32 ms·
Ask HN: Why are e-ink note-taking devices so expensive compared to iPads?
Looking at decent e-ink devices to write notes on, I cannot understand why they're so expensive. For the price of a remarkable 2, for instance, you could buy an iPad which supports note-taking, and much more.
I know there are some advantages to e-ink displays, but I don't think that's enough to justify the high price tag on these readers/note-taking devices.
There's also hidden costs involved, such as buying new tips for the e-ink pencils.
Has the e-ink industry reached a dead-end where patents are impeding progress, or are there other reasons involved?
- sneak 6y agoMy guess, from ignorance: the volumes are way lower vs traditional tablets, thinning margins and driving retail price up. Niche devices almost always cost more.
- Someone 6y agoI don’t think they still be niche if they were competitive with LCDs in other aspects, most importantly color gamut and ability to show video (I think longevity and power usage already are competitive, if not more than so). So, why? Are they inherently more difficult or expensive to manufacture, do they use materials that are too rare?
- sneak 6y agoThe way e-ink works is quite different from an LCD. They didn't even get color until recently. Personally, I think the benefits of reflective reading surfaces (ie e-ink) over backlit reading surfaces (everything else) is massively overblown. I have an e-ink tablet now that they are >300ppi and it's nice to read on, but it's a novelty. Some people love 'em, but that hasn't stopped the iPad Pro from outselling all of the e-ink tablets by a huge factor. I think e-ink's future is mainly in small/low power/ambient displays, like price tags or luggage tags. Most people read most things off of their phones or tablets and it's just fine.
- m-p-3 6y agoIf I could bind a 8/10" eInk tablet that was around $200 (or $300) on which I could read and reply to my emails, read RSS feeds, check my calendar and take handwritten notes on it (that I could export/sync) I'd constantly use it.
- criddell 6y agoThese guys sell something like that: https://www.boox.com/ https://www.boox.com/ I've heard they are great except for the GPL violations...
- pabs3 6y agoIf you are aware of a particular GPL violation, please report it to the project being violated. For the Linux kernel, that would be Software Freedom Conservancy, who recently announced a new strategy for achieving GPL compliance. https://sfconservancy.org/copyleft-compliance/ https://sfconservancy.org/copyleft-compliance/ https://sfconservancy.org/copyleft-compliance/enforcement-strategy.html https://sfconservancy.org/copyleft-compliance/enforcement-st... https://sfconservancy.org/copyleft-compliance/firmware-liberation.html https://sfconservancy.org/copyleft-compliance/firmware-liber... https://sfconservancy.org/news/2020/oct/01/new-copyleft-strategy-launched-with-ARDC-grant/ https://sfconservancy.org/news/2020/oct/01/new-copyleft-stra...
- criddell 6y agoIt's been reported. HN has discussed it: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23735962 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23735962
- cmiller1 6y agoWhat about a hybrid display for portable devices. A transparent OLED panel sitting over an e-ink display. You could have the battery life and readability of e-ink and just turn on the front panel when you needed full color or fast refresh rates such as for video.
- RicoElectrico 6y agoThe company holding patents for e-ink is literally retarded, as if they don't want it to succeed. I'm not making this up. [1] Sure e-ink has its flaws, but wouldn't it be better to have a smaller slice of a much larger cake? OLED is patent encumbered too, there's also a patent holding company, despite that you can buy smallest modules for less than $2 on AliExpress. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22829798 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22829798
- arsome 6y agoAre those $2 Chinese modules really paying to license the patent?
- RicoElectrico 6y agoI have to say: I don't know, but royalties may be also paid by upstream suppliers, as there are patents on specific chemicals. There's a chance these chemicals are made e.g. in Japan.
- 2Gkashmiri 6y agowhy do i care if they don't ? for for that matter anyone here? its not like we are owners of e-ink
- Naga 6y agoI agree completely with your points, and I'm sorry be that guy, but "literally retarded" is offensive language and is frankly below the level of discourse of HN. I'm not one to be the PC police but really, come on. You can make your argument without resulting to slurs like that. https://www.verywellfamily.com/what-is-the-r-word-3105651 https://www.verywellfamily.com/what-is-the-r-word-3105651
- StavrosK 6y agoWhile I agree, the word itself doesn't seem to be particularly offensive, no? It's a matter of using it in an offensive manner, which means that even if we move on to "disabled" now, that's soon going to meet the same fate. I think we should strive not to use mental disability in a derogatory manner, no matter the word.
- corytheboyd 6y agoI remember buying my first LCD display in the CRT era. It was tiny, thick, ugly, and of course expensive. Now they’re cheap and everywhere. The same will happen with e-ink in time. Honestly I would rather have the iPad for note taking. Response times are important for rapid idea translation, and e-ink systems are very lacking here, whereas the iPad is not. Probably an unpopular opinion, but it’s my own experience.
- pidg 6y agoResponse time (i.e. pen touch to pixel appearing) on the latest generation of e-ink devices is literally imperceptible, though I believe they've had to cut a few minor corners to get it to that level.
- ComputerGuru 6y agoDrawing a pixel where none exists is not too bad. The trouble is drawing when there is already something on the screen.
- PurpleFoxy 6y agoThe iPad also has a massive library of software. There is an app called “Concepts” which provides an infinite canvas in all directions and it seems really useful for engineering and design type people where you can just draw an idea in the middle and move outwards with notes or alternate revisions. All in color, with pressure sensitivity.
- daniellarusso 6y agoEconomies of scale?
- mariusor 6y agoI'm pretty sure you don't need a question mark. reMarkable is a small company that is now shipping their second device. Apple has shipped iPads for 11 years, even if they updated the hardware at every step, they still can rely on a well established supply chain. It feels off-putting to see people get into this entitled mindset that requires that small companies price their products in the same low ranges as well established ones can afford to - either through unethical production practices, or, like you mentioned, economy of scale - or they're not worth it. PS. Sorry to rant at OP in your replies.
- ip26 6y agoYeah, niche products feel like an education in how powerful economics of scale & competition really are. It's easy to understand conceptually without having a grasp of the magnitude. But take apart a $300 food dehydrator, and it's basically 1940's technology. The market just doesn't have competition or scale. Gives me a new appreciation for why access to goods was so limited in the past.
- cameron_b 6y agoNot E-ink, but alternative tablet - Repaper: https://www.iskn.co/repaper/shop/repaper https://www.iskn.co/repaper/shop/repaper I got my wife ( a non-techie painter ) one for Christmas and just set it up last night on our iMac. Adoption -> volume -> buying power -> lower component prices, better feature implementation I think most of the alternatives suffer from adoption challenges, but I personally love Unix-model physical devices [ which do one job well and work well with others ] So vote with your dollars, and feature requests
- hmottestad 6y agoIs that just a paper clipboard that can digitize your notes? What I like about note-taking on an ipad is that I can move stuff around, copy paste, figure-mode, undo button and camera for quickly grabbing a picture of the whiteboard or a slide.
- cameron_b 6y agoit works the same way as a Wacom-type screen-less tablet for interacting with a phone, tablet computer or desktop -- with or without paper. It has a stylus for use in screen-only interactions, but you can also use it away from a computer with pencil [ with "ring" ] and paper, and pull up your notes later.
- dominotw 6y agolow scale niche products. obviously.
- pidg 6y agoI own a reMarkable 2. There is certainly enough to justify the cost, if you are a prolific note-taker. Conversely, I find it hard to justify the cost of an iPad, becuase I already have a phone and several laptops. I can't see a situation where a tablet would be more useful to me, so I've never bought one. Turns out different people have different needs, and the e-ink note-taking market caters to that. Most people would find an iPad more useful, so they're lower cost.
- d3ckard 6y agoLet me help you - iPad is the ultimate content consumption device. It’s by far my favorite electronic device and by far the most used. I work on my computer, I communicate on my phone, but I relax on my iPad. Internet browsing, shopping, watching shorter videos (or even longer ones when cooking), sometimes playing games, reading books. Thanks for the recommendation for Remarkable 2, considering buying one for a while now.
- Cthulhu_ 6y agoI have heard of some using the ipad pro as a drawing tablet, in which case it competes with e.g. Wacom, whose prices for their display-drawing-tablets are on par with ipads.
- girzel 6y agoMy daughter is in art school. She was considering a Wacom tablet, then did her research and bought an iPad pro instead. She seems thrilled with the choice.
- matwood 6y agoI've been slowly learning to draw using paper and an iPad Pro. Obviously they are different, but the iPad Pro gets a lot of right in terms of responsiveness and pencil pressure.
- valzam 6y agoMy partner has a ReMarkable 2, I have an Ipad pro 11. I got mine earlier and thought writing on it was pretty good. But it's not even close. ReMarkable feels 90% like paper, it's crazy. Ipad (at least without one of those paperlike screen protectors) isn't even comparable, it very much feels like writing on glass. She loves it (for her PhD), if you take a lot of handwriten notes it's amazing.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- brassattax 6y agoI think e-ink screens would be great for musicians too! A lot of musicians are using iPad Pro, but I personally would rather have a dual screen e-ink device like this (for better battery life, better readability): https://www.gvidomusic.com/ https://www.gvidomusic.com/ ($1600!!) First company to build something like this and bring the cost down to something a bit more reasonable will get my business.
- mhh__ 6y agoMusicians often don't have all that much money though, so unless this device cost less than maybe $200 it's a very hard sell.
- cannaceo 6y agoEven the broke musicians I know have thousands to tens of thousands of dollars in gear.
- NeutronStar 6y agoThat's for gear. Not for a paper replacing device. What's the cost of paper and pen compared to this?
- quijoteuniv 6y agothousand in Gear! Not computers/ipads! :)
- _joel 6y agoThe broke musicians I know can barely afford to pay their rent.
- wott 6y agoBoth can be true at the same time.
- 6y ago
- throwaway4485we 6y agoThroaway to not get sued. E-ink, the company, holds the patents of the pigment core tech that makes "paper-like" displays possible and strongarms the display manufacturers and the users of their displays to absolute silence. Any research project or startup that comes up with a better alternative technology gets bought out or buried by their lawyers ASAP. E-ink don't make the display themselves, they make the e-ink film, filled with their patented pigment particles and sell it to display manufacturers who package the film in glass and a TFT layer and add a driver interface chip, all of which are proprietary AF and unless you're the size of Amazon, forget about getting any detailed datasheets about how to correctly drive their displays to get sharp images. In my previous company we had to reverse engineer their waveforms in order to build usable products even though we were buying quite a lot of displays. With so much control over the IP and the entire supply chain and due to the broken nature of the patent system, they're an absolute monopoly and have no incentive to lower prices or to bring any innovations to the market and are a textbook example of what happens to technology when there is zero competition. So, when you see the high prices of e-paper gadgets, don't blame the manufacturers, as they're not price gouging, blame E-ink, as their displays make up the bulk of the BOM. Tough, some of their tech is pretty dope. One day E-ink sent over a 32" 1440p prototype panel with 32 shades of B&W to show off. My God, was the picture gorgeous and sharp. I would have loved to have it as a PC monitor so I tried building an HDMI interface controller for it with an FPGA but failed due to a lack of time and documentation. Shame, although not a big loss as an estimated cost for that was near the five figure ballpark and the current consumption was astronomical, sometimes triggering the protection of the power supply on certain images.
- JohnJamesRambo 6y agoIt’s so silly though, have they done real correct math on how much more they would make if everyone used it?
- schnevets 6y agoMy mind immediately went to the most recent episode of NPR's Planet Money, where they explored buying rights to one of Marvel/Disney's +7,000 characters. Specifically, they tried licensing Doorman, an obscure joke of a hero who can teleport others. Although they never said it outright, it sounded like the main deterrent is just anyone else making money with an angle Disney hadn't explored. It sounds similar to eInk refusing millions if it means someone else makes a greater fortune.
- edent 6y agoI have a Boyue Likebook Ares - it cost £190. https://shkspr.mobi/blog/2019/11/gadget-review-boyue-likebook-ares/ https://shkspr.mobi/blog/2019/11/gadget-review-boyue-likeboo... It has an 8inch screen - about the same size as the iPad mini. It runs Android 8 but, obviously, some apps work better than others. It came with several nibs for its pencil. They have an 10 inch version for around £230. See https://goodereader.com/blog/electronic-readers/boyue-p10-is-a-10-3-inch-e-reader-that-costs-329 https://goodereader.com/blog/electronic-readers/boyue-p10-is... So, there are some cheapish, largeish, eInk devices out there. I was told (and I have no way to back it up) that the yields on eInk are fairly low. They make a couple of square metres of screen, and then have to cut it to size. Because of defects in the process, they can have a lot of wastage. So the larger sizes are disproportionally more expensive.
- Snitch-Thursday 6y agoI ended up with a Likebook Mars as it fulfilled the entire criteria I had. Very similar design to the Ares. headphone jack runs new enough android to run syncthing supports SD card
- jMyles 6y agoThe same reason we can't have many nice things: threats of violence toward innovators under the guise of intellectual "property".
- luplex 6y agoI suspect an additional reason: their customers are not very price-sensitive. They obviously can't compete with paper on price, so they don't even try.
- m-p-3 6y agoI'd be a customer if the price was lower..
- anigbrowl 6y ago'Veblen goods' are items that are desirable partly because poor people can't afford them. They're a way for better-off people to signal to each other. Of course, e-ink devices are not so fancy that only well-off people can carry them. But if you see someone with an e-ink device and they also have nice shoes, clothes, and accessories, it's reasonable to assume somewhat high social status.
- PurpleFoxy 6y agoWell, wording the OP alternatively. They know they can never beat the iPad on price so they don’t try to squeeze their price as much as possible and instead choosing to make the device more premium and keep the business sustainable.
- dylan604 6y agoI'd be a Tesla customer if the price was lower. Tesla gets all the love for this approach, yet small/niche electronics maker doesn't.
- toyg 6y agoBeyond patent issues, TBH I would not have a problem paying for a reMarkable this very day, if I could be 10000% sure that there wasn't some shitty SaaS service involved in using it at any stage. These days, whenever a new gadget comes up, my first reaction has become "I wonder how they try to screw you into a SaaS later".
- dec0dedab0de 6y agoI'm sure one of the people who own one will chime in, but i think the whole device is hackable, you can get into a linux shell as root and do whatever you want.
- syats 6y agoOut of the box, the SaaS thingy is not really needed, you can just signup and use the device without ever logging in or downloading their mobile app. They're just kind enough to keep all your notes for you and thus, by default, need a bunch of battery power for the sync process.
- jmholla 6y agoYou don't even need to sign up.
- neekburm 6y agoI have one, thus far their cloud service is free and hopefully will continue to be so. Every ReMarkable comes with an 8gb cloud account, which is the same amount of storage on the device. Hopefully this doesn't change, because it's really a pain to put things on the tablet without using their app.
- codethief 6y ago> Hopefully this doesn't change, because it's really a pain to put things on the tablet without using their app. Have you tried Syncthing[0, 1]? I'm actually considering buying a ReMarkable 2 right now and the fact that Syncthing seems to be working on it is playing a major role in my decision process. [0]: https://syncthing.net https://syncthing.net [1]: https://github.com/evidlo/remarkable_syncthing https://github.com/evidlo/remarkable_syncthing
- mlthoughts2018 6y agoI own a Remarkable 2 and it is vastly superior to an iPad (which I also own) for many use cases. I would likely pay more for Remarkable 2 than for a full-sized iPad at this point, as the streaming and browsing capabilities are not useful to me anymore (I would use iPhone for all of that). I’d also like better integrations with alternate cloud storage providers, but this is true for Apple products too. Combine with the fact you can literally ssh to your Remarkable and write your own apps, it’s a no-brainer.
- ohitsdom 6y agoI would have loved to buy something more capable, but instead I settled for this cheap LCD writing display as a mini-whiteboard. I don't even know how to describe this technology but it gets the job done at $20. https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B07QL11LWF https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B07QL11LWF
- AshamedCaptain 6y agoThis has been my point many times -- people actually have trouble distinguishing eInk from el-cheapo non-backlighted LCD displays.
- dpritchett 6y agoNot supporting a browser, games, or a media player IS the killer feature for anyone with ADHD or other focus issues. There are lots of us out here. Some even people do their deep work on a separate airgapped computer just to preserve their focus.
- nojito 6y agoI used to have this problem, but I set up my ipad with parental control features so that I am unable to distract myself.
- dpritchett 6y agoWhat stops you from unlocking the parental controls? If that’s not a recurring issue for you then you may not have an executive function disorder.
- matsemann 6y ago(I don't have a disorder, but) for me the case is often that I just mindlessly click my HN bookmark, open reddit app, lichess puzzle etc to kill a few minutes. Just the popup telling me that it's blocked is enough to make my brain realize what I'm about to do and abort. I could just click the button to override, but my "mindlessly browsing" mode got disturbed and suddenly I'm conscious about it happening.
- dpritchett 6y agoFor a few decades I tried and failed to make hostfile blocks, guided access mode, browser focus-tracking extensions, day planners, public accountability, timers, and more work for me. What actually works as I count the weeks to my fortieth birthday is a fragile and ever-shifting combination of adderall, sleep, diet, exercise, therapy, e-ink devices, and the courage to be open up and be vulnerable with those who depend on me at work and at home. Splurging on a color laser printer and an e-ink tablet have given me two more ways to have a hope of staying on task a bit more every day.
- ericd 6y agoI wouldn't think of the remarkable 2 as "less than" an iPad. Part of the point of it is that it is completely focused on being a paper replacement. It doesn't pop up random notifications at you while you're trying to think, and it doesn't offer the opportunity for distraction when you get momentarily stuck on something, which makes it a lot easier to power through. It's like how not having junk food in the house makes dieting a lot easier - you don't have to use willpower to do the right thing, because the wrong thing is hard to do.
- PurpleFoxy 6y agoYou can trivially disable notifications and remove games/social media from the iPad.
- powerapple 6y agoPeople buy e-ink devices for a special need, the market is small, so the price would be higher. I wish Apple can produce a eink device. I bought an Onyx BOOX Nova 3. I bought it mainly for web browsing and ebooks. Surprisingly, taking note with it was quite pleasant. Although I love it and use it everyday, I really with there is a good quality device both on hardware and software level as Apple devices.
- aurizon 6y agoFrom what I read, it has no advantages in the marketplace - except for a high price...
- jacklolo 6y agoThe 12 Best Jobs for Dog Lovers https://bit.ly/MONY23GIFT https://bit.ly/MONY23GIFT
- figers 6y agoJust bought a boox note air and love it, writing on it does feel like paper, syncs to OneNote & OneDrive Love reading kindle, feedly, hacker news, instapaper, zinio, etc
- HardwareLust 6y agoThanks man! I was thinking about replacing my paper notebook, and that just might be exactly what I needed.
- tyler109 6y agoYou should check our reddit: https://www.reddit.com/r/eink/ https://www.reddit.com/r/eink/ There is lots of advice on affordable e-readers, diy e-readers and buying advice
- tyler109 6y agoCheck this one only 300 bucks https://liliputing.com/2021/02/pocketbook-inkpad-color-7-8-inch-ereader-now-available-for-329.html?amp https://liliputing.com/2021/02/pocketbook-inkpad-color-7-8-i...