17 ms·
Man to pay £25,000 ($34,000) damages over negative TrustPilot review
- evgen 6y agotl;dr is man posts review that is quite possibly defamatory about a law firm, firm sues, man opts for self-representation and does not show up, man faces default judgement.
- henryaj 6y agoThe review seems pretty reasonable, apart from the use of the word 'scam' which the firm objected to - https://uk.trustpilot.com/reviews/5cf8eb11b055990650f42368 https://uk.trustpilot.com/reviews/5cf8eb11b055990650f42368 Hard to see how it's libel if it's an accurate reporting of his experience with the firm
- koboll 6y ago>In the review, Mr Waymouth alleged: "I paid upfront for a legal assessment of my case. "But what I got was just the information I sent them, reworded and sent back to me." That does kind of sound like a scam to me.
- fmajid 6y agoYes, but UK judges are always prompt to shield members of their own profession, or rich criminals like Trafigura: https://www.theguardian.com/media/2009/oct/20/trafigura-anatomy-super-injunction https://www.theguardian.com/media/2009/oct/20/trafigura-anat...
- eecks 6y agois scam a protected word or something? "a scam is about tricking you into parting with your money" If I _feel_ like I have been scammed surely I can say so?
- henryaj 6y agoDefendant claims he didn't attend because he couldn't afford the costs - https://uk.trustpilot.com/reviews/6022794e679d9708b4d03f7e https://uk.trustpilot.com/reviews/6022794e679d9708b4d03f7e
- londons_explore 6y agoIn a civil case like this, I don't think there is any form of legal aid. If you don't have the money to pay upfront, you lose. That's the way the law works. If it happens to you, just file for bankruptcy and get it sorted rapidly. You need a few hundred pounds for bankruptcy proceedings, so don't spend them on lawyers!
- csunbird 6y ago> If it happens to you, just file for bankruptcy and get it sorted rapidly. You need a few hundred pounds for bankruptcy proceedings, so don't spend them on lawyers! This makes it almost impossible for you to get a credit/lease a house/work with the banks in the future. Do I feel like he over-stepped by openly calling the business scammers? Yes. Do I feel like the firm/judge was stupid to ask 6000 pounds upfront, because someone just sued you and make a ruling for 25000 afterwards? Totally. Nobody should be asked to pay that much amount before showing up to the court, just to be able to excersize their legal rights and to be able to presented , I feel like the judge made a huge mistake as well.
- bdowling 6y ago> Do I feel like the firm/judge was stupid to ask 6000 pounds upfront, because someone just sued you and make a ruling for 25000 afterwards? Totally. In the UK when you lose a lawsuit you are required to pay the other party's legal costs. It appears that the defendant had previously lost on some portion of the case. Here is the paragraph of the decision relating to that: > The Defendant was ordered to pay the Claimant's costs up to and including the hearing of 6th July 2020 on the indemnity basis. This costs order has not been complied with. The Claimant seeks its costs of the disposal hearing. The schedule of costs for summary assessment seeks a further sum of £3,450. This sum is both reasonable and proportionate and I will make a costs order in the sum requested. https://www.bailii.org/ew/cases/EWHC/QB/2021/85.html https://www.bailii.org/ew/cases/EWHC/QB/2021/85.html
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- danpalmer 6y agoTrustpilot is awful. They hold businesses hostage, and have clearly set up their fee structure as a pay-to-win format. That said, while I dislike Trustpilot, and while I think this case likely has merit, it sets some dangerous precedents with regards to the ability to complain in a public forum. The bit about lack of engagement with a complaints process is one that worries me, many companies have terrible complaints processes that are designed to respond only to particular types of complaint acceptable to them (often ones they can claim are an issue with other companies), and they become a black hole if your complaint doesn't fit the right format. Trustpilot's lack of structure here is an advantage and a way to hold businesses to some account.
- throw14082020 6y agoWhy is trustpilot awful? Which businesses have been held hostage? How is their fee structure pay to win? I did notice "invite an unlimited number of customers to write verified reviews" though. https://uk.business.trustpilot.com/plans https://uk.business.trustpilot.com/plans
- boyband6666 6y agoCompanies that pay can flag negative reviews, when they get taken down, and to get it back up you have to provide all sorts of proof of your custom, and complaint. Companies can also then reply without you getting to add. Much like amazon reviews they absolutely cannot be trusted to be a representation of the truth
- throw14082020 6y agoOh my word. It looks like they've also removed some negative reviews I posted about a company in the past... This is a suitable problem to be solved by decentralised system.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- 6y ago
- Ballas 6y agoPredictably, people have flooded trustpilot with negative reviews after this article was published. I guess they weren't expecting this to make the news.
- throw14082020 6y agoIt looks like the "community" has taken this into its own hands, see https://uk.trustpilot.com/review/www.summerfieldbrowne.com https://uk.trustpilot.com/review/www.summerfieldbrowne.com Trustpilot: "this profile has been temporarily closed for new reviews."
- tyingq 6y agoSeems they didn't predict the Streisand effect when they decided to use the big hammer.
- K0nserv 6y agoTheir TrustPilot reviews[0] are a fun read now. This feels like an excellent example of the Streisand Effect[1]. I guess we'll see how suffers more, the man or the firm. 0: https://uk.trustpilot.com/review/www.summerfieldbrowne.com https://uk.trustpilot.com/review/www.summerfieldbrowne.com 1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Streisand_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Streisand_effect
- pacamara619 6y ago> Alert >This profile has seen a significant increase in reviews. >Although we understand you want to voice your opinion about things in the news and issues trending on social media, Trustpilot is a place for feedback based on genuine buying and service experiences. >Due to this, this profile has been temporarily closed for new reviews.
- SV_BubbleTime 6y ago> oh no, no, no, we’re not locking this page for censorship and manipulation reasons! We’re locking this page for “integrity“. Thing is, in this case the can be doing exactly the right and wrong thing for the same reasons. There doesn’t seem to be a win here except to not be a publisher of reviews that will (intentionally) upset unpaying and please your paying customers. I liked the old internet.
- proactivesvcs 6y ago> I liked the old internet. Where people would generally conduct themselves in a cordial manner. We would not engage in doxxing, brigading, posting negative reviews of goods or services we have not used, impotently try to manipulate search engines and we would not incite others to do so.
- passivate 6y agoWhat was so good about the old internet that we don't have anymore? I'm curious, as I've been online since 1994/1995. I can't imagine going back to it.
- dmitrybrant 6y agoPerhaps a bit off-topic, but TrustPilot is a form of near-perfect evil. If someone leaves a negative review of your business on TrustPilot, you can have it taken down... for a measly $400 per month. If you refuse to purchase their premium package, they can prioritize the negative review to be shown above the positive ones until you do. If your competitor hires a review-bombing spammer to add negative reviews en masse, well, you'll just have to upgrade to the next-tier plan. It's a shocking lack of integrity, but not surprising, given the business model. Anyway, it's disappointing that TrustPilot gets any publicity for being anything credible. Edit: A nice little touch is at the bottom of their website that says "See what our customers are saying about TrustPilot", with a hand-picked selection of reviews... from TrustPilot! About TrustPilot! Chef's kiss. Edit 2: This is not to say that Trustpilot's intentions aren't necessarily good, and they may even be striving to provide neutrality. But the problem is that their business model is, by its very nature, antithetical to neutrality. And of course Trustpilot is not the only review site that has this issue, but it's definitely a site where this issue is glaringly apparent.
- cosmodisk 6y agoThere a multiple problems here: 1) Trustpilot as a platform that is borderline racketeering. 2) Lack of regulation when it comes to posting/reviewing/ approving public reviews 3) Default support of the customer/client vs business. I had to deal with a fair share of negative Trustpilot reviews. Some people are very good at expressing their dissatisfaction with the service. They explain why, what,and when it gone wrong. Those,even if it's 1 star review,are delight to read and act upon,as they often give a very different perspective compared of those inside the business. This is about 10% customers. Majority express dissatisfaction in a rushed manner with lack of facts and often unrealistic expectations. The rest 10-10% are are simply in a coocoo land and can often be described as those who go to McDonald's with the expectations of 3 star Michelin restaurant. Having said that, Google reviews is even worse for the business with almost no control over what and who post the reviews.
- iujjkfjdkkdkf 6y agoYour point 2 takes care of itself without needing regulation, for exactly the reason you describe: normal people who read reviews ignore the ones about e.g. the bad wine selection at chain restaurants, use the average of the unexplained reviews as a guide, and may see if the issues in the detailed reviews pertain to then. It doesnt need regulation, it just needs minor critical thinking to decide if reviews on a particular site are useful or not. Also (and I realize this is tangential to your post), the idea of having to explain why you are unhappy is ridiculous in my view. This is a common device I see, asking people to explain themselves until they have reduced the problem to little things that dont seem to important, then pretending there isn't really a problem. I am far more interested in overall net sentiment towards a place than in the specific, and almost always probably minor, reasons people were unhappy. A dirty look or cold entree here and there don't really matter, but a pattern of many being dissatisfied enough to give a negative rating does.
- cosmodisk 6y ago>Your point 2 takes care of itself without needing regulation, for exactly the reason you describe: normal people who read reviews ignore the ones about e.g. the bad wine selection. I would probably agree if it was just that. Nowadays review sites are like a massive neon sign hanging above your shop saying '2 star review!!!'. That's often all people see before even having a chance to interact with the business. Reviews also get aggregated, so for instance on Just Eat, if I give 5 stars for delivery and 2 for food quality, the overall score would still be OK( which,in this case, makes it easier for the business but less informative for the customer). Also (and I realize this is tangential to your post), the idea of having to explain why you are unhappy is ridiculous in my view. >Also (and I realize this is tangential to your post), the idea of having to explain why you are unhappy is ridiculous in my view. Whenever I visit a pub or restaurant,I pay attention to the state of the toilets because it's often a good sign how serious they take the whole thing. I've been to places where the food is amazing but the place itself is filthy. So I can go and leave a review saying the place is shit.. The owner of the place would have no idea how to improve/change/fix. Now if I go and say the food is good but they need to clean the place, that's something the business can work with,should they decide to, and refusal to improve a known issue,as you said, would result in more people complaining about the same.
- oauea 6y agoSo it's London law firm Summerfield Browne (https://www.summerfieldbrowne.com/ https://www.summerfieldbrowne.com/) who attacked someone leaving a review about their business. If you're searching for reviews about London law firm Summerfield Browne on Google and are lucky enough to find this post, consider if you want to work with a business that will attack people posting reviews about them. Can you really trust the reviews you might already have read, or are they just suppressing all the negativity?
- sdfhbdf 6y agoAre you trying to game SEO here?
- forgetfulness 6y agoIt seems like it, to raise awareness of Summerfield Browne attorneys' dealings.
- sokoloff 6y agoIf I was looking for a lawyer or Corporate, Litigation, Patent, Business, Contracts, Employment, Intellectual Property, Technology, Software, Banking, Finance, Internet, Website, or Sports Law Solicitors Services, in London, Birmingham, Cambridge, Oxford, Market Harborough, Leicester, England or Wales, I would definitely look into Summerfield Browne ( https://www.summerfieldbrowne.com/ https://www.summerfieldbrowne.com/ ) and consider their overall reputation and history of dealings before making my selection of attorney, lawyer, or solictor.
- lostlogin 6y agoYou left out ‘Japanese Knotweed Solicitors’, an area in which they claim to specialise. Cavity wall and subsidence solicitors are rather less interesting.
- lostlogin 6y agoGame, or use it exactly like it’s supposed to work?
- ROARosen 6y ago>The number of business enquiries it received had dropped since the publication of the review Not that I'm taking a side, but on a practical note I'm sure after suing their former client the number of "business enquiries" will skyrocket.
- sdfhbdf 6y agoIf they can prove they lost business because of his untrue review they should have a case and should rightfully sue for damages for calling their business "scam". His defense should also prove that it is in fact a scam business otherwise it's not an opinion - this can be defamatory. Anyway it's only a civil case, no precedent so far.
- theginger 6y agoThe review is still online[1] And the defendant has even responded in a new review[2] The ruling orders trust pilot to remove the review, so I wonder if they are fighting it or just acting slowly. [1]https://uk.trustpilot.com/reviews/5cf8eb11b055990650f42368 https://uk.trustpilot.com/reviews/5cf8eb11b055990650f42368 [2]https://uk.trustpilot.com/reviews/6022794e679d9708b4d03f7e https://uk.trustpilot.com/reviews/6022794e679d9708b4d03f7e
- henryaj 6y agoOne of the Trustpilot reviews deliciously points out that the solicitors' site [https://www.summerfieldbrowne.com/ https://www.summerfieldbrowne.com/] sets cookies without displaying a cookie warning. Perhaps best to report them for violating GDPR.
- asymptotically3 6y agoJust reported them via ico.org.uk - probably best not to flood them with complaints though, I'm sure they have enough to deal with already.
- AdrianB1 6y agoWhere is the line between opinion and defamation in such a case? If I write a review saying "I was not satisfied" is, in my opinion, just an opinion, I don't have to provide many details unless there is some terms and conditions with the site to provide it. At the same time, when you have a business listed on a review site you have to accept the risk that even bad-intended people can bomb your rating, it's just part of doing business and you cannot expect to sue them all if you don't agree with the reviews, especially if some can be overseas where your friendly judge has no jurisdiction. I think they just poured gasoline over a fire.
- londons_explore 6y agoIn the UK, truth is a defence to libel. That means if you can prove that your opinion is as you wrote it was, then you win the case. Simply restating the same opinion in court would likely be sufficient. Obviously you have to have written "In my opinion, X is a scam". If you missed off the first 3 words, you are gonna lose.
- mytailorisrich 6y agoYou should be very careful here. Accusing a highly regulated professional of running a scam is a very serious accusation, and the defence based on expressing an opinion does not really allow you to add "in my opinion" then say anything you want. It should be an 'honest opinion' that "an honest person could have held ... based on any fact which existed at the time the statement was made" [1], and in any case you probably don't want to test this in court... [1] https://www.carter-ruck.com/media-law-defamation-libel-and-privacy-lawyers/libel-and-slander-faq https://www.carter-ruck.com/media-law-defamation-libel-and-p...
- llampx 6y agoHow about, "I felt that... X was a scam."
- mytailorisrich 6y agoThis case was rather clear-cut, at least under UK law. As per the article the reviewer wrote that the firm was "another scam solicitor". That's not an opinion on the service received, that's a very serious accusation, not least bearing in mind that solicitors are highly regulated, including (obviously) in terms of ethics and honesty.
- dafoex 6y agoIn what appears to be contrast with a lot of people here, I actually support fighting against libelous and untrue claims. The law firm here is entirely in the right to not want to be called scam solicitors when they are not scam solicitors.
- NiceWayToDoIT 6y agoOne is certain after this the Summerfield Browne can close down their business. What are they going to do next? Sue BBC for reporting this story?!
- Paul_S 6y agoWhich is what they're likely to do, after which they will open a new one 5 minutes later. At least it'll cost them time and money to do that, although probably not 25K.
- NiceWayToDoIT 6y agoGood point, people actually rating fictional name not a people who actually work there.
- mumblemumble 6y agoIt may be worth pointing out, for the sake of context, that the UK has a fairly expansive definition of libel. In the US, for example, you often have to prove that the defendant either knew that their accusations were false, or was acting with a reckless disregard for the truth. In English law, by contrast, you more-or-less just have to prove that the statement was injurious and untrue, regardless of the defendant's belief or intent.
- londons_explore 6y agoYou don't even have to prove the statement was untrue. The defence has the burden of proving the statement was true if they want to be found not guilty.
- anon98356 6y agoI believe opinion is a defence against libel even in the UK. Accusing them of being a scam strays close to being a claim that requires proof. But I wouldn't have thought it would be that hard to lodge a defence that it was an honest opinion and the wording in question is used in the context of common language/slang where scam can also be considered to mean not worth the money.
- M2Ys4U 6y agoThe judgment[0] addresses this point directly: >First, the defence of honest opinion. The Claimant submits that the defence of honest opinion cannot succeed in circumstances were the words used convey an allegation of fraud. Mr Bradshaw referred me to the case of Wasserman v Freilich [2016] EWHC 312 (QB), an unreported decision of Sir David Eady sitting as a High Court judge. At paragraph 16 of his judgment Sir David said: > > "The common sting in the various natural and ordinary meanings, pleaded in paragraph 27 of the particulars of claim, is that the Claimant was dishonest. That has generally been regarded as a factual allegation. It has long been recognised that "the state of a man's mind is as much a fact as the state of his digestion": Edgington v Fitzmaurice (1885) 29 Ch D 459. Juries are deciding on every day of the week, as a matter of fact, whether a particular Defendant was, or was not, dishonest. Accordingly, it is an allegation which in the context of libel is readily understood as being susceptible to a plea of truth under s.2 of the 2013 Act (as was the case with justification). It is not thought to be a matter of opinion: nor can one convert an allegation of dishonesty (or, for that matter, of murder or rape) into a matter of opinion by merely inserting in front of it a formula such as "I believe ..." or "she thinks ...": see e.g. Hamilton v Clifford [2004] EWHC 1542" >And at paragraph 22 of his judgment he said: > > "An allegation of dishonesty, fraud or attempted fraud will usually fall fairly and squarely on the side of fact rather than opinion. The same is true also, as I have already mentioned, where the allegation is of "reasonable grounds to suspect". Accordingly, I cannot allow a pleading to go forward in the form of paragraph 19A. It must be struck out." >Here Mr Bradshaw submits that the allegation of dishonesty made that the Defendant is that it is "a scam solicitor", has the plain meaning that the Claimant is dishonest and fraudulent. The Defendant seeks to present this as an opinion. Mr Bradshaw argues this is impermissible, the Defendant is putting forward the Claimant's dishonesty as a matter of fact and cannot simply say by way of defence "this is my opinion". In the circumstances I accept the law is as stated in Wasserman v Freilich and am satisfied Mr Bradshaw's submission is correct, with the result the defence of honest opinion should be struck out. [0] https://www.bailii.org/ew/cases/EWHC/QB/2021/85.html https://www.bailii.org/ew/cases/EWHC/QB/2021/85.html at paragraphs 15 and 16
- iamben 6y agoHaving been on both sides of the coin, I think consumer review sites (like trustpilot) are an incredibly difficult thing to get right. On one side as a consumer it's incredibly frustrating when you feel "wronged" - and whilst it's meant to be a 'review' it seems it's mostly used to get attention to fix a problem. So people use it as way to blackmail/last resort the business into sorting something. Which is kind of understandable, but too often the TP review goes up after 24 hours (or even before contacting anyone/actually trying to resolve a problem), even though the CS team doesn't work weekends, or repeatedly messaging on socials/emails keeps dropping the ticket to the back of the queue (and NO ONE EVER explains that to the customer) - so they feel the complaint isn't being seen (which it isn't). For all you hope people will understand some negatives are inevitable - it genuinely affects sales (in both directions, if you get it right). And as others have pointed out - good luck if you get on the wrong side, because it's very costly and painful to clean it up. Really, really, really great CS probably helps.
- fmajid 6y agoWelcome to the Streisand Effect. That said, UK libel laws are unconscionably stacked against the defendant. There is much to be said for the US' written constitution and bill of rights.
- M2Ys4U 6y ago>That said, UK libel laws are unconscionably stacked against the defendant. This defendant didn't even appear in court! He sent this by email: "I have already made it perfectly clear that this case should never be heard in court and I will not be giving it any credence or legitimacy by attending." So, while UK libel law may be harsh (although less so than it used to be), it's hardly at fault in this case.
- spuz 6y agoThere's a lot of interesting detail in the judgement that isn't covered in the article. I highly recommend reading through it (it's quite short): https://www.bailii.org/ew/cases/EWHC/QB/2021/85.html https://www.bailii.org/ew/cases/EWHC/QB/2021/85.html If I had to summarise, I would say that this is a case of a consumer doing the most emotionally satisfying thing in response to receiving a poor service, rather than what is legally allowed. As the judgement says, the defendant never attempted to complain or ask for a remedy from the solicitors themselves as he is legally entitled to. > "Also it was apparent that the Defendant made no attempt to engage in the Claimant's dispute resolution process. A complaint should always be the first stage in resolving any issues of customer satisfaction." The judgement also explains that in order for the defence of "speaking the truth" to succeed, he would need to submit evidence that others had been scammed by the same company - apparently the evidence of just a single datapoint is not enough: > "I recognise that in the context of an application for summary judgment I must not conduct a mini-trial but it seems to me the Defendant's allegations are so bold that in the complete absence of any credible material to support them I can conclude there is no real prospect of them succeeding at trial. I also take into account that the highpoint of the material submitted by Defendant is that he is unhappy with the service provided by Claimant." So while it seems that in certain cases, the correct response to receiving a poor service would be to leave a negative review, it seems the law does not agree.
- ErikVandeWater 6y ago> "Also it was apparent that the Defendant made no attempt to engage in the Claimant's dispute resolution process. A complaint should always be the first stage in resolving any issues of customer satisfaction." What bullshit legal reasoning. If you don't wait on hold on some company's help line for them to probably tell you to pound sand, that can be used against you in court?
- chki 6y agoIt can be used against you in Court if you were to make a statement that the company is a "scam solicitor". Maybe an analogy to sales would make this more understandable: If I was selling computers and the laptop I sold you had some serious issues, you cannot immediately turn around and call me a scammer. Because it might not be true, actually there is a more likely explanation that I didn't know about the issues with the laptop. Now if you would talk to me instead and I would insist that there couldn't possibly be an issue with the laptop and charge you for the faulty product, you _might_ call me a scammer. (Maybe one single instance of this wouldn't even be enough. Maybe you would even need to prove that I did in fact know about the problem with the laptop) On the other hand you can definitely leave a review saying that you received a bad product. You would not be required to talk to the company to be able to do that. Edit: To further elaborate a bit because I think people in this thread are having some weird reactions to this ruling: It's pretty normal that you cannot go around and tell lies that hurt somebody's business. If you think about it this is very normal. I cannot stand in front of a bakery with a sign that says "The bread in this bakery contains dangerous amounts of lead" if that is not in fact true. And if nobody buys bread anymore because of my sign, I will be liable for the damages incurred. This is less clear if my sign says: "In my opinion the bread in this bakery tastes funny." Because this is an opinion rather than a fact. But in the case at hand we are talking about somebody calling a company a "scam solicitor". That's mostly a factual statement, you could prove that the company is either doing regular business or that they are scamming people. If the defendant is not able to prove that they are in fact a scam business, it's very reasonable to assume that he is liable. The concrete damages incurred are however debatable in my opinion.
- CapriciousCptl 6y agoSince BBC didn't post it, here's the full decision. https://www.bailii.org/ew/cases/EWHC/QB/2021/85.html https://www.bailii.org/ew/cases/EWHC/QB/2021/85.html. Below, I pasted the review, followed by a bit from the judge. Written word has to meet a number of criteria to be libelous, but the core of the decision, I think, was that calling something a "scam" is a statement of fact and not opinion. https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2013/26/section/3/enacted https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2013/26/section/3/enact... """"*A total waste of money another scam solicitor* [Person X] left the company half way through my assessment and the replacement was useless. I paid upfront for a legal assessment of my case, but what I got was just the information I sent them, reworded and sent back to me. No new information or how to proceed or what the law says or indeed the implications of what was done. I Just got their false assumptions, full of errors showing a lack of understanding for the situation and the law. Once they have your money they are totally apathetic towards you. You will learn more from forums, you tube and the Citizens advice website about your case, for free""" And a small bit from the judge's decision-- """"An allegation of dishonesty, fraud or attempted fraud will usually fall fairly and squarely on the side of fact rather than opinion. The same is true also, as I have already mentioned, where the allegation is of "reasonable grounds to suspect". Accordingly, I cannot allow a pleading to go forward in the form of paragraph 19A. It must be struck out.""""
- boyband6666 6y agoOutside of the case, it looks like a nice business to be in! p7 shows gross profit increasing from £450k (2018) to £550k (2019) See Sept 2019 full accounts: https://find-and-update.company-information.service.gov.uk/company/07937576/filing-history https://find-and-update.company-information.service.gov.uk/c...
- jC6fhrfHRLM9b3 6y agoTime to rebrand.
- cedricgle 6y agoI am curious but if a business can sue and win for a "legitimate" bad review, can a customer sue a business for a "fake"/"promotional" good review ?. Or are business first class citizen and consumers always at the bottom ?
- passivate 6y agoNormally, a lawsuit is brought upon by the injured party to seek redress. I guess if you can produce an argument of how you were wronged, it might work?
- oh_sigh 6y agoPerhaps if you can show that you decided to use vendor X because of fake review Y, and the service you were provided with fell short of what was alleged in fake review Y?
- passivate 6y agoBut who will you bring the lawsuit against? Reviewer/Review service/website host/Vendor X/etc. IANAL, but I don't think you can sue the review service or the website host because of section 230.
- mytailorisrich 6y agoI've read the BBC article this morning and went to Trustpilot: You could see the negative reiview pouring in in real time, and the irony was that most people were there because the BBC article had mentioned that people were leaving negative reviews on Trustpilot. It took Trustpilot some time to suspend reviews.
- hankchinaski 6y agowell not surprising that leaving such review to a law firm would have resulted in defamatory charges, ironic
- mchusma 6y agoI feel like I'm theory there is some place for "confirmed reviews", since both the positive reviews and negative reviews can be gamed. But confirmed needs to be something more deeply investigated to ensure the transaction was legitimate and the complaint or positive review was valid. Don't know how to do it, but reviews are very much a problem and don't have a solution. Genuinely good businesses get hit with lots of bad reviews in certain industries. Genuinely bad businesses get lots of good reviews if they are willing to play certain games.
- jariel 6y agoSo "Summerfield Browne is a scammy law firm that sues little people for their life's savings for a mere negative comment". Is the 'legal' comment we can leave now.
- shepik 6y agoLittle people?
- Quanttek 6y ago> _[The defendant] did not attend the online hearing or send a legal representative_ That might be one of the main reasons why the case was decided in favor of the law firm. Otherwise, he could have defended himself against the libel charge (one possible defense is the truth)
- lifeisstillgood 6y agoEveryone (#) talks about regulation becoming an important part of the tech field in the coming decade. And that global regulation will become more "harmonised" as people of nations that are the same on twitter or facebook ask why they cannot do the "sensible" thing they see online. This is where the rubber hits the road. Britains Libel laws have for long been a shopping ground for international aggrieved. Do we keep our newspaper friendly libel laws? Do we become more like US or Germany? Software eats the world really means 'You must make explicit the trade offs and choices that were once nicely implicit' Its not just trolley problems. (#) ok not everyone.
- p2detar 6y agoFrom the article: "I paid upfront for a legal assessment of my case. But what I got was just the information I sent them, reworded and sent back to me." Is this a common practice? I recently reached out to an online attorney service (part of my insurance) about a minor issue and I got basically the same type of response.
- vasco 6y agoI'll pitch in $100 if he edits the review to say: EDIT: I had to pay an additional $34,000 in damages for this review.
- Ansil849 6y agoSo the takeaway is: if you want to leave a negative review, you need to do so anonymously as otherwise you may be brought to court.
- do-not-sue-me 6y agoThe judge claims: > Mr Waymouth had "never fully articulated" why he was unhappy with Summerfield Browne's work. But that's clearly not true: > Mr Waymouth alleged: "I paid upfront for a legal assessment of my case. [...] But what I got was just the information I sent them, reworded and sent back to me." In any case, libel laws are absolutely ridiculous and are fundamentally incompatible with a free and functional market economy as they make it unsafe for customers to share their experiences and criticisms. I have committed to never voluntarily do business with companies that take legal action in response to criticism, whether I believe it to be true or not. If you have sued someone for libel and I can choose a competitor who has not, I will choose that competitor even if their product or service is inferior.
- epanchin 6y agoIts a shame he hasn't published his £200 question and their response.