4 ms·
There have been people that beat the market on average all their life. I'm sure you could find many for any reasonable timeframe. Even if one can beat the marke
by sudosysgen 6y ago
There have been people that beat the market on average all their life. I'm sure you could find many for any reasonable timeframe. Even if one can beat the market there is simply no way to tell the statistical distribution that would generate from a random distribution.
- Dylan16807 6y agoYou can beat the market on average with one good investment and a whole lot of doing nothing. So you can't prove much about very passive investors. But if someone is making a 2:1 payout decision every month, and manages to be right 75% of the time, you can be quite sure it's not luck.
- sudosysgen 6y agoSure, but that is way beyond the threshold of the EMH. And it might just be that making frequent decisions is not a good way of exploiting market inefficiency.
- Dylan16807 6y agoYou can set your own threshold that's not way beyond. The point is that it's not unfalsifiable. There are pretty reasonable scenarios where you could find a group of consistent market-beaters and falsify it. If there aren't enough exploitable inefficiencies in an entire career to make that proof, then that's an interesting data point all on its own.
- sudosysgen 6y agoThere are certainly people who made their career by beating the market consistently. Many, in fact. What you're requesting is that this happens in a specific way. That specific way might not be the way that is optimal.