle 6y agoLol, the fact that they just went with IPv4 supports the theory that they know what they're doing. I've read multiple tutorials on IPv6 and it's so complicated that I still can't grasp how it all works in my head. For some context, I've personally written an Ethernet IPv4 network stack with DHCP from scratch. I also worked on Ethernet switch firmware, coincidentally for SpaceX...
- lxgr 6y agoIPv6 really isn't that complicated compared to CGNAT! Of course, today IPv6 only can't be considered full internet access, so providers usually need both – and given that CGNAT gets consumers 99% of what they want/are willing to pay for, providers sometimes can't be bothered to also implement IPv6. I used to have GCNAT + IPv6 on my provider, but the v6 part of their CPE was worse than useless – no option to open ports since "port forwarding is not needed on IPv6" (nevermind the mandatory firewall that doesn't allow inbound traffic unless completely disabled).
- IgorPartola 6y agoIt can’t? I at one point messed up my firewall rules and didn’t notice that IPv4 wasn’t accessible for a few days. Nobody complained. I eventually noticed something was amiss and fixed it but really most places seems to be running dual stack. I am starting to run some IPV6 only services.
- 6y ago
- gjs278 6y agohas it gone offline
- paulmd 6y agoWhat is the term of the contract? I have a family cabin in an area that is not served by cable, it's not a place I am going to spend 12 months or whatever and at $100/mo I am probably not going to pay for 12 months out of the goodness of my heart. But I would love the ability to go up for a couple weeks or a month and just work from up there. Could I sign up month by month, or for say a quarter at a time? Or I guess more generally, as an existing user of the service who is seeing dashboards I'm not seeing, how do you think this would play out for "occasional" users.
- walrus01 6y agothere is no contract for the beta, it's month to month, you can cancel whenever you want. unknown what they will do in the longer term. there is no seasonal 'pause' service plan offered yet.
- daveevad 6y agoCan you ssh into it or would one need to reverse tunnel?
- walrus01 6y agoThe latter. You can initiate whatever connection you want from inside the cgnat, but there's nothing externally accessible yet. Mine has a few different openvpn tunnels (clients at the starlink side, servers in datacenters elsewhere) going different places.
- daveevad 6y agoThanks - what does a regular traceroute look like? Any discernible pattern for the hops through the constellation? Any general thoughts about the topology? I appreciate it. My family got into the beta today, not just the pre-order but it sounds like it won't ship for a few weeks. Thanks again.
- walrus01 6y agoTraceroutes are all going out to the world through this google AS right now. Using the hurricane tool as a convenient GUI presentation of what it is: https://bgp.he.net/AS36492 https://bgp.he.net/AS36492 nothing obviously satellite related shows up at layer 3. There's a few hops of stuff with no rDNS, and then the edge of the AS36492 network and whatever transits or peers your traffic is going to. You can clearly discern from pinging your first hop (15.9 to 30ms away) that it's something on the other side of the up-and-back satellite link. topology at present is logically a bent pipe. satellites need to be simultaneously in view of your terminal and a spacex earth station. The ten satellites they launched into a polar orbit last month are the first with inter-satellite laser links.
- chj 6y ago> satellites need to be simultaneously in view of your terminal and a spacex earth station. Does that mean that there is no connection between satellites?
- mcculley 6y agoHow well would this work on oceangoing boats? I have tugboats in the Caribbean that could use cheaper connectivity.
- walrus01 6y agotheoretically, great, and I would be shocked if they did not release a product functionally equivalent to the iridium and inmarsat aviation and maritime terminals, because of how much potential revenue is there. it will also be much better and faster than a multi-axis motorized tracking geostationary maritime terminal ($40,000+ things you can find in radomes on large ships, operating in various ku and ka band networks). there has been no official announcement on that sort of thing yet. the current terminal has motion sensors in it and is not designed for a moving vehicle, it will turn itself off. the same 6-axis sensors that are used to orient and tilt it to the proper angle can also tell it when it's being moved.
- sverhagen 6y ago> theoretically, great Except then this thing were they assign you to a single cell and the vessel may pass the boundaries of said cell? Do you expect some sort of protocol for automatic handoff to the next cell in the future?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- nickik 6y agoThat already works fine, the dish is switching sats incredibly fast and is tracking multiple sats at a time. The limitation with the cells is that currently not all cells have the same amount of sats above them so they will not claim that guarantee anything. Some people have tested that and it worked fine if you move it. They will likely have a different terminal or plan for mobile service, would be my assumption.
- cmason 6y agoCan anyone comment on how much motion the current terminal will tolerate? I’m wondering about a boat at anchor.
- Jedd 6y agoI expect a fair bit of interest from latency-sensitive markets (eg finance) here in Australia. A few years ago when I was in the WAN optimisation space, IIRC Sydney/Singapore latency was ~150ms, partly raw distance, partly because the route was physically quite convoluted. There's some expectation that once Starlink's mesh comms ramp up, it'll be significantly faster to go up to a bird, across through one or more at close-to-c, and then down into the local base station. The fiber cable they ran from Perth up to Singapore a few years certainly won't be abandoned - it'll still be much cheaper / wider - but I can't imagine much appetite for any future under-sea cabling out of Australia (f.e.).
- walrus01 6y agoin terms of raw capacity, I do not think that the intersatellite laser links (if/when they do get that working, which is a long ways off, 10 out of the 1050+ satellites right now have them, and none in production use), will approach anywhere near the capacity of a 40 or 80 channel, coherent 100/200/400GbE DWDM submarine line terminal. it's a whole other order of magnitudes.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- GoOnThenDoTell 6y agoDo the markets need lots of bandwidth? Or just-enough with the lowest possible latency
- lookdangerous 6y agoCan Starlink travel with you? My wife and I are discussing purchasing a tiny home on a trailer and the ability to get a decent connection _anywhere_ would be an amazing amenity.
- walrus01 6y agoNot in the beta, no, they have not officially released plans for mobile terminals. I'm sure eventually there will be. It's in the faq on the website.
- gpm 6y agoIn principle, yes. They've demoed it on fighter jets. But they don't seem to be selling that capability to consumers just yet - presumably to avoid issues with too many subscribers congregating in one place. See the faq answers on "Can I travel" and "Can I change my service address" https://www.starlink.com/faq https://www.starlink.com/faq
- cromka 6y ago"Your Starlink is assigned to a single cell. If you move your Starlink outside of its assigned cell, a satellite will not be scheduled to serve your Starlink and you will not receive internet. This is constrained by geometry and is not arbitrary geofencing." I like how technical they still are. Probably a matte of time before they have to dumb-down everything there.
- AdamJacobMuller 6y agoThis seems very much like a beta-only limitation though.
- BelenusMordred 6y ago> beta-only limitation though There's no way you are crossing borders with it and transmitting from a country where it's not approved.
- starpilot 6y agoMusk said that Starlink won't work in dense areas. This is a broader business question, but do you think there are there enough remote villagers and oil rig workers that can subscribe and eventually give Musk enough money to fund a trip to Mars? He has said that is the endgame for creating Starlink.
- unionpivo 6y agoyes, if you look globally. Just usa ? Not sure. But i think that they would have to become ISP and comply with local law with most jurisdictions if they want to have local ground stations. Not sure how that will go.
- martin8412 6y agoWho do you imagine will buy it on a global scale? Rural NA areas, rural Australian areas and a few places in Europe. At the price point offered it is insanely expensive unless your only other option is satelite or a very crappy DSL. Maybe a few people in Asia, Africa, South America can afford it, but it is very few, and in the places where people can they are likely to already have better service.
- unionpivo 6y agoI mean, you can get several houses together. If you split between 5 houses, you still get decent bandwidth (you wont be watching 4k, but then again if you can afford 4k screens ...), and the price is 100 USD + 20 per month. If you don't have any other option this might be decent alternative
- voldacar 6y agoWhat is the total power consumption of the system when in use? How often do packets get dropped? Have you given it a try with quake or counterstrike?
- walrus01 6y agoIt's 100-140W. Mine is averaging about 0.5% packet loss over a 3 hour period. There will be very brief periods of slightly higher loss. I don't play a lot of fps but most realtime lag, loss and jitter sensitive applications work just fine.
- voldacar 6y agoThanks.
- doctor_sleep 6y agoCheck out Linus Tech Tips for a review of gaming on star link: https://youtu.be/Fh1a2K9ZgNA https://youtu.be/Fh1a2K9ZgNA
- 6nf 6y agoIs it awesome?
- walrus01 6y agoYes and even more so if you have the past viewpoint and perspective of having previously lived on geostationary satellite for months at a time, and could imagine using starlink in a really remote area.
- ff7f00 6y agoHow has it performed on cloudy/rainy/harsh weather days?
- treelovinhippie 6y agoI'm interested in mounting it laying flat (no stand) to the top of a van. I don't expect it to work while on the move. But do you think it would still work in a fixed configuration like that? And how much do you think tree coverage would affect service?
- walrus01 6y agoIt needs to be able to tilt and angle itself. Trees cannot be in the way. 11GHz+ doesn't like trees.
- Dylan16807 6y agoIt tries to give itself an optimal angle but it doesn't move while operating and the satellites are zipping in and out of its beamforming cone all the time anyway. The technology is capable of running with a flat mount.
- walrus01 6y agoRight now a terminal even at 48.9 latitude angles itself somewhat north, because the greatest simultaneous density of satellites at any moment in time is around 52.5 to 53 degrees north. If you mount it flat and don't allow it to move, who knows what starlink will change in the future architecture. They included the servo motor geared pan and tilt mechanism for a reason. Maybe later it will reorient itself differently as network density and satellite population changes. I'm not saying they won't ever release a flat non motorized cpe, but that is very much not the configuration now.
- Dylan16807 6y agoI don't think that disagrees with what I said. The ability to align itself allows for mildly to moderately improved reception. It's more cost-effective than improving the beamforming, and easier for the user. It's a good feature. But the terminal doesn't need it to work. (On a hardware level. Any possible software lockout is a separate issue.)
- nomay 6y agoHow fast the speed do you think they will settle for normal operation? I mean 1Gbps sounds cool, but the limitation and economics are there.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- herpderperator 6y agoCan we use it as a WAN device? Can we initiate PPPoE or whatever on our own routers?
- plugger 6y ago> My most important message to everyone reading this is that it's not intended to compete with properly implemented wireline based services. I think the key word here is properly. I put my pre-order in Feb 9th and I'm in the Perth hills in Western Australia. My wired link is ~35Mb down and ~11Mb up. Whilst StarLink will be more expensive I'm expecting a tripling of download speeds and a doubling of upload speeds for less than double the price. That math works for me, especially when you consider my link is as fast as it can go (I pay for a 50/25 service) due to my last hop being a twisted pair cable that was run half a century ago.
- itronitron 6y agoHow much does it cost?
- herpderperator 6y ago(I am not OP, but this is pretty easily found on the site.) $499 USD for the dish, $99 USD per month for service (no data cap.) Price seems to change to local currency if your country is not USA.
- richrichardsson 6y ago> this is pretty easily found on the site Is it though? Perhaps it's because it's not available in Croatia, but there is nothing on the front page that mentions price, and it's not in the FAQ either.
- herpderperator 6y agoIn my experience, if you enter the desired service address it is the very next thing that's displayed.
- itronitron 6y agothanks, after putting in the service address all I see is a $99 deposit and no mention of a monthly or annual fee...
- richrichardsson 6y agoAh, that explains it, the button says "Order Now", which scared me off as I wasn't interested in actually ordering but was curious about the price. I really dislike this kind of (almost dark) pattern. TIDAL also is not showing you the cost until you start down the sign up process, it's quite frustrating if what you really want to do is compare service costs.
- TheCraiggers 6y ago
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- josu 6y ago> really hard to reach places in the developing world Like North Hollywood, CA. https://abc7.com/att-internet-fiber-man-takes-out-wall-street-journal-ad-for-aaron-epstein/10335328/ https://abc7.com/att-internet-fiber-man-takes-out-wall-stree...
- bougiefever 6y agoOr rural Wisconsin
- alex_duf 6y agoIf i understand correctly the antenna tracks a specific satellite as it transit above it. So how does it handle the switch from that satellite to the next one without losing signal?
- speedbird 6y agoSeems like once its found the optimal pointing it stays there, the rest is done with phased array steering, so very rapid tracking / switching possible.
- walrus01 6y agothe patent for the antenna shows dual simultaneous beamforming. some form of make-before-break. how exactly they're doing it is quite opaque to the end user, and part of their secret recipe.
- dreen 6y agoWhat's the actual upload speed in good conditions?
- walrus01 6y ago15.5-18Mbps
- textman 6y agoDo you think it is practical for the rapidly growing recreational vehicle/boondocking/overlanding crowd due to the hardware and installation requirements? If your camper moves every couple days or so, seems it might be problematic.
- bogomipz 6y agoCan you say what type of average bandwidth and latency you are seeing? And how does it compare to the data plan or tier you are beta testing.
- Pfhreak 6y agoI'm considering a cabin deep in the mountains. What should I be aware of when it comes to limitations of Starlink? For a cabin that is likely to be off grid, where I'd like to have relatively stable, relatively usable internet, what should I expect?
- aquark 6y agoThe dish currently draws around 100W steady state. For many off grid installations this can be a significant addition to the power budget.
- jccooper 6y agoClear field of view of the sky is necessary, which may be a problem in the woods. The field of view will narrow with more sats; now it's quite large. Apparently they have an app to visualize it.
- nickisnotanerd 6y agoWalrus01, from a user POV, do you have consistent, reliable service for streaming, large file transfer, virtual meetings etc? Is it akin to having, say, a 100 mb/s connection through a cable service company? Is there anything that particularly irritates you about the service? Thanks for being willing to share your experience. I am in the mountains in Colorado and some neighbors envy my 10 Mbps down/0.5 Mbps up connection. Seems like a nobrainer that this will be better, but at least my DSL doesn't cut out very often.