6 ms·
If they hadn't Osborned themselves with Zen3, I probably would have ordered a P620 by now. But the weird punchline of this article seems to be it still takes a
by jeffbee 6y ago
If they hadn't Osborned themselves with Zen3, I probably would have ordered a P620 by now. But the weird punchline of this article seems to be it still takes a whole minute to launch GIMP. Software matters.
- Mauricebranagh 6y agoReally your buying Threadripper Pro's and your running GIMP on it, I find that hard to believe.
- dragontamer 6y agoI mean... Gimp works. And if your first job is CAD, Programming, or something non-artistic, Gimp is what I'm willing to pay for. I'm willing to pay $4000+ for my profession's tools. But when it comes to a hobby, cheap or free is better.
- c0nsumer 6y agoAffinity Photo is SO much better and currently only $24.99. May be worth taking a look: https://affinity.serif.com/en-us/photo/ https://affinity.serif.com/en-us/photo/
- dharmab 6y agoAffinity doesn't run on Linux, so it's not a replacement for GIMP as a Unix hacker's art tool. I like Krita (https://krita.org https://krita.org) as a painting tool. Darktable (https://www.darktable.org https://www.darktable.org) does photo editing, although I haven't used it myself.
- dbspin 6y agoNot sure why this is being downvoted. Gimp has a high learning curve and is primitive compared to contemporary commercial tools. I completely understand a disdain for Adobe's subscription model, but there are fantastic relatively low cost commercial options now. Open source is still a wasteland for actually usable video / audio and even photo editing applications. Lots of apps that are functional on paper, but have major workflow, file support or UX limitations that make them limited in practice. Edit: Guarantee not a single person downvoting this is an audio video or photography professional. This attitude of OSS above all, damn the users is likely part of the reason there aren't more viable creative apps for Linux, and more viable OSS creative apps overall.
- q3k 6y agoNot everyone who does light image editing as part of their professional setting needs professional tools straight away. The mental overhead of having to manage software installation, licensing, etc. is just not worth it, even if you're willing to spend the extra $300 per year for it. And as mentioned, Affinity/Adobe software is not available on Linux, which immediately disqualifies it for me personally, even though I'd like to upgrade past GIMP and I'm very much used to Photoshop after years of using it.
- katbyte 6y agoI would prefer to have photoshop but cost, however if the only alternative was gimp i'd throw all the money at them for my sanity. I use pixelmator pro instead and am quite happy with it.
- Mauricebranagh 6y agoEspecially in the context of workstation class systems where your looking at $5k per CPU and your quite possibly looking at 10g connections for your horizontal cable runs. At a certain point the old HP (before they where shit) Joke if you have to ask the price you cant afford it still applies.
- dragontamer 6y agoI think this fundamentally misunderstands how computer users work. Lets say I'm a programmer who needs to spin up multiple VMs / Docker / etc. etc. to properly emulate some server setup. Multiple cores and tons of RAM (more than 256GB) needed on a regular basis, with a few NVMe drives in RAID0 so that those VMs can be snapshot in blazing fast speeds. Paying $100 to $4000 for VMWare workstation, Visual Studio subscriptions, SQLServer non-express, Red Hat Virtual Machine License, Visio, and other such top-class tools would be 100% reasonable, along with the $10,000+ Threadripper pro computer with 512GB RAM or whatever. But image editing wouldn't be part of that user's workflow. Suddenly, the professional developer is asked to make a web-banner on the top of his Github document with the logo of the company on it. Guess what? Said developer probably is downloading GIMP. The hassle of going to corporate to be compensated for lol $25 on another image editor is just not worth the time.
- dagmx 6y agoHighly recommend Krita over Gimp. its a much better product and has much better tooling and color handling
- throw8932894 6y agoI tried to load 30GB image to Krita, it crashes. Gimp handles it pretty well.
- justinclift 6y agoDid you mean MB rather than GB? Kind of wondering what kind of image would be 30GB... :)
- Solid_Applaud 6y agoAperio SVS
- justinclift 6y agoThanks. Found info on that file format: * https://openslide.org/formats/aperio/ https://openslide.org/formats/aperio/ * https://web.archive.org/web/20120420105738/http://www.aperio.com/documents/api/Aperio_Digital_Slides_and_Third-party_data_interchange.pdf https://web.archive.org/web/20120420105738/http://www.aperio... Pages 14 onward give the info. Seems like it's a variation of TIFF, in tiled format. Main tile (image) size is 120k x 80k. That's huge! 29GB when saved uncompressed. I'd hope most applications would use the optional compression features. :)
- throw8932894 6y agoThis was 360 degree mosaic, about 100kX100k
- justinclift 6y agoHmmmm, how much ram did the PC have that his happened on?
- 6y ago
- account42 6y agoGIMP can use a lot of ram, you need those 8 ram slots to run it properly.
- jeffbee 6y agoI also find this preposterous, but it's what the article measured. For me it would be a replacement for my HP z-series workstation I use mostly to build C++ software.
- kjhughes 6y agoFor any not familiar with Osborned, the Osborn Effect refers to how prematurely announcing a next generation product can cannibalize sales of the existing product. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Osborne_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Osborne_effect
- PartiallyTyped 6y agoI wouldn't say so. The TR series have many more bus lanes than the desktop variants, and support >= 128GB ram, iirc official EEC support, and iirc quad channel memory.
- greggyb 6y agoTR has quad-channel and unofficial ECC support. TR Pro has 8-channel memory and official ECC support, along with support for RDIMMs. The max RAM for a TR is 256GB right now, with 8x32GB - only unbuffered DIMMs are supported. TR Pro can take up to 2TB RAM.
- ip26 6y agoThere's always a faster machine coming. Zen3 Threadripper probably won't be in a ThinkStation for, what, another year? So if you need a computer like that, P620 is the machine of the hour. It also seems likely you will be able to drop a Zen3 Threadripper into the P620's sTRX4 socket.
- junar 6y agoI agree that they should not wait, but wanted to point out that P620s use Threadripper Pro, which has a different socket (sWRX8) and came out several months after the sTRX4 Threadrippers.
- wmil 6y agoHas Gimp done any work to parallelize plugin / font loading? I recall that was the bottleneck at startup. If they haven't then more cores won't ever help.
- jeffbee 6y agoAccording to the article it’s the opposite: it gets slower as you add cores. I wonder if it’s better to launch it with `taskset -c 0-3` or similar.
- pdpi 6y agoI think that's consistent with it being singlethreaded. AIUI, unless you pin the process to a single core, scheduling can make it bounce around between cores, and the probability you'll land on a different core (and, thus, incur more cache sync issues) goes up with the number of cores.
- IanCutress 6y agoGIMP decides to optimize the plugins for each individual core in the system, so the complexity of startup increases with the number of cores present. It's a single threaded process, so more cores = takes longer. At least for the first startup when that happens anyway.
- StillBored 6y agoAs someone who submitted a patch a few years back to fix a gimp startup problem, I don't think they really care. The visual purity of seeing all those plugins loading, and having it take a long time seems to be part of the mystique they are looking for. If it just started right up, it wouldn't send the same message.
- PrototypeNM1 6y agoThey added lazy loading of fonts a couple years back, which took a chunk out of startup time.
- fanatic2pope 6y agoIt takes ~2.5 seconds to launch gimp on my janky old core i7 box.
- mpol 6y agoHere 7 seconds on my AMD A8-7600 from 2015 with an SSD from 2012 :) But the test is with a very big XCF file, loading lots of high quality layers. I would assume that takes all the time. Unless it is the MS Windows filesystem that is terribly slow, that might also be an option :)
- __turbobrew__ 6y agoIt takes about 0.5 seconds on my 7 year old i5 + Samsung 960 SSD
- burnte 6y agoI have a 3600X, water cooled so it runs at top speed reliably, 64GB RAM, and a gen 4 PCIe SSD. Photoshop takes a solid 30+ seconds to launch, and another 30+ seconds to load even a few dozen KB JPEG. Feels like an app from 1988.
- kumarvvr 6y agoSeems like an os or driver issue.
- tauntz 6y agoAnother anecdote: 2018 MBP i9 (8950HK) and 32GB RAM. warm-start (that is, launching after having previously killed the process but stuff's probably in a cache somewhere) Photoshop: 4s GIMP: 3s
- kyriakos 6y agoSomething is wrong with your setup. I have the same cpu with 32gb ram and ssd and everything Inc photoshop is fast
- Turing_Machine 6y agoAt least at one point, most of the delay in starting GIMP seemed to be it groveling through the HD looking for fonts, and getting them into a format it could use (e.g., showing the font properly in the font selection dialog). I don't know if that's still the case.