13 ms·
Bitcoin’s Overnight Collapse Probability Is About 50%
- 1-6 6y agoIt'll just bring buyers back into the game when it's at a 50% discount.
- ashtonkem 6y ago“Crashes are just discounts” is one of the more pernicious financial memes around.
- llcoolv 6y agoand the hodl-gang's interpretation: "dips exist only so that coins could go from weak hands to strong hands" :D
- freebuju 6y agoThanks for making me laugh. Kind of reminds me how "weak hands" swayed by WSB, bought GME just before its share value tanked
- tengbretson 6y agoCrashes have always been discounts.
- ashtonkem 6y agoIn theory that’s true if you’re holding long term instruments with reasonably stable value and growth (which is not guaranteed for crypto currencies) and happen to have the liquid cash to buy. But in practice it’s often not true, as most investors who try to “time the market” end up underperforming the actual instruments they trade in. It’s really not true if you have any leverage at all, where a crash might increase your margin requirements or wipe you out entirely.
- SV_BubbleTime 6y agoI remember when Hertz was deeply discounted this last spring. What an amazing deal.
- chrisin2d 6y agoSpeaking of memes, a crash is discount only when enough people believe it is to make it so.
- Ariez 6y agoI'm guessing you didn't buy any stocks around april last year? :(
- ashtonkem 6y agoI take it back, “you’re just jealous” is absolutely the most pernicious financial meme.
- suifbwish 6y agoExactly. Just because people are paying 50k a piece doesn’t mean people won’t suddenly wake up and realize that bitcoin is actually inferior to most of the other cryptocurrencies in terms of utility
- mvind 6y agoOne point as a researcher working in a central bank and studying state-of-the art macroeconomic theory, is the absolute conviction that some crypto holders have that society is rotten to the core and that the financial industry (and for that matter the broader well established large cap economy) is a malfunctioning/rotten machine only benefiting the 1%. I mean reading journals on monetary policy transmission, central banking, and finance in general, it is an extremely complex arena (understanding the global economy might be the most complex man made "game" to try to understand). And those researchers will readily admit faults and shortcomings of our current theories. I never ever see any statements from researchers that carries the same strength of conviction about any of the aforementioned topics compared to the crypto crowd, whatsoever. Some perspective might lend itself useful.
- throw8932894 6y agoI think their opinions were validated quite well. If I would listen to my crazy anarcho-capitalist friend, I would be millionaire today. Other side is represented by Trump...
- llcoolv 6y agoA lot of the people I know who were an-cap 10 years ago are millionaires today. At least from my circle. The problem is that the money-printing people are billionaires and it is a game you simply cannot win. And frankly, these days being a millionaire is not as fancy as it sounds - you can barely get a nice 7-series + a bit above average flat and living off investments/rent would require a very frugal lifestyle.
- randmeerkat 6y agoCan barely buy a 7 series... Frugal lifestyle... Move out of the Bay Area, buy a nice house, get a Tesla model 3 performance, it’s faster and cheaper than the 7 series, and maybe reconsider what’s in your lifestyle that’s so expensive that being a millionaire is barely making it.
- 6y ago
- nostrademons 6y agoMakes sense. Most of the folks who have been in Bitcoin 6+ years have observed multiple crashes, exchanges going bust, Bitcoins vanishing into the ether (no pun intended), and people being unable to recover their assets. People hold Bitcoin as insurance against the dollar collapsing. It makes no sense to assume that both Bitcoin and dollars will be circulating currencies: currency is a winner-take-all market, the most widely-accepted one will win. The Bitcoin price is a superposition of those who believe that Bitcoin is going to infinity and the dollar will become worthless, and those who believe that Bitcoin is going to zero and the dollar will retain its position as the global reserve currency.
- anm89 6y ago> currency is a winner-take-all market You are aware of other currencies,let's say the Euro, right?
- nostrademons 6y agoLike other winner-take-all markets, it splits into multiple winner-take-all markets when their are natural (or let's say "national") boundaries. Note that we don't still have deutschemarks, francs, guilders, schillings, lira, peseta, and escudo, though. The network effects of having a single currency are big enough that 19 nations were willing to give up their national currency.
- _fs 6y agoThe whole "hackernews desperately up-voting any post that cast's negative light on the investment opportunity that they missed" shtick is getting old. We get it, a lot of you knew about bitcoin in 2011 and did not buy in. Now, you are seeing it rise (and fall) over and over and are frustrated that you did not buy a couple hundred dollars worth of bitcoin 8 years ago.
- tommit 6y agoIt seems very cynical and kind of unlike this page as I got to know it over the past few years, but I struggle to come up with another reason as to why a blog post by someone named "Trolly McTrollface" would be upvoted to the front page.
- willis936 6y agoIs this another way of saying “I think we have 0 bits of information on the reliability of bitcon’s value”?”
- mef 6y agogoogle cached version https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache%3Ahttp%3A%2F%2Fwww.tr0lly.com%2Fbitcoin%2Fbitcoins-overnight-collapse-probability-is-about-50%2F&oq=cache%3Ahttp%3A%2F%2Fwww.tr0lly.com%2Fbitcoin%2Fbitcoins-overnight-collapse-probability-is-about-50%2F https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache%3Ahttp... archive version though it seems slow https://archive.vn/UvZTZ https://archive.vn/UvZTZ
- bhouston 6y agoBitcoin is powered by a shared belief in its value. While it has been powered by scams as well, couch couch Tether, tt seems to be getting more adherents to believing that it is intrinsically valuable. The fact that it tends to go up so quickly also yields to FOMO. Because Bitcoin is just shared belief, it is hard to dispel that belief via real-world events such as earnings releases and other things that affect more grounded investments. Bitcoin is more of a movement and it is somewhat revolutionary in that it aims to replace our existing monetary system of central banks and interest rates, etc. I think the main threats to Bitcoin could be governmental if it continues to grow. If it starts to be a reserve currency competitor to USD which could affect treasury sales, I could see it being banned by the US government and others... but I am not smart enough to work out all that would play out if Bitcoin became that important. I wonder if Bitcoin will ever be forced to bend towards an inflationary monetary policy controlled by government like entities? It is code and code and always be changed. If it is so successful it becomes necessary to co-opt it into the existing system.... weird stuff.
- ragnese 6y ago> I wonder if Bitcoin will ever be forced to bend towards an inflationary monetary policy controlled by government like entities? It is code and code and always be changed. If it is so successful it becomes necessary to co-opt it into the existing system.... weird stuff. You can change the code, but it's up to the miners to actually run that code. Not saying it's impossible, but that's a big ask for a controversial change like that. Maybe someday if the mining is even more centralized than it currently is.
- HarryHirsch 6y agoit is intrinsically valuable How? As an intrinsically valuable means of speculation because sound investment opportunities are absent?
- solosoyokaze 6y agoIt has a social network effect of people who agree that it's the store of value for the future. Your paper dollar bill has very little intrinsic value. It's just a shared acceptance.
- tobyhinloopen 6y agoI’ll get some btc again if it reaches 7K or less
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- llcoolv 6y agoanother (better) cached version: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fear,_uncertainty,_and_doubt https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fear,_uncertainty,_and_doubt
- aminozuur 6y agoI hope the price tanks so that BTC will be primarily used for its intended purpose, like it was in the Silk Road days.
- SV_BubbleTime 6y agoI’m far more selfish, I would just like to hear amateur investors stop talking about it. I’d really like for people to stop suggesting a database (blockchain) will fix any problem, even when problems are explicitly not database issues. I think we’re well past either of those things being possibilities though.
- jackric 6y ago> I’d really like for people to stop suggesting a database (blockchain) will fix any problem I'm developing a blockchain to block these people using sustainable AI. Want to get in on the initial coin offering?
- metalliqaz 6y agocryptocurrency proponents often discuss how manipulated and encumbered with politics normal fiat currencies are, but they don't seem to mind the obvious nation-state-level manipulation of BTC's price shrug
- justapassenger 6y agoIf Silicon Valley was filmed today, their disrupt parody would include “we’re making a world a better place by using blockchain for database”, instead of Paxos (https://youtu.be/B8C5sjjhsso https://youtu.be/B8C5sjjhsso)
- llcoolv 6y agoSilk road days are gone. Ulbrich got disproportionately punished + convicted on very very dubious hired gun charges. Since then a similar approach was applied on almost every darknet marketplace around, resulting in that these days with BTC at ATH the darknet marketplaces are at an all-time crisis (even though legacy media is still pushing the "criminal's money" narrative :/). Not to mention that all the major mining pools have voluntarily chosen to collaborate with governments on censoring the blockchain, etc. Let's hope it is just a side-step given that BTC with censorship/regulation is just a breaking of a glass-wall away from perfectly free monetary unit. P.S. If you are looking to get no-KYC truly anonymous BTC you'd better live in a top-10 city (e.g. Prague), because in a top-100 city (e.g. Sofia) it is not quite straight-forward and takes tons of waiting/selecting.
- jarym 6y agoSo about the same as any major fiat currency - sure one day you can wake up and it be gone. Next.
- Synaesthesia 6y agoKind of rare to have fiat currencies move as much as Bitcoin does in a day.
- chatallo 6y agoI think the comparison is a little unfair, as it's comparing two fundamentally different technologies - and crypto is in it's infancy. I'd be interested to learn about speculation driven volatility in currencies of the past (perhaps when the fed was first established, or with currencies of ancient civilizations), but I also think cryptocurrency is the first of its kind in many ways.
- freebuju 6y agoWho wants to wager it will down by more than 50% by June this year? Note: (current value at USD 49K time of post)
- desmap 6y ago@dang, you should think about adding a disclaimer to every crypto-related submission, just regex the title with the typical key words to catch them, with something like: Be aware that crypto-related submissions like this one might be intended to trigger or influence a wanted market behavior by OP.
- hbosch 6y agoA little superfluous. Couldn't we just assume that any blog post about any topic "might be intended to trigger or influence a wanted market behavior"? A news article critical of Amazon warehouse management could also be seen the exact same way.
- desmap 6y agoThat's absolutely true and every post can have a hidden agenda. However and in particular in this field hidden agendas are more common or let's call it pump and dump schemes. Cause and effect are so much closer together than in other fields, e.g. when I post how great Ruby is I cannot expect that the next day 10K new devs learn again Ruby haha and even if, I won't make any money over night. Maybe my Ruby course business (just an example, I don't have one haha) would get few more subscriptions but yeah.
- diegoperini 6y agoThe OP can be a victim of the original article's author as well. I agree with your intention though.
- throwaway3699 6y agoAny article posted here could cause market movements. We discuss public companies all the time.
- desmap 6y agoApples to oranges. Manipulating stock prices of public companies is much harder/more complex than of crypto currencies.
- deft 6y agoA blog by a guy going by Trolly, that can't even properly set up HTTPS, and admits he makes things up in the headerline means absolutely nothing. Tether has been involved in shady dealings for a long time. Last bull run people like this guy were claiming it was all going to blow up and tether was worthless etc etc etc. That never happened. This hysteria is very common for nocoiners, why are they so worried about my worthless bitcorns?
- minitoar 6y agodid you read the article? He calculates the risk using basic math and publicly available numbers from Bitcoin futures.
- centimeter 6y agoAh, well if he uses basic math, his conclusions must be correct.
- solean 6y agoThe guy is a notorious tether truther, but it's not surprising to see most of HN drinking that koolaid.
- zepto 6y ago> why are they so worried about my worthless bitcorbs? Can we reasonably infer that you have a financial stake in Bitcoin?
- nefitty 6y agoWhat’s interesting is that the fact that this story is gaining traction might make it a self-fulfilling prophecy. That’s the danger and stress of pure-momentum trading, which crypto basically is. It’s full on gambling. I tapped out early 2018 because the gains were not worth the interminable regrets of missing out, the constant worry that some country on the other side of the world would move the market as I slept, the increasing influence of troll/alt-right culture in the community, the insane hyperfocus that coding technical indicators on TradingView would cause, etc. Anyone who is fresh on the scene or still hodling, god bless you, you have stronger hands than I.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- marricks 6y agoDon't know if anyone else made this mistake but: author is not saying bitcoin will 50/50 collapse tonight just some night this year. > So the next time someone tries to explain to you that “Bitcoin is a store of value”, when the chances of it getting utterly destroyed overnight before the year is over are around 50/50, try not to shoot coffee through your nose laughing. EDIT: Not saying I agree with the prediction, it's just a far more timid prediction than I initially thought.
- eimrine 6y agoWhat probability to meet a dinosaur walking next to your house? It is 50%, either you will meet it or not.
- Tepix 6y agoIf you accept bets, I'm sure the odds won't be 50/50 as they are here.
- solean 6y agoWhat are the odds of a 50/50 yoy event not happening for 11 years straight?
- singularity2001 6y ago0.5**11
- 6y ago
- coliveira 6y agoWe're living in an era when it is easy to create new "currencies". Bitcoin is only the first, as some others have already been developed. The "value" of such currencies is a social construct. So, the price of BC will continue to grow as long as people have expectation that it will be valuable in the future. The only problem I see in "investing" in BC is the counterpart risk, i.e., I don't trust any of the companies that do trading in BC. I think this problem is currently bigger than the "currency" itself.
- companyhen 6y agoThat is why Uniswap and other AMM DEX's are on the rise https://medium.com/dragonfly-research/what-explains-the-rise-of-amms-7d008af1c399 https://medium.com/dragonfly-research/what-explains-the-rise...
- Tepix 6y agoUniswap is not very valuable with the current high fees.
- companyhen 6y agoThat won't be a problem for long, it's the early days for crypto still scaling.
- xiphias2 6y agoI still remember the good times on HN when the front page didn't have links to ,,Trolly McTrollface''.
- hobofan 6y agoStrange, I don't. I remember HN as a page where many blog posts had a chance, independent of the pseudonymity and ridiculousness of their author's username.
- xiphias2 6y agoIndependent and pseudonym is OK and encouraged, but ridicoulus / no responsibility for trying to be correct is very different from the cool/fun/hacker culture that is looking for the truth.
- eimrine 6y ago> p = S/(1-R) Good luck with using old instruments in brave new world. At least ppl have learnt not to use stop-loss while trading crypto.
- wwww4all 6y agoBTC is similar to art paintings or Pokémon cards in many regards. The intrinsic value is based on scarcity and perception of people in BTC network. The main driver of BTC is belief and hype, as more people believe in BTC there’s more hype and increase in demand and price.
- bravoetch 6y agoMore tether FUD that has little to do with Bitcoin.
- Shorel 6y agoTrolly McTrollface’s Blog. Username checks out.
- mlthoughts2018 6y agoI am personally long on Bitcoin. Such a crash is just a buying opportunity. I don’t even consider any part of speculating Bitcoin value on a time horizon less than 10 years.
- raihansaputra 6y agoHuh. When did you start buying your first ones? I just started recently but I don't know how much should I spend more just to be long on Bitcoin.
- cryptica 6y agoThe entire financial system is built on fraud. Corporations are crypto are the prime beneficiaries. For Bitcoin to collapse, all of society would have to collapse.
- xboxnolifes 6y agoAnd bitcoin was supposed to hit $1,000,000 last year (or was it the year prior?).
- fullshark 6y agoA lot of comments here attacking this guy's name or things totally tangential to the meat of the post: simply plugging in some numbers into a financial formula to estimate the market's implied probability of these BTC exchanges going bust. A lot of people here probably have BTC in their own wallets so don't care but the current btc exchanges (binance/coinbase etc) collapsing like mt. gox did would not be good for BTC in the short run at the very least.
- pthreads 6y agoI have been watching some BTC related companies recently and one caught my attention - Canaan. A few days ago they announced purchase orders of 100,000 mining machines for 2021. Supposedly many were pre-paid. Also of note was their claim that in late 2020 they shifted their client base from individual miners to mostly publicly traded companies. I am not sure what to make of it. Maybe HN can chip in?
- dmichulke 6y agoI know that mining is creating more revenue than ever and that will attract new miners. https://cointelegraph.com/news/btc-miners-pocket-4m-in-60-minutes-the-highest-hourly-revenue-in-bitcoin-s-history https://cointelegraph.com/news/btc-miners-pocket-4m-in-60-mi...
- kirse 6y agoAs I watch the total crypto market cap shoot through the roof over the past year, one thing I've been wondering is what will stop a global "bank run" on the exchanges when/if something like this does happen? I was reading thru Coinbase's own insurance wording, and it's clear they dance around it by saying: To the extent these funds are held as USD in U.S. banks, they are maintained as pooled custodial accounts at one or more banks insured by the FDIC. These pooled custodial accounts have pass-through FDIC insurance up to the per-depositor coverage limit then in place [1] Which basically means, only Coinbase's holding accounts are covered for $250k, not our personal accounts. I can't imagine the US Gov stepping in to rescue US crypto account holders when/if it does tank, but it might be necessary if it balloons enough. [1] https://help.coinbase.com/en/coinbase/other-topics/legal-policies/how-is-coinbase-insured https://help.coinbase.com/en/coinbase/other-topics/legal-pol...
- dahdum 6y agoCoinbase doesn't use Tether to store customer funds, they are straight USD or the BTC/ETH itself. I'm not sure how a "bank run", or heavy withdrawal of USD, would cause any more problems than processing delays.
- arcticbull 6y agoThat's a bit of a lack of imagination. What happens is any USDT-BTC exchanges utterly collapse. The price there shoots up to hundreds of thousands of USDT per BTC, those BTC all flood to legitimate exchanges like Coinbase, and deplete their USD. If you believe as I do there's way more USDT printed than backed USD anywhere in the system, Coinbase will dry up too. The price will drop to pennies per BTC on Coinbase. Then there's a ton of bag holders with BTC, and literally no USD to exchange them for. Plenty of USDT though. This is what the 2% per month risk premium is about.
- sammyo 6y agoVery likely in a serious run all the crypto exchanges will crash hard quickly and for an extended time (forever? ;-) essentially stopping trading except for personal direct transactions.
- csulmone 6y agoThis analysis is flawed. People are paying a premium in the futures market to have exposure to BTC without having to acquire and hold physical bitcoins. There is a similar trend in other regulated exchange products like GBTC https://ycharts.com/companies/GBTC/discount_or_premium_to_nav https://ycharts.com/companies/GBTC/discount_or_premium_to_na...
- JackFr 6y ago> physical bitcoins
- chatallo 6y agolet's give him the benefit of the doubt and take it as "the bits of your private keys in a hardware wallet" :)
- hdjcktnr 6y ago"Physical" has a specific meaning in financial jargon. For example, when you trade EUR/USD, you can take "physical delivery" of the position. That doesn't mean that you will get a stack of banknotes, only that the trade will be settled in a different way.
- dcolkitt 6y agoExactly. The author says: > You can’t lose your Bitcoins – you just keep them on chain, and no exchange going bust will affect your position. You absolutely can lose your Bitcoins if your private keys are compromised. Large institutions can and do get hacked or have money embezzled all the time.
- letitbeirie 6y agoOr, say, you mined a half dozen coins or so 10 years and 5 computers ago.
- JumpCrisscross 6y ago> contango for financial products isn’t normal, is that you can arbitrage it very easily, as you don’t have storage costs This is a bit hand wavy. Holding Bitcoin has real administrative and compliance costs for financial players in a position to sell Bitcoin futures. Particularly since, to do this properly, you’d need to be trading on the referenced cryptocurrency exchanges. Also, I don’t think that default probability equation works for this case. (It’s also highly sensitive to the recovery assumption.)
- hntrader 6y agoYeah. There are storage costs. Primarily the counterparty risk associated with current custody solutions.
- crdrost 6y agoThis is still a really fun and quick argument, even so. The risk might not be entirely "the Bitcoin market collapses in the next year" and the risk is an implicit perceived risk, so it might not map to reality. Those criticisms are valid. Nevertheless correcting for that you get something like “I can’t be more than 70% sure that Bitcoin is going to exist a year from now and I also can't be more than 70% sure that I can actually safeguard my bitcoins from hackers and/or malicious insiders, so combining those together as independent possibilities I can't be more than 50% sure that my investment will still exist in a year” with the belief being a belief-in-action, a ‘revealed preference.’ And the nice thing about any revealed-preference argument is that in some sense it’s also a thrown-down gauntlet. “Is this estimate full of crap, HN? Then put your eggs in this basket. Your fortune awaits.” Like, it’s not saying that your arguments are not valid to me, as if the Hacker News comment thread were some sort of arbitrator of truth if only we could argue loud and hard enough for our points of view. A revealed preference argument is saying that your arguments are not valid to you, in the sense that if you profess other confidences or values then your actions are not in line with your values. Who cares about the bluster on the HN comment thread then? This is something that you need to work out in your own case, wondering if you are convinced enough in the stability of Bitcoin to buy some Bitcoin right now to short the future, and if not then why not. Because if you do not have credit-card debt then that 24% APR should look mighty tempting.
- optimalsolver 6y ago>Imagine shorting USDT on Binance. What happens if you’re right and USDT goes to zero? Do you really think Binance will still be around to pay you? Tether's collapse will be to Mt. Gox what Little Boy was to a firecracker.
- eaenki 6y agoBitcoin in itself is quite useful, it’s something people will exchange for usd or things of value which the gov can’t censor or directly police. Bitcoin’s price is determined by zero fundamentals, so it will swing wildly if you zoom Out enough, forever. That’s why if you ask me it makes logical sense to have 1-10% Of the portfolio betting long or short, because it has a much better than 1 in 10 chances of going x10 or -90% in relatively short timeframe. I didn’t backtest it but looking at a chart it looks like there are those many-sigma shifts every 2 years. To that extent, if you’re interested in betting on it, you might want to use option contracts and make sure your max loss is fixed at the premium and the upside is unlimited.
- RIMR 6y agoBitcoin is useful for what? Getting around the law? For pumping and dumping?
- eaenki 6y agoIf you don’t trust your own gov, wether because they’re a bunch of crooks or you’re doing smth fishy, it’s useful.
- carlivar 6y agoWhich is why fiat conversion will eventually be heavily regulated. People forget private gold ownership was illegal for decades of the 20th century.
- eaenki 6y agoIt is still illegal in some countries. E.g Italy I know it goes back and forth between making it legal/illegal. I’d also argue that it is already heavily regulated- you need to give any fiat exchange ur docs. Loopholes with exchanges based in weird island territories will always exist.
- CyberDildonics 6y agoCryptocurrency is good for that. Bitcoin had a $28 AVERAGE transaction fee for the day four days ago. It is worthless for anything except for off chain speculation. No other crypto currency has this problem since this was done intentionally to cripple bitcoin.
- junippor 6y ago> Systematically, the futures contracts for months that are further away, are more expensive than those with closer expiration, and also cheaper than spot > This is usually due to the fact that there’s a risk premium on the uncertainty of the future, and it costs a little bit to be sure of the price that you’ll pay for something three months from now. This is wrong. Being sure of the the price you'll pay in the three months from now does NOT cost this premium. It costs essentially nothing (other than the transaction fee, which is much smaller - of the order of 0.025% on most exchanges, plus the orderbook spread). Note in particular that this transaction cost doesn't depend on the time horizon, unlike the premium the author refers to.
- hdjcktnr 6y agoConspiracy theory: this blog is trying to get people to sell so that some big buyer can buy with less market impact. Kind of like the constant stream of anti-Tesla posts from a couple years ago, which were linked to short sellers.
- singularity2001 6y agoFlagged for bad title
- 74d-fe6-2c6 6y agoI'm convinced Bitcoin won't collapse any time soon. Quite the opposite. It seems like it is being systematically established as a pseudonymous and transnational wealth storage by very powerful and wealthy people all around the world. I own about 0.3 BTC and intend to sell at €100k per BTC.