8 ms·
Depends on your country; I'm quite happy with the UK's restriction on adverts, including a ban on advertising prescription meds at all, and restrictions on prod
by pjc50 6y ago
Depends on your country; I'm quite happy with the UK's restriction on adverts, including a ban on advertising prescription meds at all, and restrictions on product placement.
- fsckboy 6y agojust to be clear, the video/blogger that this discussion is about is also from the UK and this video is about his unhappiness figured i'd just edit my comment here to add another topic: the video says the lyric "does your Spearmint lose its flavor on the bedpost..." was changed to "chewing gum" because Spearmint was a trademark, which was banned on UK radio. The wikipedia article does not mention Spearmint being a trademark. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spearmint https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spearmint Anybody know the story? [did more research, perhaps the answer is that Wrigley's trademarked the "arrow" design surrounding the word spearmint on the label, the arrow presumably an analogy to a "spear"]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dcomp 6y agoMost likely because spearmint was short for Wrigley's spearmint which was trademarked. I don't think spearmint chewing gum was a generic term at the time. Similar to how sellotape(TM) was trademarked but now cellotape is a generic term.
- Jiocus 6y agoI think it's the other way around. The BBC public radio are (were?) not allowed to condone -any- private businesses or products. Then it get's a bit tricky. Trademarks are a consumer protection device which affords the consumer to differentiate between competing products. As the song appeals to a chewing gum, and it's assumed that the general public are aware of one brand, two brands or 50 brands of spearmint-flavoured chewing gums for purchase - the radio may reason that the lyric would be unfit according to their mission. It's less about any actual trademark such as a Spearmint® Chewing Gum, than it is a public association to some marketed goods (and the BBC's stated mission to not condone such). This is just a random reasoning of mine, so a grain of salt etc. This entry mentions this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Does_Your_Chewing_Gum_Lose_Its_Flavour_(On_the_Bedpost_Overnight%3F) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Does_Your_Chewing_Gum_Lose_Its..., but the issue is marked 'dubious'.
- earthboundkid 6y agoThat the US allows ads for prescription drugs is totally indefensible. When I lived in Japan, it took me a while before I realized that all the drug ads were ending with the equivalent of “over the counter” because advertising prescription drugs was illegal. Once I figured it out, it made me wonder why the US would possibly have a different law. It’s crazy!
- cortesoft 6y agoThe ‘defense’ is the first amendment. It would violate it if you prevented people from telling other people about their products.
- dawnerd 6y agoI've heard another defense that's pretty laughable. Goes something like, the ads tell people about conditions they might have but not realize. I fully think we should be banning prescription drugs. There's precedent already for banning product ads - tobacco ads are no longer allowed for example.
- bryan0 6y agoI think the more charitable interpretation of this defense is: Ads tell people about conditions they might have, but not realize there is an available drug that can treat it. Or at least an encouragement to talk to their doctor about it.
- throwawayboise 6y agoIf your condition isn't bothersome enough that you need an ad to prompt you to mention it to your doctor, perhaps it's not really an issue. I think a lot of these ads prod hypochondriacs to rush to their doctor (or perhaps even the ER) to "tell them about their symptoms" which just drives up costs for everyone.
- renewiltord 6y ago
- rozab 6y agoPart 4, starting at 18:03, details how UK TV shows can completely bypass the rules. I found it very convincing, and I now think our rules are insufficient.
- globular-toast 6y agoIf you watch the video you'll see examples showing that law has essentially disappeared in the UK. I haven't watched TV for more than a decade so I was unaware of this, but it's clear that TV in the UK can now do product placement, even on the BBC.
- aembleton 6y agoI didn't know the BBC could do product placement and I didn't see Tom Scott mention that. Just found this post from the BBC that says they do product placement outside of the UK: https://www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/aboutthebbc/entries/b4b56c6d-a3c5-4ec9-b371-739b5a1ce995 https://www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/aboutthebbc/entries/b4b56c6d-a3c...