12 ms·
Pseudophilosophy encourages confused, self-indulgent thinking
- callesgg 6y agoThe author used to be my philosophy teacher. Fun to stumble on a article written by him. I think I agree with him just a smal amount of philosophy in grade school would probably be very helpful for getting more people on to a “better” path.
- fjfaase 6y agoI wonder if this an attempt to validate philosophy as a science in itself now that other sciences have invalidated many philosophical positions as being valid. My primary feeling about most philosophy is that it is a historical science instead of a systematic science, where the ideas of a certain philosopher are placed in the context of history. It also seems to me that the philosophers are more important than their ideas and that when a philosopher changes his ideas, they talk about the early and late.
- adrianN 6y agoThere is an old joke that goes like this: It is well know that the Math department is the second cheapest department at a university. The people there only need a pencil, paper, and rubbish bin. But which is the cheapest department? The Philosophy department. There you don't need the bin.
- andybak 6y agoI've heard the same joke but as "pencils and erasers". That works well too.
- bryanrasmussen 6y agoyes but nowadays the Math department needs computers, so Computer Science must be cheaper.
- sharker8 6y agoAnd the computer has a skeumorphic waste bin.
- rvense 6y agoThis is mistaken, actually: philosophers do use bins, they just don't put their own writings in them.
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoI'm not sure how much philosophy and science can ever be connected. There is surely little biological basis for systems of ethics or epistemology. Abandoning that, we're left to wonder if they can apply to social systems in the aggregate. There we find a wide variety of social systems in partial or complete disagreement on what constitutes ethics. In some systems murder is a sin; in others it is tolerated or necessary. Fidelity is variously required or shunned. Simpler things like truthful speaking are all over the map. Even epistemology is in doubt. Secular science types love provable measurements and consistent theories. Others embrace inspiration, devine communication, even mushroom-induced hallucination as true sources. So where does science impact philosophy? Perhaps as a tool for describing philosophies, like describing species of animal. That doesn't make philosophy a science, but a subject of scientific study.
- BlueTemplar 6y agoI can think of several examples where systems of ethics come from biological and/or sociological evolutionary constraints ?
- andybak 6y agoThe article isn't trying to "validate philosophy as a science". To some degree science relies on certain philosophical assumptions to be viable and philosophy aims to make those assumptions explicit and to allow one to understand the choices one has made in accepting them. I agree that certain philosophical positions have been encroached upon by science but that is not a process that can continue indefinitely. The realm of enquiry that science can operate on is by neccesity smaller than that which philosophy can act upon. Many people are going to respond to the above by saying "If your statements aren't empirical and/or falsifiable then they are meaningless - therefore philosophy outside of the natural sciences is meaningless". If that's your response then congratulations. You've just done some philosophy. Now take a step back and examine the assumptions that brought you here.
- yakubin 6y ago> The realm of enquiry that science can operate on is by neccesity smaller than that which philosophy can act upon. Maybe I'm misunderstanding you, but it sounds like you're suggesting that philosophy can talk about anything that science can. And of course, it can, in the sense that there will be uni positions for talking about just about anything in philosophy department, but I'd say that for a long time now when science is able to treat a subject, philosophical investigation of it becomes meaningless pursuit of words, disconnected from reality. And just like religion used to answer some questions about how the world works, but over centuries was in perpetual withdrawal up to the point where it's not its domain at all anymore, philosophy in areas of empirical reality is expected to be superseded by science and as such seems to be as worthwhile as ancient talks about arche and medieval religious talks about creation of the world. What understanding did we gain from arguing over whether the world is made of fire, of water, of ether/whatever? Whether it's deterministic or not? None. It seems it would be a better use of everyone's time if philosophy withdrew from areas of current and future scientific inquiry.
- tlb 6y agoI agree, at least for the hard sciences. Would you argue that, although philosophy used to concern itself with how to live a good life (for example, Stoicism) these questions are now better addressed through science of the type done in uni psychology departments?
- jnwatson 6y agoMy experience is exactly the opposite. My undergraduate philosophy degree had exactly one history class. Names of philosophers were important mostly to label ideas. I'm not sure what you're talking about with respect to philosophical positions invalidated by science. I can't think of any myself.
- Nasrudith 6y agoThe ancient Greek philosophers contain some real howlers like Aristotlean impetus and belief that women must have fewer teeth than men because of a smaller skull and an assumption that human teeth are identical in size and spacing. They refused to check their ideas to reality under a self indulgent concept of "purity of thought". I blame aristocratic influnce and the disdain for the practical.
- denton-scratch 6y agoThat would be the "pre-socratics". I was forced to study them for my degree, and I could barely contain my laughter. Some of those guys had some pretty bonkers beliefs, and it does seem to be true that they often disdained actually cheecking their claims empirically. A few of them were on the nail, though, at least sometimes; Democritus, for example.
- BlueTemplar 6y agoFunny also how pythagoricians found some mathematical truths and went all cult-like because of it...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- yters 6y agoScience used to mean knowledge in general, which is its root. Philosophy was a subset of science, and theology was the top science. Natural philosophy, what we now call science, was a subset of philosophy.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- 082349872349872 6y agoIn the Phaedrus, it was predicted that writing and reading in general (let alone specific examples such as pseudophilosophy) would eventually encourage confused, self-indulgent thinking. > You offer your pupils the appearance of wisdom, not true wisdom, for they will read many things without instruction and will therefore seem to know many things, when they are for the most part ignorant and hard to get along with, since they are not wise, but only appear wise. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24737221 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24737221
- prox 6y agoI’ve engaged in philosophy for years, and the most important thing you learn when actually debating, is to learn to think in different frameworks of mind. This alone is of great benefit when reading or taking in thoughts of others.
- asimpletune 6y agoI haven’t read phaedrus in a while, but I think that interpretation is taken a little out of context. It’s better to say reading and writing, alone, would encourage these things. There’s this theme in Plato that power isn’t the end all be all. By that same logic, reading/writing were a technology that gave you power. Specifically the ability to record/recall things. Plato/Socrates argue that power alone gives you as much ability to achieve bad as it does good. Then they go on to argue that it’s wisdom that allows one to know what is good bad, thus wisdom is critical in all things. So, that’s why it’s says that in phaedrus, probably haha. It’s not that controversial actually, and not the sky is falling kind of thing. Socrates was just really particular about the pursuit of truth being sort of like the singular focus to achieving good, and the rest were important but had to follow from there. Parenthetically, I’ll add, he also seemed to believe that working out your body was just as important and necessary to being a philosopher.
- nescioquid 6y agoThere's a strand of suspicion towards literacy in Plato. Mainly I'm thinking of the dialog in which Socrates talks to a man about to sue his father (I'm sorry, I'm blanking on the name of the dialog); mainly the idea is that writing enfeebles the memory and intellect. > In the Phaedrus, it was predicted that writing and reading in general... would eventually encourage confused, self-indulgent thinking. We don't learn things, according to Plato, but the soul is brought to remember them again, and the remembering happens by virtue of a Socratic interrogation. If you read "x is the case", your soul hasn't been made to remember it, and worse, that proposition just might not be true which you won't discover without interrogation. Elsewhere (apologies, can't remember which dialog) Plato offers a description of thinking: the mind asks a question and then answers it. The form of the dialog models that process nicely.
- ostrophonics 6y agoThis sort of thing is always by turns boring and frustrating to read, because there are good and interesting philosophical criticisms to be made of Foucault's epistemology, but the idea that for him facticity itself is questionable isn't one of them. Foucault is never really in doubt about what constitutes, e.g., an event, occurrence, or fact - actually his entire corpus very self-consciously relies on having a common set of texts that we agree constitute accounts of what happened in a given field of inquiry in a given time period. Foucault's epistemology strongly requires and insists on the objectivity of the archive. He wouldn't be able to make authoritative claims about the historical importance of Kantian representation, or Bentham's pantopticon, if he didn't think the archive of philosophical and scientific writings had some objective merit that wasn't in question. He's emphatically not the moral relativist he's made out to be by low-hanging fruit conservatism like this. What he - and a lot of his colleagues in France at the time - wanted to know was whether the system of interpretations that has accrued around this archive has gotten to the bottom of what our 19th century forebears were really up to when they were, for instance, busy examining the shapes of skulls to determine personality traits.
- rvense 6y agoI didn't read the linked article yet, but to me, Foucault really is one of the most interesting intellectuals of the 20th century (or longer) - if only because of how differently people perceive him. There's that old debate between him and Chomsky, and it's incredible how different people will score that debate. Some see obscurantist posturing versus Chomsky's towering, rigourous intellect, where others see Chomsky outclassed so thoroughly he doesn't even understand what's going on. (If you happen to be on the latter team, it's a meme format: https://foucaultnews.files.wordpress.com/2020/10/foucault-2020-meme.jpg https://foucaultnews.files.wordpress.com/2020/10/foucault-20...)
- Bodell 6y agoCan you share a link? The only videos I’ve ever seen are either a short clip or not translated. Maybe a written transcript would be best.
- seventytwo 6y agoGood read. The author’s real point is buried at the end when they argue that more emphasis needs to be placed on reading and thinking critically, and that being sure we teach students about fallacies is very important to combat this pseudo philosophy.
- elif 6y agoI like how he criticizes specifically people who reference hegel, jung, marx, etc. but then does not proceed to analyze hegel, et al or anyone that references them. Pure philosophical shade, in the exact "aura of scholarly profundity" that he is supposedly criticizing.
- steverb 6y agoThe line: "Usually, the prose is infused with arcane terminology and learned jargon, creating an aura of scholarly profundity. We can call this phenomenon obscurantist pseudophilosophy." struck me as especially hilarious in context.
- TobySKT 6y agoNice article!
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- coldtea 6y ago>Often, it’s due to simple misunderstandings (such as confusing truth with belief or knowledge), but sometimes it’s due rather to wilful obscurity Sorry, but the pseudophilosopher here is the author of the article. He can't disambiguate between truth as some property of the universe/time-space/actual historical occurence, and truth as it matters to us, and thinks that just because Foucault doesn't spell the distinction out, as if he spoke to 10 year olds, he himself confuses the too. For those actually reading continental philosophy, Foucault's meaning is perfectly clear, and no, he doesn't mean truth in the sense of "this table is wooden" or "the sun is hot". Foucault doesn't do philosophy of truth in the way some analytical philosopher would. It's the century plus old distinction between analytical and continental philosophy, and this is a tired, trite, post. As for the quote from Foucault he gives as an exercize to the reader, it's trivial to parse. Here's my take, with extra examples to make it even clearer: "The definition of what is true (and thus what is not) is based on power relations. We're speaking about social and political truths, here, dummy author, the kind people actually disagree about, not whether fire is hot or Australia exists. Truth, contrary to myth (whose workings will be worth it to examine some other time), is not some higher ideal that you achieve when you free your spirit, or something that you arrive at in quiet contemplation in solitude, or a privilege of those free from social constraints. It's something that is manufactured in this world, and it is produced following many different constraints. (e.g. truth in the medieval world followed religious constraints)."
- Veen 6y ago> It's the century plus old distinction between analytical and continental philosophy The article's claim is not that this distinction doesn't exist or that it is not a useful distinction, but that "pseudophilosphers" tend to equivocate between "truth as some property of the universe" and "truth as it matters to us". That seems to me to be an interesting position that is worth considering. (btw. the claim that "The definition of what is true (and thus what is not) is based on power relations" is untrue even in the "what matters to us" sense, if you take it to mean power is the only or main determinant of what is true. That's the problem with Foucault and his followers—the monomaniacal focus on power as the primary determiner of truth and human relations. It just ain't so.)
- dudeinjapan 6y ago$ sudo philosophy
- dgllghr 6y agoThe thing about Foucault that makes his work meaningful to me is how he hit the nail on the head about how power is changing and continuing to change in society. It has become diffuse and self-perpetuating. It lacks a direct, physical force but still coerces. It is no longer socially acceptable or legal for men to withhold food from their wives, but women suffer from eating disorders in large numbers. Slavery is no longer legal in the US, but a large % of black people are incarcerated and forced to do free labor. The internet has given us access to an enormous amount of information, and yet we are addicted to social media and controlled by algorithms. I think the same can be said about Freud, Marx, and Nietzsche. A lot of their work does not hold up, but within their work are gems of insight that have stood the test of time. Just because they do not adhere to the methodologies of analytical philosophy does not mean that they haven't produced important thought.
- bakhy 6y agoThere's a contradiction in the conclusion. Foucault was an academic philosopher, got a degree in philosophy, was awarded a doctorate, and is respected by many people who also got a lot of education in philosophy. So, how is more philosophy education supposed to have stopped him?
- whimsicalism 6y agoI suspect they are saying more analytic philosophy education a la departments in Britain and America would have lead to more critical thinking.
- denton-scratch 6y agoPublishing books on analytical philosophy, logical philosophy, and philosophy of language generally doesn't get you a bestseller that makes you rich and famous.
- whimsicalism 6y agoTheory of Justice?
- guerrilla 6y agoI mean Logicomix could have done worse ;)
- samirillian 6y agoHasn't the author heard? God is dead.
- sharker8 6y agoI have not read either Harris or Krauss's book, but yes. 100% this. If people want to learn about philosophy I suggest they create a reading list of leading analytic philosophers and just read the source text. Straw Man Hume is not as good as the real thing, trust me. Hume will not teach you anything about meditation, but he will teach you better methods for thinking.
- mrkeen 6y ago> Harris’s failure to grasp the content of many of the philosophical claims and arguments that he criticises > Lawrence Krauss engages with philosophical arguments for theism without understanding them properly. Most saliently, he ends up criticising a caricature version of the so-called cosmological argument about the existence of God. Oof. Perhaps back up those drive-by-shootings with some clarification. > Usually, the prose is infused with arcane terminology and learned jargon, creating an aura of scholarly profundity. We can call this phenomenon obscurantist pseudophilosophy. The irony.
- whimsicalism 6y ago> The irony. It's only ironic if you haven't read this so called "obscurantist pseudophilosophy." This sentence hardly holds a candle to the writings of someone like Deleuze or Derrida.
- karaterobot 6y agoAgreed with this. Also, to give the author of the Psyche article credit, he defined what he meant by obscurantist philosophy earlier in the article. In my fairly limited reading of them, Foucault, Derrida, et al., don't always do this, even when the terms they use are much less self-explanatory than this one.
- walleeee 6y agoThis is obviously very reductive, but I would argue those two helped pioneer a career arc which threatens to conscript (or recruit) many a knowledge-worker today: deconstruct the context you came up in, ride the blast wave to comfort or notoriety, and hope it keeps you afloat until you die. Ambiguity is useful if you're as interested in yourself as you are your intellectual project. Their work makes more sense if you view it as equal parts masturbation (note that this is not a value judgment; where do new ideas come from if not the mind touching itself?) and socio-political maneuvering which occasionally self-assembles into interesting theory, like most philosophy. This isn't to be totally cynical about their projects though. They both tolerated paradox more than most philosophers. I do like Derrida's intuition that text is an infinitely self-referential hall of mirrors. And Deleuze saw the extent of the cybernetic project fairly clearly.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jonathanstrange 6y agoAs somebody who makes a living "as a philosopher" in areas that overlap with CS, decision making, logic, AI and appear to be more scientific in nature, I may find this article emotionally somewhat appealing but still don't think it's a useful view about philosophy. The first and foremost thing about philosophy laymen should realize is that the vast majority of philosophers do not consider philosophy a science. They also kind of agree to disagree about what philosophy is and what the subject matter of the discipline is. To put it bluntly, I'd say the majority of philosophers silently agree that 80% of all publications or more in philosophy are nonsense or bullshit and only the rest is even worth reading, but they all disagree about which 80% percent... So Yes, I sometimes did also have the suspicion that some colleagues are bullshitting and obscuring intentionally, but overall this is not a helpful attitude. If you don't like a particular philosopher's work, you generally don't read and support it, and that's it. Calling the work pseudophilosophy will only enrage people who disagree and not help with anything. Things are different in neighbouring disciplines in the humanities. After many years in the field and having to do with some of these disciplines, I believe I can say with some confidence that some of them are indeed pseudo-sciences. I don't want to mention which and why for fear of being identified later. All I can say is that there are disciplines and sub-disciplines/fields of study in the humanities that bear all the hallmarks of pseudo-science: extremely small communities, lots of jargon, few journals controlled by everyone in the communities, bouncing articles back and forth between those journals, constantly mixing empirical theses with some philosophical claims ("ideal models"), and so on. I'd be fine if these disciplines would at least apply the fairly stringent standards for publications in philosophy, but they don't even do that. These disciplines have overall lower standards in comparison to philosophy and often make unfounded empirical claims based on qualitative studies or studies with way too small sample size.
- _qulr 6y ago> the majority of philosophers silently agree that 80% of all publications or more in philosophy are nonsense or bullshit > These disciplines have overall lower standards in comparison to philosophy Given your earlier statement, may I ask what you consider to be the higher standards of philosophy? I ask somewhat rhetorically as a former philosophy PhD student who left because I felt the whole field seemed quite indifferent to anything other than careerist journal stuffing.
- ardy42 6y ago> There are two kinds of pseudophilosophy, one mostly harmless and the other insidious. The first variety is usually found in popular scientific contexts. This is where writers, typically with a background in the natural sciences, walk self-confidently into philosophical territory without realising it, and without conscientious attention to relevant philosophical distinctions and arguments. Often implicit empiricist assumptions in epistemology, metaphysics and the philosophy of language are relied upon as if they were self-evident, and without awareness of the threat that those very assumptions pose to the author’s own reasoning. We can call this phenomenon scientistic pseudophilosophy. This sounds similar to engineer's syndrome/engineer's disease: https://ask.metafilter.com/297591/Origin-of-the-term-Engineers-Disease https://ask.metafilter.com/297591/Origin-of-the-term-Enginee... (which isn't limited to engineers, IIRC there's an equivalent term that I forget for medical doctors that overconfidently stray outside their area of competence).
- Nasrudith 6y agoOne smart aleck but serious question - what precisely makes the naive scientific distinctions wrong compared to the philsophical argument? It is overly literal and somewhat unimaginative to immediately answer theship of Theseus with "Did it sink or wind up disassembled in whole? If not then it is the same ship." But it is a consistent philosophical framework - it never was destroyed so therefore it is the same ship. Is it convention and semantic akin to say "literally" being used as figuratively? While clearly bad for cross communication and a reciepe for confusion self-consitency is all that is needed for within subset communication even if it leads to cringeworthy constructs like "he actually literally exploded" for what was previously just "he literally exploded".
- DanielBMarkham 6y agoOh wow, what a topic. I have experienced this from all angles. I'm writing programming books in which I have to extend/combine the work of various philosophers[1], I am a huge fan of history, science, and philosophy, and hell, I just tweeted about this subject[2] I agree with the general gist of what the author is saying, but I find that I have a lot of problems using the word "psuedophilosophy". If you want it bluntly, all philosophy is bullshit and trying to stick the word science in there does disservice to both. The longer version is that programming is applied philosophy: we meet, we learn, we define, we codify into a formal system, we use that system to explore the universe around us. The longer version gives us a hint, a compass to find our way around in the bullshit maze (and I use "bullshit" affectionately. My only point is that philosophy is a terribly different thing from science). Where are we going? After all, I'd argue that philosophy is the mother of all sciences, including math. It's obviously critical to humanity. But in my formulation, coders use the process of philosophy to do something, agree, create, formalize, explore. We do philosophy all of the time, but we actually do it. We don't write books on it or spend much if any time quoting or hero-worshipping others who may have done bits and pieces of it 100 years ago or more. Just this morning I ordered the Great Courses series "The Modern Intellectual Tradition: From Descartes to Derrida" I am extremely pumped to get started on it. Because of my books and my interests, I've ran across all kinds of philosophy groupies: professors, doctoral students, fans, grads who hate the subject now, etc. My take: if you don't study philosophy you're missing out on life. Some of the smartest people on the planet have spent their entire lives thinking about tough problems. Use that work. Having said that, most all of them only had a handful of good ideas and spent the rest of their career taking them too far. You have to understand that too if you're actually going somewhere with that knowledge. Otherwise you're just intellectually self-stimulating. If you're learning stuff to go places you can always look back and ask "Where am I now that I wouldn't have been without this knowledge?" That tracks well with this author because his core complaint, whether he states it clearly or not, is that folks pick, choose, skim, and misunderstand great philosophic works as a crutch to actually understanding or teaching something. It's either a prop they use to make rhetorical points or it's a mask they use to cover up their own lack of ability. Yup, they sure do. And you can tell because when you get through reading them you're not left being able to do something you couldn't have done before. Instead your previous opinions are validated, just with bigger words and some loose-fitting historical anecdotes. 1. https://leanpub.com/u/DanielBMarkham https://leanpub.com/u/DanielBMarkham (see brief intro videos to both books if you're interested in diving further) 2. https://twitter.com/danielbmarkham/status/1359094969399713793 https://twitter.com/danielbmarkham/status/135909496939971379... and https://twitter.com/danielbmarkham/status/1359156252723544065 https://twitter.com/danielbmarkham/status/135915625272354406...
- manuel_a 6y agothis guy mad at foucalt for not spelling out what he meant and allowing some ambiguity that let him choose the worst interpretation of his ideas lmao
- truthbetoldnow 6y agoReality is subjective and so should philosophy be. Nobody knows what is going on here and anyone that thinks they do is lying. What is right for me may not be right for you. Learn what is right for you through trial and error. Failure is the best teacher to find out something will not work. Nobody should follow anyone else. You should be the leader of your own life as it is your experience. The goal is not self indulgent thinking, the goal is to stop thinking. To go with the flow. To trust in yourself and believe that you can do what you set your mind to. To remove the fear of I cant and the fear of failure. It is as simple as that, no philosopher or book can tell you that. Only experience can. You can read all the books in the world, but you do not gain any true understanding until you put words into action and actually experience it.
- mr-wendel 6y agoI must disagree with almost everything. > Reality is subjective and so should philosophy be. There is no reason to believe reality is subjective. If it was, why would you appeal to a shared, objective reality to convince us otherwise? Even if it was, that still wouldn't mean that philosophy "should" be. Declaring what something "is" doesn't show you how it "ought" to be. > Nobody knows what is going on here and anyone that thinks they do is lying. Of course nobody has a perfect knowledge of it all, so lets not pretend this is an "all or nothing" deal. There are an awfully lot of well informed people who have learned quite a bit about the human experience, better and worse ways of navigating through life, and take great pleasure in sharing that hard-earned knowledge. > What is right for me may not be right for you. Learn what is right for you through trial and error. You mean you like vanilla and I like chocolate, right? Or do you mean to say for one person it can be legitimately "right" to exploit others (emotionally, economically, whatever) so long as their experiences affirm it to them? > Failure is the best teacher to find out something will not work. No, finding and learning from good teachers (and/or those who already made some mistakes) are the best teachers. Failure is necessary, as there is no trying without failure, but it is not inherently a superior model for learning. > Nobody should follow anyone else. You should be the leader of your own life as it is your experience. Of course at the end of the day you need to build and put trust in yourself as the architect of your own life, but attempting to do that without ever following and emulating others you admire (friends, families, figureheads, and even celebrities) is pure folly. > The goal is not self indulgent thinking, the goal is to stop thinking. This is an awful lot of thinking to convince people to not think. Is this also not self-indulgent? Every statement is about "you, your experience, your subjective reality" and push you to close yourself off from working with others to figure life out. > To go with the flow. How do you both discount having faith in others to support you (e.g. nobody knows, learn whats right for you, nobody should follow) and go with the flow? > To trust in yourself and believe that you can do what you set your mind to. To remove the fear of I cant and the fear of failure. Amen! The worst part of thinking you can't and that its not worth trying is that you might just convince yourself you're right and created a self-fulfilling prophecy. > It is as simple as that, no philosopher or book can tell you that. Only experience can. I'm afraid I must revert to disagreeing. Philosophers (both the kind who call themselves that and those who are too practical to don such a title) and books can create worlds and scenarios that challenge us intellectually and emotionally to question the current boundaries of what to accept and reach for in life. > You can read all the books in the world, but you do not gain any true understanding until you put words into action and actually experience it. Amen again! As Hamlet said "My words fly up, my thoughts remain below: Words without thoughts never to heaven go.". All the ideas and dreams in the world are useless until to attempt to put them into action.
- ssimpson 6y agoI have an old coworker in a group of friends that fits this description. Its frustrating because they will continue to spout this stuff off confidently, but not ever listen to the counter argument or understand that their philosophy is flawed. It makes it challenging to continue to engage with this group of friends.
- samuelizdat 6y agoBaudrillard would have more parallels to what they are trying to convey than Foucault if they want to pick French Post-modernists. The author is just a member of clergy upset that uneducated barbarians and peasants have unorthodox beliefs. Yet they are just victims to post-truth hyperreality. What is their solution to keep people in line? The AI from Metal Gear Solid 2? Who is this written for? Are flat-earth people or anti-vax people going to read this and change their mind? It's just ball fanning.
- vixen99 6y agoBe nice if this philosopher started by defining terms. For instance, are we all crystal clear as to what pseudophilosophy is? A quick search came up with (chiefly pejorative) Any philosophical system that does not meet mainstream academic standards.. I hope there's no possibility of this being an own-goal.
- rq1 6y ago> Harris’s failure to grasp the content of many of the philosophical claims and arguments that he criticises > Lawrence Krauss engages with philosophical arguments for theism without understanding them properly. Most saliently, he ends up criticising a caricature version of the so-called cosmological argument about the existence of God. Haha. Sorry. So you are the only one who understands all of it all. > What makes pseudoscientific beliefs deficient is that they’re formed in an epistemically unconscientious way. That’s to say, these beliefs are made from culpably confused and uninformed reasoning. For example, the belief that the Earth is flat can be sustained only by self-willed disregard of the massive amounts of evidence to the contrary, accumulated over several centuries by several different sciences. The Earth is flat. Tangentially where differentiable. :) > There are two kinds of pseudophilosophy, one mostly harmless and the other insidious. The first variety is usually found in popular scientific contexts. This is where writers, typically with a background in the natural sciences, walk self-confidently into philosophical territory without realising it, and without conscientious attention to relevant philosophical distinctions and arguments. Often implicit empiricist assumptions in epistemology, metaphysics and the philosophy of language are relied upon as if they were self-evident, and without awareness of the threat that those very assumptions pose to the author’s own reasoning. We can call this phenomenon scientistic pseudophilosophy. What were your assumptions when you said the Earth isn’t flat then? I stopped reading here. I can’t stand more crap. You’re way too overestimating your level.
- IfOnlyYouKnew 6y agoWhile "critical thinking skills" are great in principle, empirically they are invoked almost exclusively by people practicing their very own brand of pseudophilosophy. The core tenets of that particular groupthink are the rejection of the "mainstream media" as corrupt/"biased"/irrelevant (usually in favour of some guy publishing daily 60 minute rants on YouTube), an unhealthy obsession with IQs in general and its variability between races and/or genders in particular, and the unwavering belief that Flat Earthers and Holocaust Denialists are the result of a lack of information on the respective subjects. "Self-Indulgent" is a perfect term here: these people expand the universe of possible sources to almost infinity, which is laudable, at least in theory. But in the necessary next step of cutting it down to the amount one can actually handle, they fail to preserve the diversity of the input signal. From the rich buffet that is on offer, they pick 15 cheeseburgers.
- olooney 6y agoDistinguishing science from pseudoscience is called the "demarcation problem" and is surprisingly difficult and subtle. It would seem to me that the analogous "philosophical demarcation problem" is even more difficult and probably completely meaningless because of the open and fluid nature of philosophy itself. The author believes that "pseudophilosophy," whatever that is, encourages confused and self-indulgent thinking and therefore must be separated from proper philosophy. But many people would level the same criticism at philosophy itself. Why then is it useful to distinguish between between the two? I don't view this as a problem because philosophy is not science and is concerned with the "hypothesis generation" side of human inquiry. That is to say, the value it provides is in coming up with new, interesting, and diverse points of view that may or may not be correct but certainly broaden the mind. As Paul Feyerbend[1] argues in his book Beyond Method, "anything goes" when it comes to hypothesis generation and the more creative the better. Philosophy, chaotic and ill-defined as philosophy is, it certainly useful for hypothesis generation, and there are many famous cases of scientists citing philosophers[2] as inspiration. Once we pin down a theory and begin to seriously question if it is a good model for reality we have left philosophy and entered the realm of science. I personally don't see how it could be otherwise: theories and ideas don't spring fully formed from the head, but evolve piecemeal as vague ideas are made more coherent through criticism, and this activity is labeled "philosophy." To deny the human mind a space in which to play with half-formed ideas is to put an end to new ideas altogether. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paul_Feyerabend https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paul_Feyerabend [2]: https://www.pitt.edu/~jdnorton/papers/HumeMach.pdf https://www.pitt.edu/~jdnorton/papers/HumeMach.pdf
- TimTheTinker 6y agoPhilosophy as a field may be “open and fluid” to an extent, but analytical philosophy isn’t at all. As the author writes, there are basic, well-established methods for sniffing out fallacious ideas. All ideas—even those originating from the philosophy department itself—ought to be subjected to basic analytical philosophy before being let out the door. I think that’s what this piece boils down to.
- olooney 6y ago
- bondarchuk 6y agoTaking one sentence of Foucault out of context and then claiming it doesn't make sense. Come on now.
- colechristensen 6y ago>Usually, the prose is infused with arcane terminology and learned jargon, creating an aura of scholarly profundity. We can call this phenomenon obscurantist pseudophilosophy. Is this a joke? I honestly can't tell if it's a joke. This whole article might be.
- andybak 6y agoWhy? I'm not clear what point you want to make here.
- baron_harkonnen 6y agoIt's hard to believe that there are still people writing the old "post-modernist philosophers are bad for civilization!" rant. One thing that always surprises me about these posts are that they always fail to get the arrow of causality right. In general postmodernist philosophy is a descriptive philosophy, not a proscription one. That is Foucault and the many other philosophers this author wants to write off as pseuds aren't stating "we should live in a world where all truth is in question" but observing that we do live in this world. The rise of "astrology, homeopathy, flat-Earthism, anti-vaxx" in recent years for me is a strong argument that these thinkers were largely correct. People aren't reading Foucault and becoming anti-vaxx, and people who think Fox news is reality aren't doing so because they read some Deleuze. While it is of course folly to try to paint all of these thinker with a broad brush, the general themes that they describe is that in our postmodern, late capitalist society we're seeing systems of meaning and value begin to break down. And again, they largely aren't saying that they should break down or that this is a desirable direction to go. Just observing that this is happening. If these philosophies had made any predictions it's that as global capitalism grows more manic, we'll see the continued breakdown of systems of value and meaning, were people become completely enmeshed in a world of symbols detached for any real meaning. Not only the rise in "..., anti-vaxx" but also things like "fake news", the commodification of identity in social media, the surrealism of the radical "right" in the US, all of these things are the logical conclusion of what you would expect given the descriptions these thinkers have of who society works. The bizarreness of rants against these thinkers is somehow blaming them for the very state of society, culture and knowledge that they predicted. It's like blaming epidemiologists for a pandemic. If anything we should view postmodernist thinkers as absolutely validated.
- SummerlyMars 6y ago>It's hard to believe that there are still people writing the old "post-modernist philosophers are bad for civilization!" rant. As someone on the outside of philosophy as a discipline, this is the only sort of description of postmodernism I see. Regardless of its prevalence or correctness, what do you think leads people to interpret postmodernism in this way?
- 0x262d 6y ago> While pseudoscience is particularly prone to causal fallacies and cherry-picking of data, the most common fallacy in obscurantist pseudophilosophy is equivocation. This fallacy exploits ambiguities in certain key terms, where plausible but trivial claims lend apparent credibility to interesting but controversial ones. When challenged, the obscurantist will typically retreat to the safe house provided by the trivial interpretation of his claims, only to reoccupy the controversial ground once the critic has left the scene. I found this to be a very helpful description of a specific kind of sloppy argumentation I have seen a lot of (usually about politics) in the last few years. It seems like it's made worse by anonymous online group arguments - one person will make one trivially true claim, another person will make a farther-reaching, incorrect claim and say it is proven by the first, a third person will defend a critique of any bad claims by just defending the first trivially true one, and bad ideas thrive in the space between all these people.
- bondarchuk 6y agoIt's typically known as motte-and-bailey.
- leetcrew 6y agoFYI, there is a name for (roughly) this style of argument: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motte-and-bailey_fallacy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motte-and-bailey_fallacy useful to know, as you say it describes a lot of arguments people make online and face-to-face unfortunately.
- colechristensen 6y ago>by using the word ‘truth’ in an impressionistic fashion, the distinction between belief and truth is smudged over, allowing Foucault to make seemingly profound statements such as: >>[T]ruth isn’t outside power, or lacking in power: contrary to a myth whose history and functions would repay further study, truth isn’t the reward of free spirits, the child of protracted solitude, nor the privilege of those who have succeeded in liberating themselves. Truth is a thing of this world: it is produced only by virtue of multiple forms of constraint. >I leave it as an exercise to the reader to disambiguate this statement and see what remains. Foucault wrote in French. Translation of any work between language is hard, and always a creative effort. Philosophy, I think, suffers from this to the highest degree ... to the end that a lot of philosophy in translation comes across as nearly indecipherable nonsense which is perhaps not the fault of the author, the topic, or the translator, but only the fact that translation is difficult.
- yamal4321 6y agoPhilosophy literally can not be pseudo.
- monadic3 6y agoThis article is pretty standard analytic bilk: demand readers use your definitions of words and complain about the decline of western civilization when they don't.
- wnoise 6y ago(a): The complaint is about using the same word in different ways, without marking the difference, which has the effect of hiding that the conclusions are unfounded. (b): It's a small part of the essay, one sin among many.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- freedomben 6y agoReally interesting piece, and I especially appreciated this: > Usually, the prose is infused with arcane terminology and learned jargon, creating an aura of scholarly profundity. We can call this phenomenon obscurantist pseudophilosophy. But more of a meta comment: can we please not start calling people who disagree with us "pseudophilosophers," or start using it as an insult to hurl against people we don't agree with? The amount of ad hominem accusations of "pseudoscience" drive me crazy. So often (especially these days) we take a "real" thing and broadly misapply it to anyone or anything that disagrees with us, all the while pretending we're using "science" or "philosophy" to disarm the opposition.
- MockObject 6y agoThis was the thrust of Ayer in Language Truth and Logic, and the Logical Positivists attack against metaphysics in general.
- ostrophene 6y agogreat comments and replies in this thread! one thing that it really brings to light for me is that unfortunately, a lot of us in the West just aren't conditioned to receive continental thought. for us academic disciplines are supposed to have specific empirical domains to whose technical development they have a historical mission to contribute. for continentals in the 60s and 70s, that very notion of "missionness" was in question, especially for a discipline like philosophy which had historically partnered as much with labor as with capital.
- why-el 6y agoThis is demonstrated rather famously in the Sokal affair: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sokal_affair https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sokal_affair.
- MisterBastahrd 6y agoAll philosophy is pseudophilosophy if you ask enough philosophers.
- pseudolus 6y agoIt's somewhat tangential but it's quite amusing to hear that in France many academics are decrying the importation of "American" schools of social science and the effect it's having on French society [0]. Quite the "volte-face" with respect to ongoing complaints in some corners of the American press about the pernicious influence of Derrida and Foucault on American society. [0] https://www.nytimes.com/2021/02/09/world/europe/france-threat-american-universities.html https://www.nytimes.com/2021/02/09/world/europe/france-threa...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- andybak 6y ago> While pseudoscience is particularly prone to causal fallacies and cherry-picking of data, the most common fallacy in obscurantist pseudophilosophy is equivocation. This fallacy exploits ambiguities in certain key terms, where plausible but trivial claims lend apparent credibility to interesting but controversial ones. When challenged, the obscurantist will typically retreat to the safe house provided by the trivial interpretation of his claims, only to reoccupy the controversial ground once the critic has left the scene. This is an interesting phenomenon which has become much easier to recognise now it has been given a memorable name: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motte-and-bailey_fallacy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motte-and-bailey_fallacy