4 ms·
My experience with visual programming is that, as the required complexity of the tasks grows even just minimally, it frustrates skilled users without really emp
by toyg 6y ago
My experience with visual programming is that, as the required complexity of the tasks grows even just minimally, it frustrates skilled users without really empowering unskilled ones.
That's because the unskilled stays unskilled for a reason: they can't or won't dedicate the amount of focus necessary to learn a technology to any meaningful degree. They will do the minimum they are (very explicitly) trained to do, and that's it. Basic scripting is not hard; if you cannot (or will not) do it, chances are you cannot (or will not) formalize even slightly-complex tasks in a visual environment either.
And of course, visual environments are a productivity killer for the skilled, who then feel frustrated and eventually drop back into textual modes. This is self-evident.
Sadly, it's a marketing dream, so it keeps popping up in all companies in my niche. "If only we build a no-code graphical UI, accountants will become programmers!" - no they will not. If they were really interested in automating tasks and modelling problems, they would have already learnt VBA, which is very simple - smart accountants do it already. People capable of doing advanced math are capable of programming if they really want. Accountants who won't learn VBA will not meaningfully engage with visual paradigms either, because they are simply not interested in these activities. What really needs to happen is to empower smart accountants to be productive without involving IT. That doesn't need visual programming, it just needs a powerful set of VBA apis unshackled from "enterprise" permission systems.
- mightyRodri 6y agoThat sounds like the trite old University Professor that says to 4/5ths of their students that didnt get an A: "You lack the passion and maybe you are not made for this". @murukesh_s post wrote the retourt to that. Pointers and Windows had a substantial impact on shaping the reality we live in now. Putting all the responsibillity on the users shoulders and their "intelligence in math" is way to ego focused IMO.
- toyg 6y agoRead it again. What I wrote is that accountants are smart. They already know how to deal with numbers ad variables, and control flows are trivial to learn in something like VBA. If they don't do it it's because they don't want to, and no amount of forceful simplicity will change that. In fact, visual programming often frustrates them more than it empowers them. murukesh_s is obviously invested in this, so he's hardly an impartial observer, whereas I don't really care one way or the other and am just relying the experience of somebody helping users with these tools.
- pembrook 6y ago> That's because the unskilled stays unskilled for a reason: they can't or won't dedicate the amount of focus necessary to learn a technology to any meaningful degree. The entire history of computers and software betrays this argument. Every time we transitioned from a blank, text-command driven UI, to a visual one, we dramatically increased the percentage of the general population able to use something. Think the transition from MS-DOS to Windows, UNIX to OSX, etc. By representing concepts visually, humans find them easier to understand. In fact, I’d argue, most software innovation today is just making visual UI’s better. Think the single doc mode (photoshop) to artboard mode (sketch, figma). Single purpose (excel, word) to multipurpose (notion). Etc. Notion is blowing up with 13 year old kids on Tiktok because it’s an easier UI to do spreadsheets and create documents and websites with. Which are fundamentally valuable things. In software, what is valuable, will be made easier over time. Most B2B Saas tools are just crud apps. Not only is there no reason coding these apps has to stay complicated, but there’s economic incentive in making it easier. Unfortunately, many people have a vested interest in keeping things complicated. Like people who get paid to create CRUD apps. As the saying goes, it is difficult to get a man to understand something when his salary depends on his not understanding it.
- sergiosgc 6y agoI understand your point, and I also see where toyg comes from. Let me try to phrase it another way: Some tasks are inherently complex. Take data modelling as an example. Properly designing a database requires formal training. There's no way around it, and when you mask database design with a UI, you get the worst of both worlds. The complexity is there, unskilled users won't be able to tackle it, and the UI gets in the way of professionals with formal training. Naturally, there is a continuum of tasks to be done, some can be solved with a poorly designed solution. If a user is empowered to generate a subpar solution, it is still better than no solution at all. That's the secret for Excel being the second best tool for any data manipulation task (for each task there is a better tool, but excel gets the job done in all of them). The error here is selling visual programming tools as the next evolution step, which will phase out text UIs. It's not. It's a different tool, for a different use case, to be used by a different cohort of users.