3 ms·
> Hey now, [he is] one of these people, and [he] most definitely exists! Who? How do you know?
by hedora 6y ago
> Hey now, [he is] one of these people, and [he] most definitely exists!
Who? How do you know?
- Dylan16807 6y agoYou broke the meaning of that sentence on purpose, you don't get to blame it on the brackets. Look at it done correctly: tomc1985 objects that "[he is] one of these people, and [he] most definitely exists!" You may not like how it looks, but it completely solves the fake issue you were making fun of.
- rgossiaux 6y ago>Look at it done correctly: tomc1985 objects that "[he is] one of these people, and [he] most definitely exists!" You also need brackets around "exists" since the original quote had "exist". I think you're proving the point. I completely agree with the author that sentences like this are absolutely miserable to read. You can quote him as saying "I am one of these people, and I most definitely exist!" and, because we all have basic reading skills, we all understand that the "I" refers to the person speaking. Mangling quotes with unnecessary brackets is bad writing.
- Dylan16807 6y ago> You also need brackets around "exists" since the original quote had "exist". That's fair, I put too much trust in hedora's version. > I think you're proving the point. I may be demonstrating the article's point, that it looks awkward, but I still strongly disagree with hedora trying to make it look like the subjects get all wonky and confusing.
- roelschroeven 6y agoDone correctly is keeping the quote very close to the original and changing your text to make that work, instead of the other way around. Much better is: tomc1985 objects: "I am one of these people, and I most definitely exist!"
- mewse 6y ago> Hey now, I am one of those people, and I most definitely exist! Who? How do you know? The problem you’ve presented has nothing to do with brackets or changed words; the same problem is there even with the original words (as above), when the quote is given without attribution as in your example.