8 ms·
I think the Marketplace quote is worth noting too: >A look at the terms for the Azure Marketplace throws up this sentence: "If you purchase or use a Marketplac
by duxup 6y ago
I think the Marketplace quote is worth noting too:
>A look at the terms for the Azure Marketplace throws up this sentence: "If you purchase or use a Marketplace Offering, we may share with the Publisher of such Offering your contact information and details about the transaction and your usage."
So the publisher of something on their Marketplace gets some information.
This doesn't seem 'that' weird (well the linked in contact does) as it seems semi related to ... say apps and app stores and etc.
Edit: I'm not justifying the policy, but I am noting that on a marketplace with third parties, this seems pretty standard / something you should always consider when you install something from a third party.
- joezydeco 6y agoThis is the real answer. I almost did the same thing but decided to spin up my own image instead of buying a prepacked one from the Marketplace.
- duxup 6y agoExactly, I'm not so much cool with the policy here, but absolutely we should think about what we want and take appropriate actions like you did if we want to avoid it.
- joezydeco 6y agoWell, my reason was also because I was having so much trouble trying to find a machine+zone+disk setup that was available and under my $50/month budget since I'm running on MSDN subscription credit. What a freaking pain in the ass.
- IgorPartola 6y agoYou buy a dishwasher from Best Buy. They send your name and address to Maytag. You buy soap from Walmart. They send your name and address to Johnson & Johnson. You buy a sandwich at your local deli. They send your name and address to Boar’s Head. Cool?
- duxup 6y agoI don't know if it is cool, but I wouldn't be surprised. The idea that a AWS or Aszure market place with third parties involved is different than say my example, an App store with third parties seems like a good way to think about it. I'm not justifying the policy, but I am noting the context isn't that different and how we should think about it.
- IgorPartola 6y agoThat’s fair. I guess if Canonical is selling something directly by using Azure’s storefront that’s a different thing. Still, their response to this is pretty terrible.
- stevehawk 6y agoCool? no. The reality? Almost certainly.
- csours 6y ago> You buy a dishwasher from Best Buy. They send your name and address to Maytag. For warranty purposes of course > You buy soap from Walmart. They send your name and address to Johnson & Johnson. In case they need to recall the soap > You buy a sandwich at your local deli. They send your name and address to Boar’s Head. Cool? So you can get some cool Boar's Head swag! Just kidding of course. We need much better data privacy protection.
- IgorPartola 6y ago> So you can get some cool Boar's Head swag! I can’t even imagine what that might be. But technical support for my sandwich making needs would be fun. Kind of how Butterball (I think it’s them) has a help line on Thanksgiving for cooking turkeys. They made the news a few years ago by hiring men to work the phones because they learned that men cook more frequently now but feel uncomfortable asking women for advice. I had a good chuckle at that.
- 6y ago
- ComputerGuru 6y agoAWS has the same. If you treat it as an actual marketplace with individual images uploaded and licensed by their IP owners and not as “images of popular distros hosted by Microsoft” then it really does make sense. They’re not resellers, they’re just facilitating the marketplace.
- duxup 6y agoI remember when Docker had some bad images show up. There was much concern, but this isn't THAT different than any other marketplace. Gotta treat it that way.
- hrktb 6y ago> app stores We should praise Apple for not giving our identifying info to app developers.
- hn_throwaway_99 6y agoBut I think that these comments from the Twitter thread are very valid: > I belive you spun up the VM based on an image from the Azure Marketplace, specifically one from Ubuntu. That is not a microsoft image, you accepted an offer from Ubuntu and now they contact you to follow up. That's my understanding of the situation. Hopefully someone can clarify > Where exactly it is visible any ToS?! As soon as I clicked on "add new VM", the first option suggested was Ubuntu 18.04. I didn't dig into the Azure Marketplace. I just picked the first option available since I quickly need a linux-based test VM. I mean, I'm not as familiar with the AWS marketplace, but I use the GCP marketplace, and when I choose an offering from that marketplace it's very clear I'm just buying a prepackaged solution from another vendor, and I'd expect that other vendor gets my info. IMO this is very different from choosing the OS for your VM from a dropdown.
- btown 6y agoI think this is one of the points that the spirit of GDPR and similar legal frameworks gets right: users have the right to opt-in, without service being degraded if they don't, to data sharing unless that data sharing is "necessary" to fulfill the transaction (I believe this is the basis for "legitimate interest"). If I'm buying a SaaS or DBaaS from a vendor over a marketplace, or launching a metrics collector where phoning those metrics home is a core value prop, I'd be fine to be told that sharing information with the end operator, not just the marketplace, is necessary to fulfill the transaction. And there should be contracts in place to ensure my data's not used for unrelated purposes. If the operator breaches those contracts, the operator is liable. But in what possible way is "using a pre-packaged Linux distribution" a transaction where sharing information with the packager is "necessary?" I have no doubt that Microsoft's lawyers have covered their posteriors here. But the spirit of these regulations would be that users don't have the expectation that they're opting into Canonical getting their info just because they use a bog-standard Ubuntu distro. Users didn't knowingly consent to this. (EDIT: not a lawyer, not legal advice)
- aendruk 6y agoIn this case it's not obvious that you're participating in a "marketplace". Look at the screenshot of VM creation: https://twitter.com/LucaBongiorni/status/1359737285118410752 https://twitter.com/LucaBongiorni/status/1359737285118410752 If we accept that the Ubuntu image is a marketing device then this screen is using dark patterns.