6 ms·
Forcing Foreign Money Out Is Academic’s Fix for Canadian Housing
- api 6y agoForeign ownership of property should be heavily taxed both at the transaction and in the form of an elevated property tax bracket for non-resident owners. In urban areas with cost of living problems, non-resident should probably be defined as someone not residing in the city or any corporation with >50% beneficial ownership not residing in the city. Otherwise non-resident could be defined as non-citizen. I coined a term for this and similar things: "fiscal pollution." Fiscal pollution is essentially harmful investment or investment with strong negative externalities.
- Mediterraneo10 6y agoI would imagine that a lot of foreign-owned property in Canada is owned by foreigners that already have obtained permanent residency, or who are using relatives who have obtained permanent residency. Consequently, they may be treated no differently than any other Canadian. So, would simply “taxing foreigners” really be an effective solution?
- foldr 6y ago> Otherwise non-resident could be defined as non-citizen. I don’t think this would work well in a lot of cities. For example in London there are any number of non-citizens who are just as much resident in the city as anyone else. You’d be saying that e.g a French citizen who’d lived in London for 10 years was a non-resident.
- api 6y agoThose homes are owner occupied though. I am talking about absentee foreign ownership, which is mostly about parking money and money laundering.
- foldr 6y agoI still don't see how that makes quite the right cut. For example, I live in London any my landlord is German. She lives in London too. I can't see any reason why she should be treated differently to a UK citizen in the same position.
- 908B64B197 6y ago> non-resident should probably be defined as someone not residing in the city or any corporation with >50% beneficial ownership not residing in the city. Some places already have that distinction for capital gains. You get a different tax percentage on the capital gain resulting from the sale of your "main residence" (where you spend the majority of your time) vs any secondary or investment properties you might have. But that doesn't change property taxes.
- mywittyname 6y agoWhy not institute policies to build more housing units? Taxation should be used to manipulate prices downward only when other market options don't exist. The government could finance the construction of new houses. They could even go so far as incentivize the construction of entirely new suburbs or towns outside of major cities like Vancouver and build ultra-fast trains to connect the commercial district of the major city to the new suburb that is being built with affordable housing in mind. Trying to halt foreign investment is a fool's errand. There is too much money to be made from these people, giving a strong financial incentive to find legal ways to subvert the taxes/regulations put in place.
- jmpman 6y agoI’ve wondered why California doesn’t leverage Prop 13 to encourage more housing units. Say for any property which isn’t owner occupied, the number of rentable units must increase by N per year in order to maintain Prop 13 tax lock. Seems like very quickly we would have landlords fighting cities to expand their rentable units, expending much more money than they otherwise would in order to expand the rental stock.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- toomuchtodo 6y agoBecause there is more money than land. More realistic to push the foreign money out. If loopholes are discovered, tighten regulations further. Many countries restrict foreign real estate investment without issue (Mexico and Thailand come to mind, but there are many others).
- mywittyname 6y agoCanada seems like it has plenty of land left to build on. None of their major cities come close to the size of US cities like Dallas-Fort Worth or Chicago. Any attempts to limit the inflow of Chinese investment will fail. And the more aggressive the government gets, the more Canadians are going to get caught up in it by accident. Chinese people are willing to pay massive premiums for houses and high property taxes, all while not utilizing any of the services those taxes are paying for. Canada would be wise to start incentivizing construction in out-of-the-way places specifically to accommodate these investors. Otherwise, these foreign investors will use their extensive capital to find legal loopholes and will continue to focus on "safer" bets (read: Vancouver housing). It's exactly like the problem with DRM: being aggressive just hurts legitimate consumers because hackers will always find a loophole in the system. So the best course of action is to give customers exactly what they want with minimal friction. Funny that you bring up Mexico because Mexico's system is similar to what I'm proposing: special economic zones and other incentives that ensure that foreign investment flows where the government wants it to.
- nine_zeros 6y agoCanada is receiving so much money for investment because it is perceived as the most stable country in the Americas. But Canada just doesn't have enough assets to soak all that money up. So that money chases the few assets such as residential property stock. Canada could legally allow all this money to be invested in startups or companies that need funding instead of passive assets. That way, the same money would be funneled to actual companies and workers, while at the same time, providing assets to all this foreign money. Do it before America figures this out.
- 908B64B197 6y ago> Canada is receiving so much money for investment because it is perceived as the most stable country in the Americas. Because it's the easiest to get a passport from. US immigration is far more selective.
- 908B64B197 6y agoThe root of the housing bubble lies in Canada's out of control immigration quotas. This creates an enormous downward pressure for wages which makes housing impossible to afford. The lax immigration system also allows for unparalleled amounts of capital to flow into the country and be parked into assets that are hard to seize (real estate being the prime example). Now, with rampant birth tourism and convenience passports, it's a little pointless to go after foreign ownership: The foreign buyer will simply transfer the properties to his kids who acquired convenience passport via birth tourism and live in the city. If forced to give up assets or freedom in their original country, the real buyer will simply be allowed to immigrate thanks to the family reunification loophole. Of course, the current government has no interest in stopping it as it's making real estate developers extremely happy and more importantly, gives them a new pool of voters that are sure to keep on voting for ever increasing immigration quotas. The situation is much better in the US where immigration quotas are kept under control.
- foolmeonce 6y agoSimply eradicate the silly income taxes and use traditional real estate tax, energy taxes, road tax, sales tax, and other waste taxes. The problem is that countries that messed up their tax system during a war aren't going to revert them so they are forever dealing with the market results of taxing income instead of taxing resource usage. Why shouldn't you buy and hold important resources if the society isn't making those resources fund the system? Having these free gifts for whoever had money seemed very clever back when the rich people from a system didn't have to let foreign rich people have the same access to their plunder.
- toomuchtodo 6y agoEradication of the income tax is highly regressive and creates outsized power and control for those who accumulate excessive amounts of capital.
- jkinudsjknds 6y agoI mean it depends on what you replace it with. Sales tax on basic necessities is regressive. Real estate tax, not so much. Capital gains tax definitely not.
- sunstone 6y agoThe cost of housing in Canada is, ironically, in the land. Land is something that Canada has quite a lot of. In Australia foreigner buyers are only allowed to buy newly build homes, that might work here too.