3 ms·
Is there not a download function built into the website? It's a non-profit, they really ought to make those clips available...
by Wowfunhappy 6y ago
Is there not a download function built into the website? It's a non-profit, they really ought to make those clips available...
- cjsawyer 6y agoI bet it’s to reduce server load. If a user only sticks around for one or two sections then if everything was downloaded up front the later sections would be wasted bandwidth
- tomc1985 6y agoIt's to keep control. Plenty of services have offered full downloads over the years and bandwidth is cheap. There's no reason for them not to offer them unless they're being greedy.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ahepp 6y agoIt seems kinda weird to me to portray them as greedy. Even if the root of this decision is because they want money, don't they need to fund the content somehow? Khan Academy seems to have really raised the bar for this kind of content. I'm inclined to trust their decision on how to maintain quality and balance that with accessibility. Maybe I'm just naive? At the same time, it does seem like having the content easily available offline could help people out. I wonder if they've ever explained their rationale?
- tomc1985 6y agoBecause my statement isn't necessarily about Khan Academy, but anyone hosting cloud-based video content. Data wants to be free, as they say, and digital economies are a world of abundance where copying is free or nearly so. When a provider doesn't align with that they are imposing physical-world scarcity economics in a place where it doesn't belong. It feels like people are trying to erase fundamental concepts like files or downloading, and instead offering a bullshit rental model where anything you can do on the net is at the pleasure of the content owner. It is disempowering to users as it changes them from masters of their domain to digital peons in CC's feudalistic kingdoms. That is what I mean by 'greedy'. If you publish something online, it is out there for good. You cannot try to delete it and you cannot try to control it. You do not have a right to try to profit on the content itself because, again, data is free and no matter how much one might want to control data, ultimately they can't. DRM, ads, subscription gates -- these are all additional layers of crap that we have built to cage that data and prevent it from being freed. It is a shame that we as a people cannot handle this world of abundance, and that the tools we use to navigate it grant us less and less control with every new DRM scheme or subscription service. There are plenty of ways to monetize without locking down bits.
- Wowfunhappy 6y ago> It feels like people are trying to erase fundamental concepts like files or downloading, and instead offering a bullshit rental model where anything you can do on the net is at the pleasure of the content owner. It is disempowering to users as it changes them from masters of their domain to digital peons in CC's feudalistic kingdoms. This is why I find it so disheartening that Khan Academy doesn't allow downloads natively. I understand the incentives for a provider like Youtube are overwhelmingly in favor of streaming-only, but an educational nonprofit like Khan Academy? If even they don't offer downloads, what hope is there?
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoCould put up a torrent. I'd certainly seed that.
- dangoor 6y agoKhan Academy videos are Creative Commons licensed, and Kolibri provides a way to download the videos wholesale. Our focus is on the whole learning experience (which includes exercises and articles, plus keeping track of skills that a student has mastered). We also put a lot of work into providing tools for teachers and coaches to help students. Videos are one part of our work.
- thinkingkong 6y agoThats not how non profits work. They still have bills and alternative methods for viewing may impede their ability to earn revenue.
- andai 6y agoThey don't show ads do they? Or is most of their traffic via YouTube?
- ben_w 6y agoIf they do so, is there any risk of spiders/obsessive collectors downloading everything? It’s been a while since I ran downloads directly off my website, so I’m genuinely not sure if there are enough of either to significantly alter bandwidth requirements.
- enjoyyourlife 6y agoThe College Board (maker of the SAT) is also a non-profit
- unreal6 6y agoYes, but the College Board is evil in a way I perceive Khan Acedemy to not be.
- enjoyyourlife 6y agoKhan Academy is essentially built around preparing students for College Board exams such as the SAT and AP. The College Board is even one of Khan Academy's key supporters
- truetraveller 6y agoDirect downloads would certainly help, but I understand their concerns.
- smarx007 6y agoI think they don't want to "dilute" their value proposition. They are selling to various sponsors the idea is that their platform is the key, but if downloaded videos can suffice, it's a different story. Every platform these days want to control user "journey".
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoWhat are their concerns?
- dangoor 6y agoYou can download videos for offline viewing with the mobile apps. Khan Academy is not just for video viewing, though. We (I work at Khan) have articles and exercises, keep track of a student's mastery of the material, etc.
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoThanks, that's good to hear! I still think there should be a way to download these videos as standard mp4's via a web browser. Users shouldn't have to rely on third party python scripts if at all possible. The articles and exercises are of course also important pieces, but there's no reason to make the video portion less accessible than it could be.