6 ms·
There are three changes I would make to the DMCA: 1. All DMCA notices must contain an analysis of fair use and explain why the content does not meet fair use.
by jcranmer 6y ago
There are three changes I would make to the DMCA:
1. All DMCA notices must contain an analysis of fair use and explain why the content does not meet fair use.
2. Anyone who has received an improper notice (including an analysis of fair use that would not survive summary judgement) can countersue (or sue, if the copyright owner declines to bring suit after a counter-notice) for at least $1000 in statutory damages.
3. Any non-DMCA system that can take down user-generated material for alleged copyright violations must give users the same rights as the DMCA: the (new) mandatory analysis of fair use and the right to counter-notice (and host the content until it is determined in court). These rights cannot be waived by contract.
- munk-a 6y agoI think #2 is probably too high for private citizens to risk needing to pay if their claims are reversed. Individuals can and do exercise DMCA notices for protected content that they personally own and if that route for reconciliation would be taken away and alternative would need to be provided. There are some serious issues with DMCA abuse but I think that it'd be better to address the issues of abuse with a regulatory body that's specifically empowered to go after bad actors. The core problem here is that the internet moves really really fast and is really really worthless so trying to protect owned content on it is extremely difficult.
- croon 6y ago> I think #2 is probably too high for private citizens to risk needing to pay if their claims are reversed. As a musician I have a hard time imagining a case where an honest DMCA takedown could be reversed by someone listening to the same music I am and identifying something else.
- jimbob45 6y agoJust fix the root problem. Copyright should last fifteen years max. The system now just incentivizes companies to hoard old stuff and eschew making risky new stuff.
- jedberg 6y ago15 years may be too short for some content. I'm ok with indefinite copyright, but there should be a steep price. Like the owner of the copyright pays X% of their revenue from that copyright back to the treasury each year, where X is the number of years it's been copyrighted. So Disney would be paying 93% of their Mickey Mouse revenue in taxes this year. Have the IRS enforce it, where they can audit the books. Or they can just give up the copyright. This would also solve the abandoned works problem. Every copyright would have to have an annual filing to maintain it, with the owner listed publicly. No filing? Copyright invalid, public domain. And lastly, it would basically put a cap of 99 years, because even if you're making a trillion dollars a year from your copyright, it wouldn't make sense to pay 100% or more of your revenue.
- Dylan16807 6y agoBut if you aren't selling anything that lets you keep copyright forever. And it seems very difficult to calculate a percentage among mixed works.
- jedberg 6y agoGood point. Make a minimum fee of $1000 times X years, or whatever is enough to find the right balance. The ultimate goal is to put as much work into the public domain as possible, since that was the original goal of the framers of the Constitution.
- Dylan16807 6y agoIt seems pretty complicated to strike a balance this way, in comparison to simple time-based methods. And there's basically no reason not to keep paying the fees up to 80 or 90 years under your scheme. If you want more renewals to avoid orphan works, I'd just add more renewals. They don't need to cost much.
- jedberg 6y ago