6 ms·
The collateral requirement was imposed because of the incredibly high chance of the stock simply collapsing again. Trading halts in response to massive movemen
by pjc50 6y ago
The collateral requirement was imposed because of the incredibly high chance of the stock simply collapsing again.
Trading halts in response to massive movements aren't unusual either.
- stingraycharles 6y agoWas a change in collateral requirement something that was known / codified in some agreement, or was it an ad-hoc decision?
- MattGaiser 6y ago> How a clearinghouse judges these risks, and therefore when it makes demands for more upfront funds, is typically formulaic. Margins can be based on equations such as value-at-risk. Exactly how the formula works, and who is responsible for losses in what order, are important elements. In the case of National Securities Clearing Corp., losses would be covered by the defaulting member’s funds before the clearinghouse’s own funds or other members’ funds would be used. https://www.wsj.com/articles/how-clearing-demands-grounded-the-wallstreetbets-stocks-for-a-day-11611966092 https://www.wsj.com/articles/how-clearing-demands-grounded-t... WSJ says that it is formulaic.
- bsanr2 6y agoLet's take a look at the formula.
- ric2b 6y agoNo, they say it "is typically formulaic". It's quite possible that this time it wasn't. I'd say it's very likely that it wasn't formulaic this time, since Robinhood's CEO said in an interview with CNBC that we was called at like 4AM, well after markets closed, to deal with the new requirements.
- ummonk 6y agoIt was an ad-hoc decision to go beyond the formulaic requirements.
- katbyte 6y agoI've only been sorta paying attention so i could be wrong but trades were not suspended or halted? only buying was prevented, and only for some brokerages?
- csours 6y agoTrades at the exchange level were repeatedly halted over the course of two weeks or so of the most volatile trading. Trades by certain brokers or apps were also notably halted on a Thursday due to lack of liquidity.
- ycombobreaker 6y agoExchanges repeatedly halted for brief periods, based on predetermined rules. That part was nothing special, it's something like 5 minutes at a time, Buying to open new positions was blocked by some brokers in response to the the bump in collateral requirements they were required to fulfill. Some brokers were capable of blocking only margin account trading, but RH sounds like they blocked all buyers (plus their target market is margin account holders) DTCC is basically interested in ensuring that trade settlement occurs. They eliminate a lot of counterparty risk, but the flipside to that is that they clearly have discretion that surprises brokers.
- freeone3000 6y agoIt's the collateral increase that caused Robinhood and other no-fee brokerages to halt trading. Brokerages which had the ability to charge for trades simply required more cash on hand and charged slightly more for the trade.
- jimminy 6y ago> Only buying was prevented, and only for some brokerages? The first part of that has been a common bit of misinformation. Opening new positions (either by attempting to buy shares of the stock, or entering into a new short position) is what was prevented. Closing positions (selling for owners of shares, or in the case of short obligations buying shares) was still allowed as closing reduces credit risk for the broker. The brokerages that did restrict, were smaller firms and did so to maintain liquidity for all assets, instead of allowing a vast amount of their capital to be consolidated largely into a few assets, due to the increased capital cost of clearing.
- avereveard 6y agobut they blocked stock purchases alongside options, which makes no sense if the justification was collaterals for options
- w23j 6y agoStock purchases are settled after 2 days. If the buyer goes broke before that, the seller would be left holding to bag. To mitigate this risk you need to post collateral.
- avereveard 6y agoof course, but if you buy without margin the balance in your account should already be enough to cover the collateral.
- gruez 6y agoBut it's not the brokerage's money on the line, it's DTCC's. From the perspective of the DTCC, there's no difference between a retail brokerage buying $10M of GME and lehman brothers buying $10M of GME.
- ric2b 6y agoBut if the brokerage already has your money they can use it to post collateral. And yet they banned everyone from buying. A lot of stuff doesn't add up here.