5 ms·
TLDR: I attempted to make a COVID vaccine. It was cheap. I have no proof that it worked. Other risks are unknown. The story reminds me of Barry Marshall, but w
by 1970-01-01 6y ago
TLDR: I attempted to make a COVID vaccine. It was cheap. I have no proof that it worked. Other risks are unknown.
The story reminds me of Barry Marshall, but with less science behind it. https://jamesclear.com/barry-marshall https://jamesclear.com/barry-marshall
- bawolff 6y agoHonestly i'd be pretty shocked if this actually worked.
- wegs 6y agoWhy? In many cases, the hard part isn't so much making a working vaccine, as proving it works, scaling manufacturing, etc.
- bawolff 6y agoBecause if all it took to make a vaccine for a respiratory disease was stick some peptides up your nose, we would havev a lot more vaccines (and i dont mean just for covid.). Even if the other parts are harder (not sure if thats true. The reason proving things work is hard is because most initially promising candidates dont actually), it doesn't follow that every single vaccine candidate works.
- visarga 6y agoKind of like self driving cars, so many edge cases, so many unknowns in deployment. Got to test the shit out of it.
- wegs 6y agoIf my life depended on having a self-driving car ready in a year to drive me to California, I'd have a self-driving car ready in a year. It could drive me to California with perhaps only a 25% chance of an accident. I mean, it might be driving with the emergency blinkers on the whole time, at 10 miles per hour, and flashing the horn, or crazy stuff like that, but making a basic self-driving car just isn't out-of-scope for an amateur. DARPA urban challenge was 2007, and 6 cars finished an urban course, with the fastest averaging 14MPH, and most developed mostly by students, with professor support. Today, I can get a lot of that stuff CoTS, open source, or read papers about what they did. I couldn't sell millions of self-driving cars, because of edge cases, manufacturing, or what not, but it's not fundamentally different from biohacking. Technology moves forward. Disclaimer: I'm not an MD, biologist, or similar, but I am pretty good at all the stuff that goes into a self-driving car. I'm not claiming a /typical serious amateur/ could build one. I'm claiming /I/ could build one.
- concordDance 6y agoVaccines are sufficiently easy to make that people in the 19th century could make them. The hard part isn't making a vaccine, it's making one that's safe and reliably effective. Using 19th century techniques will kill you an unacceptably high proportion of the time (well, unacceptable unless it's something like widespread smallpox or, debateably, covid) and also often won't work.
- wegs 6y agoNon-rhetorically, I'd encourage you to look at which vaccines we're missing and why. Do any of those apply to COVID19? Early vaccines were made in the scientific equivalents of modern basements and worked adequately well. Influenza vaccines come out each year like clockwork. There are plenty of vaccines which just aren't rocket science, including for virtually all major historical viral diseases which wiped out or crippled large numbers of people. And then there are ones like AIDS. With COVID19, as far as I can tell, virtually all reasonable vaccine candidates DID work, and it was mostly a question of how quickly and how well. I'm much more excited about a 95% effective shot than a 60% effective one. The Moderna one was developed, quite literally, overnight. Once Moderna had the sequence, they had a (later proven working) vaccine candidate more-or-less instantly, in January, long before they'd seen the virus live, let alone had a way to check that it worked. Did you see many /failed/ COVID19 vaccines? I saw a few /worse/ vaccine candidates. A couple failed in some populations (e.g. Sanofi worked well for younger people, but not older). Some didn't have competitive effectiveness (e.g. Merck, presumably, but they didn't release enough to know when I last looked). Some had side effects (UQ/CSL would cause people to fail AIDS tests later). Etc. I think all of these will compete for some of the logistics chains as the winners, so it doesn't make sense to push with /less effective/ vaccines. My general impression is that COVID19, at least unmutated, is not hard to make effective vaccines for. There are questions about longevity and mutations, but for now, I can see the sticking-peptides-up-nose approach potentially working. I mean, compare that to early vaccine efforts like variolation (which worked), or the whole flu of 1918 vaccine effort (which didn't). Disclaimer: Not an MD or biologist.
- Kliment 6y agoPeptide vaccines do work - there's a very similar vaccine currently in limited use (EpiVacCorona, running phase 3 trials in Russia, with emergency use approval granted in two countries at time of writing). The inhalation based delivery mechanism is also not novel, but almost never used because you need a whole lot more spaced doses than intramuscular, and that's a massive pain logistics-wise when you are trying to run a public vaccination campaign. There is no clear reason this wouldn't work. That said, there are many reasons it can fail in practice without a GMP environment - peptide chains are fragile and contamination is a risk - with a contaminated substance inhalation is going to be a much safer mechanism than injection, but unless repeated multiple times it will be less effective. The thermal disinfection stage needs precise temp control to not destroy the peptides and in general there's a lot of handling steps that can go wrong. But that's a matter of process, not of principle - both intranasal delivery and peptide vaccines have individually been shown to work.
- stjohnswarts 6y agoHave you made a successful vaccine to a major virus before in your basement?
- bawolff 6y agoTbf, (live) rabies and smallpox vaccines can be made by hand fairly easily. Of course if you screw it up you die.
- Kim_Bruning 6y agoIt's looks like this is an open source science project originating near Boston. The white paper looks pretty thorough. I think they progress by means of people contributing back with their findings. https://radvac.org/ https://radvac.org/ I think the reason they're (clearly) not first is because it appears they had to scale their people-network as well as actually work on the vaccine. It doesn't help that biology and genetics skills are -as yet- a bit more rare than programming or editing skills yet. Given the constraints I think they've gotten impressively far within 1 year.
- ChuckMcM 6y agoThe science is in the whitepaper: https://radvac.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/12/White-Paper-SARS-CoV-2-vaccine-ver-3-3-1.pdf https://radvac.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/12/White-Paper-SA... That said, the interesting bits are: #1) Vaccine design at home. This is an application of what is known colloquially as "bio-hacking" and as a topic group is no less impactful than "computer hacking." #2) You can do something for < $1000 which wasn't possible before because of the industry that will print you rna sequences. Interesting stuff indeed.
- 1970-01-01 6y agoThe whitepaper also lists some possible short and long term side effects. I've TLDR'd most of them here for everyone: -Immune tolerance: diminished immunity resulting from exposure to an antigen -Vaccine-enhanced disease (VED): A small number of injected vaccines have led to enhancement of disease, meaning that infectivity is enhanced, or the disease is made more serious in people who have been vaccinated. -Adjuvant hyperstimulation or toxicity: ..certain adjuvants have caused hyperstimulation and other serious side effects. For example, alum produces a robust Th2 immune response, but an unbalanced ratio of Th2:Th1. A Th2 polarized response, and alum in particular, have been implicated in immunopathology, including ADE. Adjuvants can also be toxic. As one example, the intranasal use of a detoxified mutant form of Escherichia coli Heat Labile Toxin has resulted in transient Bell’s palsy, or facial nerve paralysis. The whitepaper then argues the following: "And it becomes clear why the formulation described here has not been used in a commercial product; it is not lack of safety or efficacy, but other factors.."
- xirbeosbwo1234 6y ago>as a topic group is no less impactful than "computer hacking." It's way less impactful. An amateur playing with computers might not achieve what a pro can, but it obviously has some effect. Computer programs are rarely a placebo. Little these so-called bio-hackers do is known to be effective. That's almost by definition.
- TeMPOraL 6y agoIt's more difficult due to low observability of the system, low understanding of it, and long deployment cycle. Still, it's hacking molecular nanotechnology. Possible developments are far more interesting than what we do with computers now. Let's give it some time.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jcul 6y agoThe idea of personal science reminds me of Alexander Shulgin and his experiments in PHiKAL. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/PiHKAL https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/PiHKAL
- refurb 6y agoA little different no? Shulgin was a formally trained scientist (Harvard, Berkeley, UCSF), did research at major academic and private institutions.
- bobcostas55 6y ago>Preston Estep, Don Wang, Alex Hoekstra, Ranjan Ahuja, George Church, Brian Delaney, and over 100 others Pretty sure George Church is a "formally trained scientist"!
- refurb 6y agoDude, Pfizer can make a mRNA vaccine but that doesn't mean if I follow their directions I can. This guy is a total amateur. He bought some proteins, diluted them then shot them in his nose. That's not science. And I also question his methods. Simply shooting a small peptide into your nose is unlikely to elicit any major immune response. Cells in your respiratory tract excrete proteases. I'm guessing those peptides get chewed up pretty quickly. You need to develop and validate some sort of delivery mechanism.
- sanxiyn 6y agoHe used chitosan nanoparticle as delivery mechanism, which has been validated in multiple clinical trials.
- refurb 6y agoAhh.. that’s what it’s for. Going on the radovac site there is no validation of nanoparticle formation? Just mix, shake a bit and it’s good? This is so far from any resemblance to an actual therapeutic vaccine it’s just scary. Reminds me of the recipes for making meth on the web. Sure, it theoretically works, but nobody seems to check the final product.