6 ms·
I think what we're learning from many debacles on YouTube, Amazon, and Google is this: Algorithms are not even close to substituting for human customer service
by smt88 6y ago
I think what we're learning from many debacles on YouTube, Amazon, and Google is this:
Algorithms are not even close to substituting for human customer service, human moderation, and human judgment.
Maybe this means web-scale sites like Amazon's marketplace aren't viable. I'm fine with that implication. Stores like Target and Walmart seem to have the same prices with human-curated inventories, and I don't really miss the millions of extra products Amazon has.
- melomal 6y ago> Stores like Target and Walmart seem to have the same prices with human-curated inventories, and I don't really miss the millions of extra products Amazon has. I'm sure most people are generally happy to wait 2 days for something to arrive as well. Honestly, it almost feels like Amazon is trying to become an Alibaba and potentially look to take them on with the level of product quality that is now available there.
- BoorishBears 6y agoAmazon practically is Alibaba at this point, or Aliexpress really. Half the results on any given product I search point straight back to Alibaba if I image search. Sometimes I check if Aliexpress has it too, and if I'm not in a hurry I get it there for a huge savings.
- maccard 6y agoWith two major differences - 1-2 day delivery (vs 1-2 week) and an almost guaranteed no-questions-asked returns policy (Ive never, in 15 years of using amazon, been denied a refund) They combination is what differentiates them
- lrem 6y agoI've ordered non-prime items on the local Amazon, where I'd first receive a "sorry, this is taking longer than expected, please hang with us" and then the package would come _way_ later straight from China.
- maccard 6y agoThat sucks - I'm in the UK so my experience might be different, but with the exception of something going wrong with delivery (Which I'd estimate is ~5-10% of the time, but that's not exclusive to Amazon), packages are here within 48 hours.
- melomal 6y agoExactly, it's a shit pit of affiliate marketers pumping anything for that <2% referral fee they get. As a side hustle they probably drop ship everything they are selling via Amazon affiliate links too.
- trabant00 6y agoAn important point to make imo is that algorithms will not be close to human decision making until we hit AGI. No matter how complex they get until that point you can always cheat them in absolutely ridiculous and more importantly reproducible ways. Meaning scams scale and can do way more damage than a human error. > Maybe this means web-scale sites like Amazon's marketplace aren't viable. I'm fine with that implication. Stores like Target and Walmart seem to have the same prices with human-curated inventories Not only are they viable, they are hugely more profitable without the human expenses. This inhuman model - yes, I think that is exactly what it is - will displace everything else that simply can't compete in runaway capitalism.
- mlyle 6y agoIn a non-dystopian world, though, the algorithms can make life way better. We could have filters that catch more scams and abuse than typical humans do... and then reasonable humans behind that are responsive and fix the carnage for where they go wrong. Of course, that's not what we've got...
- ivan_gammel 6y agoIt doesn’t have to displace everything else, it simply has to be regulated by law. A landlord cannot come to your physical store and remove few products. The same logic must apply here, with the platform providing sufficient means for interaction with local authorities in place of registration of the business.
- zimpenfish 6y ago> you can always cheat them in absolutely ridiculous and more importantly reproducible ways Given that's possible with human moderation too (cf tax codes), what makes you think AGI will solve the problem?
- imtringued 6y ago>Not only are they viable, they are hugely more profitable without the human expenses. I don't believe this. The reputation loss alone will cost you a lot of potential money. Stadia is basically dead because the Google brand is completely untrustworthy. B2B customers want to avoid Google as much as possible because it's just a liability that threatens to ruin their business.
- karmasimida 6y ago> Maybe this means web-scale sites like Amazon's marketplace aren't viable But the market is driving more and more money/resources to those companies/services. Let alone Amazon/Youtube/Google are very different businesses, you can say Google has non-existent customer support, but at least for consumers, so far my experience with Amazon is more positive than negative.
- smt88 6y ago> my experience with Amazon is more positive than negative I don't dispute that. But a lot of other people have issues with dropshippers, fake products, radioactive products[1], unreliable reviews, etc. When I stopped using Amazon, I realized I was returning ~90% of all my purchases just because the product was fake, described wrong, low quality, or just not durable enough to last even a month. Yes, it's great to be able to return things, but it's a lot nicer to feel reasonably confident that the person who sold a product to me actually believes it's a good fit for what I want as a consumer. 1. https://www.japantimes.co.jp/news/2017/09/20/business/nuclear-watchdog-orders-amazon-halt-sales-product-containing-radioactive-materials/ https://www.japantimes.co.jp/news/2017/09/20/business/nuclea...
- fxtentacle 6y agoThe cynic in me says that you have identified why big tech companies spend so much money funding GPT and similar research: Soon, your appeal will be replied to by an AI, too. That way, most people will have the impression that they were reconsidered by a human and found in fault, which will likely make a large percentage of them give up. We're stonewalling real humans by building fake humans :( And that means GPT could possibly reduce support costs for Amazon.
- smt88 6y ago> The cynic in me says that you have identified why big tech companies spend so much money funding GPT and similar research I don't think this is cynical. It's discussed openly. They want to provide the tools to enable all companies to automate customer service, which is where Facebook's big chatbot push came from.
- agilob 6y ago>Algorithms are not even close to substituting for human customer service, human moderation, and human judgment. And that's by design. They don't want to talk to you and help you. You're going to buy there anyway and we all know it.
- playcache 6y agoThis is where I chuckle at people talking about AI becoming software engineers and the like.
- soco 6y agoSome companies would be happy to pay that AI to develop their b$ software, because once in a position to abuse you customers, why not abuse them with less costs.
- 1_player 6y agoApparently AI gives companies an excuse to avoid dealing with false positives. If your human support team made a mistake, there was an appeal process. If your AI makes a mistake, sorry, bad robot, deal with it.
- jjcon 6y agoAI won’t be replacing software engineers anytime soon but something to keep in mind: While people talk up Googles ai (at least they once did) the truth is while they may put out some good research now and again most of the stuff they deploy is crap by design - they can’t afford to spend a dollar per day per customer to run a complex algorithm on your data, they can only spend fractions of a penny. This severely limits the quality of the ai deployed by large consumer oriented megacorps. On the other hand you look at some of the ai being deployed in the b2b space or anywhere there is a real exchange of money and you’ll see some pretty expensive and interesting ai research and deployments.
- smt88 6y agoSoftware jobs are being automated away, but not by AI. If you think about it, any time-saving library, service, or tool is going to reduce headcount at an efficient organization. For example, I currently have a company that I technically manage. It has one employee who does maintenance on the infrastructure (AWS Elastic Beanstalk), database (AWS RDS), and code for five different products. The only other people who touch the code are security auditors. That just wasn't possible 10 years ago. Managing servers alone for those products (~50 EC2 instances, ~10 load balancers, 10 database instances) would've been a full-time job.
- onion2k 6y agoAlgorithms are not even close to substituting for human customer service, human moderation, and human judgment. Algorithms are human judgement. In a strict code sense an algorithm is a way of encoding a set of assumptions that you decide on when you're developing the code to run it. Even in unsupervised machine learning an algorithm is the result of human judgement because someone decided to delegate the decision making process to a machine. Every time a computer makes a judgement call there is a human who is responsible, and should be accountable, for that process existing.
- smt88 6y agoI think you're making a semantic argument that redefines "human judgment" to such a broad definition that this entire discussion becomes meaningless. To pull it back a bit, "human judgment" in my usage meant "input processed by human using a brain" and algorithm meant "input processed by machine". Given those premises, the argument that "algorithms are human judgment" is untrue both by definition and by observation. For example, when I ask Google/Siri/Alexa a question like, "What is the best way to set up my router?", I will get a wildly different answer than if I ask a GeekSquad employee.
- prepend 6y agoComcast has lots of humans and they suck worse than Google. I don’t think the answer is humans or algorithms, the answer is organizations incentivized to solve customer problems. Google doesn’t care about customers, if they did, they would fix this. Customers are locked in because where else will you go. Just like Comcast doesn’t care because there’s only one cable company, Google doesn’t really have any AdWords or Adsense competition. I think the solution is more competition so use ddg. Once customers have mobility, Google will work to retain them.
- zouhair 6y agoAlternatively: regulations. Force them to care.
- washadjeffmad 6y agoLook, it's not fascism if they went to college and pay your salary. And even if it is fascism, they're in the Cabinet now, so technically that makes them the government, doesn't it? -Someone, somewhere in SV
- smt88 6y ago> Comcast has lots of humans and they suck worse than Google. It's harder to step on a landmine with Google, but Google's landmine is far more devastating. We've already seen lots of news stories about algorithms shutting down people's Gmail accounts, developer accounts, YouTube channels, etc. I personally went through 6 months of hell when my brother's Gmail account was locked due to "inauthentic behavior". He had become disabled and unable to log in, and when I logged in from my machine, Google's algorithm flagged it. I went through an infuriating loop of trying to unlock it and hitting the same algorithm. There was no number to call. I would've paid $10,000 to get back into that account, which would've required 10 min with a customer support rep. I tweeted at Google and they told me I had to log in to Twitter with his account in order to get help (obviously impossible for me). It was the most angry I have ever been at any company. It locked me out of important medical documents, family messages, social media -- everything. I finally fixed it by asking a friend who was a marketing exec at Google to help. He said there's an internal form you can use for this situation -- only available to Google employees. Other people have had similar experiences and had livelihoods destroyed. Whatever you think about Comcast, they will never ignore you and let your entire digital life get locked away without any kind of recourse.
- rsanek 6y agoHuman-curated? Both Walmart and Target have unfortunately switched over to the same online seller marketplace business model that Amazon has. The introduction of this on Target is fairly new, but soon I believe Amazon sellers will be going multichannel and searches for products on any of those sites will return pages and pages of white-label crap.
- smt88 6y ago> Human-curated? Both Walmart and Target have unfortunately switched over to the same online seller marketplace business model that Amazon has. On both of those sites, you can change the filter to show only products that are available in stores. Those in-store products still have whatever guarantees they did 20 years ago (selected by a human working for Target, probably going to be pulled off shelves if they result in too many returns).
- zouhair 6y agoI didn't buy anything from amazon since around 2004/5 (not sure exactly but that's close enough)and I still don't feel the need to now.
- aidenn0 6y agoI guess they don't have to. Cell phones and IP phones have terrible voice quality compared to a land-line; median quality is far worse than the worst long-distance connection I ever got in the 90s. People use them because they are cheap and convenient though. It's the same with algorithms. If you charge margins high enough for good customer service you will get out-competed by those that don't on price.
- joshspankit 6y agoI would also like to take this opportunity to remind people of the traumatizing videos that algorithms allowed in YouTube Kids. They may be great for 80% or even 99.9%, but they cannot be 100%.