6 ms·
This does not address the primary way I (ab?)use these brackets: to fill in the subject explicitly when the original author refers to it only implicitly. So qu
by kqr 6y ago
This does not address the primary way I (ab?)use these brackets: to fill in the subject explicitly when the original author refers to it only implicitly.
So quoting the last clause in the above paragraph, I might write
> when the author refers to [the subject] only implicitly.
The obvious alternative is to quote a longer passage. Maybe this is one of those cases where conciseness fights with authenticity.
Another solution might be to substitute in the subject and just not indicate it with brackets. That certainly reads easier, but risks hiding a common type of misunderstanding.
- johnorourke 6y agoHopped on here to say exactly that! I've never seen it used the way the author describes, only the way you describe.
- jusssi 6y agoNormally one should paraphrase. Quotes are reserved for special cases where that exact way something is said is essential for communicating the message. And the need to add []-blocks is evidence that it doesn't belong to that special class. Edit: All you lazy copy-paste writers downvoting all the comments here that propose paraphrasing instead of quoting: I see you.
- phnofive 6y agoWhy?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jusssi 6y agoSeveral reasons. Etiquette. Less reason mangle the words of others (arbitrarily cutting something out of larger context can also easily mangle). Let's your reader see how you understood the communication, not just that you found it somewhere and copy-pasted it in.
- Dylan16807 6y agoEtiquette is circular logic. A larger quote would still be arbitrarily cut out of a larger context. If you're extending past the good part purely to get a subject I'd even say it ends up more arbitrary. Unless you're taking a test, you don't need to prove you understood it, and if your reader lacks confidence in your understanding then paraphrasing makes the problem worse! Instead of merely worrying you missed important context, now they have to worry you completely altered the meaning. Paraphrasing can mangle words so easily. I'm baffled why you would imply otherwise. And your edit just makes you look stupid.
- jusssi 6y ago> Etiquette is circular logic. I was tempted to reply to this by throwing etiquette out of window, but that would get me downvoted to hell. Because there is an etiquette. > Paraphrasing can mangle words so easily. I'm baffled why you would imply otherwise. When I paraphrase someone, they're my words. Not the original author's. I take responsibility for them. > And your edit just makes you look stupid. You're right down there with me. Welcome.
- ddingus 6y agoSo are the words in brackets, and so should be responsibility.
- jusssi 6y agoBut a quote intermingled with [paraphrase] just becomes a more awkward way to paraphrase? Because surely it isn't a verbatim quote any more.
- ddingus 6y agoSure it is. The grammar is clear. One can know the quote exactly. Frankly, implying otherwise diminishes the language. Edit: All of which is why the article was written. People changing quotes, wrapping it in brackets so it flows better, in their view. That's a mess! Others here, myself included, correctly maintain appropriate bracket use does not change a quote, which is true until this garbage.
- kens 6y agoThe Chicago Manual of Style is fine with that. "Insertions may be made in quoted material to clarify an ambiguity, to provide a missing word or letters, or to give the original foreign word or phrase where an English translation does not convey the exact sense." This is indicated with brackets.
- ddingus 6y agoThat is exactly how I use them. When quoting critically, doing that makes a lot of sense. It can get confusing and be quite verbose without that particular device.
- gbh444g 6y agoIs it a regexp? I'm thinking if we could come up with a especially dense writing style that needs quadratic time to fully understand a sentence. Like you read a sentence of N words and get only a surface level meaning. Then you re-read it and understand a bit more. Repeat it about N times and you get the full picture.
- wiml 6y agoNo, I think you're absolutely right, and the author of the Slate piece is a nitwit. Of course it's better to find a quote that can stand alone, but if you can't do that — say, because there's a pronoun that refers to something too far away from the phrase of interest to include — then use brackets, ellipses, and so on.
- loeg 6y agoThey're both right. The Slate article is just picking on an uncommon, mistaken use of the pattern. I agree that it's pointless whining — I don't know that I've ever seen this mistake made.
- BlueTemplar 6y agoWell, the author clearly has, but since I haven't either, this article probably has no place on HN (which seems to have quite a different audience)...
- function_seven 6y agoThe author's point here is different than that, though. The original writer had no need to substitute the pronoun in the short quote. It was replaced with just another pronoun, so no extra information was inserted. It would have been just as clear if left in its original phrasing. From TFA: > Sometimes you have to use brackets anyway. Maybe the speaker or writer was using an acronym or a completely unfamiliar piece of jargon that the reader needs explained. Maybe they were referring to a person by their last name or nickname, when the reader has not yet been introduced to the person’s full name. But these changes should be both necessary and obvious.
- loeg 6y agoThat's the correct use of the pattern and the only way I've seen it used.
- ant6n 6y agoBut why remove the „it“? That changes the quote in a way that’s not marked, since the brackets denote an addition but not a removal. Keeping it would make it clearer what actually happened to the quote, That you merely expand what the „it“ references to, and thus is more trustworthy.
- zeven7 6y agoBrackets often indicate a replacement, which includes a removal of something.
- SamBam 6y agoIt can be done either way. > He said he was going to "post this on HN [Hacker News] right away." Of course, there are often other ways to do that: > He said he was going to "post this on HN right away," referring to the website Hacker News.
- thedufer 6y agoI think this is addressed in the following section: > Sometimes you have to use brackets anyway. Maybe the speaker or writer was using an acronym or a completely unfamiliar piece of jargon that the reader needs explained. Maybe they were referring to a person by their last name or nickname, when the reader has not yet been introduced to the person’s full name. But these changes should be both necessary and obvious. Not quite explicitly, but it isn't a far leap from "referring to a person by their last name or nickname" to pronouns.
- Mauricebranagh 6y agoBracketing acronym's on first use is a totally separate issue.
- greggyb 6y agoAs is creating a plural form by adding an apostrophe. (;
- thedufer 6y agoI was more pointing towards the second half about expanding a nickname or last name into a full name, but I think they're actually closely related as different ways in which the author might be adding context that is missing from the quote.
- Triv888 6y agoYou could also introduce the quote instead of modifying it (you probably are doing that already anyways).
- px43 6y agoIt annoys me when someone gets interviewed, and they make intentionally vague comments to avoid leaking non-public information, and the interviewer fills in the blanks with whatever they think will generate the most clicks, wildly misrepresenting the statement, and giving it a completely different meaning than the interviewee intended.
- interestica 6y ago> It annoys me when someone gets interviewed.... I disagree. I think interviews are critical tool of discourse! (I'm kidding...to your point) I think it's extra prevalent now when there is so much video media that users want to get summarized for them. It takes longer to watch a video than to read a summary from someone whose viewpoint I already align with to make a judgment about the video. This discussion about citation/quoting/primary sources makes me recall university days when (as a student of history) I tried to cite a DVD as a source. But, the professor's required Style guide made no provisions for the media type. Thus, there was pressure to either quote from a book (either written by the person being quoted or from a secondary source quoting the person) rather than transcribing the quote from the visual source I was verifying myself: literally seeing the person I was quoting say the exact words.
- pc86 6y agoThis is the only way I've ever seen them used - in your example, "[the subject]" would be replacing a word like "it" or "something." I seem to recall my English teacher saying it was used (paraphrasing) to change the text of a quote without changing its meaning, and that any other usage was incorrect.
- titzer 6y agoThere is a way to do that by adding context outside the quote but keep the quote verbatim. "It's an older code, sir, but it checks out", the officer said, referring to the stolen access code Han had just provided, stolen from god knows where, god knows how long ago. See, now the original quote is undisturbed and the added context is less authoritative (on purpose), since it is not inserted into the quote. The provenance of all the information is clear. Personally I think the only brackets we should use in quotes are [sic], indicating an error in the original. Otherwise we are on the slippery slope to, "oh, what they really meant to say is [phrase phrase phrase]".
- bobthepanda 6y agoBut now you’ve basically doubled or tripled the length of the whole sentence. The primary usage I see of this is to replace some second or third person pronoun with the actual name of the person, which is much simpler than appending a short biography of the person and trivially easy to verify.
- titzer 6y agoYeah, there is a cost to being precise. We can think of other ways to make it shorter, but we should respect the integrity of what is in quotes. Another option: Spitballing: "It is not worth doing," she said, [it=foobar]. We do this all the time in programming languages. Without introducing too much syntax, this is doable.
- gugagore 6y agoI'd say we only do something like that in programming if there's a benefit to using other values for `it` in other contexts, and if we'd like to refer to a template `"It is not worth doing" by name. If you're just going to use it once, or if all usages have `[it=foobar]`, I don't think you'd do it. I could imagine doing something like what you mention if I had moved code from another context, and I wanted to have a commit that shows plainly that it was moved verbatim. But then I'd make subsequent commit where I do the necessary substitution.
- Mauricebranagh 6y agoWell a native speaker of English should be able to discern the inferred subject. None of the examples should give anyone any problems. How ever there is a question should you take more care in writing when some of your audience has English as a second language?
- airhead969 6y agoYes. The intent has to be honest rather than throwing out a device without nuance. It often seems like black&white reasoning to predicate an article on "why you should start doing this" or "why you should stop doing that." As an additional device, [sic] is also helpful to indicate an original typo or improper usage not by the quoter.