5 ms·
Just how different two organisms have to be to be different species is always going to be arbitrary. It is not as though you can select a particular day (the a
by colechristensen 6y ago
Just how different two organisms have to be to be different species is always going to be arbitrary. It is not as though you can select a particular day (the absurd extreme) two populations transitioned from one species to two. Given this (and more reasonable arguments in the same vein over longer time periods), a particular number of “species” in a closely related group over an evolutionary short timeframe just isn’t an interesting or useful metric.
- amelius 6y ago> Just how different two organisms have to be to be different species is always going to be arbitrary. Isn't the decision made based on if mating can happen (and the offspring can procreate)?
- jmgao 6y agoOne of the problems with that is ring species: if A can mate with B, and B can mate with C, but A and C cannot mate, are A and C the same species?
- posterboy 6y agoWell, if AxB and BxC can mate, then the off spring has genes from A and C so by some second degree derivative they can mate. iff. Not my field of interest but I feel reminded of dialects and how difficult it is to define language. The dialect with a military meme has some truth to it, when variet are measured against a standard or prestige dialect. B obviously has an advantage so unless other disadvantages apply, it would be dominant. A societal (?) or socio-cultural definition is interesting as well. Even genetically identical specimen couldn't mate if on opposite sites of the globe, and they are bound to drift eventually. I do kindle with the idea that groups have to be understood as organisms in their own right, but I never read anything specific about it. About language families, it is startling how anthropologists reason about language by proxy via archaogenetics. Lots of open questions there, too.
- cutemonster 6y ago> are A and C the same species? To me, they are not. (In my not-know-much about this opinion) And B is a bridge species, or A C adapter species, sort of? But is this ABC situation really common? So frequent so motivates how to (not) define what a species is?
- sjcsjc 6y agoThis is discussed in the linked article
- emteycz 6y agoThen Neanderthals were the same species as we are?
- danans 6y agoI believe that this is the scientific consensus, since we harbor Neanderthal DNA resulting from intermixing.
- emteycz 6y agoI don't think this makes sense. If Neanderthals are the same species then there wasn't any mixing, it was just regular procreation. If there was mixing then Neanderthals necessarily were other species.
- danans 6y agoI didn't claim they were a different species. There were more likely a long isolated subspecies still genetically capable of reproducing with cromagnons, which is evident by the presence of their genes in modern humans. And they aren't the only examples of that, either (i.e consider Denisovans)
- ookdatnog 6y agoThis has so many edge cases that it's really more of a vague rule of thumb than a hard definition: ring species (as another poster pointed out), infertile individuals (does every infertile individual constitute a species by itself?), drift over time (like ring species, but over time: an individual might be able to (in theory) produce fertile offspring with a far ancestor or with a far descendant, but the far ancestor may not be able to mate with the far descendant), ...
- colechristensen 6y agoThis is likewise something which doesn’t just turn off one day. Lots of very distinct animals have some degree of interbreeding possible more than one would think. Plants are very much more willing to mix species, and many organisms don’t do sex at all and bacteria types do a whole lot of gene transfer... You aren’t going to get a half deer half turtle, but the closer two organisms are, the more likely they have some degree of compatibility, even after millions of years of evolution. It’s like asking people to determine if a color is orange or red. There are obvious answers and not so obvious answers.
- gumby 6y agoI learned that obsolete definition too (I'm old!) but the article touches on the problems that caused that definition to fall into abeyance (e.g. species that reproduce asexually)
- taneq 6y agoI thought species were defined as being broadly unable to interbreed? (Yes, mules and ligers exist but they’re exceptions to the rule produced by human intervention.)
- sebmellen 6y agoYes, but Homo Sapiens interbred with Neanderthals and probably also Denisovans [1]. Different species, yes, but still able to interbreed to an extent. Where exactly the line between species lies is not so clear, even though it clearly exists, just like the line between red and orange. [1]: https://www.history.com/news/denisovans-interbreeding-discovery https://www.history.com/news/denisovans-interbreeding-discov...
- kebman 6y agoIs there evidence for that mating could only occurr "to an extent," like with horses and donkeys? Is there a physiological difference making it difficult for, say, difficulties in mating between Homo sapiens and Neanderthals, or between Homo sapiens and Denisovans? There can be a number of reasons for the two not mating often outside mere physiological differences, for instance differences in preferred culture, looks and personality. While some of that can certainly be the result of biological differences, it's not necessarily so. I'm just guessing and theorizing here, though, so any leads, links or breadcrumbs would be nice. :)
- tharkun__ 6y agohttps://aeon.co/essays/what-do-we-know-about-the-lives-of-neanderthal-women https://aeon.co/essays/what-do-we-know-about-the-lives-of-ne... This quote is from way down in the article but I think the most significant one: > Most intriguingly, something of the dynamics is visible. In some earlier instances, Neanderthal women had the children of H sapiens men, but the later interbreeding after 60,000 years ago tells a different story. Nobody today has mitochondrial DNA like that in Neanderthals and, since it’s passed only maternally, this implies that interbreeding was more often between their men and our women. Some other interesting ones: > unlike other primates, Neanderthal body size doesn’t seem to have differed much between the sexes. It’s much more similar to most H sapiens populations, which suggests that violent male competition was not the dominant social structure. Instead, more likely something akin to the bonobos, whose adult lives are based around long-term female friendships, might have been possible. > Somewhere around 40,000 years ago, the many generations of Neanderthal women become invisible, at least in skeletal terms. The processes underlying this must have come in many guises, in many places, but one thing we know is that women of another kind – H sapiens – played some part, because Neanderthals were not entirely extinguished. Just 10 years ago, the first nuclear genome was meticulously reconstructed from three genetically identified females at Vindija; it revealed that, rather than ousting Neanderthals from Eurasia, we had in fact interbred with them.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- macintux 6y ago> It is not as though you can select a particular day (the absurd extreme) two populations transitioned from one species to two. Species of Theseus.
- agumonkey 6y agoWhat I wonder is how climate/geography pushed advanced (by that I mean enough brain power and memory to recognize siblings and belong to an group) species to evolve to the point that they didn't consider each others as parents.