3 ms·
Should it empower you to bypass the terms under which content you're accessing were shared? Have you considered that maybe that's disempowering other people usi
by eyelidlessness 6y ago
Should it empower you to bypass the terms under which content you're accessing were shared? Have you considered that maybe that's disempowering other people using the same tool?
Edit: as far as I can tell the groupthink has gone beyond “everyone should use a free license for everything” to “I have a free license to everything damn the actual license”.
- tshaddox 6y agoWhat evidence does the software have that you agreed or continue to agree to the terms encoded into the piece of content? If you intend to not copy text from a file, for instance, you are certainly free and empowered to not do that.
- eyelidlessness 6y agoYou agreed by accepting the distribution that expressly forbade it. The software knows you agreed by you accessing content that instructed the same software to prevent you from copying it to the best of its ability.
- h_anna_h 6y ago> Should it empower you to bypass the terms under which content you're accessing were shared? Yes > Have you considered that maybe that's disempowering other people using the same tool? I can't see why given xpdf with DRM and xpdf without DRM anyone would select the first.
- zamadatix 6y agoRestricting plain text copying on compliant readers isn't really preventing anything though. It's akin to unskippable copy warnings on DVDs, the only thing it does is inconvenience those using it legitimately.
- creata 6y ago> Should it empower you to bypass the terms under which content you're accessing were shared? I think it's disingenuous to frame it as a "bypass". The publisher is setting out a terms of use, and I think it's bad that the software try to force that I abide by such terms, because: • the software will be too conservative: there are many situations where it is legal (and even ethical) to ignore such terms, but the software will not recognize them. • there will be alternative software which does not enforce such terms, making it worthless as an actual protection measure. • like I said, I think my machine and the software runs on it ought to represent me and my interests. I would certainly hesitate before installing software that put others' interests above my own, no matter how well-intentioned. > Have you considered that maybe that's disempowering other people using the same tool? No, but I'd be more open to the thought if you'd provide a compelling example.
- eyelidlessness 6y ago> > Should it empower you to bypass the terms under which content you're accessing were shared? > I think it's disingenuous to frame it as a "bypass". The publisher is setting out a terms of use, and I think it's bad that the software try to force that I abide by such terms You coulda just said “yeah”. Edit: > No, but I'd be more open to the thought if you'd provide a compelling example. I did but I’ll make it more clear: I licensed my content to you, with the expectation you would honor my license. If you use the technology I distribute my licensed content to you to violate that license you’re undermining my ability to determine the terms under which I distribute my content.
- creata 6y ago> You coulda just said “yeah”. But then I'd be tacitly agreeing that it's a "bypass", when there's nothing to "bypass" in the first place. > you’re undermining my ability to determine the terms under which I distribute my content. Isn't this exactly what IP law is for? Why do you need PDF readers of all things to also enforce your terms?
- edoceo 6y agoBecause it hard for a single author or organization to enforce across millions of humans. It's like locks on doors. Yea, B&E is illegal and the lock helps as a forcing function/indicator. Easier to lock a door than chase 100s of thieves. DRM is like that for a publisher, and digital theft is loads easier than physical theft, otherwise publishers are really set back for getting compensated for their works (see author above). I get you don't like DRM but should software be a tool for stealing others works? Note: I loathe DRM but when I pay for content/books, I respect the game.
- eyelidlessness 6y ago> But then I'd be tacitly agreeing that it's a "bypass", when there's nothing to "bypass" in the first place. If the terms of the distributed content are “I don’t want you to copy this” and the technology has the ability to disable copying it (however flawed or limited), and your expectation is that the software disregard that express wish for distribution... you are asking the software to facilitate you in disregarding the express wish of the creator. How is that long winded way of saying it not “bypass”?
- diffeomorphism 6y ago> Should it empower you to bypass the terms under which content you're accessing were shared? Yes, obviously.