4 ms·
> Either "third party" app stores will also pay to support this ecosystem, in which case Epic will be paying the same amount either way how did you work out th
by chii 6y ago
> Either "third party" app stores will also pay to support this ecosystem, in which case Epic will be paying the same amount either way
how did you work out that the amount apple gets paid (30%) is the "correct" amount? The only way to find out is via competition. But due to the monopolistic powers of apple, there cannot be competition on their platform. Thus, we do not know the true cost of maintaining this platform - only that apple is able to maintain it with at least 30%.
> Don't take that choice away from me.
nobody is forcing you to use the third party app store if it does exist. If you continued to use apple's curated store, you will continue to get the existing benefits. Adding an extra option can't possibly hurt you.
- darknessmonk 6y ago> how did you work out that the amount apple gets paid (30%) is the "correct" amount? The only way to find out is via competition. But due to the monopolistic powers of apple, there cannot be competition on their platform. Thus, we do not know the true cost of maintaining this platform - only that apple is able to maintain it with at least 30%. 30% is industry standard. > nobody is forcing you to use the third party app store if it does exist. If you continued to use apple's curated store, you will continue to get the existing benefits. Adding an extra option can't possibly hurt you. It hurts the ecosystem - and all its users. Splitting the apps in multiple app stores is a nightmare I don't get the point: the whole idea of Apple is to have everything under their control. Nobody is forcing anyone to use Apple devices
- adamdusty 6y agoNobody is going to not put their app on the apple app store. Look at steam for example. Almost every game on steam can be purchased somewhere else, like icth.io or the game's website. 30% is industry standard among monopolistic players (Google play store, Apple app store, Steam). There are many other storefronts that take less of a cut, and don't require IAP to go through a specific payment system that the platform also owns. FDroid, MS Store, Epic Store, Galaxy Store, GOG, the list goes on.
- darknessmonk 6y ago> Nobody is going to not put their app on the apple app store. Epic will, and this is what they want > Almost every game on steam can be purchased somewhere else, like icth.io or the game's website. 30% is industry standard among monopolistic players (Google play store, Apple app store, Steam). That is a very different use case
- zepto 6y ago> Nobody is going to not put their app on the apple app store. Certainly false - just like with streaming video, platforms will pay for exclusives from popular developers to force users to visit their stores.
- Terretta 6y agoHow is Steam a “monopolistic player” when you say “almost every game on steam can be purchased somewhere else” and go on to mention Gog, MS Store, Epic Store, and “the list goes on”? That Steam, and others you mention, charge 30% categorically undermines the whinging about Apple’s 30% being out of line. I’m also curious about people’s thoughts on Sony pulling CDPR’s Cyberpunk 2077 from their Playstation store.
- adamdusty 6y agoYou're right about steam. Monopoly isn't the right word. Steam is the only one on that list that takes 30% that I know of. MS store went through a period where they would pay you to put your app there.
- gwd 6y ago> how did you work out that the amount apple gets paid (30%) is the "correct" amount? The only way to find out is via competition. The "correct" amount is the amount that everybody is happy to pay. If Epic doesn't want to pay 30%, then 30% is too high for them. That's OK -- nobody is forcing them to pay it. The competition you're describing isn't the cost of running the app store; it's the cost of maintaining the entire Apple ecosystem, including iOS, new iPhone hardware, etc. > Adding an extra option can't possibly hurt you. Yes it can, and I just explained how. But let me try to spell it out. 1. New iOS "app store" starts up, but only charges 0.1%. This is possible because they don't write the OS or any of the infrastructure; they're a simple indexer 2. Everyone moves over to this app store because the fees are cheaper. 3. Apple's revenue drops precipitously 4. In order to maintain the OS, Apple either a) raises the prices of iPhones b) starts selling my information c) invests less in the iPhone and iOS. All three of those possibilities hurt me; so yes, a new app store does hurt me.
- ginko 6y ago> New iOS "app store" starts up, but only charges 0.1%. This is possible because they don't write the OS or any of the infrastructure; they're a simple indexer Apple was already paid handsomely for OS development through the device's purchase price. > Apple's revenue drops precipitously Apple has some of the highest margins in the industry. They'll survive. > In order to maintain the OS, Apple either a) raises the prices of iPhones b) starts selling my information c) invests less in the iPhone and iOS. See my previous point.
- kempbellt 6y ago"Apple has lots of money so they can afford to give some of it away because we want them to" is not an argument that Epic can take to court, and it isn't a great argument to support adding app stores. As an iPhone user I prefer the single app store approach. Multiple app stores fragments the user experience, ultimately harming the experience of owning an iPhone. Especially when apps become exclusives to different stores, because they will. It's one of the main reasons that I moved away from Android. I completely understand the "open system" argument for Android, but a fragmented user experience is a byproduct of that openness. The last android phone I had came with a Samsung store, Google play, and I believe a Verizon app store. As well, going from my Android phone to borrowing a friends meant learning a completely new UX almost every time. "Oh, you don't have a Samsung Android, so you don't have that particular app store, so you can't get the app... Sorry" It's been several years now, so maybe that's changed, but the biggest thing that makes me stick with Apple is the consistency of the user experience, in both its OS and app store ecosystems.
- zepto 6y ago> nobody is forcing you to use the third party app store if it does exist. If you continued to use apple's curated store, you will continue to get the existing benefits. Adding an extra option can't possibly hurt you People need to stop saying this - it’s obvious completely false. As soon as other app stores are involved, there will be paid exclusives. Equivalent to Joe Rogan on Spotify, or any of the streaming video services who commission studios to make content just for their platform. It will definitely be impossible to avoid using multiple stores if you want access to the popular apps.
- diffeomorphism 6y agoNot really. It would be perfectly possible to have just one store offering multiple repos/curations etc. . And in any case "but having like three stores" is an annoyance at worst. Having one grand holy arbiter of truth is a bigger problem.
- zepto 6y ago> It would be perfectly possible to have just one store offering multiple repos/curations etc. That isn’t true. In order for it to be true you would need to explain how this would be possible if stores buy exclusive rights to apps.