25 ms·
I still don't see why this should be universal. It's a nice slogan but it's not unreasonable to have a cutoff.
by mhh__ 6y ago
I still don't see why this should be universal. It's a nice slogan but it's not unreasonable to have a cutoff.
- arcticbull 6y agoIt's convenient because you can kill off all of the "entitlements" programs at the same time. Drop SNAP, unemployment, disability, drop social security, medicaid, drop everything, and cut a check. This materializes in substantial administrative cost reductions. It's an efficiency. You can claw back from folks who don't need it at tax time.
- Tostino 6y agoThis is exactly what I was planning on typing out as an answer. Well put.
- aidenn0 6y agoI hear this argument a lot but: 1. Some people on disability need far more than any reasonable UBI would provide 2. SNAP, Social Security, Medicaid: Debt is an issue here. Even if you shield UBI payments from bankruptcy, that would still require those with large debt burdens to declare bankruptcy. Libertarians will say that choosing to starve rather than file bankruptcy is a valid life choice, but proponents of the mentioned entitlement programs will probably disagree.
- arcticbull 6y agoGenuine question: > 1. Some people on disability need far more than any reasonable UBI would provide Is that due to medical needs? Because if so, that would seem to be a job not for UBI but for a proper medical system, which this country is also woefully lacking. > 2. SNAP, Social Security, Medicaid: Debt is an issue here. Even if you shield UBI payments from bankruptcy, that would still require those with large debt burdens to declare bankruptcy. Libertarians will say that choosing to starve rather than file bankruptcy is a valid life choice, but proponents of the mentioned entitlement programs will probably disagree. While true, and I agree that it would have to be shielded from bankruptcy... Gallup found that voters who identify as libertarians ranged from 17 to 23% of the American electorate. However, a 2014 Pew Poll found that 23% of Americans who identify as libertarians have little understanding of libertarianism. I'm not sure I'm interested in blocking this proposal on 17% of Americans, 23% of whom don't even know what libertarianism actually is. At that point we're saying libertarians are the "10th dentist who hates Colgate." While I appreciate their principled stance today, I'm confident that given the choice to cash their UBI check or starve, they'll be the first ones in line at the bank.
- aidenn0 6y ago>> 1. Some people on disability need far more than any reasonable UBI would provide > Is that due to medical needs? Because if so, that would seem to be a job not for UBI but for a proper medical system, which this country is also woefully lacking. First of all, you suggested eliminating (among other things) medicaid in favor of UBI. Secondly, define "medical needs" if you are mentally incapable of managing your life, then someone has to care for you in a non-medical manner. As an extreme case, there are people who, if you walk up to them and say "please give me all your money," they will ... give you all their money.
- arcticbull 6y ago> First of all, you suggested eliminating (among other things) medicaid in favor of UBI. Medicaid is a pretty predatory program in its implementation. It provides the bare minimum of care and comes after your personal effects to try and pay for it - for those over 55, states are required by law to recover whatever they spend on you, and they put a lien on your house. [1] This serves to lock in systemic inequalities by taking away the inheritance from poor children while wealthy folks see their estate tax burdens removed or eliminated - it's a regressive tax on the poorest. The program is an atrocity. It deserves to be nuked from orbit and replaced with something humane. It's only one step above "just let them die at the entrance to the hospital." There's two ways to move forward if you choose to eliminate Medicaid. You either take a portion of the UBI payments and purchase private care, or you expand Medicare to, well, All. > Secondly, define "medical needs" if you are mentally incapable of managing your life, then someone has to care for you in a non-medical manner. As an extreme case, there are people who, if you walk up to them and say "please give me all your money," they will ... give you all their money. I do actually consider those to be medical needs but understand the point of contention there. [1] https://aspe.hhs.gov/basic-report/medicaid-liens https://aspe.hhs.gov/basic-report/medicaid-liens
- dfgdghdf 6y agoLots of libertarians like UBI; it's pretty much the smallest government you can have that still ensures a floor to everyone's quality of life. Milton Friedman advocated a negative income tax, which is similar.
- r00fus 6y ago> You can claw back from folks who don't need it at tax time. Completely agree. Means-test the taxation, not the handout. If rich people are getting the handout and don't need it, adjust tax to offset the handout with a phaseout. We have a well developed process/venue to handle fairness of taxation - best place for means-testing.
- Filligree 6y agoBecause making it universal is cheaper. If you set the cutoff threshold high, then you're barely saving any money and end up spending a lot more on the bureaucracy than you'd save. On the flip side, if it's anywhere close to the income of a middle-class person then you could get an effect where earning more money makes you worse off. Of course you can taper it off instead of making it a sudden cut-off, but that makes the bureaucracy even bigger.
- o_p 6y agoYou are adding costs and extra work because now you have to make sure everyone is on the income bracket and all the complexities of auditing. Its just much more simple and elegant to make it universal, those at the top brackets will have a negative net due to taxes anyway, so why bother?
- bluecalm 6y agoCutoffs create fiscal cliffs. This is not reasonable. You would need to make it so it's smoothly decreases with income and if you're at it you can just skip that step and deduct it from taxes paid.
- ska 6y agoThe argument is that it gets rid of as much of the bureaucratic nonsense. Say you send everyone a check, adjust income tax so it washes out at something like 2x or 3x the base rate. No extra bureaucracy because your tax authority already has to to that, and at the same time you can same money on administration of a bunch of current programs (and get rid of them). Note that it clearly doesn't replace all programs. But UBI + universal health care of some sort would sure make a dent (US specific). There are valid critiques of UBI's viability but universality isn't one of them.