8 ms·
The Great Gatsby: Misunderstood Novel
- ARandomerDude 6y agoAlso the world's most boring novel.
- northwest65 6y agoGive The Lord of the Rings a whirl...
- ttz 6y agoNothing misunderstood. IMO it's just a mediocre book with overemphasis on hiding middling meaning in prose. A story that speaks many words but says little.
- omosubi 6y agowhich novels are better?
- leephillips 6y agoSo, so, many. Moby Dick; The Scarlet Letter; Lolita; Ulysses; Et Tu, Babe; Lexicon; Malone Dies;....
- gverrilla 6y agoulysses - you gotta be kiding. did you read that?
- leephillips 6y agoTwice, and I dip into it now and then and read a chapter. It’s one of my favorites.
- gverrilla 6y agoI think Joyce was great, and I have a lot of respect for what he's done on his work regarding form, but I tried really hard and it was unbearable to keep on reading Ulysses - I got past half, but had to abandon - and this is coming from someone really used to 'hard' reads.
- QuesnayJr 6y agoI think the conceit (the different styles for different chapters) sometimes overwhelms the book, but it has a lot of highlights, like the opening and closing chapters. I think of this quote often: History, Stephen said, is a nightmare from which I am trying to awake.
- dan_hawkins 6y agoUlysses is Irish though.
- leephillips 6y agoSo is Malone Dies; maybe I misinterpreted the question, if it was asking only about American novels.
- happyconcepts 6y agoBrothers Karamazov by Fyodor Dostoevsky struck me as a better novel. But it's almost 1000 pages.
- alwaysanon 6y agoI really rate Jack London as the great American novelist. I like the lessor known Sea Wolf the best of his but White Fang and The Call of the Wild really capture a sense of adventure and the history and vibe of that period of American expansion into the West.
- deepsun 6y agoInterestingly, Jack London saw writing as purely commercial activity. He preferred to buy plots, or "take the idea" (hence lots of plagiarism accusations) to inventing.
- ReptileMan 6y agoI would say that from what is considered Great American Classics only catch 22 is actually good.
- tjalfi 6y agoThere's always The Master and Margarita by Mikhail Bulgakov.
- kinghtown 6y agoNo, it’s an excellent novel. I do think it’s a little overrated, but mediocre would be a silly take on it. It’s highly regarded for a reason. For sure there are greater American novels..
- leephillips 6y agoAn opinion that differs from yours is not, thereby, silly. I also find it mediocre. A bit of a bore overall, the prose unremarkable.
- kinghtown 6y agoWe all harbour silly opinions.
- dang 6y ago"Please don't post shallow dismissals, especially of other people's work. A good critical comment teaches us something." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- pseudolus 6y agoWhat's particularly interesting, and was unknown to me, was that 'The Great Gatsby' was not an immediate success. I was similarly surprised when I read that 'Moby Dick' had an initial print run of 500 copies and that only 3215 copies were sold during Melville's lifetime [0]. I guess authors get second chances. [0] https://www.biblio.com/moby-dick-by-melville-herman/work/5502 https://www.biblio.com/moby-dick-by-melville-herman/work/550...
- the_snooze 6y agoMoby Dick probably would have sold more early on if it weren't interleaved with chapters from a whaling ship operating handbook.
- josephorjoe 6y agolol. but the third time you read Moby Dick those are the best parts. loose fish vs fast fish is top of the line 19th century humor. i admit i was bored to tears by those sections on the first read. honestly i think it just isn’t a great read for people in their teens/20s as the world weariness, fatalism, and obsession with an imperfect understanding of an obscure expertise is something better appreciated as one ages.
- allturtles 6y agoThere are so many great parts to Moby Dick. It has a reputation for tedium, so I was surprised the first time I read it at how much humor is in it, often mingled with deep insight, e.g.: > Though amid all the smoking horror and diabolism of a sea-fight, sharks will be seen longingly gazing up to the ship’s decks, like hungry dogs round a table where red meat is being carved, ready to bolt down every killed man that is tossed to them; and though, while the valiant butchers over the deck-table are thus cannibally carving each other’s live meat with carving-knives all gilded and tasselled, the sharks, also, with their jewel-hilted mouths, are quarrelsomely carving away under the table at the dead meat; and though, were you to turn the whole affair upside down, it would still be pretty much the same thing, that is to say, a shocking sharkish business enough for all parties; and though sharks also are the invariable outriders of all slave ships crossing the Atlantic, systematically trotting alongside, to be handy in case a parcel is to be carried anywhere, or a dead slave to be decently buried; and though one or two other like instances might be set down, touching the set terms, places, and occasions, when sharks do most socially congregate, and most hilariously feast; yet is there no conceivable time or occasion when you will find them in such countless numbers, and in gayer or more jovial spirits, than around a dead sperm whale, moored by night to a whaleship at sea. If you have never seen that sight, then suspend your decision about the propriety of devil-worship, and the expediency of conciliating the devil.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- kylegill 6y agoI agree with what the article mentions, and think the concept of the Great American Novel [0] gives the Great Gatsby wings and leads to it being more _popular_ than it perhaps is _understood_. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_American_Novel https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_American_Novel
- GizmoSwan 6y agoI have seen several versions of it in the movies which were easier to interpret than the novel. Few months ago, I even saw a Korean version called The Burning on netflix!
- dondawest 6y agoThat movie was based on the Haruki Murakami short story “Barn Burning,” though it did reference Gatsby directly in the dialogue
- GizmoSwan 6y agoYes it did mention the Gatsby. The author was obviously interpreting the psycho-thriller angle by design. The privileged versus unprivileged; being trapped and unable to achieve the dream and living with unfulfilled desires...
- cercatrova 6y agoI watched Burning and Parasite as a duology, both have very similar themes about modern day Korea. I'd suggest you watch them back to back as well.
- GizmoSwan 6y agoGreat minds think alike! I have seen the Parasite too but few months before the other one. The Parasite has won an Oscar I think.
- acabal 6y agoThe Great Gatsby entered the US public domain this year, and you can read it for free at Standard Ebooks: https://standardebooks.org/ebooks/f-scott-fitzgerald/the-great-gatsby https://standardebooks.org/ebooks/f-scott-fitzgerald/the-gre...
- omosubi 6y agothe audiobook is also free on spotify - https://open.spotify.com/album/3pGXKRHWi69wIBdI39PfZc?si=rnTQc7zYSTSBcw_Y8FJIWg https://open.spotify.com/album/3pGXKRHWi69wIBdI39PfZc?si=rnT...
- wyldfire 6y agoI just started watching HBO's "The Wire." It was interesting to hear D'Angelo Barksdale's take on it [1]. I think it's related to his character's arc - inner turmoil about whether to leave the criminal world behind. [1] https://youtu.be/8DOy4hCih7w https://youtu.be/8DOy4hCih7w
- toyg 6y agoFirst time through The Wire? Oh man, I envy you.
- Mistri 6y agoHigh school ruined this book for me. It would've been easier to read if I hadn't been forced to tear apart every single sentence for analysis. Hearing "Great Gatsby" triggers my gag reflex now, along with most other books I analyzed in high school.
- toyg 6y agoIn Italy that happens with Dante’s Divina Commedia and Manzoni’s I Promessi Sposi. Very good reads on their own, they get absolutely destroyed by being forced on kids.
- jwdunne 6y agoSimilar thing happened to me but with Of Mice and Men and Macbeth. Come to enjoy those stories but it always felt like I was meant to glean a deeper meaning than even the author intended!
- tjalfi 6y agoLiterary augury[0] is my term for that kind of literature discussion. [0] https://www.britannica.com/topic/augury https://www.britannica.com/topic/augury
- RBerenguel 6y agoI had this with The Picture of Dorian Gray, but on a re-read later (several years on a bored weekend, that was before I wrote code or read about code most of the time) I came to really appreciate it.
- WalterBright 6y agoI finally got around to reading Romeo+Juliet in my 40's. It was much better than I expected, aside from all the tired cliches in the prose.
- ecopoesis 6y agoShakespeare invented those “tired cliches.”
- 6y ago
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jrumbut 6y agoI'm not how naming a couch Gatsby really reflects a misunderstanding. His character really does have an opulent house and reading about it is one of things you can enjoy in the novel.
- toyg 6y agoBut it's all fake and built on crime and blood. Would you really want a sofa that reminds people you are a fake and a thug?
- winrid 6y agoThe Green light! It must mean Envy!
- acdanger 6y agoHeh. It looks like GatsbyJS - the React static site generator - cribbed their logo from the GQ magazine pictured in the article: GatsbyJS: https://www.gatsbyjs.com/guidelines/logo#footnotes https://www.gatsbyjs.com/guidelines/logo#footnotes GQ: https://ychef.files.bbci.co.uk/1024x1280/p096h71g.webp https://ychef.files.bbci.co.uk/1024x1280/p096h71g.webp
- ksdale 6y agoThey may well have done that, but as a very nit-picky aside, that font has a pretty general art deco vibe, so it's not necessarily unique to that GQ cover.
- drewzero1 6y agoMaybe! The font on the magazine appears to be Broadway Engraved[1], but similar fonts were extremely common in the book's time period, making any of them an obvious choice. The logo looks a lot more like the C and O in Secret Agent NF[2]. Could be inspiration, or could easily be coincidence. [1] http://www.identifont.com/similar?2AG http://www.identifont.com/similar?2AG [2] http://www.identifont.com/similar?9TR http://www.identifont.com/similar?9TR
- kylegill 6y agoYeah there is certainly some truth to that, the original logo design came from an open source contributor who mentioned some ideas coming from the movie posters: https://github.com/gatsbyjs/gatsby/issues/408#issuecomment-245861049 https://github.com/gatsbyjs/gatsby/issues/408#issuecomment-2...
- mikhailfranco 6y agoAnother discussion of the book on the BBC: https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/m000r4tq https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/m000r4tq I used to think of "In Our Time" as the set of topics for which every educated person should have a basic understanding of the facts, hence hold an informed opinion, and be able to enter a meaningful discussion. But now it is approaching ~900 episodes, so the subjects are necessarily becoming more obscure, but that also means there is occasionally a fascinating surprise. https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b006qykl/episodes/player https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b006qykl/episodes/player
- icefrakker 6y agoWell I ended up with 7 years of podcasts to go through now - thanks!
- mrkeen 6y agoI misunderstood this article as well! Anyone want to let me in on what the book's really about?
- karaterobot 6y agoThe article doesn't offer a position on that. It just points out the obvious fact that it's NOT about how cool and fun it is to be rich and throw fancy parties, and that understanding the context of the narrator being a returning soldier and member of the lost generation is important.
- filoleg 6y ago>[...] understanding the context of the narrator being a returning soldier and member of the lost generation is important. This was one of my biggest annoyances about how this book is usually presented and taught to high school students. Back when I was a HS student myself (barely a decade ago), I had read that book. While it was a decent book imo, I thought it was overhyped. Mostly because the primary message of the book explained to us by teachers was that it was basically a story about a man who was so deeply in love with a woman who he didn't get to date, he had built great riches and life for himself. And yet none of that extravagant lifestyle could satisfy his desire for her, and it all ends in a tragedy. Something something greed something something green eyes are a symbol of his undying light for her or something. And while the veteran background of the narrator was mentioned by teachers quite a few times, and we were told it was important to know, teachers never went as far as explaining why and how it was important to the story. Or how it was related at all. No connection to the lost generation either, besides it being mentioned once. Basically, the book was treated as a dramatic tragedy about a very quick fall of a man due to his love and desire. At no point when the book was discussed years later with people in real life it went deeper than that. Many years later, I saw someone pointing out what you've just pointed out in your comment online, and the book had suddenly clicked for me. It all started making sense, and I finally understood why it was regarded so highly. If you view the entirety of the storyline through the eyes and context of the narrator's past, it adds a whole different dimension to the story, which not only adds depth, it straight up transforms your entire understanding of what it really was about. The only solid analogy I can think of is if someone described MLK's civil rights movement as a simple protest due to a woman being so stubborn she didn't want to sit in the back of the bus, and her friends wanted to back her up, because they were upset about separate fountains and other facilities too. But once you actually understand what it was about, it completely changes the impact and gravity of what it really was.
- steve76 6y agoMixes real world celebrity into "literature as a product." Interesting to think who would be like Fitzgerald today, and fun to think authors can do that to people, draw crowds and headlines. Creates a world that likely wouldn't exist without the book. Memento for a group of people who feel sympathy for a lost friend, and remember an era where free expression was something brand new. Paris in the 1920s was probably really nice, not decadent, more like a wonderland, seeing things for the first time. Ten years after Fitzgerald died, when America had to compete against fascism, communism and imperialism, we took everything cultural, loaded it into a cannon, and shot it at the world to see what would stick. How could it be disillusionment when we took over the world?
- solumos 6y agoIn other news, The Crucible: Misunderstood Play. It's not about the Salem witch trials, but rather, a critique of McCarthyism!
- lupire 6y agoThat was last century. Now it's about blaming women for men's mistreatment of them.