6 ms·
Markets only exist within the context of a political system. They are just a tool to reach a certain policy outcome. The idea of using the free market to replac
by imtringued 6y ago
Markets only exist within the context of a political system.
They are just a tool to reach a certain policy outcome. The idea of using the free market to replace poor governance is laughable.
It's the opposite. You have to set the right policies and incentives and only then will the free market show its true beauty. Markets fail or succeed because of improper or proper governance.
It's like a genetic/ML algorithm that is optimizing for a cost function. If your cost function is awful your algorithm will be awful but that's not an argument in favor of getting rid of cost functions entirely.
- Spivak 6y agoThank you! Sure fine at some base level there is still technically market in a purely anarcho-capitalist system but that doesn't suddenly imply that the markets we have aren't essentially a pseudo-central planning systems that actually work. A market is useless if it doesn't actually allocate goods and labor efficiently and in the way people want.
- reedjosh 6y ago> Markets fail or succeed because of improper or proper governance. I have yet to see proper governance last long enough to be of any note and worse governance tends to quickly flip to favor the powerful.
- ajmurmann 6y agoHong Kong and Singapore might be great examples
- reedjosh 6y agoTBH, I'm ignorant of these countries' regulatory systems. You may be right. What makes them good examples?
- ardy42 6y agoThe latter is famously authoritarian capitalist, and the former just gutted its civil liberties? Also, IIRC, they both benefited from being trade gateways into the PRC economy, especially when it was more closed than it is now.
- ajmurmann 6y agoThis podcast will do a much better job at explaining how solid economic policy lead success in Hong Kong: http://www.econtalk.org/neil-monnery-on-hong-kong-and-the-architect-of-prosperity/ http://www.econtalk.org/neil-monnery-on-hong-kong-and-the-ar... Of course Hong Kong is now different, but that's not because the government changed its policies, but there is a different government in power. Singapore had the benefit of a trade port, but it kept importance as such and expanded into becoming a important financial center as well as punching well over its weight in terms of innovation. They have invested in education and provide a stable environment for business.
- reedjosh 6y agoI will review. Russ Roberts is pretty good. He leans closer to no governance than any. Still, Hong Kong being different now is because the powerful (China) changed the government to favor themselves. This is actually an example of government falling to powerful interests in short order. Singapore has as bad or worse of income inequality as the US, and I wouldn't say the US is well governed. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_income_equality https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_income_eq... Still, I don't want to take equality as a primary metric since I think inequality to some degree is natural. Singapore is however a infamously repressive regime as mentioned by ardy42
- __MatrixMan__ 6y agoSuppose you've got two political systems each vying for legitimacy. They each have their own currency, and their own set of policy outcomes. Is it so laughable that whichever one achieves the best results for its users will be the one to establish both market and political dominance? Is letting such a competition play out via the value of their respective currencies any better than traditional means of resolving this kind of conflict (i.e. war)? I'm not saying I have ultimate faith in the market to do the right thing--it frequently doesn't. But it sounds like you're saying that it can't. Granted, BTC's political system involves allocating power based on who can waste the most energy--so it's a pretty laughable alternative to existing governments--but in principle I don't see why markets can't mediate the rise and fall political systems in a way that roughly mirrors the way that political systems mediate the rise and fall of companies. There's that saying: - Those who make peaceful revolution impossible make violent revolution inevitable. It seems to me that collectively changing whose currency we use based on their capacity for sound governance is the kind of peaceful revolution that we ought to strive for.
- gbear605 6y agoA market doesn’t work in countries without a strong government, since for a market to work, there needs to be faith that the other party isn’t going to break the rules of the market. If you’re trying to sell your goods and someone comes in with a gun, then you have to hope that either you have a gun or can call police. If you have to resort to using a gun, then that leads to huge costs and lots of dead people.
- boogies 6y ago> If you have to resort to using a gun, then that leads to huge costs and lots of dead people. Is that more true for you using a gun than it is for police using a gun?
- gbear605 6y agoIf it’s you using a gun, you get Somalia. If it’s the police using a gun, you get the US. (If it’s the police using a baton, you get the UK). It works because the threat isn’t just physical harm but also social consequences. Even going back through history, there would be governmental consequences for not abiding by fair trade, whether that was the local lord throwing you in the stockades or the rest of your tribe ostracizing you.