9 ms·
Exactly. Here's VC and prominent cryptocurrency enthusiast Fred Wilson saying exactly that: https://avc.com/2017/08/store-of-value-vs-payment-system/ https://av
by wpietri 6y ago
Exactly. Here's VC and prominent cryptocurrency enthusiast Fred Wilson saying exactly that: https://avc.com/2017/08/store-of-value-vs-payment-system/ https://avc.com/2017/08/store-of-value-vs-payment-system/
While I agree with him that Bitcoin is a terrible currency, I think the "store of value" thing is nonsense as well. Stores of value need to have relatively stable value. Bitcoin is hugely volatile. That's great for speculation, but nobody with any sense would use it as the equivalent of a savings account.
- mj4m1n 6y agoWhen in doubt, zoom out. On larger timescales, this isn't really that much of an issue. Volatility is also trending downwards. The bigger it gets, the more stable it becomes.
- MereInterest 6y agoYou're appealing to future data that are not available yet. Bitcoin has never been stable in its existence. You are positing without evidence that it will become stable in the future.
- _alex_ 6y agoMany assets start volatile and become more stable over time. As more money comes into bitcoin and the market cap goes up, it's reasonable to assume that volatility will go down.
- mcosta 6y agoMany assets start volatile and end up in a stable 0.
- mj4m1n 6y agohttps://charts.woobull.com/bitcoin-volatility/ https://charts.woobull.com/bitcoin-volatility/
- beefield 6y ago> The bigger it gets, the more stable it becomes. To be clear, there is no mechanism, logic or reason (at least revealed to me) why this would be true. Vice versa, increased amount of trading typically increases volatility.
- jakupovic 6y agoIf more powerful actors are owners they will not need to sell upon volatility hence providing more stability.
- mj4m1n 6y agoYes, Microstrategy or Tesla have no interest in daytrading.
- beefield 6y agoI am not sure I follow the logic. Bitcoin becomes "bigger" when there are more big actors not using it but just hoarding it? And thus less volatile - until one of these big actors decide to dump their holdings to the thin market used to trade only scraps left from these big actors... Sorry, not convincing.
- mj4m1n 6y agoThe idea is that bitcoin is something you prefer over fiat currency in your bank account. The same idea that gold bugs have. If that's the case, then bitcoin owners will only dump their holdings if a) they fear that the bitcoin network is about to collapse for some reason or b) they need to put the value stored in those bitcoins to use.
- krona 6y agoincreased amount of trading typically increases volatility. Define amount. If you mean number of trades, then the effect is decreased standard deviation if the average trade is smaller as a percentage of total market capitalisation. That seems completely logical. See: pretty much every study in to HFT.
- koheripbal 6y agoBusinesses don't operate on a "zoomed out" timeline. Volatility in the short term causes cashflow driven liquidity bankruptcy.
- joshxyz 6y agoIt's volatile because it is exposed to a fuckton of markets, but 1btc will always be 1btc.
- lxgr 6y agoThat's not how measuring the "store of value" quality works at all. For example, inflation of a given currency is measured using a basket of goods and services, not other currencies.
- perpetualpatzer 6y agoThis could be said of any economic good. "1 Tulip bulb will always be 1 tulip bulb. It's just that people but them with a bunch of different currencies and all the other currencies have been really volatile relative to tulips (though not relative to one another)."
- gruez 6y ago>Bitcoin is hugely volatile. That's great for speculation, but nobody with any sense would use it as the equivalent of a savings account. Consider the classic store of value asset: gold. It's up 17% compared to a year ago, and down 11% compared to its peak last august. Sure, it's less volatile as bitcoin, but it's hugely more volatile compared to t-bills or a FDIC insured bank account. Does that mean gold also isn't a good store of value?
- iexplainbtc 6y agoCreated an account just to say this but you beat me to it.
- alistairSH 6y agoYes, that's exactly what it means. Very few people actually use gold as a value store - they put their savings in various USD-based (or Euro, etc) savings vessels - money market, CDs, etc. Gold is generally considered a last resort for the case where the US completely falls apart. But if that happens, I'm not sure gold is going to be much use - the global economy will be screwed enough that everybody suffers, gold or no gold.
- robotbikes 6y agoIf civilization collapses then I'm pretty sure bitcoins would be worthless as the whole mining chain collapses. I guess it is a good store of value in the more cyberpunk dystopia where large corporations continue to grow in influence and power and it is used to funnel funds for the shadow economy. I mean it is valuable because people with money are convinced it is valuable and that whole feedback loop.
- JumpCrisscross 6y ago> If civilization collapses then I'm pretty sure bitcoins would be worthless If all civilisations collapse, yes. But if your civilisation collapses, a neutral store of value is easier to own than e.g. a portfolio of foreign bonds in a handful of offshore accounts.
- iforgetti 6y agoWhat incentive will there be for the community to continue verifying transactions after all the bitcoins are mined? Is it just that the system of storage will have Ongoing operational cost like a vault has ongoing costs to protect gold? Has anyone modeled what these costs might look like?
- riffraff 6y agothere's still a fee for just verifying transactions.
- veesahni 6y agoI suspect transaction costs will rise when that's the only gain
- gorbypark 6y agoCurrently, miners get the block reward plus transaction fees. Miners get to pick which transactions to include in the blocks they are processing, so of course they only include the ones with highest fees. Once there is no more block rewards, they would would have to survive off transaction fees alone.
- boh 6y agoIf the economics of verifying transactions is no longer sustainable, the code will be updated to allow more mining. That's something no one wants to admit, but the SegWit soft fork confirmed the influence concentrated miners have on development. The idea that somehow Bitcoin just works outside of any social influence is a complete fallacy.
- lallysingh 6y agoWhat competes with these stores of value? As a high-risk-high-return investment, it makes a lot of sense. I'd count it in the same category as artwork as an investment.
- toyg 6y agoThe counter-counter-argument is that it's volatile because it's still in its infancy. Gold used to be that volatile too, when wars were commonplace and new sources were found quite often. It can still swing significantly. I've come around to the idea. I don't hold any bitcoin anymore, and the best chance to get rich is gone, but I can see a future where something digital (hence fundamentally ethereal) acts as dense and largely unregulated store of value, for the people who need it. In the same way the drug trade currently uses artworks and commodities when it needs to move value across national boundaries, they can use hashes or something like that. Transaction costs to convert those from/to cash are actually higher and slower than bitcoin will likely ever be (i.e. a week or two, and several hundrend USDs, will still be acceptable). We'll never pay taxes or coffees with bitcoin, or hold savings accounts, but it will still act as a commodity.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- sharedfrog 6y ago> the best chance to get rich is gone The second best time to plant a tree is today.
- ncallaway 6y agoYes, but not always true with investments. Such a strategy is dangerous when you're looking at a Ponzi scheme, or a pump and dump, or anything else that is designed to leave the late entrants as the bag holders. I'm not saying that's what Bitcoin is, just that it's dangerous to be a late entrant to an investment and you should be more wary
- lawn 6y ago> The counter-counter-argument is that it's volatile because it's still in its infancy. So you're saying that Bitcoin isn't a store of value, but you speculate that it will be in the future.
- toyg 6y ago
- Taek 6y agoBitcoin makes sense as a store of value because it is likely to survive dramatic global economic failure. The short term volatility is higher, but it's counter-correlated with almost everything else and is a great hedge against societal collapse. Perhaps not the most fun thing to hedge against, but just like buying life insurance it's a good idea.
- robjan 6y agoBitcoin is not counter-correlated. When the stock market corrected last year, bitcoin also crashed.
- hntrader 6y agoThat's only because of fund degrossing. The idea that it's a safe haven for a near-world ending event (but not so disastrous as to wipe out all miners), is still valid
- wpietri 6y agoYour theory is that a digital currency relying on a delicate, sophisticated international network and an even more delicate technology supply chain, plus massive amounts of wasteful energy consumption will do well in "dramatic global economic failure"? I think "likely" is doing an awful lot of work there.
- Taek 6y agoBitcoin only produces about 100 kilobytes of new data every minute, and only the consensus builders (the miners) need to have any sort of real time access to that data stream. Participants can have latencies of days or even months and still be able to correctly build consensus. In extreme meltdown scenarios, you can broadcast Bitcoin over FM radio, the data rates are literally low enough. Spending bitcoin requires sending _hundreds_ of bytes, which again is small enough that you can drop down to very robust and simple technologies if you need to. Bitcoin has no "wasteful energy requirement". It adjusts the amount of hashing you need to do based on the amount of competition that's doing hashing. If 80% of the hashrate suddenly disappears, Bitcoin runs slowly for a couple of weeks and then significantly drops the hashrate requirements for the network to progress. For efficiency, many Bitcoin mining farms are established within a couple hundred meters of the power plants producing the electricity, which means that Bitcoin also generally has minimal dependence on the global electricity grid, even though it consumes an enormous amount of electricity. Bitcoin's robustness to societal meltdowns is one of the things that makes it really interesting.
- undefined1 6y agoit's volatile because it's still in price discovery mode. also, volatility only matters if you sell it. if you're holding as a store of value, then you've done extremely well over the long term.