12 ms·
‘Smallest reptile on earth’ discovered in Madagascar
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- nwellinghoff 6y agoAwesome. Hope these little guys survive.
- andersource 6y agoThe blog post the article refers to (couldn't find it in the article itself): http://www.markscherz.com/archives/4800 http://www.markscherz.com/archives/4800
- acomjean 6y agoThanks. Interesting discussion about “smallest” depend on how size is measured: “ As a result, whether or not the new species is considered the smallest amniote in the world depends on whether we define that based on the male or female body size, or the midpoint of the two. It turns out this is quite a common problem in other species with size dimorphism as well, such as frogs.”
- andersource 6y agoYeah, I wasn't even aware that such size dimorphism existed to such extent in some species.
- jjjbokma 6y agoThe anglerfish and Trichonephila clavipes are nice examples of size dimorphism.
- terramars 6y agoDid no one else notice the gem in here that BBC failed to mention, that this lizard has one of if not the largest dicks relative to body size of any vertebrate? Due to gender size dysmorphism and internal fertilization.
- stubish 6y agoHere is an article that does mention testicle size: https://newslanded.com/2021/02/06/a-new-chameleon-species-might-be-the-worlds-smallest-reptile/ https://newslanded.com/2021/02/06/a-new-chameleon-species-mi... (which I guess might tie into the other thread about minimum organ sizes!)
- bstar77 6y agoTitle should read: ‘Smallest known reptile on earth’ discovered in Madagascar.
- yreg 6y agoThat's implicit. One could add "as far as it is known" to any headline, but to what purpose?
- bstar77 6y agoI don't find it implicit and feel it has a tinge of hubris. Too much is reported as fact, and taken as such, when it's just a best guess.
- ryan_j_naughton 6y agoI disagree entirely. Some sets are completely known and others are not. For example, the youngest American president is accurate as we know all of the American presidents. While, we are discovering thousands of new species every year. It is important to remind people of this fact of species being an unknown set size.
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoThe quotes clue us in, its a title. The title is won again each time a smaller reptile is discovered. That was my immediate understanding on seeing the article. No extra words needed!
- meetups323 6y ago> a chameleon subspecies that is the size of a seed "seed" is needlessly vague term here... mustard seed or coconut?
- asymptosis 6y agoI came here to say the exact same thing. Who even goes around comparing things to seeds anyway? The writer was trying to be cute but just ended up saying something bizarre and stupid.
- stickyricky 6y agoThe article provides a length of 13.5mm which is only 10mm shorter than the distance between the seed comparison and the reported length of the species.
- meetups323 6y ago> 10mm shorter than the distance between the seed comparison This doesn't parse for me. You mean the difference between the two lengths of seeds I gave? Thats 150mm - 3mm, which is more than 10mm longer than 13.5mm.
- hn2fast 6y agoI was going to make the exact same comparison with the mustard seed and coconut, but looking at the numbers, it more or less tracks as being the center of the log scale between the two seeds. Palm seeds in general are exceptionally large compared to anything else, while we're at it.
- airstrike 6y agoWhen somebody says "seed", do you think mustard seed or coconut seed?
- meetups323 6y agoI think of a broad category of items including strawberry seeds, mustard seeds, sunflower seeds, mango seeds and other "pit"s, up to coconut seeds. I think "sunflower seed" would have been a better comparison, as its something a person can actually visualize, not a 3 order of magnitude spanning category.
- TrispusAttucks 6y agoThese little creatures would be a good candidate for pets. Small, cute, could use a boost to their numbers.
- vidanay 6y agoHouse cats love them.
- xiphias2 6y agoI think all business savy people think the same thing. I would love to bring these cameleons on my travels on the plane.
- siltpotato 6y agoThat would cause Australian rabbits or Georgia kudzu. Not a good plan.
- pistoriusp 6y agoNot all animals make good pets.
- EVdotIO 6y agoI'm guessing it probably needs a very specific diet and climate to survive. If this is like other chameleons, they are prone to all sorts of health issues and in general very hard to keep alive.
- xwdv 6y agoNonsense, a shrewd capitalist can easily sell these in kits with everything you need to keep them alive. They are so small, and if they die well they are tiny you can probably just get a new one and most people will probably keep like 4 or 5 of them at a time anyway, probably breeding their own replacements. These are fantastic can’t wait to have a terrarium filled with them.
- dvtrn 6y agoExcept for the part where the article mentions these little critters might be facing possible extinction already if it weren’t for protection laws for its native biodome. Be a lot cooler if we didn’t hasten that just to put them in little glass boxes in our domiciles, forced breeding of domesticated canine and felines have already enough caused genetic problems with breathing and bone density among certain breeds-for example. Let’s let these little fellas thrive unmolested, does anyone know where I (as a westerner) could learn more about the conservation efforts mentioned in the article?
- mekoka 6y agoWas it discovered, meaning that the indigenous population didn't know about it, doesn't have a name for it, cannot tell you anything about it, or meaning that it will now be introduced in a formal taxonomy?
- koheripbal 6y agoScience is about cataloguing and documenting nature. It's not particularly relevant if a tribe of indigenous people knew about it.
- Yenrabbit 6y agoThere are several similar small chameleons around the island, which have been long known by locals and tourists. But this new one is 'micro-endemic' to a very small, remote region. Probably been seen before, but I think 'discovered' is fair in this case when talking about discovering that this is a separate, undescribed species and not one of the more widespread ones.
- dan-robertson 6y agoA second issue is that, at lower levels, taxonomy isn’t a very well defined thing. (Perhaps one way to think of it is that phylogeny maps onto taxonomy and this mapping isn’t injective.) So if two groups of animals are reclassified as two species, it is hard to say whether or not a new species was discovered. Especially if the two variants were known before—should one backdate the species discovery to the time the variants were identified? Similarly, a species doesn’t really go extinct if the taxonomy changes so two species are merged into one. The vernacular names for some group of animals (or plants) needn’t correspond to some clade that gets a taxonomical name. Eg broccoli and cabbage are considered the same species, whereas ‘crab’ may refer to all sorts of largely unrelated animals.
- akiselev 6y ago> The vernacular names for some group of animals (or plants) needn’t correspond to some clade that gets a taxonomical name. Eg broccoli and cabbage are considered the same species, whereas ‘crab’ may refer to all sorts of largely unrelated animals. Broccoli (Brassica oleracea var. botrytis) and cabbage (var. costata/italica) are bad examples [1], since subspecies and varieties are well defined as ranks in botanical taxonomy and there are regulatory structures based on them. I think a better example would be hybrids like plumcots which are crosses of multiple species. Fitting them cleanly into natural taxonomy is a huge mess - over evolutionary timescales hybrids usually outcompete, converge with, or diverge from their parents enough to clean up their taxa for us. [1] https://plants.usda.gov/core/profile?symbol=brol https://plants.usda.gov/core/profile?symbol=brol - Subordinate Taxa tab
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoMust be some fundamental limit on the size of organs and tissues, to still function. Or, there are smaller reptiles and we just haven't 'seen' them yet! Who's looking behind every blade of grass for an iguana after all. Insects win the 'smallest' title - the Fairy Wasp is 0.13mm
- mojomark 6y agoThis comes up from time to time, but it's pertinent to the discussion (more so on larger scales, but the reverse holds true], so in case you haven't had the delight of reading [1]. 1. PDF download link: https://www.phys.ufl.edu/courses/phy3221/spring10/HaldaneRightSize.pdf https://www.phys.ufl.edu/courses/phy3221/spring10/HaldaneRig...
- ralfd 6y agoMaybe the limit is not function, but being competitive. Insects don’t have lungs and an open instead of closed circulatory system, with a tubular “heart” sloshing around hemolymph instead of blood. At this small size this should have advantages?
- pitspotter 6y agoYes, and I was thinking about its eyes. The human eyeball has diameter roughly equal to the entire length of this lizard, making its volume 10,000X larger than the lizard's eyeball. OTOH, with a pupil that small, visual depth of field must be large. So perhaps the nano-chameleon doesn't need to do much in the way of focussing. Small wonder they took so long to discover :-p
- pdpi 6y ago> OTOH, with a pupil that small, visual depth of field must be large. But the pupil is also small enough that diffraction is a major issue so their visual acuity is probably quite poor
- pitspotter 6y ago
- Yenrabbit 6y agoB. nana, brought to us by the guy who named some pygmy frogs 'Mini scule', 'Mini ature' and 'Mini mum'. I'm looking forward to the next few things they're working on going public :)
- gherkinnn 6y agoBrought to you by Dr. Scherz [0]. Scherz meaning "Joke" in German. 0 - http://www.markscherz.com/archives/4055 http://www.markscherz.com/archives/4055
- dan-robertson 6y agoWhenever I see the word minuscule, I’m reminded of a time in my childhood when my brother’s teacher spelled it wrong on a spelling test (that week was to have a collection of words starting mini-, though looking now it seems that miniscule is such a common variant that it is often accepted)
- kingdomcome50 6y agoHere's to hoping its some kind of newt. It would basically name itself!
- globular-toast 6y agoWhen did the BBC start fucking with the back button? Every time I click a link from here I have to rapidly press back to come back. So annoying.
- 93po 6y agoThe back button went down the memory hole along with their integrity.
- vram22 6y agoSkinks can be fairly small, like a few inches. Used to like watching them as a kid. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Skink https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Skink