4 ms·
Even non-connected systems can be a problem. Stuxnet was an example. But I think the main point is that owners of those systems think they are protected just by
by giantg2 6y ago
Even non-connected systems can be a problem. Stuxnet was an example. But I think the main point is that owners of those systems think they are protected just by being disconnected.
- nopzor 6y agothe stuxnet attack had a significantly higher level of sophistication than this. if your threat is a competent nation state the bar is much much higher.
- just_steve_h 6y agoIs the threat not from a competent nation-state or supranational entity? Is that not the intention of designating power & water & electricity systems as "critical infrastructure?"
- dodobirdlord 6y agoI don’t think the water treatment plant of Oldsmar, Florida falls under the same threat model as a uranium enrichment facility.
- tapland 6y agoI don't think the threat is much different, but an attacker doesn't have the patience for a stuxnet level attack on one of many water treatment facilities. If it was airgapped it wouldn't be available to easily be used by a nation state to attack infrastructure in case of other simultaneous attacks.
- giantg2 6y agoRemember the concerns during the first gulf war about Iranians potentially planning to contaminate drinking water in the US?
- sellyme 6y ago> Stuxnet Yeah, and even the best security practices aren't going to work too well if someone drops a nuke on your facility. Stuxnet was an extraordinarily sophisticated attack well beyond what a typical industrial system will need to protect against, or even be able to protect against. It's not really in the same league as anyone being able to just remote in and change settings, and while it's realistic to expect a bloke called Steve who runs the computers at the water processing plant to prevent someone just remoting in willy-nilly, it's not as realistic to expect him to defend against two nation-states working together explicitly targeting that facility.
- cm2187 6y agoWould have been better with “homer” than “steve”!
- giantg2 6y ago"...well beyond what a typical industrial system will need to protect against..." And the target system also had security systems well beyond the capability of your local water treatment plant. Let's not forget that these assets deemed as critical infrastructure could be the target of nation states. All I'm saying is that not being connected is only a small part of security for industrial systems, and that some people wrongly rely on it being enough.
- yodelshady 6y agoThe target system probably fared better than you think - as a whole, it certainly wasn't destroyed. As with this incident, operators were physically present. That seems to be the real lesson (even if - see other war stories on this thread - operators tend to themselves have a creative approach to network security).
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoThe issue was not identified for months, and from what I understood, a significan fraction of the certrifuges were destroyed. The attack worked exactly as designed - wasting time, destoying equipment while being stealthy. Had the attack tried to destoroy all equipment at once" it would have beem spotted immediately.