5 ms·
It's strange. Almost everyone I know in real life, when told "Why don't you just do X instead of Y" treats it enthusiastically as a chance to share some nuance
by renewiltord 6y ago
It's strange. Almost everyone I know in real life, when told "Why don't you just do X instead of Y" treats it enthusiastically as a chance to share some nuance about their field.
Two instances recently come to mind, my asking my father (an orthopaedic trauma surgeon) why we don't just make hips (in total hip replacement) out of dead people's bone instead of out of whatever material they do now, and my father's asking me something about why blue LEDs are supposedly so hard (why don't you just wrap them in blue film).
On the Internet, everyone is always like "you guys always think you can do our job better!". In real life, everyone is always like "hmm, that's interesting. Let me explain why". But perhaps it's just everyone I know.
I saw this the other day too in another HN comment⁰ where people assume that "Why don't you just" and questions like that are demeaning.
0: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25826835 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25826835
- zebnyc 6y agoI presume this has to do with how you frame the question and the recipient perceives your intent.
- renewiltord 6y agoI'm sure I agree, but surely there is something to how so many commentators here clearly immediately assume that the Prof's question must have been framed so that the best interpretation is condescending.
- tompccs 6y agoAbsolutely - in fact in 2021 you might even be accused of mansplaining, when actually the purpose of asking these questions is to genuinely learn more about why the world works the way it does! (And of course there are the occasional examples of genuine insights gained from having a fresh perspective - I remember reading about Alan Sugar discovering that he could make satellite dishes for a tenth of the cost by contracting the manufacture out to a bin lid factory)
- kelnos 6y agoI think we've hit the result of heavy social pendulum swings. There are enough people who actually do mansplain in the very negative way that the assumption has become that any attempt to explain something in that manner is assumed to be mansplaining unless proven otherwise. It's disappointing, because it shuts down any form of reasonable discussion, and causes people to automatically assume the worst intentions without applying the principle of charity. But on the other hand, mansplaining is actually a real, pervasive problem, so it's understandable that people can become viscerally negative toward anyone who starts explaining something without first verbally demonstrating humility.
- tompccs 6y agoI think this is fair. More broadly I'd add that we've become quick to accuse the speaker of bad intent and too rarely consider if the listener could have been more charitable. And god help you if there's someone in the room intent of hearing you uncharitably, regardless of the feelings of the person you're actually addressing. The most uncharitable interpretation will usually prevail.
- PragmaticPulp 6y agoIt's all about the context. When you ask your father why something is done a certain way, you're seeking information. You're not questioning the competence of his field or implying that you have seen an obvious solution that his entire field has simply missed. However, when engineers say "This change will require 4-6 weeks" and their boss says "Can't you just add a form field and run a database migration and ship it tonight?", the boss is casting doubt on the team's assessment of the situation and their competency in executing. The demeaning nature varies with intent. If someone is asking a simple question ("Why can't we just ship it tonight? Help me understand") it's nowhere near as bad as a boss waiving away objections with an over-simplified order ("Just change the code and ship it tonight!")
- kelnos 6y agoI don't think anyone would object that that kind of negative reaction to a repeat offender (the hypothetical manager) who has demonstrated through repeat behavior that they have little respect for their employees' expertise. What is a bit more pervasive, though, is a growing belief that any question of the form "why can't you just...?" is inherently condescending and rude. Yes, I agree that a "help me understand"-style question is the ideal way to ask, but I think people have definitely become more (IMO unreasonably) sensitive against the "why can't you just...?" form, when often it's asked innocently and without a trace of disrespect. Something I always try to remind myself: I can't control other people's behavior, but I can control how I react to it. We should try to gently correct truly bad behavior when it is safe and constructive to do so, but it generally does us no good to get all worked up about it in the first place, especially if it's something as benign as a poorly-worded question. And being impatient with these sorts of things can be to our detriment; sometimes a fresh, layman's perspective can provide an insight we hadn't considered.
- smichel17 6y agoI think a big part of it comes from the inclusion of the J word. If you just remove it from the question, it comes off as significantly less arrogant and will tend to ruffle fewer feathers. Unfortunately, it is deeply embedded in many of our vocabularies. I'm actively trying to scrub it from mine (except when something really is that simple, or to demonstrate the effect, like in this post).
- D-Coder 6y agoOkay... why _don't_ they just make hips out of bone, and why _can't_ you just wrap LEDs in blue film?
- dekhn 6y agomodern bone replacement uses cadaver bones, so the answer is "they do". As for LEDs, if you're using a color filter, that's filtering out the vast majority of photons so it's not bright or efficient.
- detaro 6y agoIsn't it with LEDs also that getting a spectrum that has blue you could filter is about as hard as getting just blue? (e.g. white LEDs are some form of blue/UV with an extra fluorescent layer, and from a (simple) red LED you can't get blue by filtering?)