33 ms·
Nouriel Roubini: Bitcoin is not a hedge against tail risk
- dsun180 6y agoThe value of everything is negative when you measure by these standards. We should stop laughing to emit less CO2.
- tspike 6y agoNo, but the way we measure value is so flawed that it can seem that way. Consider how we define poverty. Suppose we discover an as-yet unknown group of people who have been using traditional farming methods to sustain themselves in the same area for thousands of years. How would you classify them economically? Are they in "abject poverty", the same as a group whose traditional means of sustenance have been destroyed and who rely on international aid? What distinction do we make?
- Nasrudith 6y agoAs a very low but presumably stable level of income of course. Almost certainly would be abject poverty if they still had a small population after thousands of years along with presumambly genetic issues from isolation and a population size small enough to not be detected. That classification would be vwey correct despite having first world romanticized "sustainable farming" and "traditional means of sustance". They would still certainly lack things like modern medicine let alone other tools like "iron farm implements" that they would have very poor ability to purchase.
- tspike 6y agoI suppose the value judgment is between "very low but presumably stable income with small positive net worth" versus "very high but extremely unstable with massively negative net worth."
- darig 6y agoValue of Humanity is negative given environmental impact
- iso1631 6y agoBitcoin is a way of converting externalities into cash with no byproduct.
- Closi 6y agoI don’t think that’s fair, cash is easy to spend unlike bitcoin.
- darthrupert 6y agoHow do you spend cash farther than you can throw it?
- Closi 6y agoMaybe any of the established global banking and payment providers that allow me to pay for things online significantly quicker and with much lower fees than Bitcoin, without the huge cost to the environment? Or pigeon. Sorry I meant pigeon.
- iso1631 6y agoInternationally what's wrong with transferwise or paypal (for advanced economies that aren't still based on cash and checks)? Or western union? In most countries I know, in-country transfers from bank to bank are free.
- iso1631 6y agoYou generate externalities you don't pay the full price for (namely co2), others pay the price You take those generated bitcoins and sell them for cold hard cash You spend cash
- orky56 6y agoReally? I think bitcoin is a way of accelerating externalities and the byproduct is an arbitrary transfer of wealth obfuscated with the cover of decentralization and value. Mining does not accelerate the development of renewable energy but rather an exploitation of idle resources. P.S. I own crypto including Bitcoin.
- bustin 6y agoHow does someone measure the potential value of "being a pain in the ass to those who seek to control the supply of money"
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- SideburnsOfDoom 6y agoBeing a general pain in the ass is of negative utility. Define "controlled supply of money" with reference to counter-examples of uncontrolled money supply? Money supply needs limits, surely?
- bustin 6y agoI could have been more specific, you're right! I believe the value of cryptocurrency is to neuter governments' abilities to inflate or devalue currency with the push of a button, and to improve our ability to transact freely with one another. I absolutely agree with you that money needs limitations, such as hard rules on supply increases. A money supply that is uncontrolled in such a way that you can make more or less whenever you personally feel like it regardless of the other users' intentions won't be useful for very long. I personally think of cryptocurrency like a constitution but for money - whereas before whoever had the biggest guns could decree How It Is Now, the guns will be powerless to what is written down. In this way, it removes power of a select few to control the supply of money for their benefit. I don't know how this ends. Is it a net negative to the human experience? Anarchy? The select few who got into bitcoin early wielding all the power now? Taxation falling to the wayside and a deterioration of quality of life? Each of these is somewhat possible, but as someone who has 2nd hand experience of what a country can do when it has free reign to issue whole new currencies and remove old ones or devalue the existing one into oblivion, I don't really care. Let's ride this puppy and annoy some people. EDIT: some phrasing
- SideburnsOfDoom 6y ago> I believe the value of cryptocurrency is to neuter governments' abilities to inflate or devalue currency with the push of a button Central banking is necessary function of government. If government saw their ability to do it being actually "neutered" then it would get shut right down. I am not saying that it can't be mismanaged by a state, but you do not have anything better than state fiat money. > personally think of cryptocurrency like a constitution but for money (eyeroll) > Let's ride this puppy and annoy some people. You ride on. Ride off. Ride far away.
- RIMR 6y ago>The economics professor believes bitcoin is "not a unit of account," is "not a scalable means of payment," and is "not a stable store of value." Instead, he argues, it is a pump and dump scheme, where fear of missing out leads retail investors to speculate on an ever-increasing bubble. In literally no way is this guy wrong.
- zacharytelschow 6y agoOn point on all three. Bitcoin is definitely not currency.
- rybosworld 6y ago"The value of Bitcoin is negative if we applied a carbon tax to it" (paraphrased). Can't this be said about literally anything? Bitcoin and cryptos in general are actually worth more than $0 because people are tired of seeing their cash devalued on the whim of politicians and bankers.
- JumpCrisscross 6y ago> Can't this be said about literally anything? No. Carbon taxes would not make everything worthless.
- rybosworld 6y agoDeduce just a bit more, and see that I meant you can tax literally anything until it is worthless. I think you already knew what I meant but just wanted to nitpick.
- hn_throwaway_99 6y agoBut that is absolutely not the point, and it is not a nitpick. The real argument is that Bitcoin has negative value if you include externalities, and that is not the case for most assets.
- nicoburns 6y agoThe cost of releasing carbon into the atmosphere is there whether or not you price it into the market by use of a tax. Value is not limited to monetary value.
- lordnacho 6y agoIt's not a nitpick, he's referring to Pigovian Taxes. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pigovian_tax https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pigovian_tax It's obvious that you can tax anything by some amount to eat up the value. He means if you tax it according to the amount of unaccounted-by-the-market negative value, it comes out negative.
- narcissismo 6y agoGeez thats bad. What's the value of GM on that basis?
- gidam 6y agoIt does not seems very different than other trades made illegal/wrong because they make people rich at huge community costs: like destroying the nature and the planet. I am thinking about Ivory trade, or rare animals, or furs etc etc... But people are too busy to get rich to thing about the consequences.
- hanniabu 6y agoReads like a it piece only meant to slander bitcoin.
- knuthsat 6y agoThe environmental impact of Bitcoin, given it's current electricity usage is magnitudes less than what countries do with that same amount of electricity. Bitcoin is a non-issue. edit: http://www.withouthotair.com/ http://www.withouthotair.com/ I'm basing this argument on calculations from this book.
- PragmaticPulp 6y agoYou can make any number seem small if you compare it to something arbitrarily larger. That doesn’t make the original point invalid, though. Bitcoin’s energy usage is absolutely significant. In a world where we’re chasing a couple percent efficiency improvements here and there, it’s ridiculous that people are promoting a currency that literally incentivized people to perform wasteful computing operations on the scale of a medium sized country.
- knuthsat 6y agoThe world is irrational in doing 0.x% improvements on something with a small footprint. I'm waiting for a time where programmers will find it completely rational to optimize the fastest functions in their code. This whole environmental footprint of Bitcoin is absolutely meaningless. It's the most efficient and least destructive waste of energy imagined.
- icefrakker 6y ago"It's the most efficient and least destructive waste of energy imagined." Excepting political comments this is the dumbest thing I've read on HN.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- superflit 6y agoI use bitcoin. And to offset my energy expenditure I always activate the “ECO” function on my SUV. I recommend other do the same
- abraxas 6y agoBitcoin is a paperclip maximizer instantiation running on a hybrid human/machine topology.
- dnautics 6y agoso is capitalism, so is socialism, so is biology, etc...
- abraxas 6y agoNot at all. In the aggregate living organisms don't evolve to homogenize their output while vacuuming resources from more interesting pursuits. As for social/economic systems such as capitalism that's neither here nor there. Apples and oranges so to speak.
- dnautics 6y agoThere is an inherent bias in looking at paperclips like that. I'm sure that if you spend some time in the paperclip community you will find that they value their individuality; each paperclip has slightly different characteristics (one might be bent a few arcseconds more than the next one).
- rytill 6y agoWhat does socialism optimize for?
- djschnei 6y agoJust in, gold also worthless https://www.brilliantearth.com/gold-mining-environment/ https://www.brilliantearth.com/gold-mining-environment/
- guenthert 6y agoNonsense. Gold has many uses other then used as currency or for speculation.
- deeeeplearning 6y agoIf you account for the damage to the environment mining gold causes its value is actually negative
- guenthert 6y agoI don't think you appreciate the use of gold. For one, every chip is using it. Would we better off without semiconductors in exchange for a few less mercury ponds?
- deeeeplearning 6y agoYou keep missing the point.
- djschnei 6y agoI wonder if gold being useful in semiconductor design influenced the Greeks in adopting it as a currency. Maybe they just used it because it was portable, fungible, and scarce?
- mamon 6y agoNouriel Roubini has a well known hate for Bitcoin, which probably originates from the fact that it escapes his alleged "expertise": he hasn't foreseen its popularity, and rise in value. Now he hates it, because this past mistake threatens his status as financial guru, "Dr Doom". EDIT: I wouldn't take anything he says about it seriously, he's basically clueless on the topic. EDIT2: In free markets value of something, e.g. Bitcoin is not decided by some panel of experts, like professor Roubini, but by people buying and selling it. If people want to pay $45k for a Bitcoin then that's it's true value. Roubini's claims that "fundamental value of Bitcoin is zero" is riddiculous. Bitcoins are collectibles, same as, say, baseball cards, and baseball cards can go for some insane prices despite having zero practial usefullness.
- Ecstatify 6y agoDon’t agree with what he says let’s attack his intellect... “originates from the fact that it escapes his alleged ‘expertise’” “he’s basically clueless on the topic”
- mamon 6y agoHe says that bitcoin has "no intrinsic value" and he's wrong about that, because value of something is not decided by financial experts, but by people willing to pay for it (even if those people are criminals looking for new ways to launder their money). He has also been predicting that "Bitcoin bubble will burst" for the past few years, and he's been wrong about it so far. So yes, I would say he is clueless when it comes to Bitcoin.
- Ecstatify 6y agoFiat currencies have no intrinsic value so how is Bitcoin different? It crashed in 2018, it lost 65% of its value.
- jokethrowaway 6y agoBitcoin doesn't have a government and armies defending it. If tomorrow your government wakes up and make "dangerous cryptocurrencies" illegal because "criminals use them" they can do that. The reason Bitcoin value is skyrocketing is mainly speculation. People buy because they want to get rich and quit their crappy job. There is literally nothing that can't be replicated tomorrow and have the same technological characteristics of Bitcoin. Actually, other cryptocurrencies are even better. At some point, governments will have their digital cryptocurrencies to track you even better than with the current system.
- Geee 6y agoMost of bitcoin is mined with clean energy. Also, deflationary money is the best thing that can happen to environment. It's time to stop destroying savings in order to accelerate pointless consumption (and production).
- r00fus 6y ago> Most of bitcoin is mined with clean energy Do you have a cite for this?
- Geee 6y agoIt's just basic economics as renewables are the most profitable. Most of mining happens in China because the regime has overinvested in hydroelectricity and there's lots of unused capacity available. There's one study I found (not quite recent though): https://www.cryptoglobe.com/latest/2019/06/74-of-bitcoin-mining-is-powered-by-renewable-energy/ https://www.cryptoglobe.com/latest/2019/06/74-of-bitcoin-min...
- dumbfounder 6y agoThis article says by overall consumptions it's about 39%: https://www.finextra.com/newsarticle/36672/renewable-energy-not-as-prominent-in-cryptocurrency-mining-as-previously-claimed https://www.finextra.com/newsarticle/36672/renewable-energy-...
- coralreef 6y agoFunny trend: solar and wind power are now cheaper than coal. https://ourworldindata.org/uploads/2020/11/Price-of-electricity-new-renewables-vs-new-fossil.png https://ourworldindata.org/uploads/2020/11/Price-of-electric... Here's a hot take: Bitcoin subsidizes clean energy development. Miners buy cheap energy; clean energy infrastructure gets profitable return. Cost of development and manufacturing lowers further because of scale; pollution and externalities reduced; humanity wins. Bitcoin saves humanity?
- deeeeplearning 6y ago>Miners buy cheap energy; clean energy infrastructure gets profitable return. This true in China where most mining happens?
- meowkit 6y agoYes. China gets more of its energy from renewables than the US does. It is their fastest growing energy sector, and is a stated concern for economic and military security purposes. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Renewable_energy_in_China https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Renewable_energy_in_China
- coralreef 6y agoThe data I've seen is spotty at best; maybe 40% of mining in China occurs in Inner Mongolia and is based on coal? That said, lets take a first principles approach. - Miners want low cost energy. - Renewables are the lowest cost energy. - Miners are not restricted geographically (can mine anywhere cheap energy is, beam bits through satellite internet). - Cost curves of renewable energy look very promising. - Social trends and political trends look very promising. If you believe in efficient markets, then it should be obvious as to what the next 10 years of energy production (and Bitcoin mining) look like.
- creaturemachine 6y agoChina seems content in popping up dams wherever they please, no matter the human or ecological cost. https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2021/2/8/china-to-build-the-worlds-biggest-dam-on-sacred-tibetan-river https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2021/2/8/china-to-build-the-w...
- ad31mar 6y agoSo much anti-Bitcoin sentiment on HN lately, recycling decade old strawman arguments. Does the Occam's razor apply here? Are people just salty they didn't buy a few back when they first heard about it, now trying to justify themselves?
- hn_throwaway_99 6y agoI've seen this comment before, and honestly I think it's cheap. This article is about a clear, real problem with the current implementation of Bitcoin, namely that it requires enormous amounts of energy. I am not "anti-Bitcoin", I am anti a payment and financial storage protocol that requires gargantuan amounts of energy. So if you have a problem or comment on the article in question, please make it, we're all ears. But responding to valid criticisms of Bitcoin with hand-wavy "oh HN is so anti-Bitcoin" is not discussion, it's tribalism.
- emteycz 6y agoValid criticism is one thing, but this wave of criticism ignores so many basic facts about Bitcoin mining and energy generation/transportation/storage it's unbelievable. It also ignores the benefits, handwaving them away as if they didn't exist at all (it's all nice and easy for the firstworlders they can't even imagine there's a world without reliable banks, but there is!) while offering no alternative. Why would people use Bitcoin if there was a better alternative, isn't one of the arguments that it costs so much? Try to find out how much does it cost to transfer money to Ghana or Congo by other means and how reliable it is...
- hn_throwaway_99 6y agoTo be 100% clear, I believe your comment is exactly the type of valid counterargument I'm talking about, i.e. you bring up unique issues that Bitcoin solves, and point out that other monetary systems have high costs as well. Those are things one can have an honest debate about. That is very different than the "HN is so anti-Bitcoin bringing up decade old strawmen" comment I responded to. Perhaps most obviously by the fact that there are many in the crypto community itself that believe the energy usage of BTC is a real problem and are attempting to come up with viable alternatives like proof of stake.
- yladiz 6y agoI'm very conflicted about this. On one hand, I have a little bit of Bitcoin and am happy about some of the gains I've gotten (not life changing in any sense, but more than I expected). On the other hand I hesitated for a long time to buy any because I knew of the large environmental impact that its energy use has (yes, I really did avoid buying Bitcoin for a long time because I roughly knew of the environmental/energy costs). It's hard to reconcile these two positions in my mind, and part of me feels like this is a "tragedy of the commons" situation where it's fine if I have some because everyone else has some as well and I won't impact anything by _not_ having some. Curious what HNers think about this - is it bad to have Bitcoin in light of how bad the environmental impact is, especially with analysis about the taxes/cost/impact like this? Or is not participating really not reducing the impact of this in any meaningful way so you're kind of only losing if you don't?
- Taek 6y agoI'm of the mind that the government shouldn't be regulating how resources are used. It makes sense to me to regulate the manufacturing of resources - for example regulating pollution levels, dumping, etc. - but once you have a resource the market should decide how that resource should be put to use. If we've decided that we're happy producing X much electricity as a society using nuclear, wind, solar, coal, etc, we shouldn't get caught up on who ends up using that electricity or what they are willing to pay for it. If we think that the energy we are producing is harmful, we should regulate things at the production level. Ban power production that doesn't meet certain standards, put a cap on the total amount of coal burning per year, etc. And then let the market decide the best use for the energy that remains.
- PragmaticPulp 6y agoBitcoin is unique in that anyone with a power outlet and internet connection can plug hardware in and start converting energy to Bitcoin. Bitcoin mining was a problem in college dorms for a while because students used their “free” electricity and cooling to pay for new video cards. Many landlords had to abandon “utilities included” rents when they were hit with the first $500 electric bill. IT administrators have stories of catching people trying to hide mining equipment in closets or under their desks. But coiners are trying to get ahead of the narrative by planting articles about how mining is actually powered by hydro dams in Mongolia. Not only is this not true, but it would be quite a problem if the mining had become so massively centralized.
- onelastjob 6y agoNano completely solves this. Under 1 second transactions fully confirmed, no mining, no inflation, it's decentralized (and getting more so). All the coins were premined. It uses a block lattice rather than a blockchain, so it is scalable (the main net is doing 185 transactions per second now (1776 tps on the test net). The system to determine voting power (regarding confirming transactions) is basically a liquid democracy where you can delegate your voting power (based on how many coins you own) to a different representative at any time. It leaves Bitcoin in the dust and is an incredibly elegant cryptocurrency that will be the future of microtransactions online as well as an actual usable cryptocurrency. nano.org
- quattrofan 6y agoIf I had a dollar for every alt coin...lol
- ad31mar 6y agoStop shilling your shitcoin.
- onelastjob 6y agoI meant to post this in a thread about Bitcoin energy consumption, but it looks like I posted it under the wrong thread. Anyways, Nano is still a better version of Bitcoin.
- abecedarius 6y agoYou can be in favor of both Bitcoin and a steep carbon tax. The latter would not hurt the former except maybe transiently.
- rawtxapp 6y ago100% agree, there should be a carbon tax on everything that pollutes the environment.
- LatteLazy 6y agoWhat about the value of gold or diamond mining?
- traveler01 6y agoAnti crypto sentiment by the mainstream media. So expected...
- dang 6y agoUrl changed from https://markets.businessinsider.com/currencies/news/bitcoin-value-negative-environmental-impact-nouriel-roubini-cryptocurrencies-2021-2-1030067687 https://markets.businessinsider.com/currencies/news/bitcoin-..., which is based on this but doesn't (?) link to it.
- neonate 6y agohttps://archive.is/LmseS https://archive.is/LmseS
- esotericn 6y agoFossil fuels are negative. Ecosystem destruction is negative. Using energy is not negative. Focus on the problem. Bitcoin could disappear tomorrow and we'd still be fucked unless we address the real issue.
- fat_pikachu 6y agoThe logic is wrong here. Assuming bitcoin is a deflationary asset I.e. constantly goes up, the value of any bitcoin will be worth more than the energy used to mine it. For example, mining the first bitcoin didn’t create $50K in carbon costs.
- simonebrunozzi 6y ago> Since the fundamental value of bitcoin is zero and would be negative if a proper carbon tax was applied to its massive polluting energy-hogging production, I predict that the current bubble will eventually end in another bust. Since the fundamental value of a piece of paper with dead presidents printed on it is also zero, and would be negative if a proper carbon tax was applied to its massive polluting military, I predict that the current bubble will eventually end in another bust.